|
DETERMINATION OF JUDO ENDURANCE PERFORMANCE USING THE UCHI - KOMI
TECHNIQUE AND AN ADAPTED LACTATE MINIMUM TEST
|
1Federal University of São Carlos, UFSCar, 2Faculty Orígenes Lessa, Department
of Physical Education, Lençóis, Paulista, 3Faculty Fênix, Anhanguera University,
Department of Physical Education, Bauru, 4Faculty of Physical Education,
University of Campinas, UNICAMP, 5Federal University of Rio de Janeiro,
Brazil.
| Received |
|
07 November 2006 |
| Accepted |
|
26
July 2007 |
| Published |
|
01
October 2007 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2007) 6(CSSI-2), 10 - 14
| ABSTRACT |
| This study aimed to evaluate the viability to use Uchi-komi (UK)
in the evaluation of the judo endurance performance and using lactate
threshold the analysis of the blood lactate ([Lac]) and heart rate
(HR) determined through a lactate minimum test. The subjects were
a group of 6 male, volunteer judokas, from 25.17 ± 5.76 years old,
weight 84.50 ± 23.78 kg and height 1.78 ± 0.10 m, competitors of different
levels of performance (from regional to international competitions)
and match experience of (11 ± 6) years old. Three tests were performed:
a) 3000 m dash in track, b) the adapted test of lactate minimum for
running and c) for UK, with execution of the blow ippon-seoi-nague.
No significant difference was evident for the track tests and UK in
relation to blood lactate and heart rate (p > 0.05) (3.87 ± 0.38
vs 4.17 ± 0.54 mmol·L-1 and 167 ± 2 vs 152 ± 7 b·min-1,
respectively). In conclusion it is stressed that: 1) The specific
test for lactate minimum in judo sport is a promising possibility
of aerobic capacity evaluation and a instrument of intensity training
control; 2) The metabolic profile in Vlm and UKlm is similar, because
there are not differences in the [Lac] and in the HR at this intensity;
3) It is possible to estimate the training intensity through the determination
of the lactate minimum intensity in running (Vlm) and the Heart Rate
associated (HR) from the execution of ippon-seoi- nague (uchi-komi)
in judo training; 4) The Vlm for judo athletes is approximately 88%
of the V3000.
KEY
WORDS: Judo, lactate threshold, heart rate, test, endurance.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Analysis
of lactate concentration in specific situations of judo has been
reported in order to obtain information on the metabolic demand
and implications for training intensities (Jacobs, 1986;
Majean and Gaillat, 1986).
Endurance training became extremely important to judo, due to inclusion
golden score at actual rules. According to this scoring process,
a match can last 10 minutes and, an athlete can perform more than
9 matches on the same day (Azevedo et al., 2004;
Castarlenas and Solé, 1997;
Taylor and Brassard, 1981).
In the same way, it was showed that judo athletes have low aerobic
capacity (see, for example, Drigo et al., 1994
and by Franchini et al., 2001
for male judo and female athletes, respectively). Azevedo at al
(2004)
indicates that the aerobic training for judo athletes is made by
running, this training is not specific for the judo sport. As showed
by Blais and Trilles, 2006
is fundamental form performance increase.
The anaerobic threshold determination from [Lac]b has been used
for the diagnosis of aerobic capacity and to determine exercise
intensities for training and scientific investigation (Simões et
al., 1999).
According to Denadai, 2000
terminology and references for anaerobic threshold can be divided
in two categories: 1) Thresholds that identifies the beginning of
lactate buildup in blood; 2) Thresholds that identifies the maximum
stead state of lactate in blood. Both categories field tests can
be used to identify sustainable intensity exercise (Simões et al.,
2005).
As exercise increases above a certain work rate threshold, an anaerobic
component of metabolism causes lactate to increase significantly.
The threshold at which this begins is termed the anaerobic threshold
(Beaver et al., 1986).
Tegtbur et al., 1993,
proposed a lactate minimum field test to evaluate the aerobic fitness
of runners and basketball players. The intensity associated to lactate
minimum is identified based on the lowest [Lac] during a incremental
test after high [Lac] induction (Simões et al., 2005).
Lactate minimum intensity has been considered a valid measure of
maximal lactate stead state to be the highest exercise intensity
that can be maintained during long term without blood lactate accumulation
(Bacon and Kern, 1999;
Ribeiro et al., 2003).
By our knowledge there are no studies with applied test of determination
lactate minimum in judo specific situation.
Taylor and Brassard, 1981
state that limited information about physical and physiological
characteristics of judo athletes are found in the literature. The
Despite its worldwide popularity judo specific research is still
limited. After 20 years, the situation is the same because it is
hard to describe a single physiological model of judo athletes due
to the large number of variables, such as: a) difficulty of quantifying
the effort during a match; b) weight categories; c) non-cyclic character;
match time can vary from some seconds to ten minutes; d) several
matches on the same day; e) difference on physical and technical
skills of the opponents (Castarlenas and Solé, 1997;
Majean et al., 1986;
Silva, 1988).
Castarlenas and Solé, 1997,
suggest that physical preparation should not be different from everyday
training with specific movements or match. Training should be based
on combining sport specific technical and physical activities (Azevedo
et al., 2004).
However, there are few specific tests in judo that can evaluate
the physical strength and endurance during a match and these tests
are not widely advertised (Carvalho, 2000).
Thus, studies are not so deeply developed because evaluations taken
from other sports do not reproduce specifically the intermittent
timing, non-cyclic movement, muscular groups involved, and metabolic
demand with large production of lactate that occur during training
and competition of judo.
Little, 1991
suggests that successful judo performance is dependent upon the
player having a high technical and tactical ability, power, strength,
endurance and flexibility. Therefore, this study aimed to create
a test to evaluate physical fitness in judo and compares results
of this lactate minimum test adapted to judo with running (Gold
Standard), given that endurance training improves the muscular capacity
of lactate use (Bonen et al., 2000;
Hamann et al., 2001)
and increases its transportation through the membrane via increase
of monocarboxilate transporter (MCT 1 and 4) (Bonen et al., 2000;
Green et al., 2002).
This physiological change helps the intramuscular pH stability by
retire H+ ions and retarded the fatigue (Poole and Halestrap, 1993).
| METHODS |
|
Subjects
A group of 6 male judokas volunteered to participate in the
study after being fully informed of the test requirements.
Subjects are 25.17 ± 5.76 years old (means ± SD), weight 84.50
± 23.78 kg and height 1.78 ± 0.10 m, competitors of different
levels of performance (from regional to international competitions)
and match experience of (11 ± 6) years old was utilized. All
subjects had more than 4 years experience with 5 subjects
as black belt and 1 as purple belt. All of the subjects were
advised not to have any extenuating physical practice 48 hours
before the tests.
Procedures
The study was approved by the Human Research Ethics Committee
of Federal University of São Carlos, as is required, before
obtaining written consent from the participants. After having
signed an informed consent form, the athletes performed 3
tests. Each test session began with the participant performing
his usual warm-up routine. The first test was a 3000 m time
trial (V3000). The orders of the next 2 sessions were randomized
and involved
a lactate minimum velocity (Vlm) and a lactate minimum
uchi-komi (UKlm). The heart rate (HR) was monitored continuously
during all tests using a Polar Accurex Plus (Kempele, Finland).
The
3000 m velocity test (V3000)
V3000 was calculated as the mean velocity over 3000 m distance.
V3000 has been associated with running velocity reached of
the maximum oxygen uptake (VO2max) (Silva et al.,
2005).
The velocities of the incremental stages for Vlm test was
calculated based on V3000. This test was undertaken on a 400m
coal based track with 100m demarcations (Simões et al., 2005).
Lactate
minimum velocity identification (Vlm)
The athletes first performed a maximal 40 s sprint as it was
a race in order to induce a high level of blood lactate concentration.
Then, after an 8 min of recovery, the athletes performed an
incremental running test consisting of 7x800 m bouts at intensities
corresponding to 76%, 80%, 84%, 88%, 92%, 96% and 100% of
participant's V3000. The running velocity was controlled
by sonorous stimulus (beepers) given to participant on specific
time intervals. Capillary blood (25 μl) was collected
from the earlobe on the 7th min of recovery after 40 s sprint
and during 1 min rest after each 800 m stage for [Lac] measurements
(YSI 1500 Sport model, OH, USA). A scatter graphic plotting
[Lac] response in relation to running velocities during test
was elaborated for each participant. The [Lac] response curve
was fitted to identify the lowest blood lactate during test
(Figure 1). The running
velocity associated with the lowest [Lac] identified the Vlm
as described previously (Simões et al., 2005;
Tegtbur et al., 1993).
Lactate
minimum intensities for judo (UKlm)
The athletes first performed a maximal 40 s uchi-komi (classical
drill training involves little or no movement contrary to
the requirements of competition) practicing technique of ippon-seoi
(is one of the twenty throwing techniques in the Nage No Te
list). Then, after an 8 min of recovery, the athletes performed
an incremental uchi-komi test consisting of 8x1 min bouts
at intensities corresponding to 8 s, 7 s, 6 s, 5 s, 4 s, 3
s, 2 s, 1 s each drills. The uchi-komi intensities was controlled
by sonorous stimulus
(beepers) given to participant on specific time intervals.
Capillary blood (25 l) was collected from the earlobe on the
7th min of recovery after 40 s maximal UK and during 1 min
rest after each 1 min stage for [Lac] measurements (YSI 1500
Sport model, OH, USA). A scatter graphic plotting [Lac] response
in relation to uchi-komi intensities during test was elaborated
for each participant. The [Lac] response curve was fitted
to identify the lowest blood lactate during test (Figure
2).
Statistical
analysis
The results are expressed in means, SD and SE for the studied
variables. Possible differences in blood lactate and Heart
Rate between track-tests and judo-tests trials were determined
by the Wilcoxon test. Significant differences were established
at p < 0.05 and the SPSS software, version 13.0 was used
for all analyses (Costa Neto, 1995;
Siegel, 1956).
|
|
| RESULTS |
|
The
Vlm and UKlm results were identified in all
participants (Figure 1 and
2). No differences were verified
between lowest [Lac] Vlm (3.87 ± 0.38 mmol·L-1)
and UKlm (4.17 ± 0.54 mmol·L-1) (means ± SE).
Also, no differences were verified between HR Vlm (167
± 2 b·min-1) and UKlm (152 ± 7 b.min-1)
(means ± SE).
The mean relative intensity of Vlm as related V3000 (% V3000) was
88.67 ± 2.75% (means ± SD) with mean velocity 180 ± 11.92 m·min-1.
The mean of intensity of UKlm was 2.5 ± 0.5 drills·s-1.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
The
mains contributions of the present work are: a) it was showed, in
a preliminary form, the possibility of diagnostic and control of
the intensity of training for judo athletes from specific techniques
and specific physiologic demands; b) there is an indicative that
the control of the intensity of UKlm can be made by HR
and Vlm parameters; c) from judo athletes, the Vlm
is near 88% from V3000.
For efficient control of training loads and performance, it is necessary
to evaluate the athlete at specifics situations, at least similar
to judo practice (Viru and Viru, 2003).
Searching for a specific evaluation of judo practice, we performed
this study with UK utilizing lactate minimum tests, a well-known
method for determination of anaerobic threshold, agreed at control
and diagnosis of training process (Azevedo et al., 2004,
Simões et al., 2005).
Heart rate monitoring is one of the assessments utilized at prescription
and assessment of training intensity and physical effort. In addition,
it is an inexpensive and accessible kind of evaluation (Lambert
et al., 1998;
Lucia et al., 2000).
During the test for lactate threshold, heart rate monitoring is
recorded to obtain correspondent value to the intensity of anaerobic
threshold. In this study, no difference was evident among heart
rate at Vlm (167 ± 2 b·min-1) and UKlm
(152 ± 7 b·min-1) (p > 0.05). The HR values find in
this work are minor than the values obtained in the running tests,
i.e, (178 ± 10 b·min-1) from Tegtbur et al., 1993
and (178 ± 11 b·min-1) from Simões et al., 1998.
This result is important because indicate that is possible to realize
only one test, running or judo specific test, and use HR in both
test for control of training intensity.
Data showed there is no difference between Vlm and UKlm
in relation to values of lactate at the intensity of lactate minimum.
This indicates that the metabolic demands in both exercises are
similar in the lactate minimum intensity. The difference between
the time on running and UK stage exercises do not shows influence
the [Lac] in the Vlm and UKlm. It was demonstrated
by Pardono et al. (2005)
that the methodological variations effects have not significant
influence on the determination of lactate minimum intensity in the
same ergometrics tests. Endurance training in the intensity of anaerobic
threshold is important to improve muscular capacity of using lactate.
It increases its transport through the membrane, due to increase
of monocarboxilate protein type I (MCT1 and MCT4) (Gladden, 2000)
and helps the maintenance of intramuscular pH by retire H+ ions,
retarded the fatigue (Poole and Halestrap, 1993).
Drigo et al., 1994
observed judokas aerobic fitness can present some deficit. They
performed a study with three different groups (G), all male subjects.
At the test of lactate threshold groups showed speed low: G1: 170.8
± 17.9 m·min-1; G2: 159.1 ± 35.5 m·min-1;
G3: 191.8 ± 23.5 m·min-1. The authors concluded the three
analyzed groups were not appropriately prepared aerobically and,
showed high lactate concentrations, which indicates that judo training
provokes metabolic alterations compatible to the need of the match.
In the present work, the running mean velocity in the anaerobic
threshold was 180.0 ± 11.9 m·min-1. This value is similar
to the value find by Azevedo et al., 2004,
for one international competitive athlete (174 m·min-1),
and Drigo et al., 1994
by using the fixed concentration methodology (4 mmol·L-1).
These results confirm the possibility of specific metabolic adaptation
for the sport or a low performance transference from judo to running.
Castarlenas and Solé, 1997,
Little, 1991
and Taylor and Brassard, 1981
found values of VO2max. at judokas weighting 57.5 (mL·kg-1·min-1)
average, showing that physical fitness is roughly important to maintain
the high intensity of the effort during a match (Franchini et al.,
2007),
the delay for evidence of high lactate concentration and, faster
recovery of the athlete between matches.
Concerning by the UKlm, the mean value is 2.5 drills·s-1.
This is the first value find by us in the literature for the lactate
threshold specifically applied to judo sport. Usually, the training
in the lactate threshold is associated with the aerobic performance
increase. In this sense, we can suggest that the judo training in
the UKlm intensity can increase the aerobic performance.
However, deeper analysis is necessary to confirm this possibility.
The main advantage of this training method is the possibility of
direct transference of the improvement obtained by specific aerobic
training to the mach situation, in the same way indicated by Blais
and Trilles, 2006
with strength training. It is important to stress that a good aerobic
capacity is important to maintain the high intensity in the mach
(Franchini et al., 2007).
|
| CONCLUSION |
|
It
is important to develop studies on judo physiology. This area is
not so explored in literature. In this work is presented a preliminary
investigation that permit concludes:
1.
The specific test for lactate minimum in judo sport is a promising
possibility of aerobic capacity evaluation and a instrument of intensity
training control.
2. The metabolic performance in Vlm and UKlm is similar, because
there are not differences in the [Lac] and in the HR.
3. It is possible to estimate the training intensity through the
determination of the lactate minimum intensity in running (Vlm)
and the Heart Rate associated (HR) from the execution of ippon-seoi-nague
(uchi-komi) in judo training.
4. The Vlm for judo athletes is approximately 88% of the V3000.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
-
The specific test for lactate minimum in judo sport is a promising
possibility of aerobic capacity evaluation;
- This
is a instrument for intensity training control for judo players;
- The
metabolic profile is similar between running and uki-komi (ippon-seoi-nague
techniques) at lactate minimum intensity.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Paulo
H.S.M. AZEVEDO
Employment: Prof., at Anhanguera University and Orígenes
Lessa Faculty. Associated Professor at Federal University of
São Carlos.
Degree: MSc.
Research interests: Exercise physiology, athletic training,
resistance exercise, human performance and fatigue.
E-mail: paulohazevedo@yahoo.com.br |
|
Alexandre
J. DRIGO
Employment: PhD Student at UNICAMP.
Degree: MSc.
Research interests: Martial arts and sports training.
E-mail: adrigo@linkway.com.br
|
|
Mauro
C.G.A. CARVALHO
Employment: Phys. Ed. Teacher, Federal University of Rio
de Janeiro, Brazil.
Degree: MSc, PhD student.
Research interests: Kinanthropometry, athletic training,
movement analysis, high performance computing.
E-mail: maurogurgel@gmail.com
|
|
João
C. OLIVEIRA
Employment: Associated Professor at Federal University of
São Carlos, Brazil.
Degree: MSc.
Research interests: Exercise Physiology and Resistance
Exercise.
E-mail: vertical@linkway.com.br
|
|
João
E.D. NUNES
Employment: Federal University of São Carlos.
Degree: MSc student.
Research interests: Exercise physiology and fatigue.
E-mail: jednunes@yahoo.com.br |
|
Vilmar
BALDISSERA
Employment: Professor at Federal University of São Carlos.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Human
and exercise physiology. |
|
Sérgio
E.A. PEREZ
Employment: Professor at Federal University of São Carlos.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Immunology
of exercise, exercise physiology. |
|
|
|
|