|
HEAD INJURIES IN FULL CONTACT KARATE COMPETITION! IS THE PREJUDICE
IN MANAGEMENT MINIMISING THE REQUIRED INVESTIGATION?
|
Health and Exercise Science Research Laboratory, School of Applied Sciences,
University of Glamorgan, Pontypridd, Wales, CF37 1DL, UK.
| Received |
|
12 December 2006 |
| Accepted |
|
15
June 2007 |
| Published |
|
01
October 2007 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2007)
6(CSSI-2), 62 - 64
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| A 33 year old male karate practitioner presented himself for a
full-contact national karate competition. This individual competed
for approximately 2 minutes and received a kick to the head. He collapsed
in the competitive arena, and suffered a tonic-clonic seizure, lasting
for 3 minutes 25 seconds. Examination in the competitive arena revealed
an individual who was unconscious. First aid, and paramedic support
was provided immediately. Medical assessment identified the presence
of vital signs. Glasgow coma scale (GCS), post trauma was recorded
as 3/15 until the fifth minute. A patent airway was established and
a neck brace was applied. Blood pressure within 1 minute of trauma
was 195/98 mm.Hg, heart rate was 185 bpm and respiratory rate was
40 breaths·min-1. Oxygen was administered via a ventimask.
The patient was conveyed to the medical area. The patient regained
consciousness one minute after the seizure had resolved, but had amnesia
concerning the event. GCS at five minutes was recorded as 13/15. The
patient was transferred by ambulance to the nearest Hospital. The
patient was discharged, following examination without further investigation.
The finding of this study suggests that an individual with a history
of head injury should have received computerised tomography as a minimum
investigation. This may help eleviate the risk of further medical
complications.
KEY
WORDS: Cerebral trauma, computerised tomography, mild head injury,
prevention.
|
| CASE
REPORT |
|
In 2006 a 33 year old male, height 1.68 metres, weight 60 kg and
body mass index (BMI) 21.3 kg·m-2 who had completed a
detailed medical questionnaire, presented himself for a medical
prior to a full-contact martial arts competition. His past medical
history was unremarkable.
At rest his blood pressure (BP) was 130/78 mmHg; heart rate (HR)
was 72 bpm; rate pressure product (RPP) was 94 bpm. X mm.Hg x 10-2
respiratory rate (RR) was 18 (Table
1).
Routine medical examination including central nervous system examination
was satisfactory allowing competitive participation.
This individual competed for two minutes before receiving a direct
kick to the head. Examination in the competitive arena revealed
an individual who was unconscious. He was enduring a tonic-clonic
seizure, recorded as lasting for 3 minutes 25 seconds. First aid,
and paramedic support was provided immediately. Medical assessment
identified the presence of vital signs. Glasgow coma scale (GCS)
was recorded as 3/15 (E1, V1, M1).
A patent airway was established and a neck brace was applied. BP
within 1 minute of trauma was recorded at 195/98 mm.Hg. HR was recorded
at 185 bpm; the RPP was 361 bpm. X mm.Hg x 10-2, and
RR was 40 breaths·min-1. His airway was clear and his
capillary refill was < 2 seconds. Re-examination using the GCS
was 3/15 (E1V1M1) every minute for the first five minutes (Table
2). Oxygen was administered via a venti-mask. The patient was
conveyed to the medical area and disqualified on medical grounds.
The patient regained consciousness one minute after his seizure
resolved. GCS on regaining consciousness and recorded at six minutes
was 13/15 (E4, V4, M5) (Table 2).
Examination of central nervous system (CNS) revealed left sided
hyper-reflexia and a left up-going plantar response. Bilateral pupillary
examination revealed an equal reaction to light and accommodation
response. Bilateral retinoscopy examination with direct ophthalmoscope
was unremarkable. A decision was made to admit him to nearest hospital,
known to have a neurosurgical unit. The British Red Cross Ambulance
Service conveyed him there within five minutes of his seizure stopping.
A GCS score of 8 or less suggests a severe brain injury (Teasdale
and Teasdale, 1974).
The "Revised Trauma Score" (Champion et al., 1989)
in its present form does not accurately describe the relation of
GCS, SBP, and RR to mortality (Moore et al., 2006).
The Revised Trauma Score is a physiological scoring system, which
until recently has been considered to have high inter-rater reliability
and demonstrated accuracy in predicting death. It is scored from
the first set of data obtained on the patient, and consists of systolic
BP (SBP) and RR.
Six minutes post-competition the BP of the individual male was 173/88
mmHg; the HR was 70 bpm; the RPP was 121 and RR was 33.
A full history was difficult because the individual had a speech
impediment, which had not been elicited pre-competition, but which
he was lucid enough to point out. The patient complained of a headache
and nausea, but had no memory of a blow to the head.
The patient was admitted to the nearest hospital with a neurosurgical
unit. The hospital accident and emergency (A & E) department
was contacted to advise on the patient's history, and request a
neurosurgical opinion, but the telephone line was persistently engaged.
The hospital was contacted every 1-2 minutes for the next hour and
every five minutes for the following hour but
the
hospital line remained engaged and remained engaged for the remainder
of the day (a Saturday).
The patient was discharged without computerised tomography (CT),
despite a letter being presented to the A & E senior house officer
requesting a neurosurgical opinion.
The British Red Cross ambulance returned the patient to the karate
venue so he could be taken home, by his family and acquaintances.
He was taken to his sister's house for rehabilitation and remained
there for one week, before returning home. He received contact by
text and telephone with the karate medical team on a daily basis
until he returned to work, one week after the event. Two weeks after
the trauma he resumed training and is subsequently sparring. There
appeared to be no long term consequences.
| DISCUSSION |
|
Brain
injuries may be graded into mild, moderate and severe depending
on clinical and neuro-imaging criteria. Mild brain injuries
(MBI) are usually defined by an initial unconsciousness limited
to 30 minutes, a Glasgow score between 13 and 15, the absence
of intra-cranial lesion on the CT scan, a post-traumatic amnesia
period between one and 24 hours (Kosakevitch-Ricbourg, 2006).
GCS scores are widely used to quantify level of consciousness
in the pre-hospital environment.
Values for field GCS are highly predictive of arrival GCS,
and both are associated with outcome from traumatic brain
injury. A change in GCS from the field to arrival is highly
predictive of outcome (Davis et al., 2006).
Detailed clinical examination is of no diagnostic value in
detecting intracranial injuries found on head CT scan. A head
CT scan is considered essential in patients with observed
loss of consciousness or post-traumatic amnesia and GCS 13-15,
as part of their evaluation to avoid missing an intracranial
injury in the USA (Halley et al., 2004).
The British Medical Association has been campaigning vociferously
to illegalise boxing for many years (Sheldon, 2003).
There is an unfortunate belief within the national health
service, that injuries incurred as a consequence of full contact
sports, are self-inflicted and less deserving than injuries
from accidents outside sport. The cost of CT scanning all
head injuries is prohibitive. The decision to refer such a
head injury for tertiary assessment can often lie with the
most junior of medical staff in an A & E department, who
may be influenced by these prohibitions and due to high work
load may harbour prejudice against such "self-inflicted"
injuries. Patients with a cranial CT scan, that shows no intra-cerebral
injury and who do not have other body system injuries or a
persistence of any neurological finding can be safely discharged
from the emergency department without a period of either inpatient
or outpatient observation (Shackford et al., 1992).
Implementation of this practice could result in a potential
decrease of more than 500,000 hospital admissions annually
in the USA (Livingston et al., 2000).
|
|
| CONCLUSION |
| An
immediate examination post trauma can not diagnose or preclude an
intra-cranial haemorrhage. Because kicks to the head are the primary
target for an opponent's blows, karate practitioners are at risk of
acute and chronic neurological trauma. An episode of unconsciousness
and post-traumatic amnesia and a GCS < 15 should make CT scanning
mandatory. Workers within the NHS framework should receive further
training and education, which would help eliminate misconceptions
that sports injuries are 'self-inflicted' and hence, in some way,
'less deserving'. This case was one of the 62% and had a successful
outcome. The next case may be one of the 38% and may not! |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Head
injuries are common in full contact sports.
- GCS
is the examination of choice to determine neurological status
in the field.
- Detailed
neurological examination cannot detect intra-cerebral haemorrhage.
- 38%
of mild brain injuries result in intra-cerebral haemorrhage.
- Discussion
between clinicians in the field and hospital clinicians is necessary
to provide full details of the clinical picture to avoid premature
discharge.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Michael
GRAHAM
Employment: Senior Lecturer Health and Exercise Science
Research Unit, University of Glamorgan.
Degree: MbChB.
Research interests: Sports Medicine.
E-mail: mgraham@glam.ac.uk |
|
Bruce
DAVIES
Employment: Professor Applied Physiology, Health and Exercise
Science Research Unit, University of Glamorgan.
Degree: BSc, MSc, PhD.
Research interests: Cardiovascular disease.
E-mail: bdavies1@glam.ac.uk
|
|
Julien
Steven BAKER
Employment: Professor Applied Physiology, Health and Exercise
Science Research Unit, University of Glamorgan.
Degree: BA (Hons), MSc, PhD.
Research interests: High intensity exercise, oxidative
stress, muscle metabolism.
E-mail: jsbaker@glam.ac.uk |
|
|
|
|