|
PLASMA VOLUME EXPANSION 24-HOURS POST-EXERCISE: EFFECT OF DOUBLING
THE VOLUME OF REPLACEMENT FLUID
|
Waikato Institute of Technology, School of Sport and Exercise Science, Hamilton,
New Zealand.
| Received |
|
10 December 2004 |
| Accepted |
|
29
April 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
June 2005 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2005) 4, 179 - 184
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
effects of two volumes (1.5 L or 3.0 L) of commercially available
electrolyte beverage (1.44 mM·L-1 Na+) taken
during a 24-hour recovery period post-exercise, on plasma volume (PV)
expansion 24-hours post-exercise were assessed. A simple random-order
crossover research design was used. Subjects (n = 9 males: age 21
± 4 years, body mass 80.0 ± 9.0 kg, peak incremental 60-second cycling
power output 297 ± 45 W [means ± SD]) completed an identical exercise
protocol conducted in hot ambient conditions (35oC, 50%
relative humidity) on two occasions; separated by 7-days. On each
occasion, subjects received a different volume of 24-hour fluid intake
(commercial beverage) in random order. In each case, the fluid was
taken in five equal aliquots over 24-hours. PV expansions 24-hours
post-exercise were estimated from changes in haemoglobin and haematocrit.
Dependent t-testing revealed no significant differences in PV expansions
between trials, however a significant expansion with respect to zero
was identified in the 3.0 L trial only. Specifically, PV expansions
(%) were; 1.5 L trial: (mean ± SE) 2.3 ± 2.0 (not significant with
respect to zero), 3.0 L trial: 5.0 ± 2.0 (p < 0.05, with respect
to zero). Under the conditions imposed in the current study, ingesting
the greater volume of the beverage lead to larger mean PV expansion.
KEY
WORDS: Hypervolemia, dehydration, re-hydration.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
As
a consequence of exercise, an acute loss of plasma volume (PV) occurs
(Costill and Fink, 1974;
Dill and Costill, 1974).
A reduction in PV challenges the maintenance of homeostasis, as
it results in destabilization of the cardiovascular system (Hanel
et al., 1997;
Krip et al., 1997;
Neuhaus and Gaehtgens, 1994).
A conspicuous physiological response that begins almost immediately
upon exercise cessation is auto- restoration of lost PV (Convertino,
1991;
Fellmann, 1992;
Green et al., 1984;
Mack et al., 1998).
Even in the absence of fluid ingestion, PV is restored to baseline
within 60-minutes of exercise cessation (Gillen et al., 1991;
Lundvall and Lanne 1989).
This fluid-flux into the vascular space from other fluid pools,
notably the lymph, (Nagashima et al., 2001)
occurs due to alterations in Starling forces and due to elevations
in plasma albumin mass (Gillen et al., 1991;
Hayes et al., 2000;
Mack et al., 1998;
Nagashima et al., 2000).
Plasma osmolarity may also play a mediatory role (Nose et al., 1988),
as well as the specific stimulus for influx (Jiminez et al., 2002;
Kay et al., 2004).
Specifically, it has been recently shown in our laboratory (Kay
et al., 2004)
that the relative loss of body fluid itself (in the range of 0-2%
body mass) is not likely to be an important mediator of the response
(i.e. PV restoration): rather, that other coincident factors are
likely to be primary mediators.
The restoration of PV usually "overshoots" the original
PV, and is retained at 24-hours post-exercise (Gillen et al., 1991;
Haskell et al., 1997;
Nagashima et al., 1999;
2001):
resulting in the phenomenon of exercise-induced hypervolemia. The
exercise-induced hypervolemia may be further enhanced by increased
renal sodium and water retention in the 24-hours following exercise,
potentially as a consequence of an increase in aldosterone concentration
(Nagashima et al., 1999)
or reciprocally, a decrease in ANP concentration (Hanel et al.,
1997).
Further, there is an increase in the rate of albumin transcription
(Yang et al., 1998),
and a decrease in the trans-capillary escape-rate of albumin (Haskell
et al., 1997;
Lang et al., 1987).
If exercise is repeated over a number of days, the resting PV "resets"
to a higher level and PV may exceed pre-exercise levels by approximately
20% (Convertino et al., 1980).
Indeed, in the endurance-trained condition, chronic hypervolemia
has been demonstrated in cross- sectional (Maw et al., 1996)
and in longitudinal studies (Convertino, 1991;
Costill and Fink, 1974).
In recreationally active individuals, expanded PV increases end-diastolic
volume and consequently cardiac output (Hopper et al., 1998;
Kanstrup and Ekblom, 1982;
Krip et al., 1997).
The increase in cardiac output in turn increases VO2peak
(Coyle et al., 1990),
and results in lowered blood viscosity through the effects of the
Fahraeus-Lindqvist effect (Neuhaus and Gaehtgens, 1994).
These factors theoretically lead to lowered cardiovascular stress
during exercise at any given intensity. Indeed, PV expansion appears
to result in lowered physiological stress as assessed via numerous
physiological markers during subsequent exercise (Fellmann, 1992;
Hopper et al., 1998;
Kanstrup and Ekblom, 1982;
Krip et al., 1997;
Maw et al., 1996;
Mitchell et al., 2000;
Neuhaus and Gaehtgens, 1994;
Watt et al., 1999).
Little is understood however, about the various re-hydration strategies
commonly used to help maximise this physiological response over
short (0-3 hours), and longer (up to 24-hours) periods post-exercise.
It is understood that over a three-hour recovery and re-hydration
period, greater fluid volume consumed (150% volume lost vs. 100%
volume lost during exercise) is beneficial to PV expansion (p <
0.05) and whole body re-hydration (p < 0.05). However, few previous
researchers have investigated re-hydration strategy with respect
to PV expansion over a 24-hour post- exercise period. Possible mediators
over this longer time-frame include (a) the volume of fluid consumed
(O'Brien, 2001), (b) the rate of fluid consumption (Kovacs et al., 2002), (c) the sodium content in oral fluid (Hanel et al.,
1997; Nagashima et al., 2001), and (d) the dietary intake of sodium (Luetkemeier, 1995). Therefore, the intention of the current investigation
was to determine whether increased consumption of a commonly used
commercially available re-hydration beverage during the 24-hours
following a standard exercise bout, is associated with increased
exercise-induced hypervolemia 24-hours post-exercise (when factors
such as those above are controlled). It was hypothesised that the
greater beverage volume trial would be associated with greater mean
PV expansion 24-hours post-exercise.
|
| METHODS |
|
Subjects
Subjects (n = 9 recreationally active males; age 21 ± 4 years, body
mass 80.0 ± 9.0 kg, peak cycling power output 297 ± 15 W, [mean
± SD]) were recruited from within the Waikato Institute of Technology,
Centre for Sport and Exercise Science. All subjects volunteered
to take part, and provided written informed consent. The Waikato
Institute of Technology Research Ethics Committee approved all procedures.
Subjects underwent pre-screening for exercise contraindications,
specifically resting blood pressure in excess of 145 / 90 mmHg,
and resting heart rate in excess of 100 beats·minute-1.
Subjects also completed a medical history questionnaire so that
individuals with other contraindicating factors could be identified
and excluded.
Experimental design overview
The effects of two different re-hydration strategies, on PV expansion
24-hours post exercise were assessed. A randomised crossover design
was used. During the 24-hours before and the 24-hours following
exercise, all subjects underwent dietary and hydration control.
Subjects attended the laboratory on three separate occasions (each
separated by 7 days). The first session comprised the determination
of individual peak 60-sec cycling power output using a standardised
continuous-incremental protocol (5-min at 100W, then +25W·min-1
to exhaustion). During the subsequent-two sessions, an intense-intermittent
exercise bout in the heat (75% peak 60-sec cycling power output,
8 repetitions of 4-min work/5-min rest, 35oC, 50% relative
humidity) was used to elicit exercise induced hypervolemia on each
occasion. After each exercise session, subjects consumed one of
two volumes (1.5 or 3.0L) of re-hydration beverage (commercially
available beverage) during the 24-hours post exercise, in random
order. In each case, the beverage was taken by all subjects in five
equal aliquots at set times during the 24-hours post exercise (0800;
1200; 1600; 2000; 0400). The volume of beverage to be consumed was
not adjusted for fluid lost during the exercise sessions, as fluid
loss within the range expected is not likely to play an important
role in mediating eventual PV expansion (Kay et al, 2004). Venous
blood samples were obtained prior to exercise, and at 24-hours post
exercise. Haemoglobin concentration (g·dL-1) and haematocrit
(%) were measured, and these parameters used to estimate percentage
changes in PV (Dill and Costill, 1974).
Experimental
protocol
Subjects were asked to refrain from consuming any nutritional supplement,
ergogenic aid (or proposed ergogenic aid), alcohol, or other recreational
drug during the entire experimental period. Further, subjects were
asked to refrain from caffeine in food and drink for 48-hours prior
to, and during the 24-hours of testing. Finally, subjects were asked
to maintain their normal sporting and exercise activities, except
to refrain from exercise for 24-hours prior-to testing, and during
the 24-hours post-testing. Compliance was assessed via each subject
completing a nutritional and training diary, which was supplied
by the researchers. Each testing week began 24-hours prior-to exercise,
with a period of dietary and hydration control, which continued
for 24-hours post-exercise. During the second 24-hour period, there
was a slight increase in both energy intake, and dietary sodium
intake, which was in order to prevent negative energy balance or
sodium status, due to the exercise and dehydration imposed. All
subjects ate the same foods, except that dinner (commercially available
frozen meals) was available in several flavours, hence the variability
in intakes. Specifically, day one intakes were (mean ± SE) 8350
± 72 kJ (1988 ±17 kcal), 3412 ± 45 mg Na+, 1.5 L water
(5 equal aliquots). Day two intakes were 9721 ± 108 kJ (2315 ± 26
kcal), 4354 ± 67 mg Na+, the re-hydration fluid volume
was varied by week of testing, as determined by random assignment.
The researchers have assumed the water content of the different
commercial meals was the same. The sodium mass provided in the re-hydration
fluid was additional to that in the diet, discussed above. This
sodium mass was (159 and 318 mg respectively): i.e. an overall increase
in total sodium intake of ~4% in the 3.0 L trial as compared with
the 1.5 L trial. The SE (± 67mg) from the dietary variation equated
to ~1.5% of total sodium mass intake.
Following the first 24-hour period of dietary and hydration control
(which stipulated the timing of all food and fluid intakes), subjects
reported to the laboratory at the appointed time of day (0600),
which was held constant throughout the testing period. Testing began
following the last meal and fluid intake (breakfast) by two hours.
After subjects' journals were checked, all subjects were cleared
to proceed with testing. Subjects first voided, and nude body mass
was recorded. Subjects then entered the environmental chamber (35oC,
50% relative humidity), and sat on a chair with feet flat on the
floor and palms hands down on the knees for a period of 20-minutes.
This postural control was to allow for stabilisation of PV (Kargotich
et al., 1998). Following this, a 5mL sample of blood was collected
from a superficial vein in the antecubital fossa of either arm.
Samples were immediately refrigerated at 3oC, and analysed
within 120-minutes (see below). Subjects then completed the required
exercise. Subjects were required to remain in the sealed environmental
chamber throughout the protocol, and food / drinking during the
exercise session was disallowed. Following the exercise, subjects
warmed down (5-minutes at 100 W), and then towelled off, ensuring
that they were as dry as possible. Nude weighing was then repeated,
in order to assess the degree of whole-body dehydration experienced
by each subject during the session.
Finally, subjects were also asked to refrain from adopting the supine
posture for at least 5-hours post-exercise (Nagashima et al., 2000), and to refrain from water immersion for at least 5-hours
post-exercise (Hayes et al., 2000; Hinghofer-Szalskay et al., 1987). Subjects remained under observation for 30-minutes post-exercise,
in case of any ill effect from the exercise / heat stress. After
this, subjects were given the appropriate re-hydration beverage
and a drinking schedule. Subjects next reported at 0600 the following
day; for repeated weighing, postural control, and blood sampling
as above. The procedure was repeated 7-days later, such that all
subjects received both beverage volumes in random order.
Blood sampling and analysis
Blood was collected using a standard 'complete blood count' (CBC)
lithium / heparin vacuum container, and a 20-guage hypodermic needle.
Haematocrit percentage (Hct) was determined in triplicate using
capillary tubes filled from the sample containers after they had
been inverted ten times to homogenise the blood. Capillary tubes
were then centrifuged at 3600 revolutions.minute-1, for
a period of 5-minutes. A ruler marked with 0.5 mm increments was
used to determine the percentage of packed red cells after centrifuging,
according to (packed cell length / total sample length) x 100.
Haemoglobin (Hb) concentration (g·dL-1) in the samples
was determined in duplicate using a Ciba-Corning Co-oximeter (860
series, USA), following homogenisation (as above).
Determination of estimated plasma volume changes
Estimated changes in PV (mean ± SE of the difference, %) were determined
from Hct and Hb in blood samples taken at rest (Dill and Costill,
1974). In order to determine 'baseline ± SE'; on three occasions
prior-to the investigation (separated by 24-hours, and under controls
as above), Hct and Hb was determined from blood samples taken at
rest (Dill and Costill, 1974).
As the method of Dill and Costill (1974) requires two values for
both Hb and Hct, comparing sets of repeated measures in every permutation
(3 x 2 x 1; or six of), necessarily yielded a mean change of zero,
with a known SE of measurement. From this we have conducted analyses
comparing the known baseline value (zero ± SE) with the post-intervention
values for each treatment condition during the experimental period
(means ± SE). SE of the difference for reporting, was then calculated
in the usual fashion.
Statistical
analysis
Changes in body mass are reported as mean ± SE of the difference,
after absolute values for body mass change were converted to a percentage
change from baseline (i.e. zero ± SE; calculated as for PV above)
in order to allow agreement in terms between assessment of body
mass changes and PV changes (i.e. percent). Differences in mean
percent PV changes, and in mean percent body mass changes between
trials were subjected to dependent t testing. Alpha was set at 0.05.
|
| RESULTS |
|
The
1.5 L re-hydration volume trial was associated with PV expansions
of 2.3 ± 2.0% (not a statistically significant increase with respect
to zero), and the 3.0 L re-hydration volume trial was associated
with PV expansions of 5.0 ± 2.0% (p < 0.05, with respect to zero).
The mean expansions for each trial noted during the current study
however, did not statistically differ from one-another. The 1.5
L re-hydration volume trial was associated with body mass changes
over 24-hours of -0.2 ± 0.1%, and the 3.0 L re-hydration volume
trial was associated with body mass changes over 24-hours of 0.2%
± 0.3%. Neither of these body mass changes were statistically different
from zero, nor were these values statistically different from each
other. Whole-body dehydration sustained by the current subjects
during the exercise sessions was 1.0 ± 0.2% by body mass lost during
the 1.5L trial, and 1.0 ± 0.1% by body mass lost during the 3.0L
trial. These two values were not significantly different from one
another. Absolute fluid loss (as determined from changes in body
mass) was 875 ± 148 mL (1.5L trial), and 820 ± 97 mL (3.0L trial).
These values were also not significantly different from one another.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
Effects
of re-hydration beverage volume consumed on PV expansions
The major finding of this study was that under the conditions we
imposed, 3.0 L of the specific re-hydration fluid we used was associated
with a statistically significant mean PV expansion, while 1.5 L
of the same re-hydration fluid was not. It was originally hypothesised
that ingestion of a greater volume of the re-hydration fluid in
the 24-hours post-exercise would be beneficial to PV expansion 24-hours
post-exercise. The mean values we have provided appear to support
this hypothesis.
Magnitude
of PV changes with respect to body mass changes
The mean estimated PV change 24-hours post-exercise noted during
this study, was approximately half (3.7 ± 2.0%; pooled results vs.
7.3 ± 1.3%; pooled results) of that reported previously by other
researchers (Gillen et al., 1991; Haskell et al., 1997; Nagashima et al., 1999) who have used an almost identical exercise protocol as
the stimulus, and who have used the same PV estimation technique
(Dill and Costill, 1974). The degree of dehydration noted previously (Mack et
al., 1998) following the use of the same exercise protocol we have
used (except that intensity was set at 85% VO2peak);
was 10.2 ± 1.1 ml·kg-1 body mass. From the subject demographics
given by those authors, the mean percent loss of body mass during
that study was 1.0 ± 0.1%. This compares closely to the percentage
loss of body mass noted by the current investigators (1.0 ± 0.2%).
It appears therefore, that percent dehydration was unlikely to be
a major factor in this discrepancy with previous research. The current
researchers chose 75% peak power as the workload, because previous
subjects were often unable to complete the protocol due to exhaustion
(Gillen et al., 1991; Haskell et al., 1997; Nagashima et al., 1999).
Exercise
intensity as a possible mediator
Previous research (Gillen et al., 1991; Hayes et al., 2000; Nagashima et al., 1999) suggests that the movement of albumin from the lymph
to the plasma is the most likely primary mediator of fluid influx
to the plasma pool. This movement of lymph is dependant upon a period
of post-exercise hypotension (Hayes et al., 2000; Nagashima et al., 1999). Hypotension indeed occurs for several hours post-exercise
(Hayes et al., 2000), and is mediated primarily by the accumulation of chemicals
such as nitric oxide, and other metabolites (Blackman et al., 2000;
Ferrari et al., 2001; Planitzer et al., 2001). The increase in PV
may therefore occur because the hypotension creates a favourable
gradient for increased lymphatic drainage into the vascular space
(hence increased delivery of albumin), and/or for interstitial fluid
to move directly into the vascular space regardless. These arguments
provide for the possibility that relative exercise intensity may
play an important mediatory role in PV expansion post-exercise,
as nitric oxide production is proportional to exercise intensity
(Chirpraz-Oddou et al., 1997). Future research is required to elucidate.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
|
It
was originally hypothesised that under the conditions imposed during
this study, a greater volume of oral re-hydration fluid would be
associated with increased mean PV expansion 24-hours post-exercise.
The results of this study support this hypothesis.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
- Greater
volume of re-hydration beverage is beneficial to mean PV expansion
3-hours post-exercise, however this relationship has not been
previously tested under adequate controls over 24-hours to our
knowledge.
- This
study indicates that under the conditions we imposed, over 24-hours
increased volume (1.5 Vs. 3.0 L) of oral re-hydration fluid is
associated with increased mean PV expansion.
- Although
we used an almost identical exercise stimulus as previous researchers,
relative intensity was slightly lower in the current study. Coincidentally,
PV expansions noted during this study were approximately half
those reported by others.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Bartholomew KAY
Employment: Manager, Human Performance Lab., Institute of
Food, Nutrition, and Human Health, Massey University, Palmerston
North , New Zealand.
Degree: MSc (SpExSci), BSpExSci (Hons)
Research interests: Metabolism, muscular fatigue, cardiovascular
function, sport specificity of training and fitness assessment.
E-mail: b.kay@massey.ac.nz |
|
Brendan O'BRIEN
Employment: Lecturer, School of Human Movement and Sport
Sciences, University of Ballarat, Ballarat, Australia.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Metabolism, muscular fatigue, cardiovascular
function.
E-mail: b.obrien@ballarat.edu.au |
|
|
Nicholas
D. GILL
Employment: Senior lecturer, School of Sport and Exercise
Science, Waikato Inst. of technology, Hamilton, New Zealand.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Metabolism, muscular fatigue, cardiovascular
function, strength / power / conditioning, Rugby Union, sport
specificity of training and fitness assessment.
E-mail: nicholas.gill@wintec.ac.nz
|
|
|
|
|