|
NUTRITIONAL PRACTICES OF NATIONAL FEMALE SOCCER PLAYERS: ANALYSIS
AND RECOMMENDATIONS
|
1University of Worcester, School of Sport
& Exercise Science, Henwick Grove, Worcester, UK
2Medical and Exercise Science Department, The Football Association, Lilleshall
Hall, Shropshire, UK
| Received |
|
16 June 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
06
February 2006 |
| Published |
|
01
March 2006 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2006) 5, 130
- 137
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
aim of the study was to establish the nutritional practices and activity
patterns of elite female soccer players. The nutritional intake of
16 female England Soccer players was self-reported over a seven-day
period. Participants were provided with written and verbal guidelines
for the completion of the diaries. Training details were also recorded,
and used in combination with BMR predictions to calculate daily energy
expenditure. Energy, macronutrient and micronutrient intakes were
determined using DietMaster 4.0 software. Results suggest that energy
intake was low (1904 ± 366.3 kcal) in relation to previous recommendations
for soccer players. Energy expenditure (2153.5 ± 596.2 kcal) was not
significantly different (p > 0.05) from intake, suggesting energy
balance was achieved. Carbohydrate (53.8 ± 6.8%), protein (16.8 ±
2.1%) and fat (28.8 ± 6.6%) intakes were in line with recommendations.
Fluid intake (2466 ± 1350.5ml·day-1) was sufficient to
meet baseline recommendations, but would need to be higher to meet
the additional requirement of training and competition. With the exception
of vitamin A and iron, all micronutrient intakes were higher than
the DRI. In conclusion, recommendations for female soccer players
are to encourage consumption of carbohydrate-electrolyte beverages
to enhance carbohydrate intake and increase fluid intake, and ensure
sufficient iron rich foods are included in the diet to meet the DRI.
KEY
WORDS: Energy, intake, expenditure, carbohydrate, fluid, micronutrient.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Good
nutritional practice is essential to athletic success by improving
the quality of training, maximising performance and speeding recovery
time. Soccer is described as a high intensity intermittent sport
involving continual changes in activity (Hargreaves, 1994).
Elite female players have been reported to cover total distances
of 8.5km, 9.5km (Bangsbo, 1994)
and 12.4km (Holmes, 2002)
with a maintained relative exercise intensity of 70% VO2max
(Brewer, 1994)
despite spending 76% and 11% of their time in low and high intensity
activities respectively (Holmes, 2002).
Such high metabolic and energy demands of soccer training and
competition must be met by adequate nutritional intake. Previous
research of the nutritional practices of female soccer players is
limited but have reported daily energy intakes ranging from 1778
± 715 to 2290 ± 310 kcal·day-1 (Clark et al., 2003;
Scott et al., 2003)
with percentage carbohydrate, protein and fat intakes of 47.8 ±
9.8 to 55.0 ± 7.5%, 13.9 ± 4.0 to 15.0 ± 3.1 and 29.0 ± 5.7 to 33.3
± 9.5 respectively (Scott et al., 2003;
Clark et al., 2003).
Furthermore, the nutritional practice of female athletes should
be concerned with gender specific considerations of iron and calcium
(Piehl-Aulin, 1995).
Clark et al., 2003
reported that NCAA Division 1 players failed to meet the Daily Recommended
Intakes for both of these essential minerals, whilst Scott et al.,
2003also
reported iron deficiencies.
The validity of data collected via self- reported food diaries have
been questioned due to inherent limitations in the technique. These
include frequent bias towards underestimation of habitual intake
(Black et al., 1991),
failure to report all foods consumed (Goldberg et al., 1991)
and/or modification of the normal eating pattern (Stockley, 1985).
In addition to this, Bingham, 1987
stated that seven days is the shortest time necessary to cover fluctuations
in dietary patterns e.g. weekdays and weekends, and the longest
time participants can be expected to co-operate. Indeed, both of
the aforementioned studies may be limited in that they have collected
data over relatively short time frames; 2 days not including weekends
(Scott et al., 2003)
and 3 days incorporating weekends (Clark et al., 2003).
Previous research is further limited by failing to provide parallel
activity data to indicate energy expenditure, which would enhance
the interpretation of nutritional intake. The current study attempts
to address some of these limitations by recording nutritional intakes
for 7 days as well as reporting the corresponding activity patterns
during this timeframe.
Thus the aim of the present study was to further investigate the
nutritional practices of elite female soccer players by reporting
diet and activity records over a period of seven days.
|
| METHODS |
|
Participants
Sixteen international female soccer players (Age = 25.5 ± 3.9 yrs;
Height = 1.67 ± 0.08 m; Body Mass = 61.5 ± 5.3 kg) participated
in the investigation. Players were fully informed of the purpose
and procedures of the investigation and provided consent at the
outset.
Dietary
and activity collection
The participants' dietary intake and activity levels were collected,
via self-reporting diaries, during the second half of the 2003/04
competitive season when all players were participating in full training
and competition. Participants were required to record all food and
beverage intake, and any training, matches or other physical activities
for a period of seven-days. Reporting over seven-days provides the
best opportunity to collect valid information as it encompasses
the potential diversity of diet and activity practices of weekdays
and weekends (Bingham, 1987;
Tilgner and Schiller, 1991).
Players attended a training camp immediately prior to the collection
period. During this time they were issued with a food and activity
diary along with verbal and written instructions for its completion.
Information provided focused on average portion sizes for a range
of common foods (e.g. pasta, rice, cereals) and a guide to universal
household measures (e.g. teaspoon, tablespoon, cup) to improve the
estimation of daily intake.
The food section of the diary included the following headings; 'meal',
'food/beverage description', 'portion size/quantity', 'brand', 'food
type' and 'cooking method' to facilitate accurate analysis. The
activity section requested that participants record the type, duration,
and approximate intensity of each activity on a daily basis. Participants
were requested to follow their customary eating patterns during
the prospective recording days and were asked to confirm this via
a series of brief questions at the end of the food and activity
diary. Finally space was provided for participants to include any
other information including details of any dietary supplements consumed.
On completion of the seven-day recording period, participants were
requested to return their completed diary for analysis. Dietary
analysis was undertaken by a single researcher using the computerised
package 'Dietmaster 4. 0' (Stuart Dyson Associates, London, UK).
Estimation of energy expenditure was undertaken by a second single
researcher by calculating BMR (COMA, 1991)
alongside analysis of reported activities using the computerised
package 'Diet Organizer 2. 0' (Mulberrysoft, USA). The use of a
single researcher for these analyses enhanced reliability of data
by minimising potential variations in the interpretation of food
or activity reports (Deakin, 2000).
Data
analysis
A seven-day average for total energy intake (kcals), total energy
expenditure (kcals), macronutrients (g·kg-1, %), micronutrients
(mg, ug) and fluid intake (L) was determined for each participant.
Descriptive statistics were determined for all variables. Paired
samples t-tests were used to assess energy balance (energy intake
vs. energy expenditure), and to identify possible nutrient deficiencies
via comparison to Reference Nutrient Intakes (COMA, 1991).
|
| RESULTS |
|
Energy
balance
The average daily intake from the 7-day analysis was 1904 ± 366
kcal, and the mean energy expenditure was 2154 ± 596 kcal. This
represents a 250 kcal energy deficit, though statistical analysis
reveals no significant difference between intake and expenditure
(p > 0.05), suggesting average energy balance was achieved.
The relative energy intake of 30.9 ± 5.5 kcal·kg-1·day-1
falls below the recommendations for female soccer players of 47-60
kcal.kg-1.day-1 (Economos et al., 1993).
This reported intake was significantly lower (p < 0.05) than
the lower end of this recommended range (47 kcal·kg-1·day-1).
Average daily training time was 108.2 ± 35.9 minutes, which represents
31.8 ± 6.5% of the total daily energy expenditure. There was no
significant difference (p > 0.05) in body mass recorded before
and after the 7-day report period (61.5 ± 5.3kg vs. 61.6 ± 5.3kg).
Macro-nutrients
The mean intakes of the energy producing macronutrients were 53.8
± 6.8%, 28.8 ± 6.6% and 16.8 ± 2.1% for carbohydrate, fat and protein,
respectively. When reported as a percentage of total calories, carbohydrate
and protein intakes were significantly lower and higher (p <
0.05) respectively of the recommended levels. Fat intake was significantly
higher (p < 0.05) than the lower value in the recommended range
(18%), but not significantly different (p > 0.05) to the upper
end of this range (28%). When macro-nutrient intake is expressed
as g·kg-1·day-1 (Table
1), carbohydrate and protein intakes fell within their recommended
ranges.
Micro-nutrients
With the exception of Vitamin A (56% of RNI) and iron (82% of RNI),
all micronutrient intakes are above the RNI. Calcium and iron intakes
are not significantly different (p > 0.05; Table
2) from the RNI.
Mean fluid intake was 2466 ± 1350 ml·day-1, which represents
99% of the baseline daily requirement proposed by Maughan, 2000.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
Energy
The results of this nutritional analysis of elite women's soccer
players demonstrate an average daily intake, recorded over 7 days,
to be 1904 ± 366 kcal. This is lower than previously reported values
for female soccer players (Clark et al., 2003),
and when expressed relative to body weight (30.9 ± 5.5 kcal·kg-1·day-1)
falls significantly below (p < 0.05) previous recommendations
for female soccer players (47-60 kcal·kg-1·day-1,
Economos et al., 1993).
Energy expenditure data (2154 ± 596 kcal·day-1) present
a 250 kcal·day-1 energy deficit to intake (1904 ± 366
kcal·day-1). Statistical analysis revealed no significant
difference between intake and expenditure (p > 0.05), suggesting
average energy balance
was achieved. The current findings are similar to those previously
reported. Fogelholm et al. (1994)
reported daily energy intake of 2131 ± 400 kcal with a 111 ± 450
kcals energy deficit in normal weight female soccer players. The
achievement of energy balance is further supported by there being
no significant change in body mass pre and post the reporting period
(61.5 ± 5.3kg vs. 61.6 ± 5. 3kg, p > 0.05), however it is recognised
that this observation exists only within the limitations of the
assessment techniques used. However, the non-significant calorie
deficit of 248 kcals may have a number of detrimental practical
implications. Regular energy deficit over time may lead to a decrease
in body mass, including the potential loss of muscle mass, which
would be detrimental to performance. The energy deficit reported
in this study (248 kcal·day-1) would result in very gradual
weight loss of 0.03kg·week-1 (McArdle et al., 1999),
which is too small to be observed within the sensitivity of standard
weighing scales but would be significant over time. Furthermore,
a negative energy balance can also impact upon recovery rates, training
adaptations, cognitive functioning and the immune system (O'Connor
et al., 2000)
that would all be detrimental to a players capability to undertake
training and competition performance especially at an international
level where demands are higher.
Macro-nutrients
Carbohydrate is the primary fuel substrate during soccer, and consequently
high dietary intakes of 60-70% of total calorific intake have been
recommended for athletes (Devlin and Williams, 1995)
and footballers (Schokman et al., 1999).
In the present study carbohydrate intake was significantly lower
than these recommendations (53.8 ± 6.8%, p < 0.05), but fall
within the range previously reported for female soccer players 47.8
± 9.8 to 55.0 ± 7.5% (Clark et al., 2003;
Scott et al., 2003).
When expressed relative to body mass the daily carbohydrate intake
of 4.0 g·kg-1·day-1 just meet the recommended
4.0 - 6.0 g·kg-1·day-1 (Williams, 1995).
The current data provide further evidence to the commonly observed
low carbohydrate intakes that are insufficient for adequate glycogen
re-synthesis in female athletes (Nutter, 1991;
Tanaka et al., 1995).
Dietary recommendations for promoting maximal glycogen resynthesis
and for the maintenance of muscle glycogen levels are to consume
a high carbohydrate diet, 55 - 65% (Clark, 1994)
and a daily intake of 7 - 10 g·kg-1·day-1
(Schokman et al., 1999).
Based upon these recommendations players in the current study reported
carbohydrate intakes that are likely to be inadequate to replace
muscle and liver glycogen stores which rapidly deplete during repeated
bouts of high intensity exercise performed during training and competition
(Bangsbo, 1994).
Ultimately both the quality of training and match performance may
be compromised on a regular basis due to earlier onset of fatigue.
To alleviate this, it appears that players in the current study
need to consider increasing their daily carbohydrate intake. However,
Clark et al., 2003
identified that the typically low daily calorific intake of female
athletes (<2000 kcals·day-1) are insufficient to follow
the recommended guidelines of ~60% carbohydrate, as this will only
provide 4.0 - 5.0 g·kg-1·day-1. Similarly,
Economos et al., 1993
recommended a minimum of 6.0 g·kg-1·day-1
for athletes consuming less than 45 kcal·kg-1.day-1,
which applies to the players in the current study who were only
consuming an average of 31.0 kcal·kg-1·day-1.
Players in the present study would be advised to increase their
relative carbohydrate intake in preference to following percentage
value recommendations to compensate for their low energy intake.
This would need to be done carefully particularly since the players
are statistically in energy balance, however there are a range of
high carbohydrate foods that could be used to replace the moderate
carbohydrate/high fat foods that players reported in their diaries.
This would enable carbohydrate intake to be increased without simultaneously
increasing energy intake.
Strength and endurance requirements of soccer mean that players
need increased dietary protein than their sedentary counterparts
to support muscle protein synthesis and possibly act as an additional
fuel supply (Lemon, 1994).
In the present study protein intake (16.8 ± 2.1%) was significantly
higher (p < 0.05) than the 12% intake recommended by Devlin and
Williams, 1991.
This in agreement with Clark et al., 2003
who also reported values higher than the DRI (1.4 ± 0.3 g·kg-1·day-1).
The reported intake of the current players (1.2 g·kg-1·day-1)
is in line with the recommended range of 1.2-1.7 g·kg-1·day-1
for elite and professional athletes (Maughan and Burke, 2002)
and players should be encouraged to continue this practice.
In comparison to the recommendations made by Devlin and Williams,
1991
fat intake was significantly higher (p < 0.05) than the lower
value (18%), but not significantly different (p > 0.05) to the
upper end of this range (28%). The fat intakes of the players in
the current investigation (28.8 ± 6.6%) is in accordance with the
<30% recommendations for soccer players made by Ruiz et al.,
2005,
and slightly lower than those previously reported by Scott et al.,
2003
and Clark et al., 2003
(29-33%). Furthermore, from a health perspective the percent of
total fat consumption from saturated fat was 10.6 ± 3.3%, and the
percent from unsaturated sources 13.6 ± 3.8%. This is just higher
than the maximal intake of saturated fat (10%) recommended for the
general population (COMA, 1991).
Consequently, whilst current fat intakes meet recommendations these
are towards the higher end for athletic performance and health and
players should be advised that further increases in fat intake would
be detrimental.
Despite the players in the current study being in statistical energy
balance and consuming each of the macronutrients within previously
published recommendations for athletic populations, there is scope
for an alteration of the proportional intake of each which would
have practical significance in enhancing recovery rates and facilitating
players' ability to train and perform at a high intensity. Carbohydrate
and protein are key nutrients for soccer performance and in the
reported data both of these nutrients were at the lower end of recommended
intakes and thus may be limiting both the performance and rate of
recovery of these players. It is recommended, therefore, that daily
intakes of carbohydrate and protein be increased to levels that
would be more optimal for muscle glycogen resynthesis and protein
resynthesis; alongside a concomitant decrease in fat intake that
would be beneficial for health and performance.
Water
The observed fluid intake of 2466 ± 1351 ml·day-1 is
slightly below the baseline recommendation of 2500 ml·day-1
(Maughan, 2000),
however this value does not consider additional requirements to
replace fluid losses during training and matches. Convertino et
al., 1996
state that during exercise 600-1200ml fluid needs to be consumed
per hour to replace sweat losses. The reported average daily training
duration of 108.2 ± 35.9 minutes would therefore require a minimum
of 1200 ml, suggesting a total daily requirement of ~3700 ml, although
exact fluid needs are highly individual and depend upon intensity
and duration of exercise, body size and composition, body surface
area, individual sweat rates, clothing and environmental conditions
(Broad et al., 1996,
Maughan et al., 2004).
The current data indicate a shortfall in daily fluid intake of approximately
1200 ml. This would have implications for performance since dehydration
increases the thermal load of exercise and results in elevated heart
rate (McGregor et al., 1999;
Montain and Coyle, 1992)
and earlier onset of fatigue due to an increased rate of glycogenolysis
(Fallowfield et al., 1996;
McGregor et al., 1999)
and decreased performance of soccer skills (McGregor et al., 1999).
To ensure adequate fluid replacement during and after exercise,
players should consume prescribed volumes of fluid, calculated on
an individual basis to replace body fluid losses, in preference
to ad-libitum practices (Maughan et al., 2004;
Wong et al., 1998).
Furthermore, players in the current study did not report regular
consumption of carbohydrate- electrolyte drinks post-exercise. This
would be a further recommendation since the inclusion of energy
substrate helps to maintain the desire to drink whilst initiating
glycogen re-synthesis in the active muscle (Wong et al., 1998)
and would be a simple and practical strategy to increase carbohydrate
and fluid intakes in the players.
Micronutrients
Players reported Iron intakes of 12.1 ± 6.0 mg·day-1
which is below (82% of RNI), but not significantly different (p
> 0.05) from the RNI (COMA, 1991).
These data are similar to previously reported intakes of 12.2-17.3
mg·day-1 for female soccer players (Clark et al., 2003).
Iron deficiency in female athletes appears to be common (Bean, 2003;
Nutter, 1991;
Tilgner and Schiller, 1991)
and can be due to dietary intake and menstrual losses as well as
iron losses in sweat, gastrointestinal and bladder blood loss, or
haemaglobinuria from red blood cell damage in the plantar flasia
during running (Tunstall-Pedoe, 1984).
This said, without supporting haematological data, nutritional insufficiency
alone does not indicate clinical iron deficiency. In addition to
this, iron deficiency can occur even if the diet provides a sufficient
amount (Iglesias-Gutierrez et al., 2005).
Therefore ensuring daily intake is optimal will reduce the likelihood
of such a condition arising, but should not be used as a marker
per se. As a component of haemoglobin, iron is particularly important
in the oxygen carrying capacity of an individual and deficiencies
may therefore compromise aerobic capacity. Kang and Matsuo, 2004
recently observed that 4-weeks of Iron supplementation by elite
female soccer players significantly increased body iron stores and
prevented training-induced decreases in Haemoglobin concentration.
Players in the present study may benefit from ensuring sufficient
iron rich foods or iron supplementations are included in the diet
to meet the DRI.
Calcium intake 840 ± 335 mg·day-1 was above the RNI of
700 mg·day-1 (COMA, 1991).
Previous research has indicated that low calcium intake is not uncommon
in female athletes who restrict calorie intake or follow a low fat
diet (Tanaka et al., 1995).
Since fat intakes of the players in the present study were at the
upper end of athlete recommended values, calcium deficiency was
not anticipated.
Methodological considerations
Due to the errors inherent of all dietary recall methods, the values
for seven days dietary analysis may not be accurate for all the
measured parameters and should not be taken as an exact reflection
of long-term nutrient status. Bingham, 1987
suggested that seven days is sufficient to assess energy intake
but other nutrients may need to be observed over a longer period
of time. Although nutrient intake recorded over seven days is subject
to a degree of variability, this measure of consumption is more
reliable than an observation of a single day (Marr and Heady, 1986).
Methods used for measuring food intake rely on the participants'
ability to accurately record 'what' and 'how much' is eaten. Unfortunately
self-reported dietary intake protocols are frequently biased towards
underestimation of dietary intakes, which may explain the discrepancy
between energy intake and expenditure observed in the present study.
Goldberg et al., 1991
proposed that energy intake data can be used to assess the validity
of a seven day record, by the identification of a minimum level
of energy expenditure. It was proposed that energy intakes below
1.1 x BMR are not viable and therefore unlikely to represent true
habitual intake. Utilising this, the minimum level of energy expenditure
in the present study is 1911 kcals, which is higher than the mean
reported intake of 1904 kcals, suggesting that underestimation of
true dietary intake may have occurred.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
| Despite
limitations of the self-reporting techniques used, dietary intakes
of elite female soccer players in the present study are in agreement
with those previously reported (Clark et al., 2003;
Scott et al., 2003)
and meet the recommendations for carbohydrate, fat and protein intakes.
From a performance perspective an adjustment of the relative intakes
of each macronutrient is recommended to enhance rates of glycogen
and protein resynthesis during recovery. A non-significant calorie
deficit of 248 kcals·day-1 and a 1200 ml shortfall in fluid
intake were observed and consumption of carbohydrate-electrolyte fluids
during/after training is recommended to increase carbohydrate intake,
increase fluid intake and to help players to remain in energy balance.
Observed deficiencies in iron intake may also be compromising aerobic
capability through a reduction in oxygen transportation. Future research
should consider improving the accuracy of self-reporting techniques
in athlete populations by providing more training on portion sizes
and household measures and encouraging the importance to record all
food and fluid consumed on a daily basis. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Female
soccer players demonstrate a low energy intake in relation to
predicted requirements, but were in energy balance in this study.
- Increased
carbohydrate intake may be beneficial to both training and competition
performance of elite female soccer players
- Fluid
requirements should be addressed on an individual basis and matched
to player requirements.
- The
iron status of female soccer players may be compromised due to
insufficient dietary intake to meet the DRV.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Louise MARTIN
Employment: Lecturer, University of Worcester, UK.
Degree: MSc, BSc.
Research interests: Applied physiology of performance,
diurnal variation of performance, swimming.
E-mail: l.martin@worc.ac.uk |
|
Anneliese LAMBETH
Employment: Lecturer, University of Worcester, UK.
Degree: MSc, BSc.
Research interests: Nutritional analysis and intervention
in athletic groups. The female athlete. Lactate response to
exercise, an applied perspective. Optimal pacing for endurance
performance.
E-mail: a.lambeth@worc.ac.uk |
|
Dawn SCOTT
Employment: Exercise Scientist, Medical and Exercise Science
Department, The Football Associaiton, Lilleshall Hall UK.
Degree: MSc, BSc.
Research interests: The physical and physiological demands
of elite female football players, the nutritional status and
needs of elite female football players.
E-mail: Dawn.Scott@TheFA.com |
|
|
|
|