|
LEFT VENTRICULAR SYSTOLIC FUNCTION DURING TREADMILL WALKING WITH
LOAD CARRIAGE IN ADOLESCENTS
|
The Sports Medicine and Rehabilitation Division, The Zinman College of Physical
Education and Sport Sciences at the Wingate Institute, Israel
| Received |
|
11 October 2005 |
| Accepted |
|
08
March 2006 |
| Published |
|
01
June 2006 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2006) 5, 202
- 207
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Backpack carriage occurs in day-to-day tasks and has applications
in school, physical training, recreational activities and sports.
Using metabolic cart and echocardiograph, this study determined and
examined the effects of two different load carriages on left ventricular
function during 30 min. of treadmill walking in healthy adolescent
male subjects. Seventeen males (13.1 ± 0.5 yrs.) walked on
a treadmill at a speed of 4 km·h-1, each carrying
a load relative to his body mass at 333 gr·kg-1
body weight during one session and without weight during the other
session. Significant (p < 0.05) differences were noted between
the 333 gr·kg-1 body weight and the no weights with
regard to: VO2 13.6 ± 1.3 and 10.5 ± 1.1
ml·kg-1·min-1; heart rate: 133.2
± 7.1 and 121.4 ± 5.6 beats·min-1;
mean arterial blood pressure; 95. 4 ± 4.3 and 87.5 ±
3.8 mmHg and systolic blood pressure 147.7 ± 7.0 and 129.8
± 7.1 mmHg respectively. No significant differences were noted
between the two exercises with regard to left ventricular function
variables. This study suggests that in adolescents as in adults, the
vasodilatation mechanism dominates during combined dynamic and isometric
exercises. Thus, the opposing force to the left ventricular ejection
is reduced which in turn does not change the left ventricular global
function. In addition, the vasodilatation mechanism enables oxygen
supply to the contracting muscles via aerobic energy pathways.
KEY
WORDS: Echocardiography, oxygen uptake, systolic function, steady
state, vasodilatation.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Combined dynamic and isometric (such as backpack carriage to school)
exercise is of great interest in Israel and other countries. Previous
studies in normal adults and elderly showed that the effect of isometric
stress on dynamic exercise varied widely (Homans et al., 1986;
Sagiv et al., 1994;
2002).
Isometric maneuver can be very demanding, due to the pressor response
(Sagiv et al., 1985),
and may increase after-load during backpack carriage which may affect
left ventricular global performance (Miller et al., 1987).
These studies confirmed that isometric stress augments heart rate
and after-load and changes heart volumes and ejection fraction.
This in turn, influences the interplay between stroke volume and
heart rate. In addition to the isometric stress imposed during backpack
carriage, other potential factors contributing to this variability
include walking speed and grade (Sagiv et al., 2000).
The mechanics of ventricular contraction include the concept of
the inter-relationship between force, length, velocity and time
(Weber and Janicki, 1980).
The extent of myocardial fiber shortening is a reflection of interaction
between initial fiber stretch (preload), the load opposing shortening
(after-load), and intrinsic contractile state (Weber and Janicki,
1980).
Based on this relationship, several researches have proposed the
end-systolic pressure / volume relationship as a measure of left
ventricular contractility, which is independent of preload (Weber
and Janicki, 1980;
Sagawa, 1981).
Walking and carrying different backpack workloads and the redistribution
of body mass during adolescence (Jensen and Nassas, 1988)
may influence left ventricular systolic function. This coupled with
the increase in metabolic demands on adolescents may impose excessive
demands on left ventricular function. We hypothesized that adolescent
subjects would not be able to increase left ventricular contractility
as much as young adults. Thus, the purpose of the present study
was to determine and examine the effects of different loads on left
ventricular function in healthy adolescent's male subjects.
|
| METHODS |
|
Subjects
Seventeen healthy adolescent males volunteered for this study. Al1
were judged free of coronary artery disease by clinical history,
absence of major risk factors, and graded normal treadmill exercise
test up to peak VO2, utilizing the Bruce protocol (Bruce
et al., 1973).
A written informed consent was obtained from each subject's parents,
which was approved by the Clinical Science Center Committee on Human
Subjects.
Procedure
Each subject reported three times to the laboratory. The first session
was devoted to determining peak oxygen uptake, applying the Bruce
protocol (Bruce et al., 1973)
on a treadmill. The test was terminated by the following criteria:
a) levelling of or no further increase in VO2 with increasing
work rate, b) attainment of the age predicted maximum heart rate,
c) respiratory exchange ratio > 1.1, and d) when the subject
could not keep up with the load. Values for VO2 reported
were averaged from the last 10 sec of effort. Following 30 min of
recovery from the peak oxygen uptake test, the subjects walked on
motor-driven treadmill for 10 min at a speed of 4 km·h-1
while carrying a backpack with a 10 kg load, in order to accustom
the adolescents to the study protocol. During the second and third
testing sessions following resting measurements, adolescents performed
a continuous treadmill walk at a constant speed of 4 km·h-1
for 30 min. one session without load carriage and the other session
carrying a backpack with load relative to the subject's body mass
at 333 gr·kg-1 body weight at approximately 30%
of body weight as suggested earlier (LaFiandra et al., 2003).
The order of the different testing loads was balanced over subjects.
Oxygen uptake was measured for 5 min at rest and throughout the
30 min. effort by breath-by-breath open-circuit indirect calorimetry
(Medical Graphics St. Paul, MN) metabolic cart. The metabolic cart
was calibrated before each test with known primary standard quality
gasses. Electrocardiogram and heart rate were continuously monitored
during exercise. Blood pressure was monitored using a standard sphygmomanometer
cuff and stethoscope. Blood pressure measurements were taken each
five minutes throughout the test. The last measurement is the one
presented in the table.
Echocardiographic
data processing
Two-dimensional echocardiographic and M-mode images were performed
at rest and following exercise utilizing Vingmed 725 Sonotron and
Sony recorder equipped with 2 and 3 MHz transducers. The diameters
of the aorta were determined by two-dimensionally directed M-mode.
The left atrium was measured from the parasternal long-axis view.
At rest, left ventricular end-diastolic and end-systolic diameters
and intraventricular septum and left ventricular posterior wall
thicknesses were measured from the parasternal long and short-axis
views as well as from 4 and 5 chamber views, just below the mitral
valve level, according to the recommendations of the American Society
of Echocardiography (Teichholz et al., 1976).
Immediately following exercise, due to the short time available,
measurements of left ventricular volumes and ejection fraction were
determined by Simpson's rule (Van Rossum et al., 1988),
from apical 4 chamber view. All echocardiographic studies were performed
with the subjects in the standing position at rest, and within 30
s from stopping exercising. The probe was held by hand and directed
to a marked point from which resting data were obtained, while the
subject was in the standing position without motion.
The beam was directed to the aortic valve outflow tract in the 5-chamber
view, or from the supersternal approach for those subjects in whom
adequate imaging of 5-chamber or parasternal long axis views was
not obtained.
To assess the objectivity of the echocardiographic readings, all
recordings were evaluated by two independent experts who were blinded
to the load condition. The lowest correlation (r = 0.89) was found
for inter-observer reliability on end diastolic volume. All other
reliability coefficients were higher than 0.92.
Calculations
At rest and during exercise cardiovascular variables were computed
as follows:
Stroke volume was the difference of left ventricular end diastolic
volume - end systolic volume.
Cardiac output was determined as the product of heart rate
and stroke volume.
Total peripheral resistance was calculated as: (mean arterial
blood pressure x 80)/cardiac output.
Ejection fraction = (end diastolic volume - end systolic
volume)/ end diastolic volume x 100%.
End-systolic pressure volume ratio = Cuff-determined systolic
blood pressure/left ventricular end-systolic volume.
Mean arterial blood pressure = (systolic pressure - diastolic
pressure)/3 + diastolic pressure.
Statistical
analyses
The responses of all the variables during exercise with 333 gr·kg-1
body weight and without weight, were compared with one-way analysis
of variance design. A level of P < 0.05 was required for statistical
significance. If F ratio was significant, a post-hoc Tukey
2 test was used when appropriate to perform single degree of freedom
comparisons.
|
| RESULTS |
|
All
subjects completed the study without difficulties or abnormal symptoms,
dysrhythmias, or electrocardiographic responses. Mean descriptive
data for the subjects are presented in Table
1.
Table 2 presents mean values
for echocardiography and hemodynamic measurements. From rest to
the two different work-loads: without weight and with 333 gr·kg-1
subjects showed significant (p < 0.05) increases in heart rate,
cardiac output,
left ventricular end diastolic volume, systolic and mean blood pressures
and oxygen uptake, while ejection fraction and total peripheral
resistance were significantly (p < 0.05) reduced. End-systolic
pressure volume ratio, stroke volume, and diastolic blood pressure
did not differ significantly across conditions, with and without
weights. Significant differences (p < 0.05) were noted between
the two exercises with regard to: heart rate, systolic blood pressure,
mean arterial blood pressure and oxygen uptake. No significant differences
were noted between the two exercises with regard to left ventricular
function. Table 3 describes the subjects' values of echocardiographic
and hemodynamic measurements at peak exercise (mean
± S.D). Table 3
reveals that values of oxygen consumption are those attained at
peak exercise. Since subjects could not keep up with the load none
of the subjects complied with the other criteria set for the termination
of the test.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
This
study suggests that healthy adolescents responding to backpack load
up to 333 gr·kg-1 body weight and no weights did
not manifest an increase in left ventricular contractility, namely
end-systolic pressure volume ratio and ejection fraction, consequent
to a minor increase in after-load.
The oxygen consumption values as a percentage of VO2peak
were: 31.4% during the bout with weights and 24.2% during the exercise
without weights. However, this does not reflect the real workload
percentage. The approach of calculating percentage of submaximal
effort while carrying a load used in another study (Epstein et al.,
1988)
was incorrect. In that study the VO2 achieved during
submaximal isometric exercise was divided by values of VO2max
achieved during dynamic exercise without load, leading to a wrong
conclusion as to what percentage of true work the subjects were
performing. Thus, in the present study workloads expressed by VO2
do not represent the real load performed by our subjects.
Stroke volume values were alike since left ventricular volumes were
similar during the exercise with the 333 gr·kg-1
load and without the load carriage. This response can be attributed
to the vasodilatation mechanism which kept left ventricular volumes
and stroke volume during both exercise conditions at a low level
with nearly the same values as at rest. The stroke volume response
in the present study is in agreement to those reported previously,
in which the lower cardiovascular responses to exercise in children
may be attributed to their smaller heart size (Vinet et al., 2002;
Turley and Wilmore, 1997).
Although the metabolic cost differed between the two exercises,
the observed similarity in left ventricular volumes during both
exercise conditions is due, at least partially, to the minor differences
in diastolic, systolic and mean arterial blood pressures between
conditions. In addition, the interaction of the opposing physiological
influences of dynamic exercise (vasodilatation) and isometric exercise
(vasoconstriction) resulted in lower values of total peripheral
resistance compared to the resting and no weight bout values. This
reduced total peripheral resistance, although not at the level of
dynamic exercise, is in the same direction seen during dynamic exercise,
thus, facilitating ejection. This response suggests that during
isodynanic maneuver, the physiological responses of the dynamic
component mimic those of the isometric maneuver (Jackson et al.,
1973).
Left ventricular contractility did not increase during both exercises
from resting values. It seems that the minor increase in after-load
did not force the left ventricle to augment contractility. This
may be due to the force-length relation during the isovolumic phase.
In that phase, for any given contractile state the ejecting ventricle
contracts within the confines of its isovolumetric developed force-length
relation. Therefore, the extent of shortening and end-systolic length
is determined by the instantaneous course of systolic force and
length and is quite independent of initial length and time of contraction
(Weber and Janicki, 1980;
Sagawa, 1981).
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
| This
study suggests that in well-trained adolescents, as in adults, the
influence of the vasodilatation mechanism dominates during combined
dynamic and isometric exercises, thus reducing the opposing force
to the left ventricular ejection which in turn leaves the left ventricular
global function unchanged. In addition, the vasodilatation mechanism
enables oxygen supply to the contracting muscles via aerobic energy
pathways. This has implications in sports and day-to-day tasks such
as carriage of school backpack, training adolescents at a higher target
training heart rate and thus increasing efficacy of overall functional
capacity. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- This
study suggests that in adolescents as in adults, the vasodilatation
mechanism dominates during combined dynamic and isometric exercises.
- Thus,
the opposing force to the left ventricular ejection is reduced
which in turn does not change the left ventricular global function.
- In
addition, the vasodilatation mechanism enables oxygen supply to
the contracting muscles via aerobic energy pathways
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Moran SAGIV
Employment: At the Zinman College.
Degree: MPe.
Research interests: Exercise biogenetics.
E-mail: moransag@012.net.il |
|
Michael SAGIV
Employment: At the Zinman College.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Exercise physiology
E-mail: sagiv@wincol.ac.il |
|
Ruthie
AMIR
Employment: At the Zinman College.
Degree: MD.
Research interests: Exercise biogenetics
E-mail: ruthiea@wincol.ac.il |
|
David
BEN-SIRA
Employment: At the Zinman College.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Cardiovascular and biomechanics
E-mail: ben-sira@wincol.ac.il |
|
|
|
|