|
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN BODY COMPOSITION AND ANAEROBIC PERFORMANCE
OF ELITE YOUNG WRESTLERS
|
Trakya University Faculty of Medicine, Departments of Physiology, Edirne,
Turkey.
| Received |
|
22 January 2007 |
| Accepted |
|
06
September 2007 |
| Published |
|
01
October 2007 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2007)
6(CSSI-2), 34 - 38
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The purpose of the present study was to investigate the relationship
between body composition and anaerobic performance in young elite
wrestlers. Method: Eight female (age = 16.2 ± 1.1 yrs) and 8 male
(age = 17.3 ± 0.9 yrs) wrestlers from the Turkish cadet and junior
national team participated in this study. Fat free mass (FFM) and
percent fat mass (%FM) were carried out through electric bioimpedance.
Anaerobic performance was assessed by the Wingate test (load was calculated
as 0.090 kg x.kg-1 body mass). FFM was greater in male wrestlers [65.4
± 12.3 (kg)] than female wrestlers (45.1 ± 4.6 (kg) p < 0.01).
%FM was lower in male wrestlers (9.7 ± 6.3) than female wrestlers
(18.5 ± 2.8; p < 0.01). Peak power was significantly higher in
male wrestlers than female wrestlers (8.5 ± 1.0 W·kg-1 vs. 6.8 ± 0.6
W·kg-1; p < 0.01). Mean power was significantly correlated with
FFM in both genders (r = 0.73 p < 0.05 in female; r= 0.90 p <
0.05 in male). No relationship was obtained between anaerobic parameters
and %FM. In conclusion, our result demonstrated no association between
anaerobic parameters and %FM. Wrestlers and their coaches should take
into account FFM rather than %FM for higher anaerobic performance.
KEY
WORDS: Fat free mass, performance, female wrestling, Wingate
test, power.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Freestyle wrestling is one of the main styles of amateur competitive
wrestling. Other forms include female wrestling, Greco-Roman wrestling,
sambo, beach wrestling, grappling and traditional wrestling. Freestyle
wrestling is practiced in three two-minute periods with a 30-second
rest between rounds in current international competition. A wrestler
wins the match when he has won two out of three periods. Female
wrestling is classified as a different category because of the gender
difference although its rules are the same with free style wrestling
of men. A wrestling match requires tremendous physical activity,
power and strength of body musculature as well as isometric force
for various wrestling techniques (Horswill, 1992).
Power in wrestlers is related with quick and explosive effort that
leads to wrestling success (Lansky, 1999).
Anaerobic power and capacity are important in wrestling because
of the need of short-duration and high intensity performance. Wingate
test can be used to reflect the maximum ability of wrestlers to
generate power (Yoon, 2002).
Common wrestling types are freestyle, female and Greco-Roman wrestling
that can be defined as Olympic wrestling types and the collegiate
wrestling, which is common in the United States. Both Olympic and
collegiate wrestling tournaments are especially run at young ages.
The majority of wrestlers are concerned about the amount of body
weight because competitors are matched based on body-weight. They
generally want to minimize the body fat level and the total body
weight without losing their body strength and power (Yoon, 2002).
However, no relation was shown between the percentage of fat mass
(%FM) and the level of wrestling success (Horswill, 1992;
Yoon, 2002).
Since the information on anaerobic power and fatness in elite young
female and male wrestlers is limited, we investigated possible relationships
between the anaerobic performance and FFM and %FM of elite young
female and male wrestlers.
| METHODS |
|
Participants
Eighteen wrestlers (M/F, 8/8) aged between 15 and 19 yrs (mean
± SD, 16.6 ± 1.1), volunteered to participate in the study.
The participants were considered elite athletes since all
wrestlers had national and international degrees. All female
wrestlers and seven male wrestlers were the members of Turkish
women's and men's cadet national team. One male wrestler was
the member of Turkish junior national team. They qualified
for national competitions in Turkey, 36% of participants (n
= 6) achieved Turkish cadet level champion status, 81% of
participants (n = 13) achieved national degree in Turkey and
44% of participants (n = 8) achieved international degree.
The study was approved by the local ethics committee of Trakya
University. All wrestlers were assessed through the competitive
season. Details of the study were explained to each participant
and signed informed consent was obtained from the participants
or their parents whose children were below 18.. All participants
underwent a structured interview and all physical examinations
were performed by the same physician (AV). No participants
were declared any physical illnesses. A self-administered
questionnaire was used to assess age, participation age to
sports, and the amount of training in a week.
Measurements
of body fat
Body fat measurements were performed before Wingate anaerobic
test on the same day by bioelectrical body impedance analysis
(BIA) using a body fat analyzer (model Tanita TBF300 Japan.
Athletic programmed mode was selected prior to assessment.
Analyzer uses a 50-Hz current source with electrodes on each
foot to measure impedance
to electrical conductivity as it passes through body fluids
and calculates FFM, %FM and fat mass (FM). Measurements were
performed without accessories that contain metal (earrings,
belts, coins), and female wrestlers should not have a menstrual
period. To ensure normal hydration status for BIA testing,
participants were asked to adhere to the following pretest
requirements: (a) no vigorous exercise within 12 hours of
the test (b) no caffeine or alcohol consumption within 12
hours of the test. Participants verified adherence to these
instructions before testing. The reliability and validity
of BIA has been established in previous studies (Jackson et
al., 1988).
The results obtained by BIA are found comparable with the
results of other standard anthropometric methods such as skinfold
fat and hydrostatically measured percent fat.
Anaerobic
test
The Wingate test consisted of a 30-s supramaximal cycling
against a resistance load. Each test was performed on a Monark
cycle ergometer (Model 894-E) and the load was calculated
as 0. 090 kg x.kg-1 body mass for each participant.
The participants warmed up by pedalling for 3 min against
a 30 watt load. After 5 min rest period, by the command "start"
the participants began pedalling against a predetermined work
load. The participants were requested to pedal as fast as
possible to preserve maximal pedalling speed until the end
of the test period. Strong motivation was given verbally to
participants during the test. The data were used to calculate
peak power and mean power that can be seen elsewhere (Bar-Or
O. 1987).
Statistical
analysis
General characteristics of the participants were presented
as means and standard deviations. Statistical comparison of
the female and male groups was carried out using Mann Whitney-U
test. Spearman's correlation coefficients were used to express
the relationships between anaerobic test parameters and body
composition parameters (%FM and FFM). Interpretation of correlation
coefficients was as follows: r < 0.49 weak relationship;
0.50 < r < 0.74 moderate relationship;
and r > 0.75 strong relationship (Portney and Watkins,
2000).
A p value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
|
|
| RESULTS |
|
Demographic,
hemodynamic characteristics and sport history of the participants
were shown in Table 1. BMI
scores were not significantly different between female and male
groups. Mean diastolic blood pressure of female wrestlers was lower
than males (Table 1).
Anaerobic performance parameters obtained from Wingate test and
body fat measurements including FFM, %FM, FM were shown in Table
2. Peak power (W) was positively correlated with FFM (r = 0.81
p < 0.01) in male wrestlers. No significant correlation was found
between peak power (W) and FFM in female wrestlers. Mean power (W)
was significantly correlated with FFM in both females and males
(r = 0.73 p < 0.05; r= 0.90 p < 0.05 respectively). Minimum
(W) power was also positively associated
with FFM in female and male wrestlers (r = 0.71 p < 0.05, r=
0.83 p < 0.01 respectively). When participants of both genders
were examined as a whole, a strong relationship was obtained in
peak power (W) and FFM; mean power (W) and FFM; and minimum (W)
power and FFM values (Figure 1).
We also looked for the same relationship between relative (to body
weight) anaerobic power and body composition parameters. Peak power
(W·kg-1) and FFM (r = 0.49 p < 0.05); mean power (W·kg-1)
and FFM values (r = 0.55 p < 0.05) were moderately correlated
in whole group. In female wrestlers, %FM was not associated with
peak power (W) (r = 0.52 p=0.18), mean power (W) (r = 0.47 p = 0.23),
and minimum power (W) (r = 0.45 p = 0.26). In male wrestlers, no
relationship was found between peak power (W) and %FM (r = 0.40
p = 0.31); mean power (W) and %FM (r = 0.33 p = 0.41), and minimum
power (W) and %FM (r = 0.30 p = 0.41).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
In
the present study, the relationship between anaerobic performance
and body composition in elite female and male wrestlers were investigated.
Our study demonstrated that changes in peak power are primarily
related with FFM in young male wrestlers. Mean power and minimum
power were significantly associated with FFM in both female and
male wrestlers. However, no significant correlation was found between
anaerobic parameters and %FM in both genders.
Body fat includes lipids from adipose and other body tissues. In
general, most wrestlers attempt to have a very small percentage
of body fat, as they are matched by body-weight prior to each meet.
Eventually, optimal body composition is one of the major concerns
of the wrestlers. Wrestlers and coaches consider %FM as a factor
that must be taken under control. It is believed that lower %FM
values are advantageous. Our study suggested that FFM rather than
%FM may be a predictor of anaerobic performance in wrestlers. In
accordance with our study, previous studies demonstrated that changes
in power are primarily related with FFM in young male wrestlers
(Kelly et al., 1978;
Roemmich and Sinning, 1996;
1997).
It was shown that insufficient dietary intake reduces protein nutrition,
impairs muscular performance and decreases FFM levels (Roemmich
and Sinning, 1997).
FFM changes were associated with the changes in strength and power
during the sport season (Roemmich and Sinning, 1997).
The mean peak power of male wrestlers was 8.5 W·kg-1
in our study group. In a previous study, similar peak power values
were reported (Horswill et al., 1989).
The mean peak power value of elite male wrestlers (age = 17.0 ±
0.2 yrs) was reported as 8.6 W/kg in this study (Horswill et al.,
1989).
However, peak power values in our study seem somewhat lower than
those of several reports (Horswill, 1992;
Horswill et al., 1992).
For example a study of elite senior wrestlers above 20 years old,
peak anaerobic power for legs was reported as 10.8 W·kg-1
(Horswill et al., 1992).
Horswill, 1992
reported the mean range of peak power as 11.5 to 19.9 W·kg-1
in successful wrestlers. All above studies, 0.075 kg x.kg-1
of the wrestlers' mass is used as a load during the Wingate Test
(Horswill et al., 1989;
Horswill et al., 1992).
However, the load was set at 0.090 kg x.kg-1 body weight
for participants in our study. The lower peak power values of male
wrestlers may result from loading methodology (higher resistance
load) in Wingate Test. Age difference also can be considered as
another factor. Additionally, we could not find any related study
that is performed similar resistance load and similar age group
in female wrestlers to compare our peak power values.
Yoon, 2002
stated that the percentage of body fat ranges from 3 to 13 in well-trained
wrestlers. The range of % FM extends from about 4 to 9% with the
exception of super heavy-weights (Yoon, 2002).
In a previous study, it was demonstrated that %FM value of adolescent
male wrestlers was 8.03 (Roemmich and Sinning, 1997).
In another study, %FM of young male wrestlers was found as 8.4 (Silva
et al., 1981).
Mean %FM value of our male wrestlers was 9.7%. This value was similar
to the mean %FM values of the wrestlers of previous studies.
The present study included both male and female wrestlers. %FM in
female wrestlers is significantly higher than the males as expected.
In our study, mean value of %FM was 18.5 in female wrestlers. No
related study was found in female wrestlers to compare %FM with
our female wrestlers in the same age group. However, various levels
of %FM values were reported in elite female athletes in the same
age group and different sport types. For example, the %FM of adolescent
female distance runners, Greek rhythmic gymnastics and Canadian
rhythmic gymnastics was reported as 23.9%, 14.3 % and 16.2%, respectively
(Klentrou and Plyley, 2003;
Mitsuzono and Ube, 2006).
A recent study by Hubner-Wozniak et al. (2004)
demonstrated that males had higher peak power and mean power than
females after normalization for body mass and FFM of elite female
and male wrestlers. Our study population was comprised of age-matched
elite female and male wrestlers. The mean BMI values were also similar
in female and male wrestlers in our study. Considering their FFM
male wrestlers were greater than the females. Therefore we could
not obtain the normalization of FFM levels in our limited study
population.
Further studies that provide FFM normalization in both genders would
better explain the relationship between anaerobic performance and
body composition.
|
| CONCLUSION |
| Our
study demonstrated that peak power was significantly associated with
FFM in young male wrestlers. Additionally, mean power and minimum
power were significantly associated with FFM in both female and male
wrestlers. We described % FM values as 9. 7 in male and 18.5 in young
female wrestlers. No relationship was found between anaerobic parameters
and %FM in the present study. Our study suggested that both female
and male wrestlers and their coaches should take into account FFM
levels rather than %FM for higher anaerobic performance. |
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
| We
wish to thank elite wrestlers, their parents and Turkish national
wrestling team coach, Habil Kara for their participation and cooperation
throughout the data collection process. |
| KEY
POINTS |
-
Mean power and fat free mass association was obtained from both
genders.
- Anaerobic
performance parameters obtained from Wingate Test were positively
associated with fat free mass but not % fat mass in elite young
wrestlers.
- %
FM values were 18.5 in young female wrestlers, and it was 9.7
in male wrestlers.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Selma
Arzu VARDAR
Employment: Ass. Prof., Trakya University, Faculty of Medicine,
Department of Physiology Edirne, Turkey.
Degree: MD, PhD.
Research interests: The response of women to exercise,
cardiovascular effects of melatonin, the effect of exercise
on sleeping.
E-mail: arzuvardar@trakya.edu.tr |
|
Selin
TEZEL
Employment: Assistant, Trakya University, Faculty of Medicine,
Department of Physiology Edirne, Turkey.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: The response of women to exercise.
E-mail: tezelselin@yahoo.co.uk
|
|
Levent
ÖZTÜRK
Employment: Asc. Prof., Departments of Physiology, Trakya
University, Edirne, Turkey.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Sleep physiology, sleep and exercise
interactions, sleep related breathing disorders.
E-mail: leventozturk@trakya.edu.tr
|
|
Oktay
KAYA
Employment: Assistant, Trakya University, Faculty of Medicine,
Department of Physiology Edirne, Turkey.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Tha effects of anaerobic exercise
on athletes.
E-mail: doctoroktay@yahoo.com
|
|
|
|
|