|
EFFECTS OF AN EXTREME ENDURANCE RACE ON ENERGY BALANCE AND BODY
COMPOSITION - A CASE STUDY
|
1School of Health Sciences, Nutritional Physiology
Research Group, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia
2Enggist Medical Fitness, Buchs, Switzerland
3Praxisteam, Schaan, Fürstentum, Liechtenstein
4Gesundheitszentrum, St. Gallen, Switzerland
| Received |
|
21 April 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
08
December 2005 |
| Published |
|
01
March 2006 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2006) 5, 154
- 162
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The
aim of this case study was to examine energy expenditure (EE) in one
cyclist during an extreme endurance cycling race - the "XXAlps
2004" (2,272 km distance and 55,455 m altitude) which was completed
in 5 days and 7 hours - and whether the energy deficit derives primarily
from the degradation of subcutaneous adipose tissue or loss of muscle
mass. Energy intake (EI) was continuously recorded. EE was estimated
using two different methods: 1) Continuous heart rate recording using
a portable heart rate monitor (POLAR® S710) and 2) using
the individual relationship between heart rate and oxygen uptake (VO2)
determined under laboratory conditions. Body composition was assessed
by measuring body mass, skinfold thickness and extremity circumferences.
The cyclist lost 2.0 kg body mass, corresponding to 11,950 kcal (50
MJ). Fat mass was reduced by 790 g (7,110 kcal; 30 MJ) and fat free
mass by 1.21 kg (4,840 kcal; 20 MJ). Circumferences of the lower extremities
were reduced, in contrast skinfold thickness at the lower limbs increased.
Energy deficit (ED) was calculated as the difference between EI and
EE. Energy deficit using continuous heart rate monitoring was 29,554
kcal (124 MJ), and using the individual relationship between heart
rate and VO2 was 7,111 kcal (30 MJ). The results show that
the difference between ED due to decreased body mass and ED estimated
from continuous heart rate monitoring was 74 MJ (124 MJ - 50 MJ).
In contrast the difference between ED due to decreased body mass and
ED estimated from laboratory data was 20 MJ (30 - 50 MJ). This difference
between methodologies cannot properly be explained. Body mass and
skinfold thickness may be overestimated due to hypoproteinemic oedemas
during endurance exercise. Data from the present study suggests the
individual relationship between heart rate and VO2 may
provide a closer estimation of EE during extreme endurance exercise
compared with corresponding data derived from continuous heart rate
monitoring using the POLAR® S710.
KEY
WORDS: Extreme endurance, cycling, heart rate monitoring, energy
expenditure.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
It is well known that during long-lasting exercise of moderate
intensity, mostly body fat is oxidised (Krogh and Lindhard, 1920).
Generally, during very long lasting endurance exercise, energy derives
mainly from subcutaneous adipose tissue (Raschka and Plath, 1992;
Reynolds et al., 1999).
Usually a reduction of the fat mass is observed, while the muscle
mass generally remains constant (Raschka and Plath, 1992).
Thus, during long periods of exercise, lasting several hours, through
to ultra-endurance competitions lasting several days, there may
be a pronounced reduction of the subcutaneous fat. The data from
the existing literature is not consistent and even partly contradictory.
A reduction of the fat mass has not been confirmed during a long
lasting endurance event such as a 24 hours cycling race (Knechtle
et al., 2003a
), a Triple Ultra Triathlon (Knechtle et al., 2003b)
or a triathlon over 10 times an Ironman distance (Knechtle and Marchand,
2003).
In the latter races (Knechtle et al., 2003a;
2003b;
Knechtle and Marchand, 2003)
cycling was the relevant component of the exercise, whereas in the
initially mentioned work (Raschka and Plath, 1992;
Reynolds et al., 1999)
running was the predominant exercise.
We would expect there to be a difference in the reduction of subcutaneous
adipose tissue between these alternative modes of exercise. In two
recently published laboratory studies it has been shown that during
running, more fat is oxidised than during cycling (Achten et al.,
2003;
Knechtle et al., 2004).
In some situations, the body mass of extreme endurance athletes
has increased (Dressendorfer and Wade, 1991;
Knechtle et al., 2003a;
2003b;
Knechtle and Marchand, 2003),
but in most reports it is decreased (Case et al., 1995;
Colombani et al., 2002;
Knechtle and Bircher, 2005;
Knechtle et al., 2005;
Nagel et al., 1989;
Raschka and Plath, 1992).
Usually, during extreme endurance events lasting several days, an
energy deficit results (Knechtle et al., 2003c;
2005;
Knechtle and Bircher, 2005).
In a 6-day- run we determined that a runner lost approximately 7
kg of fat mass, although the body weight decreased only by approximately
3 kg. With an energy intake of 39,660 kcal (166 MJ) and an energy
expenditure of 54,076 kcal (226 MJ), an energy deficit of 14,410
kcal (60 MJ) resulted (Knechtle and Bircher, 2005).
At the RAAM (Race Across America, 2003) the same athlete suffered
an energy deficit of 83,526 kcal (350 MJ) and lost 5 kg body weight.
It was not determined, how much fat or muscle mass the athlete lost
(Knechtle et al., 2005).
In the present case study we wanted to examine whether the energy
deficit derived primarily from the degradation of subcutaneous adipose
tissue or from the degradation of muscle mass.
|
| CASE
REPORT |
|
Subject
Our subject was a non-professional well-experienced extreme endurance
cyclist (age; 34 years, height; 1. 79 m, body mass; 68 kg). He finished
the RAAM in 2003 and has won several 24 hours cycling races during
the last few years. The athlete gave written informed consent for
collecting data during the race.
Pre-race
laboratory exercise testing
One month before the race, a maximal exercise test was performed
on a stationary cycle ergometer (ergoline 900®, ergoline,
Bitz, Germany) to assess VO2peak. The exercise protocol
started at 100 Watts (W) and was increased by 30 W every 3 minutes
until volitional exhaustion. Lactate threshold was determined according
to Coyle and co-workers (1983).
Lactate threshold was identified as the VO2 at which
lactate increased 0.5 mmol • L-1 above baseline. During
exercise, oxygen uptake (VO2) and production of carbon
dioxide (VCO2) were measured continuously (Oxycon Pro,
Jaeger, Würzburg, Germany).
Determination
of energy expenditure (EE)
A portable heart rate monitor POLAR® S710 (POLAR Electro
Oy, Kempele, Finland) was programmed with gender, age, body mass
and the subject's VO2max in order to determine energy
expenditure (EE) during exercise (Hiilloskorpi et al., 2003).
Due to the fact that measurement of EE during exercise with the
POLAR® S710 starts at 90 b•min-1, we measured
the resting metabolic rate (RMR) using indirect calorimetry. The
athlete was sitting on the cycle ergometer, at rest. VO2
and VCO2were continuously calculated from inspiratory
oxygen concentration (%FIO2), expiratory oxygen
concentration (%FEO2), expiratory carbon dioxide
concentration (%FECO2) and ventilation (VE).
VO2 and VCO2were used for 10 min to calculate
the oxidation rates of carbohydrate and fat. The oxidation rate
of fat and carbohydrate was calculated using the stochiometric equations
of Frayn, 1983,
where oxidation of carbohydrates is given by the equation 4.55 x
VCO2 - 3.21 x VO2 - 2.87 n and the oxidation
of fat is given by the equation 1.67 x VO2 - 1.67 x VCO2
- 1.92 n. According to the study of Romijn and co-workers (1993),
the nitrogen excretion rate (n) was assumed to be 135 µg·kg-1·min-1.
EE from fat and carbohydrate were converted into kcal·min-1
by multiplying the oxidation rate of fat by 9.1 and the oxidation
rate of carbohydrate by 4.2 using the Atwater general conversion
factor (1909).
In addition to the method of heart-rate based measurement of EE
using the POLAR® S710, we established the individual
relationship between heart rate and oxygen uptake (VO2)
during laboratory testing (Table
1).
Data collection during the race
The athlete prepared all his food before the race and took the pre-packed
food with him. Nutrition consisted mainly of commercial food with
a detailed description of its content upon the packing (E. C. Robins
Switzerland GmbH, Cham, Switzerland). Analysis of the energy content
of non-commercial food items was determined before the race (Der
kleine Souci-Fachmann-Kraut, 1991).
The energy content of all food (commercial and non-commercial) supplied
to the athlete during the race was recorded on a daily basis.
All food supplied to the athlete during the race was continuously
recorded. The water used for drinks was measured separately using
a graduated jug. The excretion of urine was measured using a different
measuring jug. Heart rate was continuously monitored with the POLAR®
S710, and EE recorded. (The POLAR® S710 was programmed
and used according to the manufacturer's instructions).
Blood
laboratory examinations
Blood samples were collected immediately before the race (one hour
before the start), immediately after the race (after crossing the
finish line) and 5 weeks after the race. Specimens were stored on
ice and transported to a Medical Laboratory (Institut Dr. Risch,
Medizinische Laboratorien, FL-Schaan), where they were analysed
during daily routine analyses.
Anthropometric
data
Before the start, during the race - every 24 hours, and finally
after the race, a physician determined body mass with a mechanical
beam balance. The circumferences of the extremities and the skin
fold thickness were always determined by the same individual, in
the same way on each occasion. The circumferences of the extremities
were measured only on the right side, since, when cycling, both
body sides are symmetrically loaded. The largest circumferences
were always measured on the forearm and on the upper arm as well
as on the lower leg. On the thigh, the circumference was measured
15 cm above the superior pole of the patella. All measurements were
repeated three times, and the average value recorded. The thickness
of the skin fold was measured likewise only on the right side using
a skin fold caliper (GPM skin fold caliper, Siber & Hegner AG,
Zurich, Switzerland).
Measurement points were the cheek (underneath the temple at the
height of the nostrils), the chin (at the beginning of the neck,
at the centre of the chin), the chest (at the edge of the musculus
pectoralis major, on the medium height of the armpit), the flank
(central axiliar line, rib bow- crista iliaca), belly (right of
the navel), the triceps (middle of acromion-olecranon), the scapula
(below the head of the scapula), the calf (on the back of the knee)
and finally the knee (directly above the patella). All measurements
were repeated three times and the average value recorded. From this
the proportion of body fat was calculated (Jackson and Pollock,
1985).
At day 2 and day 5, the support crew was too busy to take these
measurements, therefore they are not reported.
The
race
The ultracycling race XXAlps started on August 30th 2004.
In a total distance of 2,272 km, with 55,455 meters of altitude,
49 passes had to be crossed. Seven ultracyclists entered the race
and six athletes finished within the time limit of seven days. During
the first two days, ambient temperature was between 15 to 30° Celsius
during the day and 5 to 18° Celsius during the night. On days three
and four bad weather conditions with heavy rain and harsh wind prevailed.
The temperature during the rain was not higher than 15 degrees Celsius.
Day three and day six were accompanied by heavy wind. On top of
the "Col d'Izoard" in France there was heavy snowfall
and temperature fell below 0° Celsius. Due to these weather conditions,
the cyclist had to change clothes very often. The highest pass,
the "Col de la Bonette" which is 2,805 meters above sea
level was passed at temperatures between 20 to 25 ° Celsius. The
cyclist suffered in the first day from a tense neck. On the second
day, pain in the left knee arose. The pain was alleviated with gel,
ointment and a warming pouch. The cyclist finished the race in 2nd
position after five days, seven hours and 15 minutes, three hours
behind the winner.
He completed 470 ± 72.9 km (372 - 541 km) per day with 2,582 ± 1,576
m (683 - 5,047 m) of altitude. During the whole race he slept 5
hours and rested 8 hours in order to eat.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Laboratory
testing before the race
In the VO2max test, our athlete completed 400 Watts (5.89
W•kg-1) and reached a VO2max of 61.1 mL• min-1•kg-1.
Lactate threshold was at 77 % VO2max. RMR was 2.53 kcal•min-1,
resulting in a total daily estimated EE of 3,647 kcal (15.3 MJ).
The individual relationship between heart rate and oxygen uptake
(VO2) determined during the VO2max test is
shown in Table 1.
Energy
intake (EI)
During the race total energy intake was 51,246 kcal (215 MJ) with
an average of 8,541 ± 4,153 kcal per day, consisting of 1,612 ±
795 g carbohydrates, 136 ± 72 g fat and 217 ± 102 g protein. Of
total calories, 75.4 % were from carbohydrates, 12.7 % from fat
and 11.5 % from protein (Table
2).
Energy
expenditure (EE) during the race
Collecting data from the POLAR® S710, during the whole
race suggested the athlete expended a total energy of 80,800 kcal
(338 MJ) with a daily energy expenditure of 13,467 ± 4,850 kcal
(Table 3). In contrast calculating
EE from the individual relationship between heart rate and VO2
(Table 1), the athlete's EE
was 58,357 kcal (244 MJ) for the whole race.
Energy
deficit
Energy deficit was calculated as the difference between EI and EE.
Energy deficit (ED) estimated from continuous heart rate monitoring
was 29,554 kcal (124 MJ), and ED calculated from the individual
relationship between heart rate and VO2 was 7,111 kcal
(30 MJ).
Body
mass and body composition
The athlete lost two kg in body mass (Figure
1). Fat mass was reduced by 790 g (13.8 %) and fat free mass
(FFM) decreased from 61.5 kg to 60. 29 kg (1.9 %). Percentage body
fat showed a reduction from8.49 % to 7.53 % (Figure 1). Circumference of the upper extremities remained
stable, whereas skinfold thickness in the lower extremities increased
(Table 4) and circumference
decreased (Figure 2).
Fluid
turnover
A total water intake, in liquid form, of 60.1 L with an average
of 10 L per day was measured. Excretion of urine varied from 1.43
to 2.85 litres per day (except day 6) (Table
5).
Blood
parameters
Haematology and protein values remained stable, creatine kinase
(CK) increased while testosterone decreased (Table
6).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
The
main finding of this case study is that a discrepancy existed between
the two methods of determining exercise EE. Measuring EE via continuous
heart rate monitoring during exercise has been discussed (Achten
and Jeukendrup, 2003;
Crouter et al., 2004)
and we therefore used additionally the method of the athlete's individual
relationship between heart rate and VO2 to assess EE.
Using this individual relationship, we calculated an EE of 58,357
kcal (244 MJ) for the whole race compared with 80,800 kcal (338
MJ) using the POLAR® S710.
The
cyclist lost 2.0 kg body mass, corresponding to 11,950 kcal (50
MJ). Fat mass was reduced by 790 g (7,110 kcal) and fat free mass
by 1.21 kg (4,840 kcal). Energy deficit estimated using continuous
heart rate monitoring was 29,554 kcal (124 MJ), and using the individual
relationship between heart rate and VO2 7,111 kcal (30
MJ). Neither method matches the 50 MJ EE calculated from the decrease
in body mass. With continuous heart rate monitoring there was a
discrepancy of 17,604 kcal (74 MJ) and with the individual relationship
between heart rate and VO2 a discrepancy of 4,840 kcal
(20 MJ).
These differences cannot properly be explained. An energy deficit
of 5,000 to 10,000 kcal corresponds to about 1 kg of fat or 2 to
4 kg of muscle. Our data indicates that the individual relationship
between heart rate and VO2 may provide a closer estimate
of exercise EE compared with corresponding data derived from the
POLAR® S710.
One reason for the difference in methodology could be that EE was
too highly estimated using the POLAR® S710, or body mass,
and especially skinfold thickness, were influenced by fluid overload
or oedemas.
Determination
of EE using heart rate measurements (POLAR® S710)
It has been suggested that heart rate recording with a portable
heart rate monitor during field conditions is as accurate as measuring
heart rate with an ECG (Kingsley et al., 2005).
Also heart rate recording in the field is feasible, reasonably priced
and accurate due to the new technology of portable heart rate monitors
(Hiilloskorpi et al., 2003).
Compared with indirect calorimetry or the doubly-labelled water
technique, the heart rate method shows no difference, even when
differences between subjects and within subjects are reported (Li
et al., 1993).
Nevertheless measuring EE using continuous heart rate monitoring
has limitations. During field conditions, heart rate is influenced
by emotion, high temperature, high humidity, dehydration and illness
(Davidson et al., 1997).
The determination of EE by HR is useful as a group mean, but interpretation
of the individual EE requires caution because of great deviations
from the reference values (Kashiwazaki, 1999;
Livingstone et al., 1990).
Thus the methodology employing continuous heart rate monitoring
may over estimate EE. Indeed EE measured using heart rate has been
reported to be 6 % higher compared with EE derived using the technique
of doubly-labelled water (Davidson et al., 1997).
Similarly during measurements in the field, continuous heart rate
monitoring to estimate EE shows a difference compared with the technique
of using doubly-labelled water (Kashiwazaki, 1999).
In
addition to the use of portable heart rate monitors, the relationship
between heart rate and VO2 (which reflects energy expenditure
as oxygen uptake) provides another method for predicting EE. It
is possible to estimate EE from heart rate during submaximal exercise
with a great deal of accuracy, after adjusting for age, gender,
body mass and fitness (Keytel et al., 2005).
The relationship between heart rate and oxygen uptake seems to be
linear during dynamic exercise up to about 85 % of the individual
maximum heart rate (HR max) (Li et al., 1993).
During the race our athlete had an average
heart rate of 130 to 140 beats per minute b min-1 (63
to 67 % HR max) in the first half of the race, then it dropped to
110 to 120 b min-1 (53 to 58 % HR max) in the second
half.
Loss
of muscle mass and muscle protein during extreme endurance exercise
We assume that the energy deficit was covered by degradation of
subcutaneous adipose tissue and muscle mass of the exercising limbs.
Skinfold thickness in the lower limbs increased (Table
4) and circumferences decreased (Figure
2). We presume that muscle mass decreased, and therefore hypoproteinemic
oedemas of the lower limbs occurred. Oedemas may explain the increase
of skinfold thickness with increasing duration of the race. It is
fundamental that during long lasting physical activity, besides
the energy-rich substrates such as carbohydrates and fat, protein
is diminished. During running, a reduction of the concentration
of alanine and prolin shows up in the serum, whilst the concentration
of glucose and free fatty acids rises (Huq et al., 1993).
During very long endurance exercise it has been shown that a continuous
degradation of muscle protein (Raschka et al., 1991;
Volk and Neumann, 2000)
results in the reduction of the concentration of albumin and total
protein (Robertshaw and Swaminathan, 1993).
During an extreme running race in Alaska, the athletes ingested
mainly carbohydrates. They also lost body mass, and with associated
ketonuria and proteinuria, it was concluded that proteins were metabolised
to support EE (Case et al., 1995).
Hypoproteinemia
and oedemas
We presume that an increase of body mass during extreme endurance
exercise is due to hypoproteinemic oedemas. In extreme endurance
exercise the circulating protein in the blood decreases and the
plasma volume increases. Lehmann and co-workers (1995)
showed in a Double Ironman Triathlon an increase in plasma volume
of about 15.4 %.
An increase of several kilograms body mass due to oedemas may be
apparent before oedemas become clinically obvious. Possible etiologies
for oedemas are a reduced blood volume, leakage of capillaries,
kidney factors, reduced heart minute volume and a reduced oncotic
pressure. The oncotic pressure of the plasma can be reduced by factors
which lead to severe hypalbuminemia: for example an increased salt
supply, lack of nutrition, liver damage, loss of protein over the
urinary or gastrointestinal system or a severe catabolic situation
(Golden, 1982).
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
During
an ultra distance cycle race, the energy deficit does not correspond
to the loss of subcutaneous adipose tissue and muscle mass (50 MJ
as units of energy). With continuous heart rate monitoring the total
ED was (17,604 kcal) (74 MJ) and using the individual relationship
between heart rate and VO2 (7,111 kcal) (30 MJ). This difference
cannot properly be explained - although body mass and skinfold thickness
may be overestimated due to hypoproteinemic oedemas.
Our data suggests estimating EE using the individual relationship
between heart rate and oxygen uptake may be a more accurate method
than the continuous monitoring heart rate per se, based on a generalised
algorithm. |
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
| We
thank the following people: The staff of the institute of sports medicine
of the Swiss Paraplegic Centre Nottwil for the realisation of the
VO2max test; Daniel Zwyssig of POLAR®, Leuenberger Medizintechnik,
Wallisellen, Switzerland, for his technical assistance in heart rate
measurement; Prof. Dr. med. habil. Georg Neumann, Leipzig, Germany,
for his scientific help; Matthias Knechtle, Lausanne, Switzerland
and Stephen Williams, B.Sc. (London) Cert. Theol. (Cantab)., Bedford,
England, for their help in the translation to English. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- During
an extreme endurance cycling race, energy expenditure can not
be covered by energy intake and an energy deficit results.
- The
energy deficit seems to be covered by degradation of subcutaneous
adipose tissue and muscle mass.
- Determination
of energy expenditure during extreme endurance may be properly
determined with the individual correlation of heart rate - VO2
instead of continuous heart rate monitoring.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Stefan BIRCHER
Employment: Sport Scientist
Degree: Dr. Sportwiss.
Research interests: Fat oxidation and obesity. Blood
vessel function.
E-mail: Stefan.Bircher@gmx.ch |
|
Andreas ENGGIST
Employment: Physiotherapist. Member of medical staff at
ultra endurance events.
Degree: Dipl. Physiotherapist.
Research interests: Energy deficiency during long-lasting
physical activity.
E-mail: info@medicalfitness.ch |
|
Thomas JEHLE
Employment: General practitioner. Member of medical staff
at ultra endurance events.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Protein degradation during ultra
endurance competitions.
E-mail: info@medicalfitness.ch |
|
Beat KNECHTLE
Employment: General practitioner.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: The intensity of the highest fat
oxidation and the relationship to the lactate threshold. Changes
of body composition during ultra endurance events.
E-mail: beat.knechtle@ecr.ch
|
|
|
|
|