|
ALTERATION OF IMMUNE FUNCTION
IN WOMEN COLLEGIATE SOCCER PLAYERS AND COLLEGE STUDENTS
|
1Department of Exercise and Sports Science, University of Wisconsin-La
Crosse, La Crosse, WI, USA
2Department of Biology, University of Wisconsin-La Crosse, La
Crosse, WI, USA
3Laboratory for Exercise Biochemistry, The University of Southern
Mississippi, Hattiesburg, MS USA
4School of Biomedical and Sport Science, Edith Cowan University,
Joondalup, WA 6027, Australia
| Received |
|
13 August 2004 |
| Accepted |
|
06
October 2004 |
| Published |
|
01
Decemer 2004 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2004) 3, 234-243
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
purpose of this study was to monitor the stress-induced alteration
in concentrations of salivary immunoglobulin (S-IgA) and cortisol
and the incidence of upper respiratory tract infections (URTI) over
the course of a 9-week competitive season in college student-athletes
and college students. The subjects consisted of 14 NCAA Division III
collegiate female soccer athletes (19.8 ± 1.0 years, mean ± SD) and
14 female college students (22.5 ± 2.6 years). Salivary samples were
collected for 9 weeks during a competitive soccer season. S-IgA and
cortisol concentrations were determined by enzyme linked immunosorbent
assay (ELISA). A training and performance questionnaire was given
to the subjects every week, to record the subjects' session rating
of perceived exertion (RPE) for all the training, load, monotony and
strain, as well as any injuries or illnesses experienced. The between
groups ANOVA procedure for repeated measures showed no changes in
salivary concentrations of IgA and cortisol. Chi-square analysis showed
that during the 9-week training season injury and illness occurred
at a higher rate among the soccer players. There was a significant
difference at baseline between soccer and control S-IgA levels (p≤0.05).
Decreased levels of S-IgA and increases in the indices of training
(load, strain and monotony) were associated with an increase in the
incidence of illness during the 9-week competitive soccer season.
KEY
WORDS: Training, football, endocrine, illness.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Moderate,
regular physical training is generally considered to be associated
with improved health, including decreased blood pressure and body
weight, improved glucose tolerance, and possibly a decreased sensitivity
to upper respiratory tract infection (URTI) (Mackinnon, 1997).
Among elite athletes and their coaches, a common perception is that
heavy exertion lowers immune resistance and is the predisposing
factor to URTIs. Recent epidemiological evidence is consistent with
this perception (Mackinnon, 1997). Recent studies have focused on the effects of
exercise on immune parameters in order to better understand mechanisms
by which exercise training may influence resistance to infection
(Tomasi et al., 1982; Mackinnon 1997;
Gleeson and Pyne, 2000). Intense exercise has been
shown to transiently alter and/or suppress a number of immune parameters
including the number of circulating leukocytes, plasma cytokine
concentrations, salivary immunoglobin A (S-IgA) secretion rate,
and neutrophil and macrophage phagocytic activity (Mackinnon, 1997).
Studies show that there is a positive correlation between exercise
workload and URTIs (Tomasi et al., 1982; Gleeson and Pyne, 2000).
Moderate exercise may stimulate the immune system but hard training
actually suppresses the immune system, thus increasing the risk
of infection (Shephard and Shek, 1993).
Moderate exercise may decrease the risk of acquiring an URTI, but
too much exercise may increase the risk. Moderate exercise in sedentary
subjects with naturally acquired URTI does not appear to alter the
overall sensitivity and duration of the illness (Weidner and Schurr,
2003). Illness and/or injury occur when the physical
demands outweigh the ability of the body to recover between training
sessions and competitions (Anderson et al., 2003).
Observations of the training patterns and incidence of illness and
injury during a women's collegiate basketball season have suggested
that there was no correlation between total weekly training loads
and illness rates (Anderson et al., 2003).
However, no measures of immune or hormonal markers were made in
that study (Anderson et al., 2003).
The risk of URTI appears to be especially high during the 1- or
2-week period following marathon-type race events and 1-9 hour following
prolonged endurance exercise, when the host defense mechanism is
decreased and the risk of URTI is elevated (Neiman et al., 1990).
Training at an intense level over many years can result in a chronic
suppression of salivary immunoglobulin levels (Gleeson and Pyne,
2000). The S-IgA
levels show an inverse correlation with the number of URTIs, which
indicates that the measurement of S-IgA levels over a training season,
may be predictive for athletes at risk for infection (Gleeson et
al., 1999). However,
very few studies have investigated S- IgA changes over the course
of a competitive season.
Current knowledge suggests that heavy acute and/or chronic exercise
is associated with an increased risk of URTIs. Some studies have
suggested that the incidence of infections, which are often thought
to be a marker of early stages of overtraining syndrome, were related
to excursions above individually identifiable thresholds of training
strain (Foster, 1998).
The purpose of this study was to investigate the stress-induced
alterations in immune function and stress hormones in college students
and college student-athletes.
|
| METHODS |
|
Experimental
Design
This investigation utilized NCAA Division III collegiate female
soccer athletes. The control subjects were college students not
involved in competitive athletics. Using a longitudinal study design,
the soccer and control groups were monitored throughout 9 weeks
of a semester, which corresponded to the competitive season for
the soccer players. At the beginning of every week, for 9 continuous
weeks, the subjects provided salivary samples for measurement of
S-IgA and cortisol concentrations. A training and performance questionnaire
was given to the subjects at the beginning of every week's practice
session, which was utilized to record the subjects' session rating
of perceived exertion (RPE), as well as any injuries or illness
suffered.
Subjects
Fourteen female soccer players volunteered for this study (age 19.8
± 1.0 years, mean ± SD, weight 65.9 ± 7.3 kg). All participants
had previous clearance from a physician to participate in intercollegiate
athletics and all went through an orthopedic screening by a certified
athletic trainer to determine their health status and musculoskeletal
injury history. The control group consisted of 14 healthy, physically
active female college students (age 22.5 ± 2.6 years, body weight
62.2 ± 7.3 kg). The control subjects were not involved in competitive
athletics but several of them were involved in regular exercise
programs. Subjects did not adjust their diets or lifestyles significantly
during the course of the season. Informed consent was provided by
all participants, in accordance with the guidelines of the University
of Wisconsin-La Crosse Institutional Review Board for the Protection
of Human Subjects.
Saliva Collection
At the beginning of each week, unstimulated saliva samples were
collected over a 1-minute period into pre-weighed plastic tubes.
The subjects were asked to not eat immediately prior to providing
their saliva sample and to maintain their normal dietary habits
over the course of the study period. The samples were collected
at the same time of the day to control for diurnal variations. They
were measured for volume, immediately frozen and stored at -80 °C
until analysis.
S-IgA and cortisol measures
S-IgA concentrations were determined in duplicate by an enzyme linked
immunosorbent assay (ELISA) (Salimetrics, State College, PA). S-IgA
secretion rate was calculated by multiplying absolute S-IgA concentration
(µg·mL-1) by saliva flow rate (mL·min-1).
Saliva flow rate was calculated by dividing the total volume of
saliva obtained in each sample (mL) by the time taken to produce
the saliva sample (minutes). Salivary cortisol concentrations were
determined in duplicate by ELISA (Diagnostic System Laboratories,
Webster, TX). Assay plates were read using an Opsys MRTM
Microplate Reader (Dynex Technologies, Chantilly, USA). For S-IgA,
intra-assay variance was 8.2 % and the sensitivity of the assay
was 2.5 µg·mL-1. For cortisol intra-assay variance was
7.6 % and the sensitivity of the assay was 0.011 µg·dL-1.
Training questionnaire
The subjects in both the soccer and control groups were given a
training and performance questionnaire at the beginning of each
week. The questionnaire was given at the beginning of the week for
recording the RPEs for that week's practices/exercise sessions and
for that week's illnesses and injuries. The questionnaire was comprised
of questions about the subjects training and exercise patterns as
well as any injuries or illness suffered. Questions included lists
of problems that make athletes stop or reduce their training because
of illness (colds, flu, viruses, asthma, upsets, infections, etc.),
training injuries (sprains, fractures, pain in muscles, cramps,
etc.), and other problems (accidents, family, travel or work problems,
bad weather, exams, worry, apathy, loss of interest, etc). The soccer
and control subjects were asked to provide information about the
exercise or training that they had done that week. For the soccer
group this included matches, practice sessions, and individual conditioning
sessions. For the control subjects this included any exercise sessions
they did. The subjects recorded the duration of each session and
outlined what type of exercise they did. They also provided a rating
of how hard each session was using the session RPE scale (Figure
1). Briefly, the subject used the scale approximately 30 minutes
after completion of any workout, match, or training session, and
rated " how hard was the workout?" from the scale, in
which, zero is resting and ten is maximal effort (Foster et al.,
2001).
The goal of the session RPE is to encourage the athlete to view
the training session globally and to simplify the myriad of exercise
intensity cues during the exercise bout. This allowed for evaluation
of trends in training, injury and illness in relation to the session
RPE and the global intensity of the exercise session (Foster, 1998).
It has been demonstrated to be a valid measure of both aerobic and
anaerobic exercise (Foster et al., 2001;
Gabbett, 2003).
From the session RPE method, the accessory indices of training,
monotony and strain were calculated, potentially providing an index
of the training outcomes (Foster, 1998).
Monotony was defined as the variability of practices for the entire
season, while strain was defined as the overall stress demanded
on the athlete for a period of a week (Foster, 1998).
Monotony was calculated by dividing the mean daily load over each
week by the standard deviation of load. Strain was calculated by
multiplying monotony by the weekly load (Foster, 1998).
Injury
An injury was defined as a circumstance in which the athlete received
an evaluation from the team's student athletic trainer and required
limiting their practice for at least 1 day. Each injury was counted
as single injury, whether seen for 2 days or 2 weeks; consequently,
if the athlete had two separate injuries, they were counted as two.
Injury for the college students was defined as a circumstance during
which the subject felt that she could not or was unable to perform
any exercise.
Illness
An illness was defined as a circumstance in which the subject felt
that they were limited or unable to perform the training or the
exercise session (eg. flu, cold, virus, etc.). Research has shown
that athletes, as well as the general population (control groups),
are quite able to correctly diagnose symptoms of URTI such as running
nose, sore throat, and cough in combination with fatigue, headache
and fever (Cohen et al., 1991). Each individual's illness was recorded on the
questionnaire in the same manner as injury.
The correspondence between spikes in the indices of training (load,
monotony and strain), decreases in S-IgA and subsequent (within
7 days) illness was noted, and individual thresholds that allowed
for optimal explanation of illnesses were computed. From this we
attempted to define the percentage of illnesses that could be explained
by each index of training.
Statistical
analysis
S-IgA concentration, cortisol concentration, saliva flow rate, and
S-IgA secretion rate were analyzed separately by between groups
repeated measures ANOVA. Pearson's product-moment correlation was
performed independently for both the groups to determine the strength
of the relationship between S-IgA
and cortisol concentrations with mean load, standard deviation of
load, weekly load, monotony, strain, and the number of reported
days with injury or illness. A chi square analysis was performed
to determine the frequency of injury and illness in the soccer players
and college students during the course of study. Effect size was
calculated as the difference between the means divided by the SD
of the two samples. A p ≤ 0.05 was accepted as statistically significant.
|
| RESULTS |
|
There
were no significant differences in age or bodyweight between the
soccer group and the control group at baseline
Salivary IgA
The weekly variations of S-IgA levels over the 9-week competitive
season for the soccer group in contrast to that of the control group
are shown in Figure 2. The
repeated measures ANOVA showed no changes in salivary concentrations
of IgA or secretion rate over the course of the training season.
There was a significant difference at baseline between the soccer
and control groups S-IgA levels (p ≤
0.05), with the soccer group having lower levels than the control
group (Effect size = 1.1).
Cortisol
ANOVA for repeated measures showed no changes in salivary concentrations
of cortisol between the soccer and control groups over the course
of the training season. The pattern of variation in cortisol concentration
of soccer and control groups over the 9- weeks is shown in Figure
3. There were no significant differences over the course of
9-week competitive season.
Injury
The total number of days of injury and the difference in the injury
pattern among soccer and control groups is shown in Figure
4. During the first 3 weeks of the season the number of injuries
among the soccer group was high in comparison with control group.
There was a crossover during week 4, after which the number of injuries
experienced by the control group was more than the soccer group.
But the occurrence of injuries among the soccer group was at a significantly
higher rate during the 9-week competitive season.
Illness
The total number of days of illness and the difference in the pattern
of illness among the soccer and control groups is shown in Figure
5. During the course of the study, illness occurred at a significantly
higher rate among the soccer group. No illness was recorded during
the weeks 7, 8 and 9 of the season, during which the training load
was reduced.
Monotony and Strain
Monotony and strain for the soccer and control groups are shown
in Figure 6 and Figure
7. In both the soccer and control groups, strain followed a
pattern very similar to monotony, with slight changes due to different
training loads. The training load for the soccer group was higher
when compared to the control group (Figure
8).
With our approach of correlating the incidence of illnesses with
indices of training, 55% of illnesses could be explained by a preceding
spike in training load. In addition, 64% of illnesses could be explained
by a preceding spike in strain and monotony. After correlating the
incidence of illnesses with a decrease in S-IgA, 82% of illnesses
could be explained by a preceding decrease in S-IgA. Using an increase
in cortisol levels, 55% of the illnesses could be explained by a
preceding decrease in S-IgA and increase in salivary cortisol.
Correlations
Significant correlations were found in the soccer group between
S-IgA and monotony (r = 0.75) during week 4 (p ≤
0.05). Correlations were also found between cortisol concentration
and injury (r = 0.73) during week 5 (p ≤
0.05). Among the control group, significant correlations were found
between cortisol and strain (r = 0.72) during week 1 (p ≤
0.05). Week 4 showed a correlation between cortisol and stress (r
= 0.72). Week five showed correlation between cortisol and injury
(r = 0.79) (p ≤
0.05). During week 9 a significant correlation was found between
cortisol and mean load (r = 0.73), cortisol and weekly load (r =
0.73), cortisol and strain (r = 0.72) (p ≤
0.05).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
Athletes
experience a variety of injuries and illnesses throughout a competitive
season, impacting the performance of a team and the success of a
coach. Research has been conducted on the S-IgA levels in elite
athletes (McDowell et al., 1992; Tomasi et al., 1982; Pyne and Gleeson, 1998;
Gleeson et al., 1999; Kraemer et al., 2004), but there is very limited
research on occurrence of injury and illness in college student-athletes
and non-athletic college students. The purpose of this study was
to compare the stress-induced alterations in S-IgA and cortisol
concentrations in female college students who were athletes (soccer
group) and college students who were not involved in competitive
athletics (control group). The major finding of this study was that
there was no significant difference in S-IgA
and cortisol concentrations in the soccer and control groups in
relation to URTI during a 9-week competitive season. The frequency
of injury and illness in the soccer group was significantly greater
than the control group.
This study demonstrated that there was no significant relationship
between the S-IgA concentrations and the incidence of URTIs among
the soccer and control groups during the course of the study. At
the beginning of the study there was a significant difference in
the S- IgA levels between the soccer and control groups, with the
soccer group having lower levels. This could be a result of the
soccer players being in a state of overreaching or overtraining
following their pre-season training. However, we do not have any
quantitative training data from the pre-season to confirm this.
During week 3 a decrease in the S-IgA levels among the soccer and
control groups was seen (Figure
2). This drop in S-IgA levels in soccer group could be because
the first 2 weeks of a season are frequently the most difficult
and physically demanding practices of the season. The athletes are
working towards reaching their "optimal" level of training.
However, it did appear that the soccer group had lower resting S-IgA
levels over the course of the season when compared to the control
group. There is a well known association between either chronic
or acute heavy exertion, and an increased incidence of infection
(Foster, 1998). This may relate to a modest immunosupression during
periods of heavy training (or high levels of other stressors) that
renders the individual more susceptible to infection by pathogens
in the environment. We did observe that 82% of illnesses could be
explained by a preceding decrease in S-IgA. Previous research has
shown a quantitative relationship between various indices of training
and the presence of negative adaptations to training (Foster, 1998). This is supported by our data which demonstrated
that increased amounts of load, strain and monotony were associated
with the incidence of illness.
The results showed that there was no significant change between
the soccer and control groups for cortisol concentrations by the
end of the 9-week training season. Kraemer and colleagues (2004)
showed that intense training prior to the start of the season, combined
with continued high intensity training during both practice and
competition, contribute to chronically elevated cortisol concentrations.
This study showed that there was large intersubject variability
in cortisol concentration over the course of the season. Elevated
levels of cortisol could be because of the extreme stressors experienced
during the competitive season and academic semester. Elevated cortisol
concentrations lead to increased binding at the glucocorticoid receptor,
which results in reduced protein synthesis and concomitant losses
in muscular force and functional performance (Kraemer et al., 2004). Thus the measurement of cortisol concentration
has been suggested to be a possible endocrinological marker of physiological
stress associated with exercise. Elevation of cortisol concentration
could be the result of stress, diet, inflammation, or high intensity
exercise (Hoffman et al., 2002).
Gottschall (1999)
noted that an increase in illness paralleled an increase in the
training patterns during a men's basketball season. It was concluded
that higher training patterns increase the potential for illness.
This study revealed a significant correlation between S-IgA and
monotony (r = 0.75) in the soccer group during week 4. The majority
of significant correlations were for cortisol and the various indices
of training. This further highlights the important role of cortisol
as a possible marker of physiological stress with exercise. However,
there was no consistent pattern throughout the study. IgA is the
predominant immunoglobulin in mucosal secretions providing the body's
main defense against pathogens. One such pathogen is the rhinovirus,
which if allowed to replicate, can cause URTIs. However, there are
numerous other factors that contribute to actual disease pathology
(Fahlman et al., 2001). Whether one gets sick with cold after a sufficient
amount of virus has entered the body depends on many factors that
affect the immune system other than just physical activity and nutrition.
Smoking, alcohol consumption, mental stress, and lack of sleep have
all been associated with the impaired immune function, and an increased
risk of infection (Neiman, 2000). Gleeson et al. (1999)
determined the mean pre-training S-IgA concentration in elite swimmers.
It was shown that the lower the initial S-IgA, the higher the incidence
of infection. It was observed in this study that, though the frequency
of injury and illness in the soccer group was more than the control
group there was no significant relationship between S-IgA concentrations
with illness or injury. When an individual takes part in physical
activity, there is always an inherent risk of injury. Coaches, athletic
trainers, and strength and conditioning professionals work not only
to decrease the number of injuries that occur, but also to try to
prevent injury occurrence. They need to be aware of the trends that
follow when injuries are most likely to occur. Knowledge of injury
trends could be useful for helping to implement the proper intensity
of practices during the season (Anderson et al., 2003).
Foster (1998) demonstrated that there was link between the load
of practices and the strain and monotony of practices. Monotony
was lower when practices varied considerably in volume and intensity
(6). During week 4 of the 9-week training season the training load
of the soccer group was low. Therefore, the lower monotony values
indicate variability in practice for the soccer group. Practices
need to be adjusted according to the number of games played during
the training season. In both the soccer and control groups, strain
and monotony followed the same pattern. High levels of monotony
did not exist during this particular soccer season. Gabbett (2003)
showed that the incidence of training injuries in rugby league players
was highly correlated with intensity, duration, and load of training.
Although we did not demonstrate high correlations between training
indices and illness, we did observe that 54-63% of the illnesses
were associated with a preceding spike in training load, monotony
or strain.
Some limitations of this study need to be addressed. Experience
and daily interaction with athletes have clearly shown that they
are quite aware of the history of past infections including training
days lost due to URTI. In addition most of the investigated athletes
had training logs helping them to answer the questions correctly.
Another aspect that could be criticized is that the diagnosis of
URTI was self-reported and not confirmed by a physician. The athletes
as well as the college students appeared to be able to correctly
diagnose symptoms of URTI such as running nose, sore throat, and
cough in combination with fatigue, headache, and fever.
Previous research has suggested that the menstrual cycle may have
an impact of the cortisol profile (Kirschbaum, et al., 1999).
It has been observed that women in the follicular phase or taking
oral contraceptives had blunted free cortisol responses (Kirschbaum
et al. , 1999).
A limitation of the present study was that we did not control for
the phase of the menstrual cycle that the subjects were in. However
there is evidence that suggests that morning cortisol response is
influenced by the awakening time but not by menstrual cycle phase
(Kudielka and Kirschbaum, 2003)
and not all studies have shown cortisol responses to acute exercise
to vary across menstrual cycle phase (Galliven et al., 1997).
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
During
the course of a competitive season collegiate soccer players are exposed
to a number of physical and psychological stressors from practice,
conditioning, and competition. The ability of the players to recover
following such activities can ultimately affect the quality of the
performance for ensuing physical activity. This study showed that
there were no significant stress-induced alterations in the S-IgA
and cortisol concentrations in female college students who are athletes
(soccer group) and college students who are not athletes (control
group). There was no significant difference in S-IgA and cortisol
concentrations in soccer and control groups in relation to URTI during
the course of a 9-week competitive season. It did appear that the
levels of S-IgA were suppressed in the soccer group throughout the
course of the season. The frequency of injury and illness in the soccer
group was significantly greater than the control group.
Injury and illness were not significantly correlated to S-IgA in this
particular study. However, we did observe a relationship with a decrease
in S-IgA and the occurrence of illness. In addition, there appears
to be a relationship between indices of training such as strain and
monotony with incidence of illness. This is in agreement with previous
research with athletes (Foster, 1998). It is important to monitor
players prior to preseason conditioning to gain a more complete understanding
of the changes that occur during the course of a competitive soccer
season. As most sport seasons are now extending to year-round training,
a year long study is needed to fully document changes in collegiate
soccer players compared to those of the college students.
|
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
We
wish to thank the subjects for their involvement in this study, in
particular the women soccer players at the University of Wisconsin-
La Crosse.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
-
There was a significant difference at baseline between soccer
and control S-IgA levels
- Eighty-two
percent of illnesses could be explained by a preceding decrease
in S-IgA.
- Increases
in the indices of training (load, strain and monotony) were associated
with an increase in the incidence of illness
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Praveen
PUTLUR
Employment: Graduate student in the Department of Exercise
and Sport Science,University of Wisconsin-La Crosse.
Degree: MS
Research interests: Clinical exercise physiology.
|
|
Carl
FOSTER
Employment: Professor in the Department of Exercise and
Sport Science, University of Wisconsin-La Crosse.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Clinical physiology, high performance
physiology and exercise physiology.
E-mail: foster.carl@uwlax.edu
|
|
Jennifer
MISKOWSKI
Employment: Assistant Professor in the Department of Biology
at the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Cell physiology.
E-mail: miskowski.jenn@uwlax.edu
|
|
Melissa
K. KANE
Employment: Undergraduate student in the Department of Exercise
and Sport Science, University of Wisconsin-La Crosse.
Research interests: Exercise physiology.
|
|
Sara
BURTON
Employment: The head women's soccer coach and assistant
manager of Strength and Conditioning at the University of Wisconsin-La
Crosse.
Degree: MS
Research interests: Strength and conditioning.
|
|
Timothy
P. SCHEETT
Employment: Ass. Prof. and Director of the Laboratory of
Exercise Biochemistry at the University of Southern Mississippi.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Exercise-induced immune and endocrine
system responses.
E-mail: Timothy.Scheett@usm.edu
|
|
Michael
R. MCGUIGAN
Employment: Lecturer in the School of Biomedical Science
at Edith Cowan University.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Hormonal and muscular responses to
resistance training.
E-mail: m.mcguigan@ecu.edu.au |
|
|
|
|