|
IMMEDIATE RE-HYDRATION POST-EXERCISE IS NOT COINCIDENT WITH RAISED
MEAN ARTERIAL PRESSURE OVER A 30-MINUTE OBSERVATION PERIOD
|
1Massey University, Institute of Food, Nutrition, and Human Health,
Palmerston North, New Zealand
2University of Ballarat, School of Human Movement and Sport Sciences,
Ballarat, Australia
3Waikato Institute of Technology, School of Sport and Exercise
Science, Hamilton, New Zealand
| Received |
|
02 May 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
29
August 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
December 2005 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2005) 4, 422
- 429
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| This
investigation assessed the effects of immediate or delayed re-hydration
post-exercise, on mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) and on blood
plasma volume (PV) expansion post-exercise. It was hypothesised that
fluid ingestion would raise MAP and attenuate PV expansion. On two
occasions separated by seven days, eight males (age 20.4 ± 1.7 years,
mass 79 ± 5 kg [means ± SD]; VO2max 48 ± 11 mL·kg-1·minute-1,
[mean ± SE]) cycled in the heat (35oC, 50% relative humidity)
at a power output associated with 50% VO2max, until 1.0kg
body mass was lost. 1L water was given either immediately thereafter,
or two hours post-exercise by random assignment. On both occasions,
MAP was calculated every five minutes for a period of 30-minutes post-exercise,
and change in PV was calculated 24-hours post-exercise. Repeated measures
ANOVA for MAP results suggested a low probability of a treatment effect
(p = 0.655), a high probability of a time effect (p = 0.006), and
a moderately high probability of a time x treatment interaction (p
= 0.076); MAP tended to be lower when fluid had been consumed. PV
expansions 24-hours post-exercise were not significant changes with
respect to zero, and were not significantly different by treatment
condition. In conclusion: (a) The exercise was not sufficient to elicit
significant PV expansions; thus, we were unable to determine the effects
of the timing of post-exercise re-hydration on PV expansion. (b) The
hypothesis regarding MAP in response to drinking was not supported,
rather there was a 92% probability that the inverse affect occurs.
KEY
WORDS: Dehydration, re-hydration, blood pressure, plasma volume.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Twenty-four
hours following intense exercise, blood plasma volume (PV) has been
shown to increase by ~7 ± ~1% (Gillen et al., 1991;
Haskell et al., 1997;
Nagashima et al., 1999).
The increased resting PV appears to be a compensatory response to
the exercise, resulting in increased maximal stroke volume and consequently
increased maximal cardiac output (Hopper et al., 1998;
Kanstrup and Ekblom, 1982;
Krip et al., 1997).
Increased maximal cardiac output in turn improves VO2max
(Coyle et al., 1990).
These adaptations are important, as cardiovascular stress during
subsequent exercise at any given intensity is ameliorated (Fellmann,
1992;
Hopper et al., 1998;
Krip et al., 1997;
Maw et al., 1996;
Mitchell et al., 2000;
Watt et al., 1999).
Previous research (Hayes et al., 2000)
has suggested that a period of central-venous hypotension post-exercise
may be critical in eliciting PV expansion. This is so, as translocation
of albumin from the lymph to the plasma pool appears to be the primary
mediator of PV expansion (Gillen et al., 1991;
Nagashima et al., 1999).
In order for albumin to be moved from the lymph to the plasma, the
lymphatic outflow pressure must exceed the central venous blood
pressure (CVP) (Wu and Mack, 2001).
Mean arterial pressure (MAP) is related to CVP via the Frank-Starling
Law of the Heart, therefore MAP has previously been deemed an acceptable
marker to non-invasively infer trends in CVP (Hayes et al., 2000;
Nagashima et al., 1999;
Wu and Mack, 2001).
Other researchers (Endo et al., 2001)
have reported a transient increase in MAP, immediately following
the ingestion of water. These findings provide for the current hypothesis
that immediate re-hydration post-exercise may, while ameliorating
dehydration, adversely affect CVP with respect to the processes
leading to expansion in PV.
Statement
of the problem and hypotheses
PV expansion 24-hours post-exercise is likely to be related to post-exercise
CVP/MAP (Gillen et al. , 1991;
Hayes et al., 2000;
Nagashima et al., 1999;
Wu & Mack, 2001).
Drinking immediately post-exercise may, while rapidly ameliorating
dehydration (Mitchell et al., 2000),
actually attenuate the post-exercise hypotension (Endo et al., 2001)
required for maximal PV expansion (Hayes et al., 2000;
Wu & Mack, 2001). Therefore the purpose of the present study
was to assess MAP for a period of 30-minutes post-exercise, and
to calculate PV expansion 24-hours post-exercise: a) when re- hydration
fluid was given immediately, or b) withheld for two hours post-exercise.
It was hypothesised that drinking immediately post-exercise would
be associated with increased MAP over the following 30-minutes,
and that this would be associated with lower PV expansions 24-hours
post- exercise (Hayes et al., 2000;
Nagashima et al., 1999;
Wu and Mack, 2001).
|
| METHODS |
|
Subjects
Eight recreationally active males (age 20.4 ± 1.7 years, body mass
79 ± 5 kg [means ± SD]; VO2max 48 ± 11 mL·kg-1·minute-1,
cycling power output associated with VO2max 281 ± 13W
[means ± SE]) volunteered to take part and provided written informed
consent. The Waikato Institute of Technology Human Research Ethics
Committee approved all procedures. Subjects underwent pre-screening
for exercise contraindications, specifically a) a comprehensive
written medical history questionnaire, b) resting blood pressure
in excess of 145 / 90 mmHg, and c) resting heart rate in excess
of 100 beats·minute-1.
Experimental design overview
Prior to the first experimental session (7-14 days), subjects had
their individual VO2max determined using a standard incremental
cycle ergometer (Monark 818e or 828e, Sweden) protocol. Exercise
was subsequently conducted in an environmental chamber (35oC,
50% relative humidity) on the cycle ergometer with power output
set to 50% of that associated with VO2max. Exercise was
continuous in 15-minute blocks separated by short rests while nude
weighing occurred, until 1kg body mass (1.3 ± 0.1% [mean ± SE] body
mass) was lost. In one trial, subjects consumed 1L water immediately
following the exercise, while on the other occasion the same ammount
of water was consumed two hours post-exercise. Subjects completed
trials in random, counterbalanced order. Immediately following exercise
in both trials, subjects underwent a 30-minute period of continuous
postural control (sitting on a chair in the thermo-neutral environment
[20oC] with feet flat on the floor and palms hands down
on the knees), during which time blood pressure measurement (systolic:diastolic,
mmHg) was conducted every five minutes using an automatic arm-cuff
pneumatic sphygmomanometer (Datascope Accutorr1, USA). MAP was calculated
from these blood pressure parameters, according to MAP = (systolic
pressure + (2 x diastolic pressure)) / 3 (Nagashima et al. ,
1999).
Changes in PV (%) over each 24-hour period were calculated using
haemoglobin (Hb) concentration (g·dL-1), and haematocrit
(Hct, %) from venous blood samples taken prior-to exercise, and
again after 24-hours recovery, according to ((Hbpre/Hbpost)
x (100-Hctpost / 100-Hctpre)-1) x 100
(Yang et al., 1998).
The validity of this change in PV (%) estimation method is discussed
at length elsewhere (Gillen et al., 1991;
Haskell et al., 1997;
Nagashima et al., 1999;
Nagashima et al., 2001;
Yang et al., 1998).
Urinary outputs (mL) were recorded over the 24-hour recovery period
by each subject in a journal supplied by the researchers. Ambient
temperature, relative humidity, relative exercise intensity / cadence,
body posture, diet / hydration (24-hours prior to and post-exercise),
and recovery procedures (24-hours post-exercise) were controlled
during both trials (see detailed procedures to follow).
Pre experimental protocols
Determination
of VO2max
Subjects reported to the laboratory 7-14 days prior to beginning
the experimental protocol, for the determination of cycle VO2max.
After a five minute self-directed warm up, subjects were connected
to the open circuit metabolic gas analysis equipment (Vmax 29 series,
Sensormedics, USA). VO2, and VCO2(mL·kg-1·minute-1)
were monitored breath-by-breath, and smoothed by 30-second average
during the exercise protocol. The test was conducted using a constant
cadence of 60 revolutions·minute-1, and began at a power
output of 100W. Power output was increased by 25W every minute,
and VO2max was deemed to have been achieved when (a)
additional loading elicited no further increase in VO2,
and/or (b) respiratory exchange ratio exceeded 1.05, and/or (c)
volitional exhaustion or inability to maintain 60 revolutions.minute-1
was accompanied by (b).
Pre-control and blood sampling
Subjects were asked during the entire experimental period to refrain
from consuming any nutritional supplement, ergogenic aid (or proposed
ergogenic aid), alcohol, or other recreational drug. Further, subjects
were asked to refrain from caffeine in food and drink for 48-hours
prior to, and during the 24-hours of testing. Finally, subjects
were asked to maintain their normal sporting and exercise activities,
except to refrain from exercise for 24-hours prior to testing, and
during the 24-hours post testing. Compliance was assessed via each
subject completing a nutritional and training diary, which was supplied
by the researchers. Prior to and during each experimental 24- hour
period, dietary and hydration control occurred. During this time
all subjects consumed the same foods. Specifically, energy intakes
were 8350 ± 203.6 kJ (mean ± SD), 3412 ± 127.3 mg Na+,
(breakfast 05:00; lunch 13:00; dinner 20:00), 1.5 L water [five
equal aliquots, taken at 09:00; 13:00; 17:00; 21:00; 05:00]).
Following the first 24-hour period of dietary and hydration control
subjects reported to the laboratory at the appointed time of day
(06:00), which was held constant throughout the testing period.
After subjects' journals were checked for compliance, subjects were
cleared to proceed with testing. Subjects first voided, and nude
body mass was recorded in a private room. Subjects then underwent
postural control (as described previously) for a continuous period
of 20-minutes. This postural control was to allow for stabilisation
of PV (Kargotich et al., 1998).
Next, resting MAP was determined as described previously. Following
this, a 5mL sample of blood was collected from a superficial vein
in the antecubital fossa of either arm. Samples were immediately
refrigerated at 3°C, and analysed within 120-minutes (see below).
Experimental protocol
Exercise
protocol
Following blood sampling, subjects entered the environmental chamber
(35oC, 50% relative humidity), and began cycling at a
power output equal to 50% of the power output associated with individual
VO2max (141 ± 7W [mean ± SE]). Eating and drinking during
the experimental sessions was not allowed. Every 15-minutes, subjects
moved to a private room, towelled themselves as dry as possible,
and repeated nude weighing. When 1kg was lost, exercise ceased and
subjects returned immediately to postural control in the thermo-neutral
environment. Mass actually lost ranged between 0.95 and 1.05kg.
Subjects all reached the target weight loss within 90-minutes of
exercise.
Subjects (in the immediate re-hydration trial only) were then given
1L of tap water without delay, which they consumed immediately and
in full. Following this, MAP was determined every five minutes under
continuous postural control as above. Subjects in the delayed re-hydration
trial were issued with their bolus of water and instructed to consume
it in full at the appropriate time (2-hours post-exercise cessation).
Finally, before departure subjects were asked to refrain from adopting
a supine posture for at least 2-hours (Mack et al., 1998;
Nagashima et al, 1999),
to refrain from water immersion for at least two-hours (Hinghoffer-Szalskay
et al., 1987),
and to refrain from exercise until they next reported to the laboratory
24-hours later (06:00) for repeated nude weighing, postural control,
and blood sampling as above.
Blood sampling and analysis
Blood (5mL antecubital venous sample) was collected on each occasion
using a standard 'complete blood count (CBC) lithium / heparin vacutainer',
and a 20-gauge hypodermic needle. Haematocrit was determined in
triplicate using capillary tubes filled from each sample vacutainer
after they were inverted ten times to homogenise the blood. Capillary
tubes were then centrifuged at 3600 revolutions·minute-1,
for a period of five-minutes. A ruler marked with 0.5 mm increments
was used to determine the percentage of packed red cells after centrifuging,
according to (packed cell length / total sample length) x 100.
Haemoglobin concentration in the samples was determined in duplicate
following homogenisation, using a Co-oximeter (Ciba-Corning, 860
series, USA).
Statistics,
reliability of plasma volume change (%)
All changes (%) and absolute values are reported as mean ± SE. Changes
in PV and body mass, as well as absolute urinary outputs (mL) were
subjected to t-tests for dependant paired means. Alpha was set at
(p < 0.05). MAP values were submitted to ANOVA with repeated
measures analysis (treatment, time, and treatment x time). Pre-experimental
repeated Hb and Hct determinations were used to determine the reliability
of change in PV method as described by Dill
and Costill (1974).
Subjects supplied blood samples at rest following controls as described
above; on three occasions separated by seven days. This analysis
indicated that subjects PV routinely changed from reading to reading
(without any intervention) by (on average) 0% ± 2.96% (i.e. mean
± SE).
|
| RESULTS |
|
Subjects
experienced an identical 1.27 ± 0.06% dehydration (% body mass)
in both trials. Subjects' body masses at 24-hours post-exercise
were also identical (99.7 ± 0.3% of baseline). Whole body re- hydration
was therefore not different between trials. 24-hour urinary outputs
were 1488 ± 132mL after immediate re-hydration, and 1353 ± 94mL
after delayed re-hydration. These values were not statistically
different. The change in PV (%) 24-hours after the immediate re-hydration
protocol was 1.57 ± 2.48%, while the change in PV (%) 24-hours after
delayed re-hydration was 0.82 ± 0.88%. Neither of these mean PV
expansions were significant increases over zero, nor significantly
different between trials.
Mean arterial pressure at rest, and at 5-minute intervals post-exercise
(absolute values) is presented in Table
1. Mean arterial pressure (% resting) is presented in Figure
1.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
MAP
responses
The important finding of this study was that drinking immediately
post-exercise (at the intensity and dehydration level here assessed),
did not result in raised MAP over 30-minutes post-exercise; as compared
to withholding oral fluids for two hours, as expected. Rather, there
was a tendency (p = 0.07) toward the reverse. The practical utility
of this finding is that drinking immediately following exercise
is not apparently contraindicated for those who wish to induce PV
expansion 24- hours subsequent, assuming the theoretical basis alluded
to (Wu and Mack, 2001)
for PV expansion in the period of several hours post-exercise, holds
over a 24-hour period. However, further research is required in
order to clarify the relationship between post-exercise MAP and
PV expansion over 24-hours post-exercise, as changes in PV reported
here were not significant.
The finding that MAP tended lower, rather than higher as hypothesised,
in the immediate re- hydration trial cannot be easily explained
by differential influences of confounding variables discussed elsewhere
by others (Anderson et al., 1998;
Blackman et al., 2000;
Carter et al., 1998;
Convertino, 2003;
Crandall et al., 1999a;
1999b;
Fellmann, 1992;
Ferrari et al., 2001;
Flamm et al., 1990;
Graça et al., 2002;
Hinghoffer-Szalskay et al., 1987;
Johansen et al., 1998;
Krier et al., 1998;
Lundvall and Lindgren, 1998;
Nishida et al., 1988;
Nose et al., 1988;
Nagashima et al., 1999;
Nagashima et al., 2001;
Planitzer et al., 2001;
Sandler et al., 1984;
Stewart et al., 2002;
Wu and Mack, 2001),
as comprehensive control procedures have been adopted. Ambient temperature,
relative humidity, relative exercise intensity / cadence, body posture,
diet and hydration volume and composition (24- hours prior to and
post-exercise), and recovery procedures (24-hours post-exercise)
were controlled during both trials as previously discussed. Future
research is required to elucidate the mechanism of this phenomenon,
therefore.
PV
expansions
The exercise regimen used during the current research lead to insignificant
PV expansions (with respect to zero) 24-hours later. The current
researchers proceeded under the parsimonious assumption that fluid
loss from the vasculature was likely to be the primary causal stimuli
for reduced MAP post-exercise. Indeed, percentage dehydration levels
(by body mass lost) were similar to those induced by other research
designs using shorter, intermittent and higher relative intensity
exercise protocols (Gillen et al., 1991;
Haskell et al., 1997;
Kay et al., 2004;
Kay et al., 2005;
Nagashima et al., 2001).
Paradoxically, those researchers were invariably able to demonstrate
significant PV expansions 24- hours later. Indeed Kay et al. (2005)
were able (subsequent to the collection of this data) to demonstrate
that percentage dehydration is not likely to be the primary causal
mediator.
Rather, those authors (Kay et al., 2004;
2005)
proposed relative exercise intensity may be the primary causal mediator.
To elucidate, the current research shows that cycle exercise at
50% VO2max for up to 90-minutes elicited insignificant
PV expansions of ~1.2% (pooled results). Further, PV expansions
elicited by exercise at ~75% VO2max, were ~3.7% (Kay
et al., 2004;
Kay et al., 2005),
somewhat lower than PV expansions noted by other researchers (~7.3%)
when intensity was 85% VO2max (Gillen et al., 1991;
Haskell et al., 1997;
Nagashima et al., 2001).
The likely underlying mechanism of increased PV expansion reported
after higher intensity protocols (Gillen et al., 1991;
Haskell et al., 1997;
Kay et al., 2004;
Kay et al., 2005;
Nagashima et al., 2001)
may be altered Starling forces (Haskell et al., 1997),
and the likely effects of nitric oxide on MAP post-exercise (Blackman
et al., 2000;
Ferrari et al., 2001;
Planitzer et al., 2001).
Further research is required in order to test this new hypothesis,
and clarify this suggested relationship between exercise intensity,
nitric oxide, MAP, and PV expansion.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
| It
was originally hypothesised that drinking immediately post-exercise
would raise MAP, and lower the magnitude PV expansion 24-hours post-exercise.
Under the conditions imposed here, the first hypothesis was not supported,
and the second cannot be commented upon. Immediate fluid ingestion
was associated with somewhat lower MAP values post-exercise and very
slightly higher PV expansions 24-hours post-exercise (review results
for exact magnitudes and probabilities) when compared to delayed fluid
ingestion. The relatively low (~1.2%) PV expansions noted here make
the statistical interpretation of any differences between conditions
with respect to PV changes impossible, due to the inherent precision
(~2% typical error from biological and technical sources combined)
of the PV expansion calculation adopted. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Post
exercise hypotension is perhaps the most important mediator of
plasma volume expansion post exercise
- It
was hypothesised that drinking water immediately post exercise
would attenuate post exercise hypotension by rapidly ameliorating
dehydration
- We
found that not only was our hypothesis incorrect, but rather a
92% probability exists that the inverse is true, i.e. drinking
water in fact leads to lowered blood pressure, as compared to
not drinking.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Bartholomew
KAY
Employment: Manager, Human Performance Lab., Institute of
Food, Nutrition, and Human Health, Massey Univ., Palmerston
North, New Zealand.
Degree: MSc (SpExSci), BSpExSci (Hons).
Research interests: Metabolism, muscular fatigue, cardiovascular
function, sport specificity of training and fitness assessment.
E-mail: b.kay@massey.ac.nz |
|
Brendan J. O'BRIEN
Employment: Lecturer, School of Human Movement and Sport
Sciences, University of Ballarat, Ballarat, Australia.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Metabolism, muscular fatigue, cardiovascular
function.
E-mail: b.obrien@ballarat.edu.au |
|
Nicholas D. GILL
Employment: Senior lecturer, School of Sport and Exercise
Science, Waikato Inst. of technology, Hamilton, New Zealand.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Metabolism, muscular fatigue, cardiovascular
function, strength / power / conditioning, Rugby Union, sport
specificity of training and fitness assessment.
E-mail: nicholas.gill@wintec.ac.nz |
|
|
|
|