|
EFFECTS OF FUNCTIONAL ELECTRIC STIMULATION CYCLE ERGOMETRY TRAINING
ON LOWER LIMB MUSCULATURE IN ACUTE SCI INDIVIDUALS
|
1Department of Athletic Training, Indiana State University,
Terre Haute, Indiana, USA
2Department of Health and Sport Science, School of Education
and Allied Professions, University of Dayton, Dayton, Ohio, USA
3Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Endocrinology
and Metabolism, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA
4Department of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation., The
Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, USA
5Sport and Exercise Science Program, The Ohio State University,
Columbus, Ohio, USA
| Received |
|
08 April 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
15
June 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
September 2005 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2005) 4, 263 - 271
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
purpose of this study was to compare three different intervals for
a between sets rest period during a common isokinetic knee extension
strength-testing protocol of twenty older Brazilian men (66.30 ± 3.92
yrs). The volunteers underwent unilateral knee extension (Biodex System
3) testing to determine their individual isokinetic peak torque at
60, 90, and 120°·s-1. The contraction speeds and the rest periods
between sets (30, 60 and 90 s) were randomly performed in three different
days with a minimum rest period of 48 hours. Significant differences
between and within sets were analyzed using a One Way Analysis of
Variance (ANOVA) with repeated measures. Although, at angular velocity
of 60°·s-1 produced a higher peak torque, there were no significant
differences in peak torque among any of the rest periods. Likewise,
there were no significant differences between mean peak torque among
all resting periods (30, 60 and 90s) at angular velocities of 90 and
120°·s-1. The results showed that during a common isokinetic strength
testing protocol a between set rest period of at least 30 s is sufficient
for recovery before the next test set in older men.
KEY
WORDS: Aging, muscle strength, muscle fatigue, isokinetic test.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
The
functional consequence is of Spinal Cord Injury (SCI) are associated
with changes in the physiologic, histologic, and morphologic properties
of the affected skeletal muscle. Changes include muscle atrophy,
decreased muscle fiber cross sectional area (CSAf), decreased
force of contraction in response to electrical stimulation, decreased
oxidative enzymes, decreased fatigue resistance and a transformation
of Type I, slow-twitch muscle fiber to Type IIx fast-twitch
muscle fibers (Baldi et al., 1998;
Burnham et al., 1997;
Castro et al.,1999).
It has been reported that CSAf decreases more than 60%
by 24 weeks post-injury (Castro et al., 1999)
with a 21% decrease in lower extremity lean body mass 36 weeks post
injury (Baldi et al. 1998).
Transition from Type I to Type IIx muscle fibers appears
to begin 24 weeks post-injury with the initial changes being from
Type IIa to IIx (Castro et al. 1999)
with a complete transition occurring one to two years post injury
(Burnham et al. 1997).
Remodeling of muscle to faster isoforms has also been demonstrated
in a number of other disuse models such as spinal contusion (Hutchinson
et al., 2001)
and short-term space flight (Day et al., 1995).
The shift to faster muscle isoforms may have some effect to conserve
power output by shifting the force-velocity curve (Faulkner et al.,
1995),
however, when normalized to fiber area (N·cm-2), force
production is reportedly not affected by fiber type (Brooks and
Faulkner, 1988).
Therefore, decreased force and power following SCI appears primarily
to be due to decreased CSAf , while a shift towards Type
II isoforms would decrease fatigue resistance of muscle.
One modality used to try to attenuate or reverse changes in skeletal
muscle as a result of SCI is electrical stimulation, however to
date the affects have been modest. In chronic SCI survivors, more
than 2 years post-injury, exposure to prolonged low frequency electrical
stimulation resulted in a reversal of Type II muscle fibers towards
Type I muscle fibers and no change in CSAf (Martin et
al., 1992).
Other researchers reported increased fatigue resistance and an improvement
in oxidative capacity (Rochester et al., 1995a;
1995b)
with similar protocols. Other more modest low frequency stimulation
protocols documented an increase in fatigue resistance, no change
in MHC isoform content, but in situ hybridization documented that
mRNA for the Type I MHC isoforms were up regulated and the Type
IIx MHC isoforms were down regulated (Harridge et al.,
2002).
Protocols utilizing functional electrical stimulation cycle ergometry
(FES-CE) to train chronic SCI survivors have been documented to
alter the effects of SCI on muscle morphology and histology. An
FES-CE protocol of one year duration reported a significant shift
in MHC composition from an overwhelming predominance of Type IIb
to a predominance of Type IIa fibers with no discernable
change in Type I MHC isoforms (Mohr et al., 1997).
Others have reported an increase in muscle mass (Mohr et al., 1997;
Scremin et al., 1999)
and a modest increase in CSAf (Chilinbeck et al., 1999).
Significant improvement in fatigue resistance (Gerrits et al., 2000)
and power output (Faghri et al., 1992;
Hooker et al., 1992)
have also been reported in similar studies using FES-CE training.
One study trained acute SCI (14- 15 weeks post- SCI) using FES-CE,
reported prevention of the loss of lean body mass after 3 month
of training and hypertrophy of leg muscles after 6 months of training
(Baldi et al., 1998).
These data then support the potential for electrical stimulation
to reverse the plasticity observed in skeletal muscle after SCI
and thereby improve the strength and endurance properties of that
muscle for potentially functional purposes. The magnitude of the
strength and endurance changes in response to electrical stimulation
of chronic SCI survivors have been relatively modest despite the
utilization of varied stimulation protocols and parameters under
isometric contraction, contraction against no load or FES-CE conditions.
Previous work in our laboratory (Baldi et al., 1998)
demonstrated attenuation of loss in lean body mass muscle mass when
FES-CE training was initiated within weeks of SCI. However, conservation
of muscular power or changes to CSAf or fiber type in
response to early intervention with FES-CE is unknown. Therefore,
the primary purpose of this study was to determine if intervening
4 to 6 weeks post injury using FES-CE can attenuate the change in
muscle fiber cross sectional area and MHC composition that is otherwise
observed in response to SCI. It was hypothesized that 13 weeks of
FES-CE training starting 4 to 6 weeks post injury would increase
average cyclic power output and attenuate decreases in CSAf
seen post SCI.
|
| METHODS |
|
Subjects
A total of ten SCI subjects participated in this study and were
recruited from the acute spinal cord injury (SCI) in-patient rehabilitation
center. Subject demographic information can be found in Table
1. Criteria for selection were cervical or thoracic motor complete
SCI (American Spinal Injury Association [ASIA] A or B) individuals
17-50 years of age (Maynard et al., 1997).
All subjects were clinically stable before entering the study and
continued their normal rehabilitation programs throughout the period
of the study. Subjects were required to be able to sit upright for
greater than thirty minutes before they were allowed to start training.
Exclusion criteria include the presence of pressure ulcers, recurrent
urinary tract infection, and transportation problems, prescribed
medications that directly affect bone and muscle metabolism, lower
extremity fracture at the time of the SCI, prolonged bleeding times,
full dose anticoagulation, a history of clotting abnormalities,
or known bleeding diathesis. All prospective subjects were given
a thorough neurological and physiological exam including range of
motion of lower limbs, resting electrocardiograph, and X-rays of
lower extremities before participating in the study. Subjects were
randomly assigned to either SCI-control (IC) or SCI- Functional
Electric Stimulation Cycle Ergometry (FES-CE) (IE) groups. Non-injured
age and gender-matched individuals were recruited from the faculty
and student population of the Ohio State University to serve as
uninjured controls (UIC). Following explanation of the procedures;
purposes, benefits and risks of the study each subject provided
written informed consent. This study was approved by the Institutional
Review Board.
Equipment and training protocol
The FES-cycle ergometer training system is composed of a Stimaster
Clinical Ergometry system (Electrologic of America, Inc., Dayton,
OH), which was connected to an electrically braked cycle ergometer
(Therapeutic Alliance, Inc., Fairborn, OH). As described previously
(Baldi et al. 1998)
training sessions were held 30 minutes·day-1, 3 days·week-1
for 13 weeks. Before each FES-CE training session 12 reusable electrodes
were placed over appropriate motor points on the quadriceps, hamstring,
and gluteal muscle groups. Each training session began with a one-minute
warm- up, during which stimulation was delivered to all muscles
at 50% of the threshold value (the minimum required to produce a
palpable, tetanic contraction). Pedaling motion was assisted by
an able-bodied operator throughout the warm-up and for the first
10-30 seconds of full stimulation, until the subject's legs created
enough power to maintain the cycling motion independently. All subjects
began at 2 watts with the goal of completing 30 minutes of continuous
cycling. As subject's legs fatigued, and after delivered stimulation
increased to the maximum (140 mA), pedaling cadence would slow.
The stimulator is programmed to terminate the stimulation once cadence
decreased to 35 rpm. Post ride, each subject went through a two-minute
passive pedaling cool-down. Upon completion of 3 consecutive 30-minute
training sessions, subjects' resistance was increased by 6.1 watts.
Subjects that were unable to ride at 2.4 watts for any length of
time were trained to increase their quadriceps strength by performing
electrically stimulated knee extensions. The leg was stimulated
for 5 seconds with a 30 seconds rest before the next leg extension.
When the subject was able to perform 30 repetitions of 45° knee
extension with 1 kg, they were placed on the cycle ergometer and
followed the training regimen as described above.
Functional changes
Functional changes in power output of the IE group were determined
by changes in average weekly power output during FES-CE training.
Average weekly power output was determined from the average power
output of each ride as calculated by the Stimaster Clinical Ergometry
system and the number of training sessions per week.
Tissue Collection
Needle biopsies of the vastus lateralis (VL) muscle were taken initially
4-6 weeks post-SCI and after 13 weeks of training. Initial biopsies
in SCI subjects varied between 4 and 6 weeks post-injury when subjects
could sit upright for 30 minutes without orthostatic hypotension.
Biopsies were taken from the non-injured control subjects 13 weeks
apart. Biopsies for all subjects were taken from the non-dominant
leg with a 25-gauge biopsy needle. Tissue was rapidly coated with
Tissue-Tek OCT compound (Fisher 15-183-13), placed in a microcentrifuge
tube, rapidly frozen in liquid nitrogen and stored at -80 °C for
subsequent analysis.
Muscle histology and morphology
Ten-micrometer serial cross-sections were cut from the muscle biopsy
sample using a Reichert Histostat Microtome cryostat (-20° C), placed
onto coverslips and stained using hematoxylin and eosin for identification
of nuclear density and muscle fiber cross sectional area (CSAf)
(Luna 1968).
Slides were viewed under a Leitz Weitcher microscope equipped with
a top mounted video camera. Images were sent to a Pentium 1 computer
with Bioquant Classic 95 software package (R&M Biometrics, Inc.)
for analysis.
Fiber CSA was determined by calculating the CSA of 100 fibers using
computer software (Bioquant 95, R&B Biometrics, Inc.). The muscle
fiber cross-sections were captured and traced on a video monitor
using a hand held mouse. The software was calibrated to determine
the area in µm2. Average fiber CSA was determined for
each muscle from the mean of 100 fibers quantified for each muscle.
To reduce experimental bias in the selection of fibers for measurement,
all of the fibers on randomly selected slides were quantified. Quantification
of CSAf was practiced until a coefficient of variance
of less than 5% was repeatedly achieved (See
Figure 1).
Myonuclear density was defined as the number of myonuclei·mm-2
of CSA and was determined by counting the number of nuclei in a
set area and dividing the number by the area in square millimeters
(Allen et al., 1997).
Five counts were taken from different regions of each muscle section
and the average of these values was used to determine nuclear density.
To reduce experimental bias in the selection of nuclei for measurement,
the slide was randomly selected for performing myonuclei counting.
Myosin heavy chain (MHC) composition was determined using sodium
dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) as
described previously (Talmadge and Roy, 1993).
The SDS-PAGE gels were stained with rapid coomassie blue and scanned
with a Pharmacia LKB Ultrascan laser scanning densitometer for quantification
of MHC composition (See Figure
2).
Statistical
analyses
A one-way ANOVA with repeated measures was used to determine changes
in functional power output for the SCI exercise group. A two-way
ANOVA was used for statistical analysis of nuclear density, fiber
CSA, and changes in MHC composition. Level of significance was set
a priori at p < 0.05. The Student-Newman- Keul method was used
to determine specifically where the significant difference occurred.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Functional
changes
At the onset of training, subjects average power output was 2.4
± 0.88 watts (mean ± SEM). Average weekly power output increased
in the IE group by week four. Power output continued to increase
with training and reached a maximum of 24.5 ± 3.2 watts (Figure
3).
Muscle
morphology
There was no difference in CSAf between SCI groups at
time of initial biopsy. However, compared with uninjured control
subjects, SCI resulted in a 36 % decrease in CSAf in
both injured groups (Figure 4;
p = 0.009). There was a continued decrease (72%) from initial biopsy
after 13 weeks in the IC subjects (p < 0.001). In contrast, FES-CE
training increased CSAf 63% in IE subjects following
13 weeks of training (3376 ± 625 vs. 5518 ± 1205 µm2).
However, the difference was not significant (p = 0.172). After 13
weeks of FES-CE training the CSAf of the IE groups was
171% greater than the CSAf in the IC group (p = 0.05).
There was no significant difference in nuclear density in SCI subjects
compared to UIC at baseline. In addition FES-CE had no effect on
nuclear density (Figure 5).
Similarly, MHC composition of the muscle was unaffected by SCI and
FES-CE (Table 2).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
There
is a paucity of data related to understanding the training consequences
of functional electric stimulation cycle ergometry (FES-CE) on the
maintenance of skeletal muscle form, structure, and function after
acute spinal cord injury (SCI). To date, the effect of FES-CE in
acute SCI subjects has been limited to measures of lean body mass
and not focused on potential alterations to the morphological and
physiological characteristics of skeletal muscle. Therefore, the
primary aim of the present study was to
determine the affect of FES-CE on muscle fiber cross-sectional area
(CSAf), as well as to characterize changes in myosin
heavy chain (MHC) composition, myonuclear density, and power output
on a bicycle ergometer in acute SCI participants.
Previous
studies utilizing FES-CE training on chronic SCI survivors have
reported increases in power output, defined as force input of a
particular skeletal muscle or muscle group multiplied by velocity,
that range from 5.1-17.1 watts following 8 -52 weeks of FES-CE training
(Chilinbeck et al., 1999;
Faghri et al., 1992;
Hooker et al., 1992;
Mohr et al., 1997;
Scremin et al., 1999).
In contrast, data from the present study demonstrate that the weekly
power output averaged 24.5 ± 3.2 watts, which was achieved with
13 weeks of FES-CE training. Thus, the increase in power output
found in the present study is substantially greater than seen in
previous studies using chronic SCI subjects, suggesting that early
intervention utilizing FES-CE training more effectively conserves
power output when compared with other electrical stimulation training
protocols using chronic SCI patients.
A potentially salient adaptation known to result in an increase
in power output is an increase in force development and, force production
of a given muscle is directly related to its cross-sectional area
(CSA). Previous work in chronic SCI subjects indicated the increases
in power output were due to increases in either whole muscle CSA
(Mohr et al., 1997;
Scremin et al., 1999)
or CSAf (Chilinbeck et al., 1999).
In the present study, there was a 3 times greater increase in power
output than reported by Mohr et al. (1997)
suggesting that the more substantial attenuation of muscle atrophy
observed in this study as a result of the acute intervention, contributed
to diminishing the loss of power output (Figure
3).
In the present study, the CSAf in SCI subjects decreased
by 36% by 4-6 weeks post-injury, and 72% at 17-19 weeks post-injury
relative to uninjured control subjects. These data are in close
agreement with those of Castro et al. (1999)
who reported decreases in CSAf of 37% and 62% 6 and 24
weeks post-injury, respectively. Previous reports state that the
CSAf of chronic SCI subjects was 53% to 68% less than
the CSAf of uninjured control subjects (Castro et al.,
1999;
Martin et al., 1992).
Therefore, the present data demonstrate a similar progressive loss
in CSAf and underscores the observation that the majority
of changes in CSAf occur within the first 24 weeks following
a spinal cord injury event.
The CSAf in the SCI exercise group (IE) of the present
study, increased by 63% above pre-training levels after 13 weeks
of FES-CE training and was 171% greater than the SCI control group
at the same time point post-SCI. Previously, Scremin et al. (1999)
and Mohr et al. (1997)
reported increases of 31% and 12% in vastus lateralis and thigh
CSA respectively; with 1 year of FES-CE training in chronic SCI
patients while Chilinbeck et al. (1999)
reported a 23% increase in CSAf with 8 weeks of training.
However, the increases in both CSAf and whole muscle
CSA seen in training chronic SCI subjects are relative to the pre-training
CSA, but when the training effect are compared with the CSAf
of the uninjured control subjects, there is still an approximate
55% deficit. Thus, the training-induced increases in CSAf
in the present study are greater in magnitude than seen in chronic
SCI training studies (68% vs. 23%), and occurred following a much
shorter training period. Also the CSAf post training
in the acute SCI group was only 24% less than the uninjured control
group CSAf versus approximately a 55% deficit seen in
chronic SCI studies. Collectively, these observations again strongly
support early intervention using FES-CE training as more effective
in increasing CSAf following SCI.
Following SCI muscle decreased power associated with decreases in
whole muscle CSA and CSAf , may be partially compensated
for through a shift of MHC isoforms from slow to fast (Castro et
al., 1999;
Burnham et al., 1997).
Mohr et al. (1997)
reported that in chronic SCI subjects, the MHC composition of the
vastus lateralis muscle adapted to 5%, 33%, and 62% for Type I,
Type IIa, and Type IIx MHC, respectively.
However, in spite of the in spite of the large decrease in power
MHC composition in SCI subjects was not different than control at
either 6 or 19 weeks post-injury. Similarly, others (Castro et al.,
1999)
have reported no change in muscle MHC up to six months post-SCI.
Therefore, changes in MHC in SCI subjects appears to occur at a
slower time course than in other disuse models, such as spaceflight
(Day et al., 1995)
and further, decreased muscular power in SCI subjects appears to
be largely due to decreased CSAf.
The present study also showed no changes in MHC composition due
to FES-CE training, whereas, studies utilizing FES-CE training with
chronic SCI subjects reported changes in MHC isoforms from Type
IIx to Type IIa, but no changes in Type I
MHC composition (Mohr et al., 1997).
One possible reason for no training effect of FES-CE on MHC in the
present study was that no shift in MHC had occurred pre- training,
therefore no stimulus for a reversal adaptation was present. Another
possibility is that while the training stimulus was not great enough
to cause shifts in MHC isoform profile, in situ hybridization could
have potentially documented an up-regulation of the Type I MHC and
down-regulation of Type IIx MHC isoform mRNA as noted
by Harridge, et al in their electrical stimulation study involving
chronic SCI survivors. The precise stimulus parameters needed to
maximally elicit adaptation of MHC isoforms using electrical stimulation
are not currently known.
One potential cause for lack of a training effect in response to
FES with chronic SCI subjects compared to that observed in this
study utilizing acute SCI subjects could be a change in the adaptability
of the muscle. Muscle adaptations are related to the number of myonuclei
present within fibers (Allen et al., 1997).
To date no data exist that report alterations in myonuclear density
in either acute or chronic SCI patients. Previous studies in non-SCI
subjects reported increases in the number of myonuclei with increases
in CSAf (Hikida et al., 2000).
In the present study, with acute SCI subjects, the loss of CSAf
had no effect on myonuclear density. Therefore our data suggest
that sufficient myonuclei are retained in acute SCI survivors to
facilitate the increase in CSAf and a subsequent increase
in power output, with FES-CE training. Thus, our findings on myonuclear
density suggest that the large leg muscles of acute SCI patients
retain their potential to adapt to functional demands.
Although these data demonstrate an enhanced response to FES training
in acute SCI subjects relative to chronic SCI subjects, the CSAf
had already decreased by 36% at our baseline assessment of 4-6 weeks
post-SCI. These data would then suggest that to maximally conserve
the cross-sectional area of the muscle, training should start immediately
post-injury. However, the time required to recover from surgical
stabilization, secure hemodynamic stability, and recover from spinal
shock sufficiently to observe muscle contractions in response to
stimulation realistically precludes the initiation of a FES-CE training
program sooner than our baseline 4-6 weeks post-injury.
A potential limitation of this study is the sample size and therefore
the applicability of the study to the general SCI population. The
small sample size (n = 5 per group) occurred despite recruitment
of individuals with SCI from a large Midwestern rehabilitation program
with approximately 100 admissions for SCI rehabilitation per year.
The recruitment pool was primarily limited by the inclusion criteria
that potential subjects must have a motor complete injury and therefore
fall within an ASIA A or B (American Spinal Injury Association)
injury severity category due to the concern that the active exercise
through volitional movement during the concurrent rehabilitation
of patients with ASIA C or D type injuries would confound our outcome
variables (Maynard et al., 1997).
The second largest category of subjects excluded from the study
involved injury related issues such as lower extremity fractures
precluding FES-CE training, peripheral nerve injuries resulting
in an inadequate response to electrical stimulation and thromboembolic
disease requiring full dose anticoagulation, thereby precluding
a muscle biopsy. Finally, the third significant barrier to subject
recruitment involved transportation difficulties to training sessions.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
|
In
conclusion these data indicate that early intervention after SCI
with FES-CE attenuates the changes in both the CSAf and
the loss of power output more effectively than that seen with chronic
SCI and the maintenance of myonuclei suggests a preservation of
the muscle's potential to adapt to functional demands. In view of
the fact that the medical and neurologic consequences of the acute
SCI precludes earlier intervention with FES than the 4-6 weeks after
injury seen in this study, the rehabilitation and performance implications
of these observations suggest that further development of training
and stimulation protocols that enhance muscle strength and endurance
for functional purposes such are needed. Future studies may therefore
consider utilizing a combination of isotonic extension against resistance
with FES-CE. Additionally, modifying the FEC-CE protocol once weekly
to incorporate "sprint" training with repeated short bouts
of high relative resistance followed by a rest period could be explored
as mechanism to elicit a greater training effect.
|
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
| Funding
was provided National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research
# H133A980056. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Muscle
fiber cross sectional area (CSAf ) decreased 38% following spinal
cord injury (SCI).
- Early
intervention with functional electric stimulation cycle ergometry
(FES-CE) prevented further loss of CSAf in SCI patients and increased
power output.
- Muscle
myosin heavy chain (MHC) and myonuclear density were unaffected
by SCI or FES-CE
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Timothy J. DEMCHAK
Employment: Department of Athletic Training, Indiana State
University.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Therapeutic Modalities, Post-Injury
Muscle Regeneration.
E-mail: tdemchak@indstate.edu |
|
Jon
K. LINDERMAN
Employment: Department of Health and Sports Science, University
of Dayton.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Muscle Physiology.
E-mail: jonlinderman@udayton.edu
|
|
W. Jerry MYSIW
Employment: College of Medicine and Public Health, The Ohio
State University.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Head Injury, Functional Electrical
Stimulation, Osteoporosis |
|
Rebecca JACKSON
Employment: College of Medicine and Public Health, The Ohio
State University.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Osteoporosis; Metabolic bone disease
|
|
Jihong
SUUN
Employment: Department of Physical Medicine & Rehabilitation.,
The Ohio State University, Columbus. |
|
Steven
T. DEVOR
Employment: School of Physical Activity and Educational
Services, The Ohio State University.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: skeletal muscle physiology
|
|
|
|
|