A PILOT STUDY TO INVESTIGATE EXPLOSIVE LEG EXTENSOR POWER AND WALKING
PERFORMANCE AFTER STROKE
|
1Department of Clinical Neurology, University
of Oxford, UK
2School of Healthcare, Oxford Brookes University, UK
3School of Biological and Molecular Sciences, Oxford Brookes University,
UK
4Oxford Centre for Enablement, Oxford, UK
5School of Technology, Department of Mathematical Sciences, Oxford Brookes
University, UK
6School of Health Sciences,, University of Birmingham, UK.
| Received |
|
27 June 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
18
October 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
December 2005 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2005) 4, 556
- 562
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| We
examined explosive leg extensor power (LEP) and gait in men and women
after a stroke using an experimental observational design. A convenience
sample of consecutively referred individuals (8 men, 6 women) with
chronic stroke mean age ± SD, range, 46.4 ± 8.4, 32 - 57 years, and
able to walk for four minutes were recruited. The test re-test reliability
and performance of LEP was measured together with walking parameters.
LEP (Watts·kg-1) and gait measures during a four-minute
walk; temporal-spatial gait parameters (GAITRite®) and
oxygen cost of walking (mL·kg-1·m-1) were recorded.
Percentage Asymmetry LEP (stronger LEP - weaker LEP/stronger LEP x
100) was calculated for each person. LEP was reliable from test to
re-test ICC [3, 1] 0.8 - 0.7 (n = 9). Greater Asymmetry LEP correlated
strongly with reduced walking velocity, cadence, stance time, and
swing time on the weaker leg (n = 14) (p < 0.01). Findings demonstrate
explosive LEP, in particular Percentage Asymmetry LEP, can be measured
after stroke and is both reliable and related to walking performance.
LEP training of the stronger or weaker leg warrants further investigation
in this group.
KEY
WORDS: Stroke, leg extensor power, walking, asymmetry.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Walking
has been shown to be limited after stroke by a variety of factors
including spasticity (Bohannon and Andrews, 1990;
Hsu et al., 2003),
decreased balance (Bohannon,
1987;
Nadeau et al., 1999;
Suzuki et al., 1990),
impaired sensation (Brandstater et al., 1983;
Dettmann et al., 1987;
Friedman, 1990;
Keenan et al., 1984),
and muscle weakness (Bohannon, 1991;
Nadeau et al., 1999;
Nakamura et al., 1988).
Investigations of muscle weakness in this clinical group have shown
that the strength of knee extensor (Bohannon, 1986;
1987;
1991;
1997;
Nakamura et al., 1988;
Suzuki et al., 1990)
and hip and ankle flexor muscle groups (Nadeau et al., 1999)
correlates with walking velocity. Moreover, dynamic muscle measures
such as isokinetic torque (Lockhart et al., 2003)
or the rate at which a contraction can be generated (Pohl et al.,
2002)
have been shown to have a stronger relationship with walking performance
than measures of static strength.
Explosive leg extensor power (LEP) is a measure of a person's ability
to generate fast functional movement and may give a better indication
of walking performance than strength measures per se. LEP has been
shown to be a simple, easy to use field measure that correlates
well with walking velocity in healthy older men and women (Bassey
et al., 1992; Skelton et al., 1994). Reduced LEP has also been correlated with lowered walking
velocity following proximal femur fracture (Lamb et al., 1995). Lower limb explosive power, and in particular asymmetry
in LEP (Asymmetry LEP) has been shown to be predictive of functional
difficulties such as slow walking and falls in the elderly (Skelton
et al., 2002) and it may well be related to mobility and independence
following stroke (Bean et al., 2002).
To date, an individual's ability to generate leg extensor power
and the latter's relationship with walking velocity and other measures
of walking performance has yet to be investigated after stroke.
Explosive LEP and Asymmetry LEP were investigated in relation to
walking performance in men and women after a stroke.
|
| METHODS |
|
Participants
Individuals attending a specialist neuro-rehabilitation unit who
were greater than six months after a stroke, were identified through
consultant referral. All patients who could walk continuously for
four minutes or more were included in the study. Anyone with anyone
with an unstable medical condition or cognitive impairment affecting
his or her ability to perform the testing procedure was excluded.
Fourteen participants (8 men, 6 women) with stroke (12 ischaemic,
2 haemorrhagic) were recruited during the study period of six months.
Nine people were available for re-testing and the reliability study
is therefore reported with n = 9.
Procedure
Individuals participated after giving informed consent in accordance
with the declaration of Helsinki (1979) and local ethical committee
approval. All individuals then attended for a familiarisation session
with the equipment and procedures to be used in the study. Testing
was conducted in a physiotherapy gymnasium. Participants were asked
to refrain from the consumption of food, caffeine, alcohol and medication
and to avoid strenuous exercise during the two hours prior to testing.
On arrival information was recorded about age, height, body mass,
compliance with pre-test requirements, physical activity levels,
medication, and general health. Mobility level, Rivermead Mobility
Index (RMI), disability, Barthel Index (BI) and leg spasticity,
Ashworth Scale, were measured.
Measures of expired air were taken at rest, following this measures
of leg extensor power and walking performance were recorded. For
the purpose of the present study walking performance was defined
as the measurement of walking velocity, together with temporal-spatial
gait parameters (e.g. cadence, step length) and oxygen cost (mL·kg-1·m-1)
was taken a measure of walking effort.
Expired air was collected by means of lightweight respiratory valves
and hoses in a 100 litre Douglas bag (Waters et al., 1988). Individuals were initially familiarised with wearing
the Hans Rudolf facemask and then rested supine for a period of
six minutes, immediately followed by the collection of expired air
for a further period of six-minutes. The composition of the expired
air was determined by oxygen and carbon dioxide analysers (Servomex
Series 1400, Crowborough, East Sussex, UK) and the volume of expired
air was measured by means of a dry gas meter (Harvard Apparatus
Limited, Edenbridge, Kent). The gas analysers were calibrated on
each testing occasion by means of gas mixtures of known concentration.
Oxygen consumption was calculated using standard open circuit methodology
and the values expressed under standard conditions (STPD).
Measurement of explosive leg extensor power
The explosive leg extensor power (LEP) rig (Medical Laboratory Workshops,
Nottingham) originally described by Bassey and Short (1990) has
been found to be a safe and acceptable method of measuring explosive
LEP across a wide range of age and levels of ability. Power measurements
from the rig have been shown to correlate strongly with peak isokinetic
power and with power produced by a vertical two-legged jump on a
force plate (Bassey and Short, 1990). It has also been shown to be reliable (inter-observer
and test-retest) in normal elderly control subjects and those with
a history of falls (Lamb et al., 1995; Skelton et al., 2002). The instrument itself consists of an adjustable seat
and large foot pedal connected to a flywheel, the final angular
velocity of which indicates the power output. LEP was measured according
to the method described by Skelton et al. (2002). A value for the LEP in Watts was obtained for each leg
by taking the maximum power achieved when the power output reached
a plateau during an average of five attempts following familiarisation.
As the measurement of explosive LEP has not been previously reported
following stroke, stability of LEP was examined within one week
under standard conditions in a sub-sample of nine individuals.
Measurement of walking performance
Following the measurement of LEP, the walking test was explained
verbally and demonstrated to each individual. Subjects were asked
to walk at their normal, comfortable walking pace around a measured
40-m track in a physiotherapy gymnasium. During walking trials individuals
were accompanied by a researcher to ensure maximum safety. To ensure
physiological steady state conditions patients walked for four minutes
in total. During the walking tests, the researcher walked behind
the subjects, continuously monitoring walking velocity. Expired
air was collected in a 100-litre Douglas bag mounted on a wheelchair
during min 3-4 using light-weight ducting and a facemask. Steady-state
oxygen uptake, gross (walking) (mL·kg-1·m-1)
was measured. Net oxygen consumption was calculated (walking oxygen
consumption - resting oxygen consumption). The net oxygen consumption
values were used to calculate the oxygen cost of walking (mL·kg-1·m-1).
Temporal and spatial parameters of gait were recorded using a GAITRite®
(SMS Technologies, Harlow) mat (180 x 35.5 inches) positioned on
the track during minutes 3-4 when individuals had established a
comfortable rhythm. The system has previously demonstrated test
re-test and concurrent validity (McDonough et al., 2001).
For each variable the system calculated the mean over two passes.
One researcher collected and analysed the data for all individuals.
The variables included velocity, cadence, step length and stance
time. The GAITRite® system was checked for accuracy using
a known measure prior to each testing session. The system consisted
of a mat containing embedded pressure sensors (active area 144 x
24 inches), which was connected to a laptop computer where the GAITRite®
software analysed the data collected.
Data
analysis
Descriptive statistics were calculated for demographic characteristics
and for measures of LEP and gait parameters. For each leg, power
output was divided by body mass to give LEP (W·kg-1)
(Bassey et al., 1992; Lamb et al., 1995; Skelton et al., 1994; 2002). The following measures of LEP were calculated: LEP of
the stronger leg (Stronger LEP), LEP of the weaker leg (Weaker LEP),
and the difference between legs as a percentage of the strongest
leg, giving an asymmetry index (Percentage Asymmetry LEP) (Skelton
et al., 2002).
From temporal-spatial data asymmetry ratios (1 - weaker/stronger)
were calculated for step length and single leg support time. The
relationship between gait parameters and explosive leg power was
examined by a Spearman Rank Correlation Coefficient (ρ) (one
tailed). Reliability of LEP measures before the intervention were
examined using standard statistical measures: Student's t-test,
95 % Confidence Intervals (CI), upper and lower limits of repeatability
(differences of the mean ± 1.96 SD), bias and random error and interclass
correlation coefficient (ICC) [3, 1].
|
| RESULTS |
|
Table
1 shows the participants were: relatively young; mobile outside
using the following devices: no aid, five; a stick, seven; a wheeled
walking frame, two; ankle foot orthosis, seven; functional electrical
stimulation (FES), one. Participants were functionally independent
with minimal spasticity in their legs.
Test re-test data of leg extensor power (n = 9) revealed good reliability
for Percentage Asymmetry LEP: Student's t-test, t = 0.61, p >0.05,
[95% CI -33.66 to 21.11]; ICC [3,1] 0.812, 95.00 % [C.I.: Lower
= 0.369 Upper = 0.954] bias -6.28 ± 71.25 and for Weaker LEP: Student's
t-test, t =0.57, p > 0.05; [95% CI -13.70 to 22.93]; ICC [3,
10] 0.763, 95.00% [C.I.: Lower = 0.252 Upper = 0.941], mean diff
(W) (bias) 4.6 ± 46.7. Reliability was moderate for Stronger LEP:
Student's t-test, t =0.52, p > 0.05; [95% CI -26.14 to 47.91];
ICC [3, 1] 0.664, 95.00% [C.I.: Lower = 0.055 Upper = 0.913]; mean
diff (W) (bias) ± (1.96*SD diff) random error 10.9 ± 94.3.
Explosive
leg extensor power and gait parameters
Table 1 shows measures of explosive
leg extensor power (LEP), self selected walking velocity, temporal-spatial
gait parameters and oxygen cost (mean ± S.D). Leg extensor power
was asymmetrical 1.99 ± 0.85 vs. 1.07 ± 0.50 W·kg-1 for
the stronger and weaker leg respectively (p < 0.05).
Table 2 shows there was a modest
correlation between Stronger LEP and stance time (p < 0.05).
There was a similar correlation of Weaker LEP to weaker leg step
length (p < 0.05). However, there were strong correlations between
Percentage Asymmetry LEP and walking velocity, cadence, stance time,
swing time of the weaker leg (p < 0.01), step length and oxygen
cost (p < 0.05).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
We
found measuring explosive LEP feasible in this clinical group, with
the only required testing adaptation the provision of a supporting
hand to prevent the knee from moving in the frontal plane, whilst
individuals prepared to perform the explosive 'push' phase with
each leg. We found good stability of measures of LEP over the period
of a week, particularly when calculated as an asymmetry index, with
the difference between legs reported as a percentage of the stronger
leg (Percentage Asymmetry LEP). This practice effectively removing
variability arising from general fluctuations in a patient's state
(such as fatigue or reduced motivation) (Bohannon,
1987).
We found explosive LEP lower than that reported in healthy adults.
Stronger LEP was reduced to 56% of that found in healthy men (3.6
± 1.1 W·kg-1) and to 83% of that reported in healthy
women (2.4 ± 0.8 W·kg-1) aged 50-54 years (Skelton, 1999).
The asymmetry we observed in LEP was in line with muscle strength
measures recorded following stroke (Bohannon, 1986). Weaker and Stronger LEP (W·kg-1) did not
correlate strongly with walking performance compared with percentage
Asymmetry LEP (%). Asymmetry LEP correlated negatively with walking
velocity and temporal-spatial parameters (r = -0.78, p < 0.01)
and less strongly with oxygen cost (r = 0.63, p < 0.05). It appears
from this cross sectional data that an imbalance in power between
limbs may be interfere with the general mechanism of coupling between
limbs in the gait cycle (Donelan et al., 2002). We measured reduced walking speeds ( Nadeau et al.,
1999; Witte and Carlsson, 1997) and shorter stride lengths compared with normal healthy
controls (Suzuki et al., 1999). We also observed a threefold increase in the effort
of walking (mL·kg-1·m-1) compared with healthy
control subjects (Waters and Mulroy, 1999).
Asymmetry has previously been implicated as affecting walking speed
(Lamb et al., 2003) and
functional mobility and has been suggested as a factor in falls
in the elderly (Skelton et al., 2002).
Indeed sixty percent of women over the age of 65 years who fell
had Asymmetry LEP (Skelton et al. 2002).
The 10% difference between Stronger and Weaker LEP reported by Skelton
and co-workers (2002)
is relatively small compared with the asymmetry found in our study
in individuals after stroke (43%). Individuals after stroke have
also been reported as having a higher incidence of falls compared
with the healthy population (Lamb et al., 2003). Attaining safe, effective mobility is a major focus
in rehabilitation - and investigation of LEP may inform future interventions.
The present study focused on individuals who were relatively mobile
and in the sub-acute phase of recovery - and our findings may not
generalise to other stroke groups. Further investigation should
consider a larger sample of both acute recovery and chronic stroke
patients and the effect of training weaker and stronger limbs.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
| The
pilot data suggests that explosive LEP, in particular Asymmetry LEP,
is a reliable measure, and is related to walking performance after
stroke. Earlier studies have shown that it is possible for training
programmes to increase muscle strength and power (Badics et al., 2002;
Dawes, 2003; Sharp and Brouwer, 1997).
Investigation of LEP training of the stronger or weaker leg in both
the acute and sub-acute phase of recovery may provide a means of better
understanding the factors that impact on walking performance following
stroke and so help guide future interventions. |
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
| Dr.
Delva Shamley, School of Health Sciences, Oxford Brookes University,
Physiotherapy Dept. at Oxford Centre for Enablement, Charlotte Elseworth
and Martyn Morris, Movement Science Group Oxford Brookes University. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Explosive
leg power (LEP) is a reliable measure in individuals recovering
from a stroke.
- Significant
asymmetry occurred in LEP in this group.
- Greater
LEP asymmetry related to reduced walking performance after stroke.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Helen DAWES
Employment: Senior lecturer
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Movement Science applied to neurological
populations.
E-mail: hdawes@brookes.ac.uk |
|
Catherine SMITH
Employment: Physiotherapist NHS.
Degree: BSc.
Research interests: Physiotherapy. |
|
Johnny COLLETT
Employment: PhD student.
Degree: BSc.
Research interests: Movement science. |
|
Derick
WADE
Employment: Consultant and Professor of Neurological Rehabilitation
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Neurological rehabilitation. |
|
Ken HOWELLS
Employment: Principal lecturer
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Movement Science.
E-mail: kfhowells@brookes.ac.uk |
|
Roger RAMSBOTTOM
Employment: Senior lecturer
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Physiological and metabolic responses
and adaptations to exercise and training.
E-mail: rramsbottom@brookes.ac.uk |
|
Hooshang
IZADI
Employment: Senior lecturer
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: statistical support.
E-mail: hizadi@brookes.ac.uk
|
|
Cath
SACKLEY
Employment: Professor of Physiotherapy
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Community rehabilitation, stroke.
|
|
|
|
|