|
PHYSICAL ACTIVITY - A NEAT SOLUTION TO AN IMPENDING CRISIS
|
Institute of Human Performance, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong.
| Received |
|
20 March 2007 |
| Accepted |
|
18
July 2007 |
| Published |
|
01
September 2007 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2007) 6, 368 - 373
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Childhood obesity is arguably the most significant global public
health threat, yet effective strategies to contain or prevent the
disease are not available. This review examines the physical activity
patterns of children and the role physical activity plays in daily
energy expenditure. The prevailing focus on moderate to vigorous activity
in childhood means there is limited objective information on either
sedentary behaviour or non-exercise activity thermogenesis (NEAT),
the energy expended during the activities of daily living. Most strategies
targeting the prevention of childhood obesity have focused upon adding
moderate to vigorous activity and have not been particularly successful.
The low efficacy of more purposeful activity is perhaps not surprising
because of the small variance in children's physical activity levels
explained by moderate to vigorous activity. Subtle changes in NEAT
have in contrast been shown to account for differences in fat-mass
gain or resistance in adults. Theoretically, manipulating a child's
living environment to enhance NEAT would create a positive gain in
TDEE, a gain that could lead to the prevention of excess fat-mass.
More careful consideration of the specific aspects of physical activity
that are most influential in the maintenance of body weight in childhood
is a priority. Appreciating the role NEAT may play in the variation
of total daily energy expenditure in children is a future challenge
for physical activity research.
KEY
WORDS: Physical activity, energy expenditure, obesity, children.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
The Year of the Pig brought with it something of a baby boom in
China, as tradition expounds that the 'xiao zhu' or little pigs
born this year are blessed with the fat and prosperous image of
the pig. Overweight has long been regarded as a symbol of wealth
in traditional Chinese culture. Unfortunately, the excessive accumulation
of fat now apparent in many Chinese youngsters has well- established
adverse consequences, with the most apparent being the increase
in lifestyle disease risk in Chinese children, including a clustering
of cardiovascular risk factors in those found above the 85th
percentile for BMI and waist circumference (Sung et al., 2007).
Population surveys now indicate that over the last decade the prevalence
of overweight and obesity in Chinese children has increased by 180
% (Ji et al., 2004).
Obesity is particularly pronounced in boys, with 24 % of 6-12 year
old Hong Kong boys and 27 % of 6 to 12 year old Beijing boys reported
to be obese (Hong Kong Department of Health, Personal Communication
April 2006; Mi et al., 2006).
It is estimated that nearly one quarter of China's total population
will become overweight or obese, with this estimate projected to
double if the urbanization of China continues at its current pace
(Wu et al., 2005).
Importantly, 50 to 80 % of obese children become obese adults, further
increasing adult obesity and related co-morbidities (Styne, 2001).
Unchecked, the economic consequences of this epidemic are predicted
to be grim (Popkin et al., 2006).
Prevention is urgently needed.
Overweight and obesity are the result of chronic energy imbalance.
Increases in caloric intake, reductions in energy expenditure, or
both, result in excess energy being stored and excessive weight
being gained. A theoretical quantification of the imbalance was
proposed by Hill and colleagues (Hill et al., 2003).
Using NHANES data, the accumulated energy in adults necessary for
excessive weight gain was estimated to be in the magnitude of 100
kcal per day. This excess was termed the energy gap, a gap which
widens as one progresses from lean to overweight and from overweight
to obese. Recent analyses of NHANES data for children estimated
that the average energy gap was 110 to 165 kcal per day (Wang et
al., 2006).
These data have important implications for the future development
of obesity-prevention strategies. They suggest that small changes
to daily living, changes which result in an approximately 150 kcal
per day difference, could impart energetic changes associated with
the gain of initial excess weight.
There is substantial evidence to suggest that changes to daily living
have resulted in a chronic depletion in total daily energy expenditure,
specifically physical activity thermogenesis (Cavadini et al., 2000;
Durnin, 1992;
Hill et al., 1999).
The decline in active transport, minimal manual household tasks
and advances in electronic play have all been implicated in excessive
accumulation of energy and the escalation of overweight and obesity
(Bell et al., 2002;
Lanningham-Foster et al., 2003;
Robinson, 1999). The worldwide pandemic of overweight and obesity has
led to a renewed interest in physical activity energy expenditure,
but it is imperative that the precise aspects of physical activity
that are important for weight maintenance are identified before
it can be confidently promoted as the focus for prevention.
| TOTAL
DAILY ENERGY EXPENDITURE, ACTIVITY THERMOGENESIS AND THE PREVENTION
OF EXCESSIVE WEIGHT GAIN |
|
There
are three primary components that constitute total daily energy
expenditure: resting metabolic rate, the thermic effect of
food and physical activity thermogenesis. Resting metabolic
rate accounts for approximately 50 to 60 % of TDEE. Variation
between individuals is small and is essentially a function
of body size. The thermic effect of food accounts for only
10 to 15 % of TDEE, whilst the contribution made by physical
activity thermogenesis can vary enormously from a meagre 15
% in the sedentary to 50 % in the active (Donahoo et al.,
2004; Levine, 2004b). There is more limited data on the components of TDEE
in children under 12 years of age children, however, the relative
contribution of the three components would appear similar
(DeLany et al., 2006; Montgomery et al., 2004).
Levine and colleagues (Levine, 2004a; Levine et al., 2006) have shown that the variation in physical activity thermogenesis
is better understood when it is sub-divided into exercise
activity thermogenesis and non-exercise activity thermogenesis
(NEAT). NEAT is unstructured activity and constitutes all
the lifestyle movement patterns and postural adjustments engaged
in as a matter of course, rather than the energy expended
through more purposeful or structured exercise activity thermogenesis
(EAT). NEAT comprises three sub-components. These include
body posture, ambulation, and all other movements, essentially
fidgeting (Levine et al., 2001b). In comparison to the 1-2 % variation in TDEE contributed
by EAT, NEAT varies enormously between individuals and has
been shown to play an important role in the maintenance of
body weight (Levine et al., 2005). This is best illustrated by Levine's observation that
it is not EAT that delineates the lean adult from the obese;
rather it is sub-components of NEAT. Their discovery that
obese adults sit for 164 minutes per day more than lean adults,
whilst the lean stand and ambulate for 152 minutes per day
more than the obese, led to the conclusion that the variation
in NEAT in adults was primarily related to ambulation and
body posture (Levine et al., 2005). The energetic benefit of standing and ambling ranged
from 269 to 477 kcal per day. Levine et al., 2005 suggest that if the obese adult adopted the postural and
ambulatory patterns of the lean, they would expend an average
350 kcal per day more, and assuming energy intake remained
constant, resist further weight gain.
The role of NEAT in paediatric obesity has yet not been evaluated,
but may prove to play a key role in modulating weight gain
in children. Variation in body posture and ambulation may
also distinguish the lean from the obese child. Theoretically,
manipulating a child's living environment to enhance NEAT,
and create a positive gain in TDEE, could lead to the prevention
of excess fat-mass. These concepts have not yet been tested.
The complexity of assessing NEAT and its sub-components has
been highlighted by Levine and colleagues in their development
and validation of the Physical Activity Monitoring System
(PAMS) for this purpose (Levine et al., 2001a; 2001b;
2003).
Recently Lanningham-Foster and colleagues (2005) validated the PAMS for use in children, which promises
future evidence of the primary predictors of NEAT in children,
as well as an understanding of the role NEAT may play in the
variation in TDEE in youngsters.
Advances in the objective assessment of physical activity
have meant we have amassed a sizable literature on childhood
physical activity patterns over the last two decades. Whilst
there is minimal evidence of the degree to which specific
aspects of activity account for variance in TDEE, there is
evidence of the predominant pattern and intensity of activity
in children. This information can help build a better understanding
of the relative contribution activity of differing intensities
makes to the variation in total physical activity.
|
| THE
PATTERN AND INTENSITY OF PHYSICAL ACTIVITY IN CHILDREN |
|
There
is an abundance of data which shows sustained periods of physical
activity are rarely apparent during the daily movement repertoire
of children (Armstrong et al., 1991;
2006;
McManus et al., 1995;
Welsman et al., 1997).
Through a comprehensive series of studies, Armstrong and colleagues
have provided probably the largest heart rate derived activity
data set for children (Armstrong et al., 2006).
Moderate intensity physical activity has been defined as activity,
which elicits a cardiovascular response between 140 to 159
beats·min-1. This threshold has been found to correspond
to walking at 4 km·hr-1 in both Caucasian and Chinese
children (Armstrong, 1998;
McManus et al., 2004),
and has largely been adopted as an appropriate marker of moderate
intensity activity (Livingstone et al., 2003).
Likewise, a threshold of >159 beats·min-1 has
generally been accepted as an appropriate marker of vigorous
intensity. Very few children sustain 20-minute periods of
at least moderate activity (Armstrong et al., 1991;
Gilbey et al., 1995;
McManus, 2006;
McManus et al., 1995).
Even a single 10-minute period of sustained moderate intensity
activity was absent in at least one quarter of 7 to 12 year
olds (Armstrong et al., 1991;
Gilbey et al., 1995;
McManus, 2006;
McManus et al., 1995).
Children's preference for intermittent short-duration movement
has long been recognized (Astrand, 1952)
and is best illustrated by the work of (Bailey et al., 1995).
Through two separate analyses (Bailey et al., 1995;
Berman et al., 1998),
bouts of activity in children were found to be frequent (83
and 89 bouts per hour in boys and girls respectively), with
a mean duration of 20s. The majority of activity bouts were
of low-to-moderate intensity, interspersed with very occasional
bursts of vigorous intensity movement (median duration 3s).
As such there has been a shift away from an emphasis on encouraging
sustained periods of physical activity (Sallis et al., 1994),
toward accumulating moderate to vigorous physical activity
throughout the day (Cavill et al., 2001;
Strong et al., 2005).
Figure 1 provides a summary
of the time spent being moderately (A) and vigorously (B)
physically active per day in 4 to 12 year old boys and girls.
These data are drawn from a range of European and Asian studies
using heart rate monitoring (Armstrong et al., 1991;
Falgairette et al., 1996;
Gilbey et al., 1995;
Harro, 1997;
McManus, 2006;
McManus et al., 1995;
Sleap et al., 2000;
Welsman et al., 1997).
Many of the European children attain or are close to attaining
the recommended 1 hour per day of moderate intensity activity
(Strong et al., 2005).
In stark contrast, the Hong Kong Chinese boys and girls accumulated
on average 37 minutes per day less moderate intensity activity
than the European children. A similar pattern is
apparent for the vigorous intensity activity, with Hong Kong
Chinese children accumulating far less vigorous activity than
either the European or Singaporean children.
Distinguishing between sedentary and low intensity activity
is problematic with heart rate monitoring because of extraneous
influences upon low level heart rates such as emotions and
fitness. A threshold of > 120 beats.min-1 has
been used to quantify lower intensity activity and these data
are available for Singaporean and British children (Gilbey
et al., 1995;
Sleap et al. , 2000).
Singaporean boys accumulated 167 minutes per day of light
intensity activity, whilst their British counterparts accumulated
118 minutes per day. The Singaporean girls spent 116 minutes
of the day in light intensity activity, in comparison to 105
minutes per day in the British girls. If these values are
considered relative to the total physical activity level (low,
moderate and vigorous activity combined), light intensity
activity accounts for between 71 % and 74 % of total physical
activity level in the Singaporean boys and girls respectively.
In the British boys and girls, light intensity activity accounts
for 59% and 64% of total physical activity respectively. Moderate
to vigorous activity comprised only 29% of the total active
time for Singaporean boys and 26% of total active time for
Singaporean girls. Whilst 41% of total active time was spent
in moderate to vigorous activity in the British boys, and
36 % in the British girls (Gilbey et al., 1995;
Sleap et al., 2000).
Accelerometry studies are more difficult to interpret because
of variation in devices used, as well as inconsistent definitions
and thresholds for intensity (Freedson et al., 2005).
Accelerometers are however, easy to use and affordable and
a number of large-scale studies have provided extensive information
on the physical activity levels of European children. Dencker
and colleagues reported that 9 to 10 yr old Swedish boys and
girls accumulated 210 and 190 minutes of moderate intensity
activity per day respectively (Dencker et al., 2005).
Boys accumulated forty-six minutes of vigorous activity, whilst
girls accumulated thirty-five minutes per day. Similarly aged
boys and girls from Sweden and Estonia (from the European
Youth Heart Study) accumulated 182 and 161 minutes of moderate
activity respectively (Ruiz et al., 2006).
The boys accumulated 31 minutes of vigorous activity per day,
whilst the girls accumulated 22 minutes per day. Further data
from over 1000 participants of the European Youth Heart (Ekelund
et al., 2004)
found boys spent 12 % of their day engaged in activity of
at least moderate intensity, whilst girls accumulated somewhat
less (8.7 %). This translates to an average of 86 minutes
for the boys and 63 minutes for the girls, and is quite similar
to heart rate estimates from Armstrong and colleagues (Armstrong
et al., 1991;
Welsman et al., 1997).
Interestingly both data sets are interpreted using a threshold
equivalent to walking at 4 km.hr-1. What is clear from this
large scale data set is that most of a European child's day
is spent being sedentary or engaged in light intensity movement.
This is true of both boys and girls who were shown to spend
similar amounts of time being sedentary (61.8 and 65.3 % respectively)
or engaged in light intensity movement (26 % for both).
The most substantial evidence of the relative contribution
activity of differing intensities makes to the variation in
overall physical activity levels of children comes from a
study of young Scottish children (Montgomery et al., 2004).
Total daily energy expenditure was assessed using doubly-labelled
water in 2 to 7 year olds, and activity thermongenesis and
physical activity level calculated. Specific dimensions of
physical activity were assessed using accelerometry, and the
relative contribution sedentary, light, and moderate to vigorous
intensity activity made to physical activity levels determined.
It was found that moderate to vigorous activity explained
only about 10 % of the total variance in physical activity
level. Instead, the variation in physical activity level appeared
to relate primarily to light intensity movement and sedentary
behaviour. It was concluded that in children moderate to vigorous
activity contributes little to overall physical activity levels.
Parallel to Levine's work, these findings would suggest that
the most promising approach to increasing TDEE in children
would be the conversion of sedentary behaviour to low intensity
activity, as opposed to focusing on moderate to vigorous intensity
activity.
|
|
| FUTURE
STRATEGIES |
|
Strategies
utilizing physical activity as the focus for the prevention of childhood
obesity have predominantly used activity of at least a moderate
intensity and have not been notably successful. When the effect
of physical activity on weight or body composition was considered
both from longer term and short term randomized controlled trials,
these have largely failed to impact on the weight status of children
(Doak et al., 2006;
Lobstein et al., 2004;
Reilly et al., 2003;
Summerbell et al., 2005;
Wareham et al., 2005).
Perhaps because moderate to vigorous activity accounts for
a relatively small amount of the variance in activity thermogenesis,
then these findings are unsurprising and would suggest that more
careful consideration of the specific aspects of physical activity
that are most influential in the maintenance of body weight is warranted.
If preventing weight gain needs on average only 150 kcal per day,
this could easily be accomplished by adding incidental movement
or NEAT to a child's daily routine. For example, replacing rides
on escalators with stair climbing, or walking rather than riding
escalators. Alternatively nutritional modification as opposed to
activity modification may be a more achievable way of closing the
energy gap in children. Wang and colleagues have suggested that
restricting caloric intake by, for instance, a can of coke per day
was an easily achievable way of closing the energy gap, whilst asking
a child to exchange 1.9 hours of sitting for 1.9 hours of walking
was not (Wang et al., 2006).
It is hard to argue with this logic. Technology is constantly evolving
to provide the most visually stimulating, exhilarating and interactive
play-forms for children. The long-term sustainability of an obesity
prevention strategy that depends upon removal of a child's preferred
entertainment form is doubtful. Perhaps however NEAT affords more
imaginative intervention solutions. Consider screen time. Various
reports suggest that children spend between 4 and 6 hours a day
in front of a television, computer or gaming device screen (Vandewater
et al., 2004;
2006).
What if screen time involved incidental movement? Recent experimental
investigations have shown that screen time can provide meaningful
increases in energy expenditure if interactive (Lanningham-Foster
et al., 2006).
Interactive game technology (Sony EyeToy; Dance Dance Revolution
Ultramix 2) resulted in energy expenditure increases between 108
to 172 % above rest. What if the majority of screen time took place
while walking? Lanningham-Foster et al., 2006
has shown that watching the television whilst walking on a treadmill
increased energy expenditure by 138 % above rest. These data provide
support for the idea that converting the sedentary screen time enemy
into a NEAT ally is a feasible, and likely appealing, way of adding
activity back into the otherwise sedentary lives of children. Efforts
need to be channelled into creating and testing the efficacy of
innovative NEAT solutions such as these.
|
| CONCLUSION |
|
It
is paradoxical that whilst childhood obesity is a public health
priority we have yet to find effective strategies to prevent it.
The available objective data on physical activity levels in children
clearly show that low intensity activity dominates the daily activity
pattern of a child. Physical activity research needs to build an
objective base of information on the sedentary behaviour and light
activity component of physical activity, as well as the sub-components
of non-exercise activity thermogenesis in children. Most importantly,
the most modifiable of these components needs to be determined.
Finding NEAT solutions to convert children's otherwise sedentary
pursuits into active pursuits should be a priority in the fight
to slow the obesity crisis.
|
| KEY
POINTS |
-
Excessive weight gain affects children in both developed and developing
countries alike, and results initially from small energy imbalances.
Increasing the energy expended in daily living has the potential
to re-adjust energy balance and prevent initial excess weight
gain.
- Sedentary
behaviour and light intensity movement, as opposed to moderate
or vigorous movement, dominate a child's day. We need to understand
more about which aspects of activity account for variance in total
daily energy expenditure in children.
- Finding
innovative and creative ways to increase the daily energy children
expend should be a priority.
|
| AUTHOR
BIOGRAPHY |
Alison
M. McMANUS
Employment: Assistant Professor, Institute of Human
Performance, University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong
Kong.
Degree: BA Ed (Hons), MMED.Sci, PhD.
Research interests: Physical activity and energy
expenditure of children.
E-mail: alimac@hku.hk |
|
|
|
|
|