Table 1. Draft pick comparison for DScore and actual draft system for the 2005 AFL season.

Team

DScore
pi = TWi/r

DScore
pi = .05

AFL Draft System

Carlton

9

9

4

Collingwood

7

7

5

Hawthorn

5

3

6

Essendon

2

2

7

Richmond

11

11

8

Brisbane

4

4

9

Fremantle

6

6

10

Western Bulldogs

1

1

11

Port Adelaide

3

5

12

Melbourne

14

13

13

Geelong

15

14

14

Kangaroos

13

15

15

St Kilda

10

10

16

Sydney

8

8

17

West Coast

16

16

18

Adelaide

12

12

19

Priority

17

17

1

Priority

18

18

2

Priority

19

19

3

Carlton, Collingwood and Hawthorn received priority picks 1, 2 and 3 respectively under both the AFL model and our model, although ours comes into effect in round 2 of the draft. Variations in the 2005 season round-by-round results are given in Figure 1.