|
MOOD CHANGES FOLLOWING GOLF AMONG SENIOR RECREATIONAL PLAYERS
|
1University of Wolverhampton, UK
2University College Worcester, UK
| Received |
|
05 October 2004 |
| Accepted |
|
26
December 2004 |
| Published |
|
01
March 2005 |
© Journal of Sports Science
and Medicine (2005) 4, 47 - 51
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Golf
has been recommended as a relatively risk-free form of exercise for
an ageing population. The aim of this study was to investigate the
effects of playing a round of golf on mood states in recreational
players. Ageing male golfers (N = 34; Age: M = 68.7, SD = 5.4 years)
completed a mood measure immediately before and after an 18-hole round
of golf. Distance walked per game was measured using a pedometer.
Results indicate reported scores on Anger, Depression, and Fatigue
increased and Vigor reduced following the game. However, it should
be noted that although there was an increase in unpleasant mood states,
this should be seen in the context of the overall mood profile, which
was positive. Pedometer results indicated golfers walked a mean distance
of 10.21 km (± 1.11). Results show participants of this age-group
engaged in a meaningful exercise session and that mood scores deteriorated
following play. Findings from the present study show that elderly
golfers experienced mood profiles following golf similar to younger
athletes following competition. For golf to be recommended as an activity
for promoting physical activity among an aging population, the player's
ability to regulate unpleasant mood states should be considered. Future
research should investigate the effects of experiencing negative mood
states following golf on motivation to participate.
KEY
WORDS: Health, affective states, exercise, emotion, and fitness.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
It
is commonly accepted that participating in regular exercise has numerous
health related benefits including reduced risk of coronary heart disease,
weight control, improved cardiovascular efficiency and improved psychological
well-being (Blair and Morrow, 1998;
Craig et al., 1999;
Kopelman, 2001;
US Department of Health and Human Services, 1996).
Walking is a rhythmic, dynamic aerobic physical activity that confers
the multifarious benefits of this with minimal adverse effects. Moreover,
it is manifestly a sensible and relatively risk-free form of exercise,
particularly for potential sensitive groups such as pregnant women
(Sternfeld, 1997)
and for the elderly (Morris and Hardmann, 1997).
Golf includes long bouts of low to moderate intensity walking, which
have been shown to have favourable effects on many health and fitness
indicators in middle aged men and has been recommended as an appropriate
and risk-free form of health-enhancing physical activity (Parkkari
et al., 2000).
Participation in golf has risen most notably in the 50-59 age group
(Therialut and Lachanche, 1998).
However, while physical benefits of golf have been demonstrated, psychological
effects are less well understood.
A great deal of research has investigated changes in psychological
states assessed by self-report measures such as the Profile of Mood
States (McNair et al., 1971)
following exercise (Biddle, 1995;
Mutrie and Biddle, 1995).
In a review of salient research, Berger and Motl (2000) cited evidence
of both acute and chronic mood enhancement following exercise, and
identified several factors proposed to maximize its mood-enhancing
effects. These factors included duration of 20 - 30 minutes; moderate
intensity; regular frequency (3 x week); rhythmic breathing; predictable
and repetitive movements; and an absence of interpersonal competition.
It is argued that playing golf for an ageing-population is light to
moderately intense exercise, has rhythmic breathing, with some degree
of predictable and repetitive movements. An 18-hole round of golf
will typically last over an hour. Although it might be speculated
that the majority of elderly golfers play for recreational and health-related
reasons, a competitive element remains, although there is an absence
of research investigating participation motives toward playing golf
in this age group. It should be noted that the changes in mood following
competition are different to those reported following exercise (see
Abele and Brehm, 1993; Berger and Motl, 2000).
Successful performance has been found to be associated with positive
mood (Biddle and Hill, 1991;
Hall and Terry, 1995;
Hassmén and Blomstrand, 1995).
Unsuccessful performance is related to negative mood (Biddle and Hill,
1991;
Hall and Terry, 1995;
Hassmén and Blomstrand, 1995;
Hoffman et al., 1999;
Lane at el., 2002; Lowther and Lane, 2002).
Therefore, golf could be associated with negative mood states following
competition.
Several studies have investigated psychological states experienced
playing competitive golf among a range of different populations (Cohn,
1990;
Beauchamp et al., 1996;
Thomas and Fogarty, 1997;
Kirschenbaum et al., 1998;
Giacobbi et al., 2004). Giacobbi et al. ( 2004) explored cognitive and emotional responses
to playing golf among a sample of 11 players using qualitative techniques.
They found golfers experience a range of discrete and intense emotional
responses during competition, arguing the golfers should be taught
a range of psychological skills. This finding is consistent with previous
research with non-elite golfers (Cohn, 1990;
Beauchamp et al., 1996;
Thomas and Fogarty, 1997;
Kirschenbaum et al., 1998).
Given the notion that golf is recommended as a relatively risk-free
form of exercise for potential sensitive groups such as an ageing
population, findings that show mild to moderate exercise is associated
with positive mood, but with counter findings showing that golf is
associated with stress. Therefore, the aim of this study, was to explore
the effects of playing a round of golf on mood states in ageing recreational
players. On one hand, the nature of the exercise experience should
promote mood-enhancement, but on the other hand, unsuccessful performance,
which in terms of playing golf could mean playing below handicap or
performers worse than playing partners, should be associated with
increased unpleasant mood. |
| METHODS |
|
Participants
Thirty-four regular male golfers from an ageing population (Age:
M = 68.68, SD = 5.41 years) completed a mood measure immediately
before and after an 18-hole round of golf. All participants were
regular golfers (> 1 day per week) and members of the seniors
section of a private golf club. An acknowledged limitation of the
present samples was that participation motives to playing golf were
not explored.
Measures
Mood
Mood was measured using a 32-item scale that used subscales from
two previously validated scales (Matthews et al., 1990;
Terry et al., 1999;
2003). The Brunel Mood Scale (Terry et al., 1999;
2003) is based on the Profile of Mood States (McNair et al., 1971)
and assesses the mood states of anger, confusion, depression, fatigue,
tension, and vigour. The subscales of happiness and calmness were
taken from the UWIST (Matthews et al., 1990).
Recent research has questioned the use of the POMS model of mood
in an exercise setting (Ekkekakis and Petruzzello, 2002).
Ekkekakis and Petruzzello, (2002)
suggested the use of the circumplex model as a conceptual and measurement
model for studying affect in the context of exercise. A limitation
of the POMS model of mood is that it does not address the full range
of positive mood states with recent research suggesting that positive
mood dimensions, such as happiness and calmness, may also influence
sports performance (Hanin, 2000).
It is suggested that the eight mood dimensions assessed provide
a more balanced assessment of positive mood and negative mood.
Anger items include "Bad-tempered" and "Angry",
Confusion items include "Mixed-up" and "Uncertain",
Depression items include "Depressed" and "Downhearted",
Fatigue items include "Worn out" and "Tired",
Tension items include "Anxious" and "Panicky",
and Vigor items include "Alert" and "Energetic".
Calmness items include "Calm" and "Relaxed"
and Happiness items include "Cheerful" and "Happy".
Items are rated on a 5-point scale anchored by "not at all"
(0) to "extremely" (4).
Terry et al. (1999;
2003)
provided comprehensive evidence of factorial, concurrent and predictive
validity of the BRUMS. Matthews et al. (1990)
provided evidence of factorial validity. Internal consistency coefficients
for subscales were:
Anger, alpha = .88; Calmness, alpha = .84; Confusion, alpha, = .72;
Depression, alpha, = .74; Fatigue, alpha, = .88; Happiness, alpha,
= .89; Tension, alpha, = .74; and Vigour, alpha, = .87.Distance
walked
Distance walked per game was measured using a pedometer.
Procedure
Data were collected during the day of the 'monthly medal', an in-house
and light-hearted social competition between golf club members.
Participants competed against their friends and other players in
the club. All participants were seated in the lounge area of the
golf club and issued with the BRUMS during the 5-minute period immediately
prior to starting play. Each participant then played 18 holes of
golf at their regular pace with their normal playing partners. The
weather was clear and pleasant with no precipitation. Following
the round of golf, participants were allowed 5 minutes to put away
their golf clubs and change footwear before returning to the lounge
where a second BRUMS questionnaire was administered.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Repeated
measures multivariate analysis of variance compared mood scores
over time and indicated a multivariate effect (Wilks lambda 8,26
= 0.59, P < 0.05, Eta2 = 0.41, see Table
1). Univariate results indicated that post-game mood scores
were higher for Anger (F1,33 = 12.17, p < 0.01, Eta2 = 0.27),
Depression (F1,33 = 6.54, p < 0.05, Eta2 = 0.17) and Fatigue
(F1,33 = 8.57, p < 0.001, Eta2 = 0.21), with lower scores on
Vigor (F1,33 = 9.10, p < 0.01, Eta2 = 0.22). Pedometer results
indicated golfers walked a mean distance of 10.21 km (± 1.11). Results
showed that participants of this age-group engaged in a meaningful
exercise session and that mood scores deteriorated following play.
Although results showed mood deteriorated, after-game variability
as indicated by the standard deviation of mood scores was larger
than pre-game mood (p < 0.05).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
The aim of the present study was to explore mood state responses
to playing a round of golf. Results of the present study indicate
that playing golf is associated with increased unpleasant mood states,
a mood profile more associated losing or poor performance (see Biddle
and Hill, 1991;
Lane et al., 2002;
Lowther and Lane, 2002)
than exercise. These results show that elderly golfers experienced
mood profiles following golf similar to younger athletes following
competition. Although the walking element of golf resulted in players
engaging in a meaningful exercise session for their age, the psychological
response seems to suggest that positive feelings that should accompany
exercise are not so consistent.
Although results show an increase in unpleasant mood states following
playing golf, it should be noted that participants reported much
larger scores for pleasant mood states than unpleasant mood states.
Therefore, it could be argued that although there was an increase
in unpleasant mood states, this should be seen in the context of
the overall mood profile, which was positive. Research has emphasised
the importance of exploring the interplay between mood states (Lane
and Terry, 2000).
In the present study, increased anger showed the largest effect
size, and previous research has shown anger can be facilitative
of performance under certain conditions (see Beedie et al., 2000;
Lane and Terry, 2000).
It is suggested that increased arousal associated with anger might
be helpful for performance if it enables players to increase concentration.
Research has found that individuals are aware of mood states associated
with performance (Hanin, 2000)
and make attempts to regulate mood to optimal states. Thus, among
some individuals, anger might be perceived as helpful, and when
a player feels increases in anger, attempts to reduce anger are
not attempted. Lane and Terry (2000)
indicated that anger experienced with depression is qualitatively
different to anger experienced with positive mood states such as
vigor.In the present study, results suggest individuals reported
feelings of anger, calmness and happiness simultaneously. It is
suggested that some individuals use feelings associated with anger
as a strategy to aid performance.
Findings of the present study lend support to previous research
that has investigated psychological state responses to playing golf
(Cohn, 1990;
Beauchamp et al., 1996;
Thomas and Fogarty, 1997;
Kirschenbaum et al., 1998;
Giacobbi et al., 2004). Consistent with suggestions of Giacobbi
et al. (2004, intervention strategies designed to teach
golfers emotional control techniques should be considered. Following
Giacobbi et al. (2004) suggestions, the Rational Emotive Behavioral
Therapy program that teaches individuals how to document negative,
self-demeaning dialogs, emotional reactions, and the circumstances
that give rise to these reactions should be considered. Encouraging
golfers simulate stressful situations on the golf course (e.g.,
hitting a difficult shot, performing in front of others, or playing
with good golfers) could assist in developing of strategies for
regulating negative mood states. Therefore, golfers of all skill
levels should be encouraged to regularly practice behavioral simulations
in the presence of other people with the driving range offering
a possible place for such practice to occur.
We suggest that future research investigates mood changes following
performance on an intra-individual basis. Individuals who consistently
experience unpleasant mood states following performance are likely
to develop negative expectations toward playing, which in turn can
become de-motivational. For golf to be recommended as an activity
for promoting physical activity among an aging population, players
should be taught strategies to regulate unpleasant mood states.
A strategy for regulating negative mood among elderly players should
be to encourage social interaction. The benefits of social support
gained from interacting with peers whilst playing golf should be
considered as a potential strategy for mood-regulation. Thayer et
al. (1994)
found that social support was a commonly used and effective self-regulation
strategy to counter negative mood states, a finding that was supported
on a sample of athletes by Stevens and Lane et al (2001).
There are several limitations to the results of the present study.
First, the stability of mood changes during competition and following
competition were not known. Mood has been found to be an ephemeral
construct and thus it was possible that mood states changed from
hole to hole. Second, the sample size was relatively small even
for this specific population. Third, measures of goal attainment
and goal expectancy were not assessed. Understanding the link between
goal outcome and mood states might offer a clearer rationale for
mood responses in golf.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
| In
conclusion, results suggest that while golf provides a sufficient
walking for health related benefits it could promote negative mood
disturbance, something that should be considered by practitioners
if golf is to be recommended as a strategy for exercise among an ageing
population by practitioners. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Findings
show ageing male golfers engaged in a meaningful exercise session
and that mood scores deteriorated following play.
- Mood
profiles before and after playing golf for elderly golfers were
similar to younger athletes following competition.
- For
golf to be recommended as an activity for promoting physical activity
among an aging population, the player's ability to regulate unpleasant
mood states should be considered.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Andrew M. LANE
Employment: Prof. in Sport and Exercise Psychology, School
of Sport, Performing Arts and Leisure, Univ.of Wolverhampton,
Gorway Road, Walsall, WS1 3BD, UK.
Degree: BA, PGCE, MSc, PhD.
Research interests: Mood, emotion, measurements, coping,
and performance
E-mail: A.M.Lane2@wlv.ac.uk |
|
|
Haydn JARRETT
Employment: Senior Lecturer, Univ. College Worcester,
Henwick Grove, Worcester, WR2 6AJ, UK.
Degree: Bachelor of Education (Hons) in Physical Education;
Master of Science in Physical Education (Exercise Physiology)
Research interests: Health related exercise and physical
activity & health.
E-mail: H.Jarrett@worc.ac.uk
|
|
|
|
|