|
FIRST RIB STRESS FRACTURE IN A SIDEARM BASEBALL PITCHER: A CASE
REPORT
|
1Department of Orthopedic Surgery and Sports Medicine, Kitade Hospital,
Gobo,Wakayama, Japan
2Department of Sports Studies, Kitade Hospital, Gobo, Wakayama, Japan
3Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, Kitade Hospital, Gobo, Wakayama,
Japan
| Received |
|
25 January 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
07
March 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
June 2005 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2005) 4, 201 - 207
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Stress
fractures of the first rib in athletes are rare. A 14-year-old male,
a baseball pitcher who changed from an overhand to a sidearm style,
with a stress fracture of the first rib, was reported. Most Stress
fractures in the first rib occur at the subclavian groove, between
the attachments of the scalenus anterior and scalenus medius muscles,
which is the thinnest and weakest portion of the rib. However, in
this case the stress fracture occurred at the uncommon region, posterior
to the insertion of the scalenus medius muscle, in the first rib.
The motion analysis of the pitching in this case demonstrated that
the sidearm style induced much more horizontal abduction in the shoulder
at the top position than did the overhand style. The findings of electromyography
in the serratus anterior muscle, one of the muscles which insert on
the first rib, through the pitching motion did not demonstrate any
significant differences between the two styles. In this case, the
repetition of horizontal over-abduction of the shoulder when sidearm
pitching appears to have been the cause of the unusual stress fracture
of the first rib at this site.
KEY
WORDS: Motion analysis, horizontal abduction, electromyography,
serratus anterior muscle.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Stress
fractures of the first ribs in athletes are rare; in baseball pitchers
this injury has been reported in pitching arm (Edwards and Murphy,
2001;
Gurtler et al., 1985)
and non-pitching arm sides (Curran and Kelly, 1966;
Tullos et al., 1972).
Most stress fractures in the first ribs occur at the subclavian
artery groove between the attachments of the scalenus anterior and
scalenus medius muscles, which is the thinnest and weakest portion
of the rib (Brooke, 1959;
Curran and Kelly, 1966;
Edwards and Murphy, 2001;
Gurtler et al., 1985;
Lankenner and Micheli, 1985;
Matsumoto et al., 2003;
Mintz et al., 1990;
Proffer et al., 1991;
Tullos et al., 1972).
The serratus anterior also attaches at this level.
We report the case of a young male baseball pitcher with a stress
fracture of the first rib located uncommonly at the posterior portion
of the rib. To clarify the mechanisms, we performed motion analysis
and electromyography (EMG) of the serratus anterior muscle in his
pitching style.
|
| CASE
HISTORY |
|
A 14-year-old
male, a right-handed pitcher with a sidearm style, heard a snap
in his right shoulder followed by severe pain while pitching in
the first inning of a game. He had changed from an overhand to a
sidearm style 6 months before the onset of severe pain. He had experienced
discomfort in his pitching side shoulder for several days before
the onset. Prior to the injury, he had no history of direct trauma
to the shoulder girdle, and he usually practiced pitching three
times per week. On physical examination, the patient had no atrophy
of his chest or
upper extremity muscles, either anteriorly or posteriorly. Deep
breath induced pain at the right upper chest. The ranges of motion
of both shoulders were normal. Tenderness was elicited with deep
palpation in regions of the right anterosuperior chest and the superomedial
border of the right scapula. Initial radiographs demonstrated a
radiolucent line without a displacement at the posterior portion
of the first rib (Figure 1).
The radiolucent line of the medial portion was wider than that of
the lateral portion. Magnetic resonance imaging also showed a similar
clear high- intensity line, posterior to the insertion of the scalenus
medius muscle, on a T2-weighted image (Figure
2).
The fracture site, posterior to the insertion of the scalenus medius
muscle, of the first rib was considered an uncommon region for a
fracture because most first rib fractures occur in the subclavian
groove, the thinnest, weakest portion of the rib. We diagnosed this
fracture of the first rib as a stress fracture and treated it conservatively.
The patient was advised not to throw for 6 weeks but was allowed
to exercise by running or through any activities that were without
pain. After this period he gradually began to throw again; but he
decided to change his sidearm style back to an overhand one. At
2 months post-injury, follow-up radiographs showed callus formation
at the fracture site but with no displacement (Figure
3). The patient had no discomfort in his shoulder girdle during
any physical activities and has completely returned to full pitching
activities.
|
| BIOMECHANICS |
|
To
clarify the mechanism by which this uncommon first rib stress fracture
occurred at the posterior portion of the rib, we performed motion
analysis and the EMG of the serratus anterior muscle during pitching
at 4 months post-injury. A pitching motion can be divided into five
phases: windup, arm cocking, arm acceleration, arm deceleration,
and follow-through (Fleisig et al., 1994).
In arm cocking, the arm and trunk of the pitching side rotates back
after foot contact. In this article, "top position" is
defined as the time at which the ball is held up at its highest
position when the arm and trunk of the pitching side rotates back
maximally after the foot contact. Six high-speed Falcon high-resolution
cameras at 60 Hz (Motion Analysis Corp., Santa Rosa, California,
USA) recorded the locations of reflective markers on the patient.
The three-dimensional location of each marker, based on data from
the cameras, was automatically digitized with the Eva RT 4.0 software
(Motion Analysis Corp.). Surface electrodes (Blue Sensor, Medicotest
A/S, lstykke, Denmark) with on-site preamplifiers (Myosystem 1200,
Noraxon USA, Inc., Scottsdale, Arizona, USA) used to access EMG
activity of the serratus anterior muscles. EMG data were recorded
synchronously with the motion analysis data and analyzed using a
Bio-Signal Analysis Software, BIMUTUS2 (Kissei Comtec, Nagano, Japan).
Thirty reflective markers were placed on his trunk and extremities
for the motion analysis, along with three pairs of electrodes on
his right serratus anterior muscle (upper, middle and lower portions)
for EMG data (Figure 4). In
this article, the angle of horizontal abduction in the shoulder
was defined as the angle between the line which connected right
shoulder (marker No.1) with spinous process of C7 (marker No.29)
and the line which connected right shoulder with right lateral elbow
(marker No.3, Figure 5A). The
angle of abduction in the shoulder was defined as the angle between
the line which connected right shoulder with right hip (marker No.8)
and the line which connected right shoulder with right lateral elbow
(Figure 5B). In calibration
process, the motion analysis system used a dynamic linearization
technique. First, a small four-point calibration device is used
for defining the XYZ axes. A 500mm wand (for large capture volumes)
is then used for establishing camera linearization parameters. The
error of measurement was by less than 0.164%. The EMG data were
expressed as the integral values of voltages measured on surface
electrodes during each phase in pitching. In the testing facility,
pitches were thrown from a flat mound toward a target zone located
7 meters from the pitching line. The patient was given sufficient
time for a warm-up (stretching and jogging), and each ten pitches
of 70% and 90% efforts in his maximum effort to prepare the pitching
style. He was asked to perform three full pitches either sidearm
or overhand style for the motion analysis and the EMG data.
The motion analysis of the pitching in this case demonstrated that
the sidearm style induced greater horizontal abduction (121% of
the overhand style; Table 1
and Figures 6A and 6B)
in the shoulder at the top position. The findings from EMG in the
serratus anterior muscle during pitching showed no clear differences
between the sidearm and overhand styles (Table
2).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
Previous
reports have fully described the anatomical features of the first
rib and the causes of stress fractures of the rib (Curran and Kelly,
1966;
Gurtler et al., 1985).
The first rib itself is broad and flat with the tubercle located
at the junction of the anterior third with the posterior two thirds.
On either side of this tubercle is a groove for the subclavian artery
posteriorly and the subclavian vein anteriorly. The groove is deeper
for the artery than for the vein, forming the weakest point in the
first rib. The groove in the bone also lies between forces pulling
up (the scalenus anterior and medius muscles) and forces pulling
down (the serratus anterior and intercostals muscles). Therefore,
the groove for the subclavian artery is the most common location
for stress fractures; including cases involving baseball pitchers
(Curran and Kelly, 1966;
Edwards and Murphy, 2001;
Gurtler et al., 1985;
Tullos et al., 1972)
and other athletes (Lankenner and Micheli, 1985;
Matsumoto et al., 2003;
Proffer et al., 1991).
Our case demonstrated a stress fracture of the first rib that was
uncommonly located at the posterior portion of the rib posterior
to the insertion of the scalenus medius muscle. To our knowledge,
there are just two reports, of a spontaneous (Chan et al., 1994)
and a stress (Mamanee et al., 1999)
fracture at the same site, the posterior portion of the first rib.
However, the mechanism for the fractures of the first rib at this
location is unclear. Training errors, such as overuse or a rapid
increase in training contributes to a stress fracture of the first
rib (Lankenner and Micheli, 1985).
The case in this study changed from an overhand to a sidearm style
6 months before the onset of severe pain. Therefore, we considered
that the change of the patients pitching style might have been the
cause of this stress fracture. The motion analysis of the pitching
here showed that horizontal abduction in the shoulder and the rotation
of the trunk to the back was maximal at the top position in both
of the two pitching styles (data not shown). The first rib has a
rigid attachment both to the sternum anteriorly and to the first
thoracic vertebrae posteriorly. Horizontal abduction in the shoulder
induces adduction of the scapula.
These findings and the anatomical features suggest that horizontal
abduction in the shoulder, adduction of the scapula, and the rotation
of the trunk to the back cause great stress to the posterior portion
of the first rib at the top position during pitching. The motion
analysis data demonstrated that the sidearm style induced much more
horizontal abduction in the shoulder at the top position than did
the overhand style. The findings of EMG in the serratus anterior
muscle through the pitching motion did not demonstrate clear differences
between the two styles. It appears that in this case the repetition
of over abduction horizontally in the shoulder at the top position
of his sidearm pitching caused the stress fracture of the first
rib at this uncommon location (Figure
7).
Gregory et al. well reviewed the clinical aspects of stress fractures
of the first rib (Gregory et al., 2002).
The onset is usually insidious, although it can often start with
a pop and acute pain. There may be tenderness medial to the superior
angle of the scapula, at the root of the neck, supraclavicular triangle
or deep in the axilla. Shoulder movements may be painful or restricted.
Plain chest radiographs are usually initially negative and diagnosis
requires computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging. The
recommended treatment of a first rib stress fracture involves immobilization
of the shoulder girdle on the affected side with a sling with adequate
analgesia offered. Long-term follow-up, with serial radiographs
for 6 months, is advised to assess late developing complications.
Our case did not need any immobilization of the shoulder girdle
because there was only mild motion pain in the shoulder and shoulder
girdle. The critical issue for athletes is when they can return
to competitive levels. Two papers have reported first rib stress
fractures on the pitching side in baseball pitchers (Edwards and
Murphy, 2001;
Gurtler et al., 1985).
A 17-year-old male, left-handed pitcher, because of delayed union,
returned to full pitching at 9 months post-injury (Gurtler et al.,
1985).
A 15-year-old male, right-handed pitcher, returned to full pitching
at 6 months post-injury with non-union of the fracture, but without
any symptoms (Edwards and Murphy, 2001).
The period of return to full pitching in our case (2 months post-injury)
was much shorter than in previous cases. In the initial phase of
training post-injury, the patient decided to change from the sidearm
style back to his previous overhand one. This change to the former
pitching style, avoiding over horizontal abduction in the shoulder,
might have quickened the return to full pitching.
There are several limitations to this study. The number of samples
(pitches) is too small to identify the significant differences between
the two pitching styles. The data speed (60 Hz) of motion analysis
might be insufficient to analyze the pitching motion. The analysis
of motion was retrospective and the movement might not represent
the pre-injury technique. Scalenus anterior and scalenus medius
muscles, which are considered to mainly cause the stress fracture
in the first ribs, were not studied in EMG because of technical
difficulties in the EMG study with the surface electrodes.
In summary, we detailed the case of a young male baseball pitcher
with a stress fracture of the first rib that was uncommonly located
at the posterior portion of the rib. In this case, the repetition
of horizontal over-abduction of the shoulder when sidearm pitching
appears to have been the cause of the unusual stress fracture of
the first rib at this site. First rib stress fractures can be considered
a rare cause of shoulder or shoulder girdle pain in a baseball pitcher.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
- Most
Stress fractures in the first rib occur at the subclavian groove,
between the attachments of the scalenus anterior and scalenus
medius muscles, which is the thinnest and weakest portion of the
rib.
- We
report the case of a young male baseball pitcher with a stress
fracture of the first rib located uncommonly at the posterior
portion of the rib.
- In
this case, the repetition of horizontal over-abduction of the
shoulder when sidearm pitching appears to have been the cause
of the unusual stress fracture of the first rib at this site.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Takeshi SAKATA
Employment: Chief in Department of Orthopedic Surgery and
Sports Medicine, Kitade Hospital, Gobo, Wakayama, Japan.
Degree: MD, PhD
Research interests: Biomechanics of throwing and throwing
injury, osteoporosis induced by unloading.
E-mail: sakatatakeshi@hotmail.com |
|
Yasunobu KIMURA
Employment: Ass. researcher in Department of Sports Studies,
Kitade Hospital, Gobo, Wakayama, Japan.
Degree: BSc
Research interests: Motion analysis in throwing athletes.
E-mail: soudan@tiara.ocn.ne.jp |
|
|
Toshiko HIDA
Employment: Physical therapist in Department of Rehab.
Medicine, Kitade Hospital, Gobo, Wakayama, Japan.
Degree: PT
Research interests: Athletic injuries and rehab-ilitation
|
|
|
|
|