A
KINEMATIC STUDY OF FINSWIMMING AT SURFACE
|
1Laboratoire Adaptation Perceptivo-Motrice et Apprentissage,
Université Paul Sabatier, Toulouse, France.
2Laboratoire d'Aérodynamique et de Biomécanique du Mouvement,
Université de la Méditerranée, Marseille, France
| Received |
|
29 August 2004 |
| Accepted |
|
19
May 2004 |
| Published |
|
01
June 2004 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2004) 3, 91-95
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Finswimming
is a sport of speed practiced on the surface or underwater, in which
performance is based on whole-body oscillations. The present study
investigated the undulatory motion performed by finswimmers at the
surface. This study aiming to analyze the influence of the interaction
of gender, practice level, and race distance on selected kinematic
parameters. Six elite and six novices finswimmers equipped with joints
markers (wrist, elbow, shoulder, hip, knee, and ankle) were recorded
in the sagittal plane. The position of these anatomical marks was
digitized at 50 Hz. An automated motion analysis software yielded
velocity, vertical amplitude, frequency, and angular position. Results
showed that stroke frequency decreased whereas the mean amplitude
of all joints increased with increasing race distance (p < 0.01).
Mean joint amplitude for the upper limbs (wrist, elbow and shoulder)
was smaller for experts than for novices. Whereas that of the ankle
was larger, so that the oscillation amplitude increased from shoulder
to ankle. Elite male finswimmers were pitching more acutely than female.
Moreover, elite male finswimmers showed a smaller knee bending than
novices and than elite females (p < 0.01). This indicated that
elite male finswimmers attempt to reduce drag forces thanks to a weak
knee bending and a low upper limbs pitch. To sum up, gender, expertise,
and race distance affect the performance and its kinematics in terms
frontal drag. Expertise in finswimming requires taking advantage of
the mechanical constraints pertaining to hydrodynamic constraints
in order to optimize performance.
KEY
WORDS: Swimming, undulations, technique, movement.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Finswimming
is a speed competition sport practiced at the surface or underwater
with different monofins of variable rigidity. Alike the motion of
dolphins (Videler, 1981),
propulsion bears on the vertical displacement of the whole body.
The use of the upper body is forbidden for propulsion purposes.
The vertical displacement of the body during the stroke cycle has
been described as wave-like (Ungerechts, 1982).
Since such motion could be characterized by specific amplitudes
of oscillations. Such oscillations were also specified by a particular
frequency and phase relationship (Sanders et al., 1995).
Our knowledge on finswimming bears mostly on underwater finswimming.
It was shown that the wave-like motion traveled along the body in
the caudal direction and that finswimmers adapted their undulations
in frequency and amplitude, starting the propulsive motion at the
hip level (Baly et al., 2002).
Nevertheless, because of the air-water interface, finswimmers' motion
is quite different in amplitude and frequency at the surface than
underwater.
Concerning finswimming at the surface, Zamparo et al. (2002)
performed a kinematic study that quantified the efficiency of human
swimming in using fins. Another study revealed the effect of the
monofin shape on the propulsive forces by analyzing the change in
the swimmer's velocity over one cycle of the monofin's motion (Tamura
et al., 2002).
Finally, a finswimmer is at one and the same time a propelling and
a propelled body. Given the speed reached (3.89 m·s-1),
body pitch and knee bending must be weak in order to limit the frontal
surface area, as defined by Vogel (1994),
a main factor of hydrodynamic resistance. The gliding and the propulsion
must be finely tuned in order to optimize performance. A previous
study at the surface showed that the race distance and practice
level increase the stroke frequency and the ankle vertical amplitude
(Gautier et al., 2004).
However the gender influence on kinematic parameters was not taken
into consideration.
In the present study, we hypothesized that the gender affects finswimming
performance in association with the practice level and the race
distance. Thus, we aimed to quantify finswimming at the surface
in terms of kinematic parameters such as the swimming speed, the
movement excursion, and the degree of knee bending according to
gender, race distance and practice level. Their analysis may provide
information useful to coaches and technicians in order to reduce
drag of the finswimmer.
|
| METHODS |
|
The
experiment was carried out in a 50 m pool. Six elite finswimmers
members of French National Team (3 males, 3 females) and six novices
(3 males, 3 females) who started competition six months ago participated
on a voluntary basis. For the elite group, average age was 20 ±
4 years, body mass 69.1 ± 8.1 kg, and stature 1.74 ± 0.8 m. For
the novices, average age was 25 ± 3 years, body mass 64.6 ± 5.2
kg, and stature 1.69 ± 0.4 m. Finswimmers were instructed to perform
3 random trials of 25 m per race distance (100 m and 800 m). Using
a snorkel, finswimmers performed trials with their standard monofins.
Passive disk markers were applied on selected joints to facilitate
their tracking and video analysis: wrist, elbow, shoulder, hip,
knee, and ankle were visible to the camera throughout the stroke
cycle. Video images were collected from two digital cameras (SONY
VX-2000E, 50Hz). One digital camera was immerged and securely fixed
in a watertight box at 0.15 m below the water surface and recorded
in sagittal plane. A calibration was carried out separately for
each trial, at the middle tank and 5.34 m away from the camera.
The width of the optical field of view in the plane of motion was
6 m. The other digital camera (SONY VX-2000E, 50Hz) was placed in
the axe of the first to record motion above the water in order to
control whether the whole body was kept underwater, except for the
snorkel, vertex, and heel.
The markers were semi automatically tracked (3D Vision, Kihopsys).
The analysis period comprised one complete stroke cycle starting
from the video frame corresponding to the first whole body appearance.
Body marks were seized to determine a 5-segment human model: forearm,
arm, trunk, thighs, and shank. The knee bending angle was determined
using the relative angle between the distal extension joint center
of the thigh and the shank. As for all biomechanical data, random
error from the digitizing process was reduced using a recursive
fourth-order Butterworth digital filter with a frequency cut off
at 4 Hz.
The analysis consisted of a repeated measures ANOVA with gender
(male vs. female) and expertise level (novice vs. expert) as between-subject
factors, and distance (100 m vs. 800 m) as within-subject factor
(N = 12). The dependant variables were the velocity, the amplitude
and the frequency of oscillation, and the knee angle. All effects
were declared significant at a threshold of p < 0.05.
|
| RESULTS |
|
The
average speed for 800 m was lower than for 100 m for the experts
(2.09 m·s-1 ± 0.17 m·s-1 and 2.66 m·s-1
± 0.26 m·s-1, respectively). Novices were slower than
experts (1.69 m·s-1 ± 0.11 m·s-1 and 2.07
m·s-1 ± 0.18 m·s-1 respectively). Irrespective
of the distance, males were faster than females (2.58 m·s-1
± 0.40 m·s-1 vs. 2.15 m·s-1 ± 0.31 m·s-1).
Table 1 shows that the average
frequency of stroke cycle decreased with increasing distance for
both experts and novices (p < 0.01). On 800 m, novices were slower
than elite finswimmers, although their frequency was higher. Such
frequency was higher for males (1.61 Hz) than female (1.22 Hz) on
100 m as well as on 800 m males (0.81 Hz vs. 0.61 Hz, respectively).
Figure 1 indicates that the amplitude of body oscillation increased
as a function of race distance (p < 0.01) for all expertise levels.
The upper limbs amplitude of oscillation (i.e., wrist, elbow, and
shoulder) was smaller for experts than for novices. Concerning the
lower limbs (hip, knee, and ankle), only the amplitude at the ankle
level was larger for experts than for novices. There was non difference
between male and female in vertical ankle amplitude (0.56 m vs.
0.51 m, respectively). However, wrist amplitude was significantly
lower in female (0.22 m) than in male (0.26 m).
Knee bending was a factor of performance as a function of the expertise
(p < 0.01) associated with the important vertical amplitude of
the ankle. Bending for experts was smaller than for novices (119.25
± 3.31 deg. and 104.60 ± 4.96 deg. respectively on 100m). On the
800 m, novices' knee bending was higher than the elite's one (94.85
± 7.30 deg. vs. 108.87 ± 6.61 deg.). However, such main effects
on knee bending were comprised within a 4-way gender x race distance
x practice interaction. This result will be discussed in the following
part.
|
| DISCUSSION |
The
present study investigated the undulation motion performed by finswimmers
at the surface, aiming to uncover the influence of gender, practice
level, and race distance on selected kinematic parameters.
The undulation frequency and the swimming speed decreased with the
increasing race distance from 100 m to 800 m for both expertise levels.
This suggests an adaptive decrement in the energy expenditure for
long races. Moreover, although novices were slower than experts on
800 m, they showed a higher frequency. Novices seem thus to rush their
action, privileging muscular strength and quick motion in a attempt
to swim faster. This point to a lack of efficiency in the novices'
stroke technique.
While stroke frequency decreased with increasing race distance, mean
joint amplitude increased, irrespective of the expertise level. This
also suggests that both novices and experts can adapt their energy
output. Regarding motion amplitude, the experts' upper limbs appeared
to act as a stabilizing device. Expert finswimmers limit potential
energy due to upper limbs oscillation in order to increase kinetic
energy. In contrast, novices' larger upper limbs amplitude and lower
speed indicate that potential energy is not transformed in to kinetic
energy as efficiently. Such an inefficacy is reinforced by the fact
that their shoulder operated as a pivot point, so that the body behaved
as a pendulum rather than as an element along which a wave was transmitted,
and by the fact that their frontal area was wider due to their larger
upper limbs amplitude. In addition, the novices' shoulder was nearer
to the snorkel, as they were privileging breathing and were not as
used to submerge their head as elite finswimmers. They did not take
advantage of buoyancy to balance their upper limbs. Note that underwater,
the undulatory motion starts from the hip down to the ankle (Baly
et al., 2002),
whereas at the surface this motion basically starts from the shoulder
for novices.
Regarding gender, females were slower than males, and their stroke
frequency was lower. Females' upper limbs oscillation was larger,
while that of the lower limbs was smaller. In spite of such a large
lower limbs oscillation and an important knee bending, males were
faster than females. They appear to take most advantage of the maximal
acceleration generated at the moment of down-kick than female (Tamura
et al., 2002).
The experts' vertical amplitude at the ankle was larger than for novices
irrespective of the
race distance. Likewise, thanks to the stabilizing role of the upper
limbs and the resulting streamlining, the energy gained and stored
was used to increase the ankle vertical amplitude. Therefore the speed
reached by male finswimmers might be due to the potential energy generated
by the wrist amplitude, which is transformed in kinetic energy and
transmitted caudally, in the line of the suggestion made by Sanders
et al. (1995). That
amplitude increased from hip to ankle in elite finswimmers, particularly
on 800 m, suggests a whip-like action (Ungerechts, 1982).
Both the reduction of frequency and the rising of ankle amplitude
induced a relief in the foot pain resulting from the friction and
the rigidity of the monofin. Nevertheless, standard monofin with specific
length and rigidity allowed to reach an amplitude and a frequency
most adept to the race. As suggested by Videler and Kamermans (1985)
for dolphins, elite finswimmers seem to beneficiate from a large propellant
area and to accelerate during downstroke, which they optimized by
setting both a gliding and a propellant phase. Interlimb dissociation
allowed elite finswimmers to reach and to preserve their high speed
and to achieve the best performance.
Expert male finswimmers exhibited a smaller knee bending than females
of the same expertise and than male novices, inducing a limitation
in frontal drag. Indeed, at the surface, the body has better be always
profiled.
In comparison to underwater results reported by Baly et al. (2002),
the experts' upper limbs were used as a stabilizing device at the
surface too. For novices however, an efficient oscillation starts
at the shoulder level at the surface, whereas it starts at the hip
level underwater. Stroke frequency at surface is higher than underwater
for the same race distance, whereas the ankle amplitude is bigger.
For both surface and underwater swimming, hip and knee amplitude of
oscillation is almost similar. Interestingly, our out-water camera
did not record any marker. This suggests that even in surface swimming,
finswimmers tended to operate in a quasi-underwater situation, probably
because underwater swimming is faster than doing so at the surface.
The ankle amplitude was larger underwater than at the surface, despite
the lower hip angular excursion. Such results may be understood by
the larger mass of water efficiently used underwater.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
Finswimmers
cannot get away from body streamlining in order to reach high level
of performance through the adaptation of stroke frequency and motion
amplitude to the constraints of a race at the surface. Elite male
finswimmers achieve such a feat thanks to a weaker knee bending and
a low upper limbs pitching, reducing concomitantly their frontal area
and drag. Moreover, they optimally transform potential energy into
kinetic energy during stroke cycles and transfer it caudally, tantamount
contributing to a propulsive whip-like action. Expertise may be conceived
as taking advantage of the mechanical constraints pertaining to hydrodynamics
in order to optimize performance. This empirical study represents
a first if incomplete step towards a more thorough modeling of finswimming.
|
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
We
would like to thank Mr. Scribot at the CREPS in Toulouse for his logistic
support. We are also grateful to the Extrem Vision Company for its
technical aid.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
- Finswimmers
are at one and the same time a propelling and a propelled body.
This study investigates the undulatory motion performed by finswimmers
at the surface.
- Elite
male finswimmers were pitching more acutely than female swimmers
and showed a smaller knee bending than both novices and elite
female swimmers.
- Finswimmers
tended to perform a dolphin-like motion, which is used underwater
situation and optimizes hydrodynamics.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Jimmy GAUTIER
Employment: Doctoral Student
Degree: MS in sports sciences
Research interests: Biomechanics of sports gestures.
E-mail: jgautier@cict.fr
|
|
Laurent BALY
Employment: Project manager
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Biomechanics of sport
E-mail: laurent.baly@decathlon.com
|
|
|
Pier-Giorgio ZANONE
Employment: Professor
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Dynamics of coordination and learning
E-mail: zanone@cict.fr
|
|
Bruno WATIER
Employment: Assistant Professor
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Biomechanics
E-mail: watier@cict.fr
|
|
|
|
|