|
COACHING IN NORTHERN CANADIAN COMMUNITIES: REFLECTIONS OF ELITE
COACHES
|
Ben
Avery Physical Education Center, School of Human Kinetics, Laurentian University,
Sudbury, Ontario, Canada
| Received |
|
16 December 2004 |
| Accepted |
|
08
March 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
June 2005 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2005) 4, 113 - 123
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| This
study addressed geographical uniqueness in relation to elite coaching.
The study explores the complexities associated to coaching in northern
Canadian communities, and how unique geographical surroundings can
affect coaching success. The views of fourteen National and International
elite coaches from different northern Canadian communities are included
within the study. The respondents were from 9 different sport backgrounds
and averaged 17.1 years of coaching experience (range: 8-30 years).
Data were gathered using a structured open-ended questionnaire, a
focus group, and a follow-up in-depth semi-structured interview. Content
was analyzed to uncover emergent themes. Based on the respondents'
views, there is indication that despite numerous adversities, rural
coaches experience advantages that are unavailable in larger urban
centers. Precisely, there is evidence that northern Canadian coaches
acquire unique skills while responding to the demands placed on them
within their unique communities. Generalizations in regards to coaching
development strategies across physical locations are questioned following
the findings of the current study.
KEY
WORDS: Coaching, contextual factors, geography, adversities,
advantages.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Coaching
success at the elite level requires numerous aspects including a
competitive attitude, commitment, as well as confidence (Partington,
1988).
As Schinke et al. (1995)
noted a decade ago, all of these skill sets are acquired for the
purpose of guiding the development of aspiring elite athletes. In
addition to their interpersonal demands, elite coaches have spoken
of extensive administrative responsibilities. For instance, facilities,
equipment, and support personnel all play an important part in their
coaching process day to day and at competitions (Martens, 1990).
Despite the aforementioned commonalities in coaching tasks across
elite coaches, Gauthier et al. (2004)
have recently noted that there are some differences in coaching
demands when geographic location is considered. Elite coaches located
in remote and rural locations, for instance, face unique challenges
that differ from those experienced by elite coaches in large cities
with greater population densities. The theme of contextual uniqueness
is precisely what guided the current study.
The current study was conducted in northern Canada and the researchers
questioned a pre-determined selected respondent group of elite coaches
in regards to their experiences coaching athletes at the National
and International levels. Based on their responses the current study
provides insight regarding how their geographical surroundings affect
their coaching success. Precisely, our study explored the challenges
as well as the advantages, faced by elite coaches from regional
northern Canadian communities within our outlying area of 240 miles.
With northern Canadian geography as a backdrop, this study outlines
the unique skills that emerge within a small pool of elite coaches
as a result of their geographical location. Through this paper,
the authors indicate how the respondent group of northern elite
Canadian coaches adapted their coaching approach in response to
their geographical challenges. In addition, this paper overviews
the context specific struggles experienced by elite coaches working
in northern Canadian locations.
Coaching
research: A call for qualitative enquiry
As research with elite coaches becomes more prevalent in the sport
literature, the intricate processes that summarize their profession
will be better understood. Salmela (1994),
for instance, affirms that behind every successful elite athlete
there is an effective coach. Initially, elite coaching experts such
as Orlick (1986),
Partington (1998),
and Martens (1990)
provided outlines of the numerous facets that meld as part of the
elite coaching formula. A description of how coaches can attain
success is made available by these coaching experts.
All of the above insightful researchers spurred the use of qualitative
research methods. Martens (1979)
emphasized the need for research into to coaching effectiveness
to be driven by the actual experiences of coaches. Orlick and Partington
(1986)
took Martens suggestion one-step further by interviewing successful
international athletes to gain a clearer understanding of their
experiences and their needs. These three sport researchers started
a research tradition that has facilitated researcher and practitioner
understanding from the life experiences of sport participants. One
line of coaching research that followed the qualitative tradition
spurred by Orlick and Partington (1986)
and Martens (1990)
was initiated by Salmela (1994),
along with a number of colleagues. Both the above mentioned authors
and Salmela focused solely on elite coaching expertise and traced
the developmental paths of successful expert coaches. The coaches
whom they interviewed were all individually selected by their National
Sport Organizations as top Canadian coaches and were all elite certified
coaches. Salmela's (1994)
work clarified that successful elite coaches demonstrated a delicate
balance among coaching attributes including a passion for their
sport, strong communication skills, compassion, and a strong drive
for success. Some additional personal characteristics that surfaced
from Salmela's research included the ability to sell a vision, inspire
excellence among elite athletes (Schinke et al.,1997)
and the ability to mentor (Bloom et al., 1998).
According to all of the coaches' responses, the ability to select
athletes, communicate effectively with them, engage in stringent
goal-setting, and maintain a standard of relentless attention to
detail, is what culminated in success at the National and International
levels. Therefore, successful coaching at the elite level is comprised
of a wide number of technical and tactical skills. To arrive at
a conclusion that coaching skills ought to be presented without
a reconciliation of contextual factors, however, would be an over
simplification. In an attempt to resolve coaching context, Côté
et al. (1995)
established a Coaching Model from a study with 17 experienced and
nationally recognized elite Canadian coaches. According to Côté
and colleagues, elite coaching includes three components; organization,
training, and competition, which all affect each other reciprocally.
The factors that emerge as affecting this process are each coach's
inter personal characteristics, which have already been discussed,
the athlete's personal characteristics, and central to the immediate
paper, the contextual factors in which training and competition
happen. The contextual factors Côté alluded to range from variable
working conditions to uncontrollable subjective official judging.
Working conditions, such as facilities, support staff personnel,
and environment, can vary depending on geographical location. Dissimilarity
in elite coaching working conditions can be associated to geographical
location. A variety of geographical environments can offer a wide
range of attributes, either positively or negatively affecting the
elite coaching process.
Geographical context
Although Côté and colleagues' (1995)
do acknowledge the influence of contextual factors, their study
generalized these factors across elite coaching contexts without
considering geographical location. Though such generalizations are
a possibility, it may also be possible that the "contextual
factors" affecting the coaching process include geographical
location and associated community differences.
The immediate study was conducted in northern Ontario, Canada. Among
numerous northern locations, the chosen area covers the northern
region of one Canadian province. This area was selected for the
current project based on its unique geographical characteristics.
Northern Ontario's land covers nearly 89% of the province, but only
represents a mere 7.4% of its provincial population (Ministry of
Northern Development and Mines). Northern Ontario's population density
is 1.0 person per square kilometer, in comparison to its southern
Ontario counterpart at 104.3 persons per square kilometer (Ministry
of Northern Development and Mines). These statistics indicate that
much of northern Ontario, Canada is uninhabited wilderness and less
populated rural areas and community settings. Thus, a northern Ontario
coaching experience could be quite different from one in a larger
urban center. The current project is a preliminary attempt to identify
and understand whether and how contextual factors within elite coaching
differ as a result of geographical location.
More specifically the immediate study served three purposes. The
first purpose was exploraroty. Through examination of the experiences
of coaches, we explored differences between northern elite Canadian
coaches and those from more urban areas. Second, we identified adversities
faced by northern Canadian area coaches and how do they cope with
these obstacles. Third, we sought to uncover the perceived benefits
to coaching in northern Canadian communities.
|
| METHODS |
|
Researchers
as data instruments
Several researchers, including Martens (1987)
and Strean and Roberts (1992)
previously questioned the findings within sport research due to
the responsivity concerns of assumed researcher objectivity and
contextual familiarity. In short, researchers' interpretations of
their respondents lived experiences sometimes differ from what their
respondents inferred (Schinke and de Costa, 2000).
As duly noted by Higgins and Schinke (2004)
recently, there is a difference between knowing of and knowing from
lived experiences. Within this study, the principal researcher has
been involved with numerous sports in Canada, not only as an athlete,
but also as a developmental coach. The second researcher has an
extensive elite sport background. His experiences range from being
an international athlete and coach, to a consultant within elite
sporting contexts. The third researcher has extensive athletic experience
at the elite level. She has spent most of her sport career in a
northern Canadian setting, part of it as a university athletic director,
and part as a coach. It was with their combined experiences that
the research team approached this study and its respondent group
of northern Canadian elite coaches.
The respondents
A purposive convenience sampling method was used within the current
study. All of the coaches were elite, domestic, and international
coaches. The term elite coach was adopted from Schinke et al. (1995)
work on the career stages of elite Canadian coaches. Elite coaches
are those whose athletes compete either nationally or internationally.
The elite coaches were approached to participate in this research
project during two separate national coaching certification courses
held within our northern Canada location. The coaches were attending
National Coaching Certification Program Level Four courses, meaning
that they were completing the formal national prerequisites necessary
for national elite status and coaching Canadian athletes at major
games. These coaching courses include sport specific tasks that
are taught by subject specialists and sport specific mentor coaches
(Gowan, 1992).
Three criteria were used for respondent eligibility. First, each
respondent had to be a current coach working at the national elite
level or above, meaning at a minimum they coach at the varsity level
or represent their province at national competitions. Second, all
coaches had to be currently coaching in a northern Canadian setting.
Third, all respondents had to fall within the definitional boundary
of level IV candidacy. The coaches who fit these criteria and were
interested in participating in the project were asked to sign an
ethics consent form. A total of 14 coaches agreed to participate.
The respondents were from 9 different sport backgrounds, Equestrian
(2), Cross Country Skiing (5) Track and Field (1), Swimming (1),
Volleyball (1), Basketball (1), Curling (1), Soccer (1), and Hockey
(1). The respondent group consisted of 5 female coaches and 9 male
coaches. The coaches averaged 17.1 years of coaching experience
(range: 8-30). Their average time spent coaching per week was 23.2
hours (range: 6-47.5) (see Table
1).
Pre-collection
expert review
The study was initially reviewed by four well established elite
coaches working in Northern Canada. The coaches possessed on average
26.75 years of coaching experience (range: 10-45). Two of the coaches
were individual sport coaches, and two were team sport coaches.
The four coaches revised a preliminary version of the structured
open-ended questionnaire in order to ensure a proper beginning to
the study. The expert coaches helped us refine the initial topic
matter surrounding the strengths and weaknesses in a northern Canadian
setting. Furthermore, they provided us with a broader understanding
of the context in which our respondents operate. The reviewers commented
on the terminology, structure, and relevance of our preliminary
structured questions. For example, one reviewer commented on the
ordering of certain questions and recommended changes. Following
the review, the document was modified accordingly. In addition to
an improved flow of the document, this evaluative process, based
on the review of the expert coaches, resulted in the elimination
of questions due to irrelevance and the refinement of others to
improve their clarity.
Data collection
As indicated by Strean and Roberts (1992),
within applied sport research, especially with elite populations,
flawless data collection methods and understanding do not exist.
Multiple data sets were used for the data collection of this study,
with the aforementioned structured questionnaire serving as the
point of entry. This ensured that we were representing the experience
of elite coaching in northern Canadian locations. In terms of representation,
Schinke and de Costa (2000)
noted that it is important that in-depth research is undertaken
within and across methods of data collection. Our respondents answered
a structured open-ended questionnaire. Those attending a specialized
course on elite coach leadership were invited to participate in
a focus group and those within proximity responded to a follow-up
semi-structured interview. The multiple data collection methods
used within our study allowed us to pursue the experiences of our
elite northern Canadian coaches, with the earlier questions directing
subsequent elicitation. Fourteen coaches contributed to the study,
eleven of them responded to the questionnaire, seven of them attended
the focus group, and eight of them were interviewed with a semi-structured
interview guide. Higgins (2004)
duly noted that all elite coaches are faced with extensive and demanding
obligations. Time constraints are compounded for those removed from
urban settings because location often limits their accessibility
(Gauthier et al., 2004). For these reasons the fluidity of participants', and
therefore participation from one national coaching certification
task to the next, varied among respondents.
The structured open-ended questionnaire
We deductively assumed that there would be unique challenges and
advantages to coaching in a northern Canadian community. Through
the inductive data collection methods proposed by Patton (1987),
specific questions were formulated and then refined in order to
obtain a general understanding of the demands and strategies of
elite coaching in northern Canadian settings. For example, the structured
questionnaire included such topics as unique coaching skills acquired
in northern Canadian communities, advantages of coaching in a northern
Canadian setting, disadvantages of coaching in a northern Canadian
setting, coaching self-concept, as well as recommendations to aspiring
northern Canadian elite coaches. These subject areas allowed us
to probe on a deeper level through the in-depth qualitative methods
that followed the focus group and the semi-structured interview.
The nine page questionnaire document contained 18 questions, including
sub-questions. The questionnaire took approximately 30 minutes to
complete.
The
focus group
The focus group discussion lasted 75 minutes. The discussion was
both video and audio recorded. The video recorder was situated with
all the respondents and the researcher in view. The audio recorder
was placed in the center of the discussion circle and the taped
audio content was used for transcription. This ensured that each
statement was properly associated to the corresponding coach. During
the second stage of data collection we followed up on the information
obtained during the earlier structured questionnaire. When new topics
or more specific themes emerged during the structured questionnaire,
the focus group allowed us to follow up at the group level with
the coaches to ensure representation. The researcher's responsibility
during the focus group was to facilitate discussion. He asked questions
and elicited the shared experience among the group. For example,
one coach mentioned that when coaching in a northern Canadian community
you tend to develop "thick skin". This had not been mentioned
by any other coach, but during the group discussion this theme led
to a unanimous agreement across respondents. In addition, the focus
group allowed the respondent group to differentiate common themes
from topics isolated to one respondent. Initial findings were verified
by deepening previous discussion topics and by comparing newly emerging
themes brought forward by focus group respondents, as suggested
by Frey and Fontanna (1991)
and Rubin and Rubin (1995).
The coaches exchanged reflections, often leading to new and more
elaborate experiential details. Throughout this process, the researcher
asked probing questions and sought additional details. At all times,
the facilitation ensured that the discussion stayed focused on the
emergent aspects of elite coaching in northern Canadian communities.
The follow-up semi-structured interview
At the third stage of collection, a follow-up semi-structured interview
guideline was formulated based on Patton's (1987)
interview guidelines criteria. The follow-up semi-structured interview
outline was evolved from earlier questioning, meaning the questionnaire
and focus group data previously collected. The semi-structured interviews,
as suggested by Rubin and Rubin (1995),
allowed for the introduction of topics and specific probing questions.
For example, the primary researcher introduced the topic of disadvantages
of coaching in a rural setting by saying "Based on what has
been shared among the group, it seems that rural athletes have fewer
competition opportunities." The researcher then probed that
statement by asking "Is this true in your experience, and if
so, does it affect athletic development?" The intention of
the follow-up interview was to solidify the findings gleaned through
earlier structured questionnaire and focus group data collection
strategies.
The follow-up interviews brought forth more specific in-depth information
loosely falling within the following topics: (1) unique coaching
skills acquired in northern Canadian communities, (2) advantages
of coaching in a northern Canadian setting, (3) disadvantages of
coaching in a northern Canadian setting, (4) coaching self-concept,
and (5) recommendations to aspiring northern Canadian elite coaches.
A total of eight interviews were conducted. The interviews were
conducted in person when possible, but due to respondent location,
three interviews were conducted over the telephone. The follow-up
interviews lasted 45 minutes on average.
Data analysis
The analysis produced 480 meaning units, with 120 meaning units
(amounting to 25 % of total data collected) falling within the boundaries
of the current study. A meaning unit according to Tesch (1990)
is a segment of text that contains a single idea relating to a specific
topic (see Table 2).
The meaning units varied in length from 1 to 15 lines. Throughout
the ongoing data collection-data analysis cycle, the data was analyzed
according to the three steps suggested by Côté and Salmela (1994).
Initially, we transcribed the information verbatim, followed by
a brief review of the entire document. The first step to the analysis
was to create tags, segmenting the document into "meaning units".
Each meaning unit was labeled according to its respective method
of collection; structured open-ended questionnaire (SOEQ), focus
group (FG), and a follow-up semi-structured interview (FSSI). Second,
once completely "tagged", categories were developed to
group generic higher and lower order meaning units. The categories
were developed and modified with the consensus of the three researchers.
Therefore, as the research project progressed from beginning to
end, the emergent themes continually evolved. The third and final
step was to carefully analyse the specific content of each meaning
unit within the categories. Following each analysis steps, specific
questions suggested by Côté and Salmela (1994)
were asked in order to ensure that the data was properly tagged
categorized and analyzed.
Trustworthiness of the analysis
In order to ensure the trustworthiness of the study different criteria
could have been assessed. As Manning (1997)
states; "trustworthiness was conceived as a parallel to the
empiricist concepts of the internal and external validity, reliability,
and objectivity (p.95)." We ensured the quality and rigor of
the project by evaluating the trustworthiness of the project according
to the work of Guba (1980). We considered the aspects
of credibility, confirmability, dependability, and transferability
throughout the data analysis.
Credibility according to Guba (1980) is assessed by examining researcher
interpretation. The credibility of the researchers' interpretations
was assessed in two ways. We conducted regular research meetings
to ensure research team agreement throughout the data interpretation.
Furthermore, an internal audit was conducted by allowing each respondent
to review the data before any final results were reported. We forwarded
the results via electronic mail to all the respondents for review
and authentication. The respondents were given a two week opportunity
to express their recommendations or acknowledgments regarding the
data's accuracy and representation.
Confirmability can be defined as the considerable efforts devoted
to ensure that research results truly represent the respondents'
views. By exploring multiple methods of collection, the respondents
were given numerous opportunities to express their personal views
and to clarify any inaccuracies. The respondent had the opportunity
to voice any concerns and opinions with regards to either the focus
group or the in-depth semi-structured interview. Further, the aforementioned
internal audit allowed the respondents to review the data analysis
before results were finalized.
Dependability is examined by ensuring that consistent results can
be obtained more than once (Guba, 1980). The review of the questionnaire
by experienced coaches ensured that what we were initially asking
truly represented the experiences that comprise coaching in northern
Canadian communities. Further, by considering three different data
sources we increased the likelihood of proper representation. The
data collection-data analysis cycle, as well as the peer consensus
of the data's interpretation, allowed for a trustworthy analysis
that ensured minimal information going unnoticed or being misinterpreted.
Due to the specificity associated with geographic location, the
findings herein may not be directly transferable to all other northern
locations in other provinces, or northern locations in other countries.
However, what this study does provide is insight into one province's
northern region. Its physically constrained insights indicate that
the demands faced by elite coaches are not necessarily the same
across geographical locations.
Limitations
Stake (1995)
defines data source triangulation as, "…an effort to see if
what we are observing and reporting carries the same meaning when
found under different circumstances (p.113)." The current project
does triangulate by using multiple data collection methods and sources,
as well as multiple researchers. Due to the demanding schedules
of coaches, most of whom are also parents and professionals outside
of sport, not all coaches were able to participate in all three
of the collection sets. In a Canadian context, a full-time coaching
profession rarely occurs. Therefore the triangulation did not occur
at the level of every respondent. Instead, representation was sought
at the group level through multiple data sets. However, such uncontrollable
factors, we believe, do not undermine the relevance of the immediate
study.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Advantages
From the data analysis, numerous themes emerged within two general
deducted categories. The two categories are (1) the advantages of
coaching in a northern Canadian community and (2) the disadvantages
of coaching in northern Canadian communities. The themes that emerged
within the advantages of coaching in a northern community were:
(1) community social support, (2) athlete's perceived toughness,
(3) community exposure, and (4) adaptation to geography. The four
themes will be discussed in turn.
Community social support: The elite coaches emphasized their appreciation
of small northern Canadian communities. They expressed that it was
advantageous to a have a tightly knit community where everybody
involved within their sport was willing to lend a helping hand.
The advantages related to northern Canadian community social support
ranged from public attitude and outlook, to the cooperative involvement
of all involved within their sport. As one coach stated:
- "Northern
(province) people and kids are great. They have a more relaxed
philosophy towards life and are very quick to thank the coach
for coaching their kids. There often is a great community spirit
to support your work… Parents are used to helping out doing whatever
is needed."( Respondent 4-SOEQ)
Further,
the coaches felt that their community's welcoming characteristics
worked to their advantage when it came to attracting prospective
athletes and associate coaches. Our elite coaches felt that they
could use community uniqueness and more involved and encouraging
social support as an attractive alternative to urban anonymity experienced
by aspiring elite coaches. In essence, our coaches acknowledged
that coaching in a northern Canadian community offered a supportive
environment that served as a motivational influence for both aspiring
elite athletes and coaches.
Athlete perceived toughness: Often being faced with adverse training
conditions and numerous obstacles, such as a lack of facilities
and inadequate training equipment, the coaches felt that their athletes
developed a resilient self-perception. Northern Canadian trials
and tribulations fostered a sense of "toughness" within
the athletes that allowed them to respond positively during game-day
challenges, as explained by this coach:
- "…the
training situations that we have to go through are incredible.
We've had (a person) come up here who was recruiting… she (the
athlete) was running in the hallways, running up and down linoleum
hallways and stairs. We train in 2 months of nice weather and
the rest is iffy. They've (the athletes) learned to adapt and
when the weather is really bad at a competition it does not phase
them…" (Respondent 3- FSSI)
Some
of the coaches suggested that "perceived toughness" could
also be a characteristic acquired through the small community lifestyle.
Precisely, it was suggested that the great majority of northern
Canadian trained athletes, especially those from hard working blue
collar families, carry their vicariously learned work habits over
onto the sport playing field.
- "…I
think that our athletes tend to be more hardy. It's a characteristic
or an intangible that other programs or areas often highlight
being something they recognize in our athletes. I'm not really
sure where that comes from… maybe it's bred somehow into our blue
collar work ethic…" (Respondent 13-FSSI)
Despite
the subjectivity of the above mentioned category, our coaches felt
that a self-perception of "toughness" allowed the athletes
to overcome any sense of inferiority when competing in larger venues.
Community exposure: Numerous factors to be mentioned indicate that
within a small community, athletes are highly recognized for their
efforts. Elite coaches and athletes have less competition and are
the main event within their community. Therefore, they receive an
abundance of coverage.
- "You've
got media here that realize that local sport is important. Certainly
in the last few years especially… they've put a lot of attention
on local athletes, especially those who are doing well in larger
venues, like at the provincial, national or international level.
Because we are in a smaller market, we get more attention than
certainly somebody from (more urbanized regions)." (Respondent
3- FSSI)
As
well, when athletes and coaches achieve success within their sport
in spite of their challenges, it is often acknowledged as an extraordinary
feat. Such acknowledgement appears to be due to the inferiority
of physical training resources.
Adaptation to geography: The coaches felt that they developed and
acquired skills, beyond what is typical, due to their unique environment.
It was suggested that this personal coaching skill was essential
to their professional adaptation and subsequently their coaching
success. Adaptation to geography is discussed by expanding on the
aspects related to this skill.
With a wide number of disadvantages stemming from northern Canadian
elite coaching, the respondents tended to develop an adaptable coaching
style. For instance, they become accustomed to modifying their training
sessions in accordance to what is made available to them.
- "I
believe I have developed the ability to be flexible and to quickly
substitute workouts because of our unpredictable weather and difficult
training conditions. A fairly high percentage of our workouts
are changed or adapted on-site." (Respondent 3-SOEQ)
As
the coaches learned to adapt, they become more creative, which allowed
for a constant interest and progression within their athletes.
- "Because
of difficult winter conditions, I've become very creative in keeping
workouts fun and different, for example snowshoe running and running
on ice in spikes." (Respondent 3 -SOEQ)
Once
again, the coaches must work within the confines of what they have
in order to develop resilient northern Canadian athletes. They must
modify their training sessions and create innovative ways to help
their athletes consistently improve.
The northern Canadian coaches expressed that they were often faced
with numerous hardships. For example, they regularly struggled with
recruitment and retention regularly. They also struggled with limited
financial resources, facilities, and equipment. In the face of these
struggles, the coaches felt that they developed a resiliency beyond
what is typical. As one respondent expressed, when coaching in a
northern Canadian community you tend to develop "thick skin".
It is this "thick skin" that helps them to manage and
bounce back from hardships.
- "…I've
lost kids that no one else recruited. I've talked to kids for
two years that no one else was talking to…at least I could have
lost him to coach so and so from that school... Having thick skin,
I think is huge…" (Respondent 8-FG)
Despite
being faced with numerous challenges, northern Canadian coaches
manage to stay persistent and optimistic due to their resilient
personalities. The above mentioned advantages clearly indicate that
a northern Canadian coaching experience can be highly beneficial
despite their northern Canadian contextual challenges.
Disadvantages
Despite the advantages of coaching in northern Canadian communities,
several disadvantages were also delineated. They are (1) travel
distance, (2) lack of resources, (3) athlete retention and recruitment,
(4) lack of competition, as well as (5) facilities and equipment
availability.
Travel distance: Being at a considerable distance from any
major urban center can create numerous disadvantages. Nearly all
the coaches mentioned travel distance as a significant challenge.
Coaching in a northern Canadian community means traveling widespread
distances, which equates to spending extensive hours on the road.
Physical remoteness reciprocally affects other personal aspects
of the coach's life, such as time away from work and time away from
family and friends.
- "…time
for the coach to attend races is much greater than if one lived
in (urban city). It is a 2 day drive to an event in (urban city).
This means that you lose more work days and your vacation days
are entirely devoted to traveling to and from events with the
team which can lead to family conflict. (Respondent 4- SOEQ)
Adding
to the challenges caused by distance, northern Canadian coaches
are faced with increased travel cost and, therefore, they have to
cut their expenses elsewhere. This sometimes means making the sacrifice
of having outdated equipment and substandard facilities.
- "Over
half of my budget is travel, if we travel more that means we get
less equipment and that means we get less money for assistant
coaches. (Respondent 2-FSSI)
Travel
distance is the most evident adversity to coaching in a northern
Canadian community and unfortunately there is no solution. Coaches
simply learn to accept and cope with their physical remoteness in
comparison to their urban competitors.
Resources: Coming from northern Canadian communities, the resources
are not as abundant, both monetary and personnel. In terms of finance,
it becomes very difficult to attract big sponsorships from local
businesses in order to obtain the necessary financial support. In
terms of personnel, several coaches emphasized the fact of having
a smaller pool of qualified coaches affects the developmental stages
of athletes within their sport. Without the proper coaching at the
grassroot levels, it is inevitable that it will affect the number
of elite athletes who emerge down the road. Speaking to this latter
type of resources, one coach shared his views:
- "The
common denominator coming back has always been resources and availability
of coaching development. I think looking at the coaching development
side of it, I coach women's soccer, we are so far behind…because
they start at an early age, they have resources, they have qualified
coaching early, they are leaps ahead of us…" (Respondent
10-FG)
As
well, having a small personnel resource base, it becomes difficult
to get specific assistance in certain specialized areas, both technical
and tactical. One coach stated:
- "Often
it is hard to find someone who can help you with certain aspects
of training a team, for example a sport psychologist." (Respondent
1-SOEQ)
Insufficient
resources, of any kind, can significantly influence a coach's effectiveness.
A lack of personnel and financial support, then, tends to put northern
Canadian sport organizations and their elite coaches at a disadvantage.
Athlete retention and recruitment: Two further disadvantages
discussed were the challenges associated with recruiting athletes
from elsewhere, and retaining talented locally produced athletes.
Some coaches felt that it was very difficult to attract prospective
athletes. They faced challenges when it came to convincing athletes
that a northern Canadian community has its advantages and is the
"right" choice.
- "The
big problem is recruiting. There's a big bias toward my city,
my university, the size of my school…My program is an issue as
well; if you win a National championship then people are knocking
at your door to get in to your program. They can be selective,
it's not you recruiting them, it becomes the other way around,
they recruit you." (Respondent 8- FG)
It
was also expressed that it would be difficult to retain local athletes
opting toward a more urban area. It was believed by coaches that
some young individuals felt that they needed to move on to bigger
and better things in order to achieve their athletic goals. Others
simply moved on to pursue academics in more urban communities, as
this coach stated:
- "…we
lose many top junior "prospects" at 17-18 years of age
as they move away to go to post-secondary schools- just as they're
coming into their prime as junior curlers." (Respondent 1-SOEQ)
As
one coach summarized, there seems to be a limited flow to northern
Canadian communities, with many urban athletes staying in their
own regions, and many northern athletes moving on to urban locations.
Lack of competition: A smaller community also means a smaller
pool of athletes to compete against. With less competitive athletes
living in their regions, there are decreased chances of training
daily with suitable competitors.
- "…if
the teams that I'm coaching were in (a more regional location),
we could attend a junior competition every weekend…The experience,
the strategy aspects, the tactics are the big things. We just
don't compete against as many quality teams. (Respondent 1- FSSI)
With
dismay, many of the coaches mentioned that there is no obvious solution.
As difficult as it is to travel to find adequate competition, it
is just as difficult, if not more, to get competitive opponents
from larger centers to travel to northern Canadian communities.
Without suitable level competitive opponents, the athletes and teams
trained by our coaches tend to suffer in regards to their cumulative
competition experience.
Facilities and equipment availability: Another noted disadvantage
was access to appropriate facilities and equipment. Smaller communities
do not have the same revenue and therefore it affects their expenses.
They do not have sufficient monetary resources to have the most
efficient training equipment, let alone a facility, at all.
- "Winter
training, our indoor training facilities are horrible, we have
no indoor track." (Respondent 3- SOEQ)
One
coach even raised the point of having a hard time quickly replacing
damaged equipment. Equipment that would usually be easily and quickly
available in an urban area, could take weeks to deliver out to a
northern Canadian community. When equipment needs to be replaced,
the coaches need to think of a quick alternative as they wait for
the replacement piece
- "…
Helping athletes get good equipment is also a challenge because
you often have to ship it in… If you break equipment mid-season
or close to a race you can't just drive down the street and select
a replacement..." (Respondent 4- SOEQ)
Equipment
accessibility and an adequate training facility may considerably
improve an athlete's development. Without these attributes northern
Canadian athletes could lag behind their urban competitors.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
The
results of the study indicate the importance of geographical location
in relation to the coaching process of northern Canadian elite coaches.
The findings provided us with an outline of the numerous facets
to coaching in this unique Canadian region. We have discovered that
northern Canadian elite coaches gain exclusive skills in the process
of overcoming the countless adversities associated to their environmental
surroundings. Skills such as adaptation to their environments, creativity
within their training sessions, and resiliency while overcoming
disappointments must be overcome. Furthermore, the study confirmed
that our northern Canadian elite coaches felt that the uniqueness
of their coaching location also provided them with numerous rewards
that would not otherwise be available within a larger urban area,
such as community social support and media exposure. In general,
our study supports the numerous aspects outlined in the previous
literature by Orlick (1986),
Partington (1988),
and Salmela (1994),
such as the skills needed to coach at the elite level of competition
and the factors affecting their success. Further, the study puts
forward a new ideology that could affect the way we approach, not
only northern Canadian elite coaching development, but also regional
coaching on a global scale.
Coaching at the elite level can be challenging at times. There are
certain attributes that are needed in order to succeed in this profession.
Several researchers have successfully identified coaching attributes
within a generic elite coaching context. Martens (1990)
recognized that all successful elite coaches develop the ability
to be great teachers, leaders, as well as motivators. Furthermore,
as outlined by Salmela (1994),
specific emerging personal characteristics lead to eventual success.
Successful elite coaches with these generic attributes can respond
effectively to the numerous elite coaching demands. Our respondent
group of northern Canadian elite coaches demonstrated a strong intensity
and desire towards reaching personal success which has also been
mentioned by Salmela (1994).
In addition, our coaches demonstrated above average leadership skills
not only towards their individual team or athletes, but within their
entire local sport community. These leadership skills, as delineated
by Schinke et al. (1997),
were then imparted to their athletes by selling their vision and
inspiring them to pursue athletic excellence. Furthermore, elite
coaching qualitative research traditions introduced by Orlick and
Partington (1986),
which reveal the lived experience of successful elite coaches and
athletes, allowed the researchers to provide a truthful and accurate
representation of elite coaching in a northern Canadian community.
The current study also supports the acknowledgement given to contextual
factors and their contribution within the coaching process indicated
by Côté et al. (1995).
There exists without a doubt certain unpredictable and variables
that affect coaching procedures within an elite coaching context.
Some contextual factors may be generically considered across coaching
cases. However, our findings suggest that contextual factors can
be elaborated one step further by mentioning environmental specificity
within this peripheral factor. Further emphasizing the variables
within each individual geographical environment may make a significant
contribution to elite coaching development. As mentioned previously,
we are endlessly influenced by our working conditions, and therefore
the challenges and advantages affecting the coaching process differ
remarkably from one geographical location to the next. In essence,
each coaching scenario should be individually evaluated based on
individual geographical demands.
Using this suggestion could in turn lead to modifications within
our approach to guiding aspiring elite coaches from various remote
and rural locations. Coaching development programs in rural and
remote communities should look at the coaching needs within specific
environmental contexts. Creating an awareness of contextual specificity
could better prepare aspiring elite coaches for the demands to be
placed on them within a unique environment. Aspiring elite coaches
should also focus on developing the necessary attributes needed
to properly respond to rural and remote elite coaching adversities
in order to further improve their rates of success, despite their
physical isolation. The findings within the study also raise additional
elite coaching research questions. Additional research should be
conducted in order to explore if there exists any commonalities
within the developmental stages of northern Canadian elite coaches.
It may be possible that most northern Canadian elite coaches have
previously been northern Canadian elite athletes and therefore are
better prepared as coaches to respond to their unique environmental
surroundings. Furthermore, our findings suggest that if context
specificity affects coaching demands and process, it may also affect
elite athlete development and outcome. In addition, this research
topic should be expanded by exploring the experiences of elite coaches
from various international rural and remote locations. The results
could further emphasize the importance of context specificity, from
a global perspective, affecting the elite coaching profession.
To summarize, our study has not only contributed to the current
literature on elite coaching, it has also produced research possibilities
that can further the area of elite coaching and athlete development.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
There
is much to conclude from the immediate study. First, there is indication
that geography influences upon the elite coach's planning behaviours.
In relation to daily training, in northern Canada for instance, coaches
are often compelled to develop training plans that overcome weather
and terrain challenges. Second, there is also competition planning
to consider. Precisely, geographical proximity affects athletes' amassed
experiences, as well as their level of experience in competition tactics.
Combined, these two facets alone indicate that coaching researchers
interested in applied understanding would be best served by a reconciliation
of geography.
In addition, coaching researchers and applied trainers interested
in formalized coaching certification delivery can also benefit from
the inclusion of geography. For example, coaches in northern and remote
locations ought to learn personal and athlete adaptation skills that
are unique in some ways from those working in larger urban centers.
The nuances associated with geographical uniqueness gained through
focus groups for instance, can lead to better suited and more meaningful
coaching education programs.
In closing, the conclusions considered affirm the importance of regional
location as a contextual consideration for coaches and sport scientists.
Through a refined understanding of coach and athlete functioning in
relation to their geography, sport science and sport application will
flourish. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Both
the Yo-Yo intermittent endurance test and 20m multistage shuttle
run test are valid measures of aerobic exertion in soccer players
- Measured
VO2max per se may not be suitable to characterize soccer players'
intermittent endurance performance.
- In
comparison with the MST, the YIET may be a more favourable field-based
assessment of soccer player's endurance performance.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Alain P. GAUTHIER
Employment:Laboratory technologist in the School of Human
Kinetics at Laurentian University.
Degree: MA
Research interests: Rural development and coaching studies.
E-mail: agauthier@laurentian.ca |
|
Robert J. SCHINKE
Employment: Professor in the School of Human Kinetics at
Laurentian University.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Psychology and Human Kinetics in
a study examining the nuances of context specific cultural sport
psychology.
E-mail: rschinke@laurentian.ca |
|
Pat PICKARD
Employment: Professor in the School of Human Kinetics at
Laurentian University.
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Coaching Pedagogy and Crowd Behaviour
E-mail: ppickard@laurentian.ca |
|
|
|
|