| Combat
Sports Special Issue Research article |
|
|
A PROFILE OF OLYMPIC TAEKWONDO COMPETITORS
|
Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College and Ryerson University, Toronto,
Ontario, Canada.
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2006) 5 (CSSI), 114
- 121
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
purpose of this study was to identify the profile of the Olympic champions
and the other competitors who were involved in the Games. The information
on each of the athletes was obtained from the "Official Site
of the Sydney 2000 Olympic Games, www.olympics.com/eng/sports/TK"
and included weight category, weight, height, age, points obtained,
warnings, deduction point, defensive/offensive kicks and punches.
One hundred and two athletes competed (54 males and 48 females) in
the Games. The mean average age and BMI (Body Mass Index) of 16 male
winners was 24.4 ± 3.3 years and 21.9 ± 2.4 respectively compared
to 25.2 ± 4.3 years and 22.8 ± 3.3 for the 38 male non-winners. The
mean average age and BMI of the 16 female winners was 23.1 ± 3.9 years
and 20.8 ± 2.3 respectively compared to 24.9 ± 4.7 years and 21.3
± 2.7 for the 32 female non-winners. For all four types of athletes,
offensive kicks accounted for at least 52% of the techniques to score
a point. Ninety-eight percent of all techniques used to score were
kicks. Although not statistically significant, winners overall tended
to be younger in age and taller with slightly lower BMI than their
weight category average. Taking into account the literature cited
in this article, future studies should be designed to examine the
relationship between performance and functional variables such as
muscle power, muscle endurance, reaction time and aerobic capacity.
KEY
WORDS: Taekwondo, martial arts, body weight, body mass index,
height, age.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
The
origins of the Korean martial art of Taekwondo go back 1500 years.
Originally Taekwondo was taught for warfare, self-defence, and physical
fitness. Over the centuries, the art form has spread throughout the
world. Today, an estimated 75-120 million children and adults worldwide
participate in martial arts with an estimated annual growth rate of
20-25% (Birrer, 1996).
Taekwondo is practiced in over 140 countries around the world and
120 nations are official members of the sport's major organizing body,
the World Taekwondo Federation (WTF). Taekwondo reached the Olympic
stage as a demonstration sport in the 1988 Seoul Olympics and the
1992 Barcelona Olympics. It became an official Olympic sport in the
2000 Sydney Olympic Games.Taekwondo, renowned for its high and fast
kicks, was developed as a technique used by Korean peasants to dismount
their attackers, who rode on horseback. In competition, kicks and
punches score points when contact made to the torso (by punches and
kicks) or head (only by kicks) is sufficient to produce a displacement
of the body segment. A match can be won by a knockout or on points.
While punching to the head is not permitted, kicks to the head and
face are allowed. Research studies related to Taekwondo have tended
to concentrate on injury rates (Beis et al., 2001;
Chuang and Lieu, 1992;
Philips et al., 2001;
Pieter et al., 1995;
1998a;
Pieter and Lufting, 1994;
Pieter and Zemper, 1995;
1999; Serina and Lieu, 1991;
Zemper and Pieter, 1989).
Studies have been conducted on the epidemiology of trauma which is
proposed to be related to skill level, gender,
weight, age, mechanism, body part, situation, and years of experience
(Beis et al., 2001;
Philips et al., 2001;
Pieter et al., 1995;
1998b;
Pieter and Lufting, 1994;
Pieter and Zemper, 1995;
1999; Zemper and Pieter, 1989).
However, very little research has been conducted in the area of performance
in the martial arts, and how it might relate to anthropological variables
such as body weight. Kules, 1996
examined the impact of anthropometric variables on judo performance
for female judokas. Kules, 1996
established that body weight, the circumference of the extremities,
skin folds on the upper arm, back and height were identified as important
determinants of performance. In addition, Pieter et al.,
1998b
described the somatotype of 19 elite Filipino female judo athletes,
also comparing them to a sample of elite American female Taekwondo
athletes. Pieter et al., 1998a
concluded that the Taekwondo athletes were leaner than the judo athletes.
In a study of 30 elite Chinese male Taekwondo athletes, Gao, 2001
demonstrated that the dominant somatotype was a well-proportioned
stature, well-developed muscles and skeletons, and low subcutaneous
fat.
Other sports have also conducted anthropological studies including
gymnastics, volleyball, basketball, rock climbing, swimming, freestyle
wrestling, and ten-pin bowling to mention a few (Callan et al., 2000;
Cleassens et al., 1999;
Khosla, 1984;
Tan et al., 2000;
Toriola et al., 1987;
Watts et al., 1993;
Yamamura, 1999).
Studies have been conducted examining the links, if any, between anthropological
variables and actual performance outcomes: These include physiological
profiles of elite freestyle wrestlers; a comparison by age, height,
weight and somatotype of the finalists at the Seoul Olympics, and
physiological profiles of male and female Taekwondo (International
Taekwondo Federation, ITF) black belts (Heller et al., 1998).
The majority of these studies have found that, in each sport, the
elite athletes fit a certain physical or anthropometric profile. One
study concluded that lack of 'proper physique' (which was not defined
by the authors) could hinder successful sport performance at the Olympic
level (Toriola et al., 1987).
Toriola et al., 1987
found that the differences they observed between their athletic groups
were related to the morphological factors that influenced the basic
components of competitive sports performance.
One study does give a hint at what somatotype may have a better chance
at excelling in competition (Gao et al., 1998). The researchers found that the body fat percentage
in five elite athletes was relatively low compared to average athletes
(Gao et al., 1998).
Gao et al., 1998 concluded that because aerobic ability in Taekwondo
is very important, decreasing body fat percentage and increasing lean
body mass are needed to gain the highest possible VO2max.
In contrast, Melhim, 2001 found no significant differences in either resting heart
rate or aerobic power after training; however, significant differences
were observed in anaerobic power and anaerobic capacity. Markovic
et al., 2005 examined the differences between successful and less successful
Croatian national Taekwondo champions and found that successful athletes
achieved significantly higher maximum running speed, significantly
higher ventilatory anaerobic threshold at significantly lower heart
rate, significantly higher explosive power, anaerobic alactic power
and lateral agility somewhat lower body fat (2.3%), and were slightly
taller (by 5.8 cm) than less successful athletes. On the other hand,
other researchers (Callan et al., 2000; Cleassens et al., 1999;
Gao, 2001; Gao et al., 1998;
Heller et al., 1998;
Khosla, 1984;
Tan et al., 2000;
Toriola et al., 1987;
Watts et al., 1993;
Yamamura, 1999)
agree that the possession of specific anthropometric qualities alone
cannot guarantee a gold medal. Success in competition is indeed a
combination of physical attributes, talent, skill, technique, determination,
strategy and psychological preparedness. Many of these qualities have
not been investigated in elite WTF Taekwondo athletes.
Work by Yujin and Zeng, 1999
concluded that training should focus on offensive fighting as the
major focus. Smith et al., 2000
examined the effect of a 3%-4% loss in body mass on a boxing-related
task. They found that some participants were able to resist the deleterious
effects of a rapid loss of body mass prior to competition and suggested
the necessity of further research to find the mechanism. In a subsequent
study, the effects of serial reductions in energy and fluid intake
on two simulated boxing performances separated by two days recovery
were assessed (Smith et al., 2001).
Smith et al., 2001
concluded that energy and fluid restrictions in weight-governed sports
do not always lead to a significant decrease in performance. However,
they cautioned the readers to use these findings with care since their
sample size was small and there were large variations in individual
performances (Smith et al., 2001).
Fogelholm et al., 1993
studied the effects of gradual versus rapid weight loss in national
wrestlers and judo athletes on nutrient intake, micronutrient status,
and physical performance (sprint, jump height, and anaerobic performance).
A 5% to 6% reduction in body weight was reported in the gradual and
rapid loss groups. Nutrient intake was significantly decreased in
both groups in vitamin B1 and B2, and K+, Ca+2,
Mg+2, Fe+2, and Zn+2 values, compared
to baseline measures. Speed, vertical jump, and anaerobic performance
were not impaired by either rapid or gradual weight loss (Fogelholm
et al., 1993).
In contrast, Filare et al., 2001
reported that all mean micronutrient intakes were below recommended
values, while triglyceride levels and free fatty acids were increased
in weight cycling judo athletes. Left hand grip values and 30-second
jump test output were decreased after seven days of food restriction
(Filare et al., 2001).
In examining the literature, some might argue that the evidence of
health risks from weight cycling is equivocal. Even so, there are
several possibilities that may help explain the lack of supporting
data. One possibility is that there may be no effect. Waslen et al.,
1993
found that the duration, frequency, and severity of food restriction
among the judo athletes in their study may not have been sufficient
to have an effect. Even with a lack of strong support to illustrate
the ill effects of weight cycling, monitoring dietary habits of athletes
in weight class sports is recommended. It is more prudent to assume
that larger weight losses and more frequent dieting could potentially
result in negative physiological and performance consequences. Widespread
regulations need to be implemented to control weight cycling practices
among weight class sports.
The purpose of this study was to identify the characteristics of the
champions (Gold, Silver, and Bronze medalists) who competed in Sydney
2000 Olympic Games and to compare these characteristics to those who
competed but did not earn medals. |
| METHODS |
|
The
data for this study were obtained from the "Official Site of
the Sydney 2000 Olympic Games, www.olympics.com/eng/sports/TK"
(a public domain web site). The information obtained included: The
participants in each weight category, their weight, height, date
of birth, country, round by round report, points obtained, warnings,
deduction point, defensive kicks, offensive kicks, offensive/defensive
punches, list of referee and judges with their country of origin.
The information was entered into an Excel spreadsheet and then transferred
to an SPSS file (Version 11.5). Variables were coded and labeled.
Statistical
analyses
Descriptive statistics were calculated for the age, weight, height
and body mass index of the athletes by gender. Analyses of variance
were used to compare differences between demographic characteristics
and techniques used to score. The level of significance was set
at p = 0.05. A variable (rank) was created based on performance
outcome (1=gold, 2=silver, 3=bronze, 4=bronze 5=no medal) in order
to examine relationships between the demographic and technique variables.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Profile
of athletes
For both male and female athletes, there were no statistically significant
differences between winners and non-winners in age, height, weight
or body mass index (see Table 1).
Scoring
techniques
The male non-winners used offensive kicks more often when compared
to male winners. Offensive kicks accounted for at least 52% of the
techniques (see Table 2). Information
on the type of kick used to score was not published on the web site.
In general, an offensive technique was used to score
slightly more often than the defensive one. However, male non-winners
had the highest percentage of offensive kicks (63%). In terms of
techniques used, female winners used 45 more techniques (or 8%)
than male winners. In addition, the margin between female winners
and female non-winners (122 techniques) was greater than between
male winners and non-winners (70 points).
Round
scores
In both male winners and non-winners, Round 1 had the highest percentage
of scoring (43%, and 65% respectively). In females, winners scored
only 19% of the total in Round 1 in contrast to female non-winners
(59%) whereas in Round 2 female winners score more than half (53%)
of their total points (see Table
3).
Warnings
received
In both male and female winners, the number of warnings per match
received was far higher than among non-winners (see Table
4).
Country
representation
Korea was the most successful nation with two gold medals in the
female division and a gold and silver medal in the male division.
The Korean female gold medal winners and the male silver medallist
used a defensive technique to score more frequently when compared
to their weight category average. However, the Korean male gold
medallist used a defensive technique to score less frequently when
compared to the weight category average.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
Overall,
both male and female winners tended to be somewhat younger than
the average age in their respective weight category average. This
may be a result of the inclusion of Taekwondo in the Olympic Games
which may have broadened its exposure to younger athletes. In addition,
application of scientific training principles early in their development
could be another reason for having younger winners.
In all weight categories, the average height of male winners is
greater than the category average. This finding correlates with
a longstanding Taekwondo coaching belief that taller athletes in
their weight category maybe more successful due to longer reach,
leaner body, and longer lever which helps them to cover larger distances
expending less energy than their shorter counterparts.
In all weight categories except over 80 kg, the average weight of
male winners was greater than the weight category average. In the
heavy weight categories, for both male and female, the average weight
of the winners was less than the category average. These findings
are best explained through calculating Body Mass Index. Body Mass
Index (BMI) is a reliable indicator of total body fat, which is
related to the risk of disease and death. The BMI score is valid
for both men and women; however, it may overestimate body fat in
athletes and others who have a muscular build. It may also underestimate
body fat in older persons and others who have lost muscle mass (Bickley
and Szilagyi, 2003). The mean BMI ranged from 20.8 for female winners to
22.8 for male non-winner athletes. This is well with the normal
range (18.5-24.9) and probably in the lower aspect of the normal
range since this population comprised elite athletes who have higher
muscle mass compared to general population (Bickley and Szilagyi,
2003).
The average BMI of winners in general was lower than that of non-
winners but did not achieve statistical significance. This may suggest
that the winners had a leaner body than the non-winners and lower
body fat content as supported by Gao, 2001,
who showed that the dominant somatotype was a well-proportioned
stature,
well-developed muscles and skeletons, and low subcutaneous fat.
Heller et al., 1998
in their study of the Czech national Taekwondo (ITF) team reported
low adiposity for their male and female athletes (BMI 21.9 and 22.0
kg·m-2, respectively). Gao et al., 1998 suggest that a certain somatotype (ecto-mesotype)
may have a better chance at excelling in competition. These authors
found that the body fat percentage in five elite athletes was relatively
low compared to average athletes. Gao et al., 1998
also concluded that to gain the highest possible VO2max
(aerobic ability) in Taekwondo, decreasing body fat percentage and
increasing lean body mass are needed. Melhim, 2001
examined nineteen Taekwondo male adolescent practitioners with regards
to resting heart rate, aerobic power, anaerobic power and anaerobic
capacity. He found no significant differences in either resting
heart rate or aerobic power after training; however, significant
differences were observed in anaerobic power and anaerobic capacity.
The increases in anaerobic power and anaerobic capacity were 28%
and 61.5% respectively. Markovic et al., 2005
assessed the differences in VO2max, explosive and elastic
leg strength, maximal strength, muscular endurance, anaerobic alactic
power, agility and flexibility of thirteen Croatian national Taekwondo
champions divided in two groups according to their senior international
competitive achievements. The successful athletes achieved significantly
higher maximum running speed, significantly higher ventilatory anaerobic
threshold at significantly lower heart rate than in the less successful
athletes. These authors also reported significant differences in
three tests of explosive power, anaerobic alactic power and lateral
agility. They found that the successful athletes had somewhat lower
body fat (2.3%) and were slightly taller (by 5.8 cm) than the less
successful athletes. They concluded that the performance of Taekwondo
female athletes primarily depends on the anaerobic alactic power,
explosive power expressed in the stretch-shortening cycle movements,
agility and aerobic power (Markovic et al., 2005).
The nature of Taekwondo performance mainly requires bursts of sudden,
fast and powerful kicks that lend itself to having a speed and power
athlete profile and not an endurance athlete physiological profile
suggested by Gao et al., 1998. In addition, there is no indication in the literature
that a lower body fat and high lean body mass is required to gain
the highest possible VO2max. An adequate VO2max
enables the Taekwondo athlete to recover between rounds or burst
of activity.
Toriola et al., 1987 observed that lack of proper physique could hinder successful
sport performance at the Olympic level. Previous studies have looked
at anthropometric variables in terms of a potential indicator of
athletic performance. Yamamura, 1999 found no significant correlation between the performance
scores of 16 well-trained synchronized swimmers and anthropometric
variables. Claessens et al., 1999 and Zhao et al., 1999
found an association between decreasing athletic performance and
increased subcutaneous fat among elite gymnasts and Taekwondo athletes
respectively. The Claessens et al., 1999
study, however, concluded that the association was not strong enough
to predict individual performance scores. However, Heller et al.,
1998
found that among male ITF black belts, competitive performance was
significantly related to maximum power output and upper limb reaction
time only, whereas in females, performance was related to maximum
power output and ventilatory threshold. In our study, for both males
and females, the difference between winners and non-winners in terms
of height, weight, and body mass index were not statistically significant.
However, there is some evidence that lower BMI and taller athletes
may have advantage to their counterparts in Taekwondo.
Overall, 98% of all techniques used to score were kicks. This was
expected since major focus has been put on kicking skills in Taekwondo.
However, one may use this fact to develop punching techniques to
score since most Taekwondo athletes may not be trained sufficiently
and may not have proper defensive techniques to counter. In addition,
WTF Taekwondo rules and regulations at the time of Sydney Olympic
Games did not encourage scoring with punches. At the time of these
Games, the punches were used mainly as a closing technique to negate
an attack. However, new WTF Taekwondo rules (see from URL: http://www.wtf.org)
place greater emphasis on the scoring with punches by making wearing
gloves mandatory. In addition, decreasing the duration of each round
to two minutes from three minutes, decreasing the size of the competition
area to 10m x 10m from 12m x 12m, win by 7-point gap, win by 12-point
ceiling, and increasing the corner judges to four instead of three
will encourage more intense bouts of fight with utilization of various
techniques and possibly more accurate scoring. In general, an offensive
technique was more commonly used to score, 57% in the men's competition
and 53% in the women's. Although Yujin and Zeng, 1999
concluded that training should focus on offensive fighting as the
major focus, they did not provide any rationale. It is the first
author's experience that using offensive techniques frequently during
a match are viewed as an athlete's aggressiveness and being in control
of the match since the athlete that retrieves often during the match
may get warnings for not engaging.
In terms of total points scored, female winners scored 45 more points,
8% more than male winners. In addition, there is a greater point
differential between female winners and female non-winners than
between male winners and male non-winners, suggesting a greater
gap between the top female Taekwondo athlete and the remainder of
the field than between the top male athlete and the remainder of
the male field. Taekwondo female athletes' participation in competitions
and even in the sport started much later than the male athletes.
In addition, the number of female Taekwondo athletes in the world
is lower than that of the male athletes. Hence, the pool of female
athletes is smaller than that of the males. In some countries, such
as Iran, participation of female Taekwondo athletes in International
competitions is banned due to religious belief. This may affect
the degree of emphasis put on developing elite international female
Taekwondo athletes in different countries, therefore, explaining
the large difference in scoring between female winners and non-winners.
In both male winners and non- winners, Round 1 had the highest percentage
of scoring (43%, and 65% respectively). However, male winners scored
less than non-winners in Round 1. Among females, winners scored
only 19% of the total in Round 1 in contrast to female non-winners
(59%) whereas in Round 2 female winners score more than half (53%)
of their total points. It is the principle author's opinion that
these findings may be due to the fact that winners might have used
the first round to evaluate their opponent moves and conserve energy.
In both male and female winners, the number of warnings per match
received was far higher than among non-winners. This may be due
to the winners' aggressiveness and lack of fear of receiving warnings.
Korea was the most successful nation with two gold medals in the
female division and a gold and silver medals in the male division.
Taekwondo is Korea's National sport; therefore, Koreans have a huge
pool of players that can be pushed as hard as possible. In our study,
the Korean athletes, in general, used a defensive technique to score
more frequently when compared to their weight category average.
The Korean Taekwondo coaches might have studied the trend of scoring
and worked on scoring with defensive techniques rather than offensive
ones. It is the first author's opinion that the most important factor
in scoring with an offensive or defensive technique is the timing,
which is execution of a technique at the right time to surprise
the opponent and score. Developing the proper timing requires development
of speed, reaction time and understanding of the various sparring
situations. Development of defensive techniques may even requires
further skills, timing, speed and practice since one has to decide
what technique to use and be fast and effective to counteract and
score.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
|
This study
examined 102 athletes who competed in the Sydney 2000 Olympic Games.
The findings suggest that the winners tended to be younger in age
and taller with slightly lower BMI than their weight category average.
In general, an offensive technique was used to score slightly more
often than a defensive one. The majority of all techniques used
to score were kicks. In both male and female winners, the number
of warning per match received was far higher than among non-winners.
Comparing the findings from subsequent Olympic events is needed
to determine if the trends observed in this study are the same.
In addition, it is recommended that future studies be conducted
to examine the relationship between performance and functional variables
such as muscle power, muscle endurance, reaction time and aerobic
capacity (identified in other studies) in addition to the variables
used in this study.
|
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
|
We would
like to thank Danny Myrtos for data entry, and the Canadian Memorial
Chiropractic College for its support.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
- Winners
tended to be younger in age and taller with slightly lower BMI
than their weight category average.
- An
offensive technique was used to score slightly more often than
a defensive one.
- Overall,
98% of all techniques used to score were kicks.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Mohsen KAZEMI
Employment: Sports
and rehabilitation specialist, and acupuncturist. Assoc. Prof.
and Sports Sciences Residency program coordinator at Canadian
Memorial Chiropractic College
Degrees: RN, DC, FCCSS(C), DACRB, FCCRS(C)
Research interests: Epidemiology, sports physiology and
trauma in Taekwondo and Chiropractic
E-mail: mkazemi@cmcc.ca;
drkazemi@sportdoc.biz
|
|
Judith WAALEN
Employment: Professor
Emeritus, Department of Psychology, Ryerson University Toronto,
Ontario Canada
Degrees: PhD
Research interests: Validation of instruments used in
measurement of disability, psychomotor skills, and quality of
life; evaluation of technology-enabled education
E-mail: jwaalen@ryerson.ca |
|
Christopher J. MORGAN
Employment: Chiropractic
sports specialist and Fellow with the College of Chiropractic
Sports Sciences, Canada
Degrees: BSc., DC, FCCSS
Research interests: The conservative management of sports
related injuries
E-mail: mcw4life@rogers.com |
|
Anthony R. WHITE
Employment: Doctor
of Chiropractic, Paulding County Chiropractic, 55 East Paulding
Dr Suite 146, Dallas, Georgia 30157
Degrees: BSc., DC
Research interests: Chiropractic
E-mail: drawhite@bellsouth.net |
|
|
|
|