|
THE INFLUENCE OF FLUID INGESTION
ON PERFORMANCE OF SOCCER PLAYERS DURING A MATCH
|
1Human Nutrition, Postgraduate Course - PRONUT, University of
São Paulo, Brazil
2Rehabilitation Program, Postgraduate Course, State University
of São Paulo, Brazil
3Department of Physiology, State University of São Paulo, Brazil
4Department of Nutrition, School of Science and Pharmacology,
University of São Paulo, Brazil
| Received |
|
31 March 2004 |
| Accepted |
|
26
August 2004 |
| Published |
|
01
Decemer 2004 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2004) 3, 198-202
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
purpose of this study was to verify the effects of a carbohydrate-electrolyte
drink on soccer performance. Twenty soccer players volunteered to
participate in the study. Players were allocated to two assigned trials
according to their positional roles in the team: CHO group (ingesting
a 6% carbohydrate-electrolyte solution at regular 15 minutes intervals)
and NCHO (ingesting no fluid) during 75 min on-field soccer game.
During the trials, body mass loss, heart rate, time spent running,
number of sprints and core temperature were measured. There were statistically
significant changes (p < 0.05) in body mass loss (CHO: 1.14 ± 0.37
kg vs. NCHO: 1.75 ± 0.47 kg) and number of sprints performed (CHO:
14.70 ± 4.38 vs. NCHO: 10.70 ± 5.80) between groups. The main finding
of the present study indicates that supplementation with a carbohydrate-electrolyte
drink during a soccer match is beneficial in helping to prevent deterioration
in performance.
KEY
WORDS: Sports drink, carbohydrate, soccer performance, heart
rate, core temperature.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Soccer
is characterized by intermittent high- intensity exercises (Reilly,
2000) and it
is well established that the loss of only 2% of body mass is sufficient
to impair performance and cognitive function (Shepard, 1999). Besides that, without
an adequate fluid intake during exercise players can experience
an increase in core temperature and heart rate (Casa et al., 2000;
Murray 2000).
Fatigue during a soccer match is often associated with carbohydrate
depletion and, depending on the level of competition and fitness
level of the player, his body carbohydrate reserves (muscle glycogen)
will decrease in proportion to the duration and intensity of the
game (Bangsbo, 1992;
Castagna and O´ttavio, 1999;
Hargreaves, 1994;
Hawley, 1994).
It has been observed that when players ingest a fluid that contains
carbohydrate during a simulation or in a real match, they cover
a greater distance, have higher muscle glycogen concentration after
the game, perform better and feel less fatigued than those players
that do not ingest any fluid (Leatt and Jacobs, 1989;
Mc Gregor et al., 1999;
Nicholas et al., 2000). According to soccer's rules, during the game there
are no formal breaks that allow players to ingest fluids and if
the game is played under warm environmental conditions they face
heavy demands upon both body fluid and carbohydrate reserves (Monteiro
et al., 2003;
Sanz-Rico et al., 1996;
Shepard, 1990).
However, there is little information available investigating the
influences of carbohydrate-electrolyte drinks on performance of
players during soccer match. Therefore, the aim of this study was
to examine the effects of a carbohydrate-electrolyte drink on soccer
performance.
|
| METHODS |
Subjects
Twenty male soccer players of São Paulo Futebol Clube participated
in the study, which had university ethical committee approval (Research
Ethics Committee from University of São Paulo). All participants were
informed verbally and in writing about the nature and demands of the
study, as well as the known health risks. The physical characteristics
and % body fat (Jackson and Pollock, 1978)
of the players are shown in Table
1.
Protocol
The game consisted of one 45 min half, 15 min of interval and another
30 min half. The environmental conditions were measured using a wet
bulb globe temperature, which is a convenient index to assess it,
by the following equation: 0.7 (Twb) + 0.2 (Tg)
+0.1 (Tdb), where Twb is the wet bulb temperature,
Tg is the globe temperature and Tdb is the dry
bulb temperature. Before the game players were allocated to two randomly
assigned trials considering their positional roles: ingesting carbohydrate-electrolyte
drink (CHO) or not ingesting carbohydrate-electrolyte drink (NCHO).
During the trial, the ambient temperature was 28° C. Every 15 min
the game was interrupted and the fluid trial ingested 300 ml (ACSM,
1996) of a commercially available carbohydrate-electrolyte drink (6%
tangerine-flavored carbohydrate Gatorade solution). During the interval
all players were allowed to ingest water ad libitum; this was
monitored by an observer.
Body weight was determined prior and after the game with a digital
scale, accurate to 50 g. Subjects wore minimal clothing during weighting
and did not wear taping, ankle guards, or jewelry.
Heart Rate measurements
Heart rate was monitored every 15 minutes during the match using short-range
radio telemetry (Polar Sport TesterTMS610, Finland). Mean
heart rate for the match was used as a marker of the load imposed
to the cardiovascular system due to the intensity of performance and
to the environmental heat stress.
Performance measurement
Twenty volunteers observed each player during the entire game and
used a stopwatch to determine the time each player spent with or without
the possession of the ball, no matter the direction. They also observed
the number of sprints each player performed during the game. Those
measurements were divided along the first and the second halves. Those
volunteers were previously trained for that job.
Core Temperature
The core body temperature was determined by an ingestible "thermometer-pill"
(Cor Temp Disposal Temperature Sensor) which together with the recorder
(Cor Temp 2000 TM) provided continuous and accurate real core body
temperature data. Once swallowed the sensor passed harmless through
the subject's gastrointestinal tract at his normal rate of motility
and then was eliminated naturally from the body after 24 - 72 hours.
The CorTempTM Disposable Temperature Sensor utilizes a
temperature sensitive crystal which vibrates in direct proportion
to the temperature of the temperature of the substance surrounding
it. This vibration creates an electromagnetic flux which continuously
transmits harmlessly through the surrounding substance. The CT 2000
recorder receives this signal, which is then displayed on the unit
and simultaneously stored to memory. Each CorTempTM Disposable
Temperature Sensor is individually calibrated at the factory, and
the calibration adjustment is entered into the CT 2000 prior to use,
assuring a temperature accuracy of ± 0.1º C. Players ingested those
pills eighteen hours before the protocol.
Statistical
analyses
Data are expressed as means ± standard deviation. A probability level
less than 0.05 was accepted as statistically significant. To analyze
differences in heart rate, core temperature and match load in hydrated
vs. no hydrated trials t test was performed. The data were
analyzed using the statistical package SPSS, PC program, version 11.0
(SPSS Inc., USA).
|
| RESULTS |
|
The
physical characteristics of the players are listed in Table
1. Results on body mass loss, heart rate, time spent running,
number of sprints and core temperature are shown in Table
2. Body mass losses were higher in the NCHO group (p < 0.05).
It was expected that heart rate would be higher in NCHO group during
the whole match, but there were statistical differences only during
the second half of the game between CHO and NCHO groups (p <
0.05). Players ran more during the first half of the game and there
were statistically significance between the first and the second
halves in both groups. Regarding the number of sprints performed
the same situation occurred. However, statistically significant
differences (p < 0.05) between CHO group and NCHO group were
observed only during first half, where the CHO group performed more
sprints than NCHO group. There was a trend for the core temperature
to be higher in the NCHO group during the match; however, this was
not significant (p > 0.05). During the interval the CHO group
drank 340 (± 201) ml and the NCHO group 890 (± 263) ml of water.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
This
study compared a CHO electrolyte drink group and a no fluid ingestion
group because those players in the latter group are used to spending
the whole game without drinking any fluid. So it was not a problem
for them to exercise without consuming fluid. The main finding of
this study was that the carbohydrate - electrolyte drink improved
performance during a soccer match compared with no ingestion of
fluids at all. It is well established that dehydration resulting
in as little as 2% body weight has a negative impact on exercise
performance, impairs muscular endurance, mental functioning, thermoregulation
and increases both core temperature and heart rate (Casa et al.,
2000). Nicholas
et al. (2000)
observed a loss of 2.2 kg of body weight during a soccer match.
In our study there was a loss of 1.14 kg and 1.75 kg body mass of
CHO and NCHO, respectively. In this study the body mass loss of
CHO group were lower than in the NCHO group, thus it would be expected
that the CHO group had a better performance during the match than
NCHO group. Similar data was found by McGregor et al. (1999)
who studied the effects of fluid ingestion on soccer specific skills
and concluded that performance was deteriorated 5% in the group
that did not ingest any fluid during the trial.
Leatt and Jacobs (1986),
Foster (1986),
Smith (1992),
Nicholas (1995),
and Ostojic and Mazic (2002)
reported positive effects of carbohydrate-electrolyte drinks on
performance of soccer players. Carbohydrate in this situation can
be helpful because: (a) by the end of a soccer match most players
become depleted of muscle glycogen (Nicholas et al, 2000);
(b) deterioration in specific skills might be linked to depletion
of muscle glycogen stores because glucose is the main substrate
for metabolism in the central nervous system (Mc Gregor et al.,
1999); (c) players
with low glycogen content run and perform less sprints than those
with normal content, specially during the second half (Hawley, 1994).
As sprinting is considered a high-intensity activity and represents
8 to 12% of total distance covered during a match by a player, we
can assume that those who have a less deterioration in performance
run more sprints, particularly during the second half of the game.
It is expected that during the second half of the game, players
perform 5% less than during the first half (Rienzi et al., 2000). In this study we observed
that the number of sprints performed were higher during the first
half in CHO group, suggesting that CHO group had a better performance
during the first half of the match than NCHO group. Unfortunately,
we expected that CHO group would maintain a better performance also
during the second half when supposedly carbohydrate would contribute
to avoid or at least delay fatigue. It is well established that
water can attenuate the negative effects of dehydration, but regarding
performance it can not contribute as much as carbohydrate does.
Dehydration in exercise results from the need to maintain body temperature
close to the normal resting value of about 37 ° C. As soccer is
an endurance sport involving 90 minutes of activity of varying
intensities, it will present a thermoregulatory challenge (Maughan
and Leiper, 1994). In soccer most of the championships are played
under warm environmental conditions and as a consequence core temperature
in players above 39 ° C are commonly observed after soccer matches
(Ekblom, 1986;
Sanz-Rico et al., 1996; Shepard, 1999). This was reported in our
study where both CHO and NCHO groups had their mean core temperature
above 39 ° C by the end of the game.
Heart rate is an important instrument to evaluate soccer players´
performance during a match although fatigue and the partial result
of the game could disguise the real behavior of heart rate. In both
situations the tendency is that players run less and make less effort
during the match (Ali and Farally, 1991).
During moderate-intensity exercise, the magnitude of the increase
in heart rate was directly related to the degree of dehydration.
In the present study no statistically significant was found between
CHO and NCHO group probably because those groups are used to play
without drinking any fluid during the match.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
This
study provides encouraging evidence that soccer players should drink
a carbohydrate-electrolyte drink throughout a match to avoid the negative
consequences of dehydration, especially regarding performance. Future
work should examine the optimal volume of fluid needed to sustain
high levels of exercise.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
- Supplementation
with a carbohydrate-electrolyte drink during a soccer match is
beneficial in helping to prevent deterioration in performance.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Isabela GUERRA
Employment: Dietitian, PRONUT (Curso Interunidades Nutrição
Humana Aplicada) University of São Paulo, Brazil.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Soccer science, sports nutrition,
hydration and supplementation.
E-mail: isabelaguerra2003@yahoo.com.br |
|
Rodrigo CHAVES
Employment: Physical educator, Masters degrees´ student
of State University of São Paulo (UNIFESP), Brazil.
Research interests: Soccer science, high-performance
athletes, hydration.
E-mail: isabelaguerra2003@yahoo.com.br
|
|
Turibio BARROS
Employment: Professor, Department of Physiology, São Paulos´
Medical School (UNIFESP), Brazil.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Soccer science, high-performance
athletes, hydration and physiology.
E-mail: cemafe@uol.com.br |
|
Julio
TIRAPEGUI
Employment: Nutrition Laboratory of Faculdade de Ciências
Farmacêuticas of University of São Paulo (USP), Brazil.
Research interests: High-performance athletes, supplementation
and sports nutrition.
E-mail: tirapegu@usp.com |
|
|
|
|