COMPARISON OF VISUAL ACUITY IN REDUCED LUMINATION AND FACILITY OF
OCULAR ACCOMMODATION IN TABLE TENNIS CHAMPIONS AND NON- PLAYERS |
Optometry Department of Iran University of Medical Science (IUMS), Tehran,
Iran
| Received |
|
27 October 2003 |
| Accepted |
|
30
January 2004 |
| Published |
|
01
March 2004 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2004) 3, 44-48
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
|
A
table tennis player should fixate at different distances; track
the objects with different speed, and in different visual environment.
Their visual skills must be well developed for these capabilities.
Therefore, visual acuity in reduced lumination and facility of ocular
accommodation those are two criteria for visual skills have been
compared in table tennis players and normal non-players. Twenty-nine
young table tennis champions and 29 normal matched non-players (did
not take part in any racket sports game) were evaluated. Basic visual
and eye examinations were done for both of them. Normal results
in basic examination were fundamental requirement for all the subjects.
+/-2.00 sphere lenses for accommodation facility are used. An electrical
current regulator changed the output light intensity of a conventional
chart projector (Topcon). Light intensity decreased to 10 cd·m-2
and visual acuity tested. In comparison of visual acuity in reduced
lumination and facility of ocular accommodation in table tennis
champions and non-players there are significant differences (p <
0.001). In the preliminary visual tests there was not any significant
different in the two groups but the results in the top level table
tennis player was very uniform and in every test and the standard
deviation was lesser in tennis player group than non-players. These
results show that motor and sensorial functions of expert players
are well developed. That is consistent with other researchers. This
result was interpreted as reflecting a better perceptual system
of experts to the constraints encountered during table tennis and
its use in practical settings for evaluating athletes or detecting
sport talents. However some visual and perceptual training that
usually used in orthoptics can be used for novice table tennis player
to improve their abilities.
KEY WORDS: Racket sports, visual acuity, and ocular accommodation,
table tennis.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
In
the second century Galen (131-201) believed that there is a relation
between ball sports and body and visual status (Hitzeman and Beckerman,
1993). Despite
this primary point of view about visual importance in sports, it
has been forgotten for many years. In the middle of 20th
century new scientific opinions for sports were developed. They
think that sports are a multidisciplinary approach. Science and
technology developments influence sports prominently. All the sports
game may develop human sensory and motor systems. But every one
may influence specific system selectively.
Table
tennis is a dynamic sport that training of sensory and motor systems
may be more influence in expert performance (Seve et al., 2003).
Different sensorial and motor systems actively contribute the sportsman
achievements or failures. Three-dimensional kinematics analysis
of line-of-gaze, arm and ball was used to describe visual and motor
behavior. This study determines the role of head, eye and arm movements
during the execution of a table tennis forehand stroke (Rodrigues
et al., 2002).
The conceptual and methodological frameworks of co-ordination dynamics
can be applied, appropriately, to the analysis of discrete movements
in table tennis players (Sorensen et al., 2001).
Table tennis players use saccadic eye movement, in saccadic eye
movement first and last point of fixation is very important (Ripoll
and Latiri, 1997).
Therefore, accommodative system should follow fixation point appropriately.
Visual system is an important sensorial and motor coordinator of
human activities. Skilled players were faster than their less skilled
counterparts in anticipating the direction of opponents' tennis
strokes, with this superior performance being based, at least in
part, on more effective visual search behaviors (Williams et al.,
2002). The similar
results for visual system can be found in other researches (Totterdell,
2000; Abernethy
et al., 2001;
Fery and Crognier, 2001;
Rowe and McKenna, 2001).
There are many connections between visual system and postural and
proprioceptive systems. A table tennis player should fixate on a
small ball that moves very rapidly in the free space with lack of
spatial clue. Additionally he should see the opponent and table
simultaneously. These visual actions take place in reduce contrast
and dynamic fixation environments.
According
to this situation the player should change his accommodation very
rapidly and correctly. However they should be able to retain their
visual performance in spite of reduced contrast and luminance differences
of objects.
It seems that the functions of the visual system in table tennis
players may be more developed, and some visual skills in table tennis
players may be better than the novice. If it so, we must try to
find out, which skill may be more prominent. Therefore two visual
skills; visual acuity in reduced lumination and facility of ocular
accommodation in table tennis champions and non-players was compared.
|
| METHODS |
|
Twenty-nine
expert table tennis players were chosen. These young male (18-25
years old) had at least five years experience and they were champion
in different national and international games. The main inclusive
criterion for champion invitation was their championship. According
to table tennis ranking in Iran we call them on from top to down,
and explained about the research. A specific time was fixed for
every one. The elites were evaluated for any systemic and visual
problems. They were asked about any history of medication and systemic
disease. The following visual and ocular tests have been done for
them.
-
Visual acuity test with Topcon chart projector at six meter and
Snellen near acuity chart for forty centimetres. These tests have
been done in photopic condition.
-
Objective refraction by static retinoscopy and autorefractometry
and subjective refraction including: visual acuity, cross cylinder,
Bichrome test has been done for every subject. Hyperopia lesser
than 0.75, myopia, against the rule and oblique astigmatism lesser
than 0.25 and with the rule astigmatism lesser than 0.5 considered
normal and accepted in this study.
-
Ocular motility evaluations consist of heterophoria and fusional
vergence recording at far and near distance. The results assessed
according to compensation criteria.
-
Amplitude of accommodation measured by push up technique.
-
Biomicroscopy and ophthalmoscopy of the eye for all the subjects.
The
entire tests for two groups were done in the clinic of the optometry
in the Iran University of Medical Science (IUMS).
The
table tennis champions compared with non-players. The control group
age, education and sex were the same and similar visual and ocular
exam were done for every subject. We try to match a champion with
a specific non-player with same age, education and sex. According
to an Iranian law "Every champion can enter the university (usually
in sports college or university) without any qualifying entrance
exam". Therefore most of champions are student and we could select
the control group from other male students in IUMS. The systemic
and medication history evaluated in same manner. Every person in
the control group matched by an elite.
The
main difference between table tennis player and control group was
that, they don't play any ball- racket games seriously or even as
a hobby.
After
preliminary exams a code assign to every person in two groups. An
optometrist that didn't know about subject's group measured the
acuity in reduced luminance and facility of accommodation. He used
+/-2.00 sphere lenses for accommodation facility. A near chart positioned
at 40 centimetres in front of subject. He instructed to fixate at
20/25 row in well illuminated examine room (Griffin, 1988).
The subject should read aloud every optotype that optometrist wants.
At the same time the flipper power change. The subject asked about
clearance of optotypes. The optometrist waits for clear vision in
every change of flipper. He counts the cycles of flipper changes
per a minute as a criterion for accommodation facility.
Acuity
in reduced luminance is another test that the examiner did not know
about the subject's group. A conventional visual acuity chart projector
(Topcon, Japan) used for acuity measurement. An electrical current
regulator changed the output light intensity of projector. Light
intensity at acuity screen measured by a photometer (Leibold, Germany).
Light intensity decreased to 10 cd·m-2 and visual acuity tested.
For all the subject acuity measurement is done according to 75%
correct answer for every row. All data was recorded in a specific
record card that its code is unique for every person. The data analyzed
statistically by Statgraphics statistical package.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Descriptive
and analytic statistics have been you for recorded data. As it shown
in table 1 the average and
standard deviation of the conventional acuity measurements in two
groups are the same. This result is predictable because one of the
inclusive criterions for groups was 20/20 or better conventional
acuity.
The
equivalent sphere of the recorded refractive error shows that ametropia
is lesser in table tennis players. However there is not a significant
difference between two groups. The standard deviation is lesser
in elite; it is mean that inter-subjects differences are lesser
in this group. All of the results in preliminary exams aren't the
same in two groups, but the differences are not significant. The
results of preliminary exam in table tennis player are better than
non-player. The average and SD of results are better in champions.
Two
variables that evaluated in two groups are significantly different
in table tennis player and non-players (Table
1). Facility of accommodation is significantly (p < 0.001) better
in table tennis players. In facility test, as it shown in table
1, the frequency of clearance in sports man is 14 cpm but in
other group it is 9 cpm. Visual acuity in reduced lumination is
also significantly (p < 0.01) different in two groups. As it shown
in table 1 acuity reduction
in non-player is more prominent. In other word sports man can retain
20/20 acuity despite of luminance reduction. This is seen in a situation
that all first acuity measurement was the same. Acuity changes and
inter-subject differences in champion were lesser. It means that
acuity is more stable in champions.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
As
the results shows there is significant differences between facility
of accommodation and acuity in reduced lumination in champions and
normal non-players. Development of these two parameters may improve
the efficiency of visual system.
Facility
development may shorten the time that visual system needs for taking
a clear image. In table tennis fixation points change as fast as
the ball and opponent velocity change. The velocity of ball is very
high and the eyes should clearly see it. Therefore any person that
can follow the ball as fast as possible, he would be more successful.
Saccadic eye movements are used for fixation on the ball (Ripoll
and Latiri, 1997).
Suppression takes place in saccadic eye movements. Only the first
and last point of fixation can be seen and along the saccadic pathway
suppressed (Ripoll and Latiri, 1997).
Therefore the first and last point is very important from visual
acuity point of view. A table tennis player should change his accommodation
as fast as his saccadic eye movements for his achievements. There
is close relationship between accommodative system and vergence
and binocular vision system (Griffin, 1988).
Binocular vision improvement factors usually improve facility of
accommodation and also binocular vision anomalies cause anomalies
of accommodation (Pickwell, 1986).
Table tennis improves binocular vision (Ripoll and Latiri, 1997)
therefore; it may cause improvement of accommodation facility.
Another
point that may explain improvement of accommodation facility in
table tennis players is autonomic system. Accommodation controlled
by autonomic system and recent study (Ferrauti et al., 2001)
shows that autonomic system in tennis players may be more efficient.
It seems all the above-mentioned factors may improve the facility
of accommodation.
Acuity
in reduced lumination is another skill that evaluated in this study.
As it shown there is a significant (p < 0.01) differences between
table tennis players and non-players. Visual acuity test is one
of psychophysical tests. In psychophysical tests the respond of
subject depends on peripheral and central nervous system, but perceptual
centers involve prominently in the respond process. It seems perceptual
systems are more efficient in champions. Other studies in racket-ball
sports (Totterdell, 2000;
Abernethy et al 2001;
Fery and Crognier, 2001;
Rowe and McKenna, 2001;
Williams et al., 2002)
show that sensory; motor and perceptual conditions in champions
are more efficient than novice and non-players. An expert player
should anticipate ball trajectory, direction of opponents' strokes,
opponent's stroke movements, and opponent's pattern of play. Also
temporal and spatial judgments of ball, environment and opponent
in a short time should be done. And specific motor abilities for
effective visual search must be considered for any successful player
(Totterdell 2000;
Abernethy et al., 2001;
Ferrauti et al., 2001;
Fery and Crognier, 2001;
Rowe and McKenna, 2001;
Williams et al., 2002).
Naturally the above sensory, motor and perceptual advantage of elite
may result better psychophysical performance of champions (Vergauwen
et al., 1998).
Reduced
lumination cause Purkinje shift. Visual acuity in Purkinje shift
would be reduced (Boyce, 1973).
As it shown in this study, better acuity can be seen in table tennis
players than non-player in reduced lumination. According to this
study and similar studies we can deduct that table tennis player
can retain good visual acuity despite of unsuitable environmental
conditions.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
Two
visual skills, facility of accommodation and visual acuity in reduced
lumination, are shown that significantly developed in table tennis
players. In this study we just describe the visual performance of
table tennis players and non-players in restricted aspects. This study
shows that the visual skills may be different in table tennis players
and non-players. We don't know the visual skills development is a
primary phenomenon, i.e. every person with well-developed visual skills
progress very fast in table tennis, or it is secondary to table tennis
practice. Nevertheless, the main point is that, the visual skills
are very important in table tennis players.
The other point that may be interesting for further research is the
quantitative evaluation of visual skills developments in table tennis
players. If the visual skills are primary in table tennis players,
it will be useful for better evaluation and selection of the players.
If it is secondary to table tennis practice, orthoptics and visual
skills development by special training will be considered.
Other visual skills should be tested in another research. Other visual
skills may be more descriptive and determinative in table tennis players.
At the end, it should be mentioned that the couches and talent scouts
should not concentrate only on the physical performance of players.
They should be aware that, the vision is a factor that may influence
the physical performance of an athlete.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
-
That the ability of a champion depends on many sensory, motor
and perceptual factors.
-
Visual factors such as facility of accommodation and visual acuity
in reduced lumination should be considered in table tennis players.
-
Visual training may be useful for novice and also for experts.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
|
Ebrahim JAFARZADEHPUR
Employmen:tAssistant Professor of Iran University of Medical
Science
Degree: BSc. MSc. PhD
Research interests: Sports vision, VEP and psychophysics
Email:jafarzadehpur@iums.ac.ir
|
|
|
Mohammad R. YARIGHOLI
Employment:optometrist
Degree:
BSc
Research interests: Sports vision
|
|
|
|
|