|
THREE INTERMITTENT SESSIONS OF CRYOTHERAPY REDUCE THE SECONDARY
MUSCLE INJURY IN SKELETAL MUSCLE OF RAT
|
Department of Physical Therapy, Federal University of São Carlos,
São Carlos, SP, Brazil.
| Received |
|
26 January 2006 |
| Accepted |
|
28
March 2006 |
| Published |
|
01
June 2006 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2006) 5, 228
- 234
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Although cryotherapy associated to compression is recommended
as immediate treatment after muscle injury, the effect of intermittent
sessions of these procedures in the area of secondary muscle injury
is not established. This study examined the effect of three sessions
of cryotherapy (30 min of ice pack each 2h) and muscle compression
(sand pack) in the muscle-injured area. Twenty-four Wistar rats (312
± 20g) were evaluated. In three groups, the middle belly of
tibialis anterior (TA) muscle was injured by a frozen iron bar and
received one of the following treatments: a) three sessions of cryotherapy;
b) three sessions of compression; c) not treated. An uninjured group
received sessions of cryotherapy. Frozen muscles were cross- sectioned
(10 µm) and stained for the measurement of injured and uninjured muscle
area. Injured muscles submitted to cryotherapy showed the smallest
injured area (29.83 ± 6.6%), compared to compressed (39.2 ±
2.8%, p= 0.003) and untreated muscles (41.74 ± 4.0%, p = 0.0008).
No difference was found between injured compressed and injured untreated
muscles. In conclusion, three intermittent sessions of cryotherapy
applied immediately after muscle damage was able to reduce the secondary
muscle injury, while only the muscle compression did not provide the
same effectiveness.
KEY
WORDS: Tibialis anterior, hypothermia, damage.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Cryotherapy is one of the least expensive and most used therapies
recommended in the immediate treatment of the skeletal muscle injury.
The major objective of the use of cryotherapy in the early follow-up
of muscle injury is to minimize adverse effects related to the damage
process, as pain, edema, haemorrhage and muscle spasm, but above
all, reduce the area of secondary injury caused by ischemia induced
by the primary injury (Knight, 1995;
Knight and Londeree, 1980;
Merrick et al., 1999,
Jarvinen et al., 2005).
According to Knight (1995),
the physiological responses to primary injury may lead to a secondary
injury by means of enzymatic and hypoxic mechanisms that affect
the peripheral cells of the primary injury. The secondary injury
caused by post-trauma hypoxia is due to several factors such as
bleeding of the injured vessels, hemostasis, decreased blood flow
due to increased blood viscosity and increased extravascular pressure
and swelling caused by injury of the cellular membrane, that may
occlude small vessels further increasing the ischemic area (Fisher,
1990).
Then, in the first hours after the primary injury there is an increase
in the total area of injury, which is a consequence of the secondary
injury (Knight 1995; Merrick et al., 1999).
The physiopathology of soft tissue injury is characterized by increased
cell metabolism, bleeding, hyperemia, swelling, and recruiting of
leukocytes (Olson and Stravino, 1972).
These factors are the rational for the use of local cooling in the
early treatment of soft tissue injuries including bruising, strains
and luxation (Shelbourne and Wilckens, 1990;
Jarvinen et al., 2005).
The physiological effects induced by the cooling of the skin include
the reduction of the temperature, metabolism, circulation, pain,
muscle spams and inflammatory process (Olson and Stravino, 1972;
Kowal, 1983;
Kellet, 1986).
Although several procedures have been reported for the use of ice
(gel, spray, ice packs, immersion, etc), in clinics, hospitals and
sports activities ice packs are the most used (Enwemeka et al.,
2002).
Previous reports suggested that in acute skeletal muscle injuries,
cryotherapy reduces the metabolic rate of hypoxic tissues, allowing
better cell survival in this period and therefore reducing the area
of secondary injury (Knight and Londeree, 1980;
Knight et al., 1981;
Merrick et al., 1993;
Merrick et al., 1999).
An interesting report showed that an early treatment consisted of
5h of continuous cryotherapy application after crush lesion, slowed
secondary injury in the triceps surae muscle of rat (Merrick et
al., 1999).
Nevertheless, is not common the continuous application of cryotherapy
for hours in humans because the risk of frozen injuries (Knight,
1995).
The intermittent use of cryotherapy, as for example 30 minutes of
ice pack each one or two hours has been recommended to be used after
muscle injury in humans because is therapeutically effective and
safe (Knight 1995;
Jarvinen et al., 2005).
Although sessions of cryotherapy associated to compression is recommended
and used as immediate treatment during the first 72 hours after
muscle injury (Knight, 1995),
the effect of intermittent sessions of this treatment in the area
of secondary muscle injury is not well established. Also, it is
not well established which number of sessions, applied immediately
after injury are effective to reduce the secondary muscle injury.
In addition, it is important to consider that for several subjects
are difficult or impossible to apply intermittent sessions of cryotherapy
for long periods, as for example during the night when they sleep.
Several aspects difficult the studies of the muscle injury in humans,
as for example, the variability of injured muscles, differences
in the extension of the injured area and in the local of injury.
Also, models of human muscle injury could have serious ethical restrictions.
Then, as studies about the skeletal muscles of the mammals using
animal models revealed similarities during the regeneration process,
they have been used to evaluate the effect of different kind of
treatments after muscle damage (Jarvinen, 2005).
Also, animal models were used to evaluate the effect of cryotherapy
and hypothermia in the skeletal muscle injury (Knight, 1995;
Merrick, et al. 1999;
for review see Jarvinen et al., 2005)
and provided important information about the use of cryotherapy
after injury in the soft tissues.
The studies using animal muscles are necessary in this case because
it permits to induce a similar area of injury in the same skeletal
muscle of a large number of animals, which permits a scientific
comparison among them. Then, in the present study the skeletal muscle
of rat was injured to evaluate the effect of sessions of cryotherapy
in the extension of the secondary injury. Specifically, it was examined
the effect of three intermittent sessions of cryotherapy (ice pack)
and muscle compression (sand pack), applied immediately after muscle
damage, in the area of secondary injury of the rat skeletal muscle.
|
| METHODS |
|
Animals
care
Twenty-four Wistar rats (312 ± 20g) were randomly divided
into four groups of six animals each one. They were housed in plastic
cages in a room with controlled environmental conditions and had
free access to water and standard food. This study was conducted
in accordance with the University approval for the care and use
of laboratory animals, which is accordance to the policy statement
with respect to the Declaration of Helsink. The animals were anaesthetized
by an intraperitoneal injection of xylazine (12 mg/kg) and ketamine
(95 mg/kg) during the induction of tibialis anterior (TA) muscle
injury, application of cryotherapy and compression on the muscle,
and for the muscle remotion. Afterwards, they were euthanised by
an overdose of the anaesthetic.
Induced
muscle injury
To induce muscle injury on the middle belly of the right TA, the
skin around the muscle was trichotomized and cleaned. Then, a transversal
cut (about 1 cm) of the skin over the muscle middle belly was carried
out, exposing the TA muscle. Afterwards, TA middle belly was injured
by freezing (cryoinjury), which is a common procedure used to induce
muscle injury (Miyabara et al., 2006).
A rectangular iron bar (40 x 20 mm2) was frozen in fluid
nitrogen and then kept for 10s on the muscle belly. The same procedure
was repeated two consecutive times with a time interval of 30s.
Finally, the skin was sutured and cleaned with iodine alcohol. This
injury procedure was previously tested in our laboratory and it
was chosen because produce a similar area of primary muscle injury
in the superficial middle belly of TA muscle of rats.
Cryotherapy
Immediately after the induced muscle injury, the animals were maintained
in horizontal position on a plastic table and the ankle of right
paw was fixed by tape for the exposition of TA muscle skin. The
sessions of cryotherapy (3 sessions of 30 minutes applied each 2
hours) consisted of the application of a plastic pack filled with
crushed ice, fixed by tape directly on the skin of the right TA
muscle. The ice pack covered all the extension of the TA muscle.
As the ice pack also produces a muscle compression, which could
affect the extension of the secondary muscle injury, an additional
group of animals was evaluated using the same experimental conditions,
but the ice pack was replaced by a sand pack with the same weight
used in the ice pack (30g).
Animal groups
The middle belly of the right TA muscle of three groups of animals
(n = 18) was injured and each group was submitted to one of the
following procedures: a) three sessions of cryotherapy (ice pack,
n = 6), as previously described; b) three sessions of compression
(sand pack, n = 6); c) not treated (n = 6). One group of animals
was not injured, but also received three sessions of cryotherapy
(n = 6). This group was included to evaluate possible presence of
muscle injury induced by the sessions of muscle cooling.
Immediately after the last cryotherapy or compression sessions,
e.g., 4 ½ hours after induced muscle injury, both right (injured
side) and left (uninjured side) TA muscles of all animals group
were carefully dissected, avoiding mechanical injuries and removed.
Afterwards, they were individually weighed (Denver Instruments Company,
Model 100a, USA) and frozen in isopentane, previously frozen in
liquid nitrogen and stored at -80oC (Forma Scientific,
USA).
Muscle
injury area
Histological serial muscle cross- sections were obtained (one section
of 10 µm each 100 µm) in cryostat (Microm HM 505E, Germany),
along of the TA muscles middle belly. Afterwards, Toluidine Blue
stained the sections for morphological evaluation by light microscopy
(Axiolab, Carl Zeiss, Germany).
The signs of TA muscle injury were characterized by disrupted and
hypercontracted muscle
fibres and large clear areas between the fibres (Figure
1), as well as by the presence of tissue infiltration with polimorphonuclears
cells and swelling, as previously reported (Minamoto et al., 1999;
Salvini et al., 2001).
After that, one histological cross-section of each TA muscle located
in the central region of muscle injury was choose to measure the
cross-sectional area of both injured and uninjured area of the muscle,
using the light microscope and a software for morphometry (Axiovision
3.0.6 SP4, Carl Zeiss, Germany). For this, pictures of the cross-section
were obtained by light microscopy to reconstruct the total muscle
cross-section, which permitted to identify and measure the injury
and uninjured areas of the musc1e. Since the primary injury was
standardized for all damaged muscles, possible differences in the
final area of injury were considered as a consequence of different
extensions in the secondary muscle injury. A double-blind procedure
was used for both the selection of the muscle cross-section and
the measurements of the injured and uninjured areas of the muscles.
Statistic
analysis
Student paired t-test was used for the comparison between TA muscles
of the same animals group. ANOVA and Duncan tests were used for
the comparisons among groups. Significance level considered was
5%.
|
| RESULTS |
|
Muscle
weight
Only the injured, but not treated group of animals increased the
TA muscle weight, when compared to contra lateral one (0.55 ±
0.03g vs 0.51 ± 0.03g; p = 0.004), Table 1. Contrarily, there was not muscle weight difference
between injured TA muscles submitted to cryotherapy or isolate compression,
in comparison to the contra lateral ones. Also, normal TA muscle
treated with cryotherapy did not present muscle weight difference
compared to its contralateral one (Table
1).
Muscle
injury area
Injured TA muscles submitted to cryotherapy presented the smallest
injured area (29.8 ± 6.62%), compared to the group submitted
only to the muscle compression (39.2 ± 2. 88%; p = 0.003)
and injured not treated muscles (41.7 ± 4.03%; p = 0.0008),
Table 2. However, there was not difference in the injured
area between the muscles treated only with compression and the injured
but not treated muscles (p > 0.05, Table 2). Normal TA muscles submitted to cryotherapy
did not present signs of muscle injury (Table
2).
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
The
results of this study showed that three intermittent sessions of
cryotherapy, associated to muscle compression and applied immediately
after primary muscle injury, was effective to avoid the gain of
muscle weight and to reduce the area of secondary injury. Contrarily,
although sessions consisted only of muscle compression were effective
to avoid the increase of muscle weight, they were not able to avoid
a significant increase in the area of secondary muscle injury, which
was similar to the injured, but not treated muscles.
The increased muscle weight observed in the injured, but not treated
TA muscles indicate the presence of an acute inflammatory process.
As previously described, the mechanism of injury causes
swelling and bleeding in the damaged muscle, resulting in increased
muscle weight (Crisco et al., 1994;
Jarvinen, 1976).
The absence of muscle weight gain in the injured muscles submitted
to a similar compression (ice pack and sand pack), indicate that
the compression itself was effective to reduce the local blood flow
and edema.
However, considering that only cyotherapy treatment caused a significant
reduction in the area of secondary muscle injury, the results of
this study suggest that only the reduction of local blood flow and
edema were not able to avoid the increase of secondary injury. Some
studies have suggested that the use of cryotherapy in acute injuries
has beneficial effects, more likely due to metabolism reduction
than to circulatory changes (Hocutt, 1982;
Knight, 1985;
1995).
The results of the present study confirm this statement.
According to Merrick et al. , 1999
the combination of cryotherapy and compression slow the development
of secondary injury, and cryotherapy acts at a tissue level in the
treatment of skeletal muscle injuries.
It is know that compression over an ice pack produces greater decrease
in superficial and deep temperatures during application of the ice
pack than the ice pack alone. This temperature decrease may result
from blood flow reduction due to compression (Merrick et al., 1993;
Thorsson et al., 1987).
Previous reports on microcirculatory dynamics after contusion and
the immediate application of cryotherapy suggest that cryotherapy
does not change the arteriolar diameter but it increases the venular
diameter, which could explain the increase observed in the reabsorption
of swelling as well as in leukocyte endothelial reduction (Menth-Chiar
et al., 1999;
Smith et al., 1991).
Recent study examined the effect of local tissue cooling on induced
rat muscle contusion in the microvascular hemodynamics and leukocites
behaviour using real-time intravital microscopy, suggested that
local tissue cooling, similar to cryotherapy, improves edema and
inflammatory reaction, and may be useful for reducing inflammatory
response without inhibiting blood flow after muscle contusion (Lee
et al., 2005).
It was also reported that cryotherapy reduces the microvascular
permeability by the reduction of the number of rolling and adherent
leukocytes, and this association suggests that the reduction in
edema in injured skeletal muscles following cryotherapy may be due
to a reduction in leukocyte- endothelial interactions (Deal et al.,
2002).
Recently, an interesting report found by means of magnetic resonance
image that cooling attenuates the perfusion elevation and prevents
the edema formation in skeletal muscle when used immediately after
exercise (Yanagisawa et al., 2004).
Eston and Peters, 1999
also described that cold water immersion may reduce the amount of
post-exercise damage after strenuous eccentric activity in humans.
In the present study, cryotherapy treatment was effective to reduced
both edema and secondary injury in muscles previously injured.
A few studies have investigated the effect of cryotherapy in muscle
injuries, reporting that decreased tissue temperature causes a decrease
in metabolism and in the demand of cellular oxygen, therefore minimizing
the injury by secondary hypoxia (Merrick et al., 1999).
To our knowledge the present study provides new information about
the effect of a small number of sessions of cryotherapy and compression
used immediately after induced muscle injury. Although the results
of this study were obtained in the rat skeletal muscle, they are
interesting for both rehabilitation and sport activities because
they showed the beneficial effect of the immediate use of cryotherapy
in the muscle injury area evaluated under scientific experimental
conditions. Considering the similarities among the muscles of mammals,
the results of this study provide new information about the role
of cryotherapy in the muscle injury and contribute to support the
clinical recommendation of the immediate use of cryotherapy after
muscle injury.
Despite this kind of study is difficult to be developed in humans,
future investigations in the human skeletal muscles are necessary
for comparison. In addition, complementary studies will also be
important to evaluate the area of secondary injury at different
periods after the protocol of cryotherapy used here.
|
| CONCLUSIONS |
| In conclusion,
three intermittent sessions of cryotherapy (30 minutes each 2 hours),
applied immediately after induced muscle injury, were effective to
avoid the increase of muscle weight and to reduce the area of secondary
muscle injury. Only the use of muscle compression did not provide
the same effectiveness in the secondary area of injury. |
| ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
| This study
received financial support of Fundação de Amparo à
Pesquisa do Estado de São Paulo (FAPESP; Grant: 2001/00904-0),
SP, Brasil. Elaine P. Rainero was fellow of FAPESP (Grant: 01/009505-
6). The authors are grateful to Dr. Jorge Oishi for his help with
statistical analysis and to Tereza F. Piassi for her technical assistance. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- Three
sessions of cryotherapy (30 min each 2 hours) applied immediately
after muscle damage reduce the secondary muscle injury.
- Sessions
of compression applied after muscle damage are not able to reduce
the secondary muscle injury.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Nuno M. L. OLIVEIRA
Employment:PhD student, PhD Program of Physiological Sciences,
Federal University of São Carlos, São Carlos,
SP, Brazil.
Degree: PT, MS.
Research interests: Skeletal muscle plasticity.
E-mail: pnmlo@hotmail.com |
|
Elaine P. RAINERO
Employment: Undergradute Sudent, Department of Physical
Therapy, Federal University of São Carlos, São
Carlos, SP, Brazil.
Degree: PT.
Research interests: Skeletal muscle plasticity.
E-mail: laristhil@hotmail.com |
|
Tania
F. SALVINI
Employment: Full Professor, Department of Physical Therapy,
Federal University of São Carlos, São Carlos,
SP, Brazil.
Degree: PT, MS, PhD.
Research interests: Skeletal muscle plasticity.
E-mail: tania@power.ufscar.br |
|
|
|
|