|
EXERCISE TESTING AND TRAINING WITH THE YOUNG CYSTIC FIBROSIS PATIENT
|
Children's Health and Exercise Research Centre, School of Sport and Health
Sciences, University of Exeter, UK.
| Received |
|
14 March 2007 |
| Accepted |
|
18
July 2007 |
| Published |
|
01
September 2007 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2007) 6, 286 - 291
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The purpose of the article is to review the literature related
to exercise and Cystic fibrosis (CF), with particular focus on the
young CF patient. Exercise intolerance is a characteristic of CF,
however, recent studies in adults have advanced our understanding
of how exercise can be used effectively as a prognostic marker and
for rehabilitation purposes. New analyses from exercise testing have
shown to have prognostic value, and different methods of exercise
training have been reported to improve the functional capacity and
quality of life of the young CF patient. There is a growing awareness
and belief among clinicians of the benefits of exercise testing and
training, however, recent work suggests that exercise is being underused
in the healthcare management of the CF patient. More research is needed
to identity which exercise tests and training programmes would be
most feasible to incorporate into CF centres routine clinical procedures.
KEY
WORDS: Cystic fibrosis, young patients, exercise testing, training
programmes, physical activity.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Cystic fibrosis (CF) is a genetic disease. It is caused by a mutation
in a single gene on the long arm of chromosome seven. The gene encodes
a protein, the cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator
(CFTR), which functions as a chloride channel. Mutations to the
CFTR cause abnormal chloride concentration across the apical membrane
of epithelial cells, especially in the airways of the lung and the
pancreas. Consequently, patients with CF experience progressive
lung disease and malnutrition. The mutated gene responsible for
CF was identified in 1989 (Riordan et al., 1989),
however, no cure for the disease has been found. In the UK CF affects
approximately 7,500 people, and each week five babies are born with
the disease. The average life expectancy for a CF patient in the
UK is 31 years.
Exercise intolerance is an established characteristic of CF and
is dependent on the progression of the disease. When compared to
healthy controls, young patients with CF exhibit a reduced muscle
size and strength, and a deficiency in aerobic and anaerobic capacity.
Research investigating the effects of exercise in CF began in the
early 1970s, when Godfrey and Mearns, 1971
began studying the physiological responses. During the late 1970s
and early 1980s work by Keens et al., 1977
and Zach et al., 1981
showed that exercise training programmes and exercise can be used
to improve ventilation and help clear respiratory mucus, respectively.
Over the last three decades, however, extensive research into exercise
and the young CF patient has been lacking. At present only 118 research
articles have been published in this area since the work of Counahan
and Mearns, 1975,
who to the best of the author's knowledge, were the first to specifically
research young CF patients by examining the prevalence of exercise-induced
bronchial constriction in their relatives.
Compared to the extensive amount of research that exists into exercise
and the healthy child, research into exercise and the young CF patient
has been neglected. By comparison many of the physiological responses
and adaptations to exercise in the young CF patient remain unknown.
Finding a clinical use for exercise, whether as a prognostic tool
or therapeutic therapy, is an area of renewed interest to clinicians
and physiotherapists. Nixon et al., 1992
reported an association between the aerobic capacity of young CF
patients and survival over eight years. Recently, studies by Pianosi
et al., 2005
and Javadpour et al., 2005
have shown the significance of exercise testing and the relationship
between quality of life, life expectancy and functional capacity.
Furthermore, Klijn et al., 2004
and Orenstein et al., 2004
have recently reported the benefits of anaerobic and strength training
in young patients with CF. These methods of exercise training have
been traditionally neglected in exercise prescriptions in favour
of aerobic exercises. Such work has helped further the continuing
interest among clinicians of the importance of exercise in the management
of CF in young patients. Recent work by Barker et al., 2004
has shown that exercise is being incorporated into CF centres routine
clinical procedures in Germany.
The purpose of the present review is two-fold. Firstly, the review
aims to inform the reader of recent contributions to the exercise
and CF literature, with particular attention on the young CF patient.
Recent contributions to the literature will be categorised under
the following headings; exercise testing and prognosis, exercise
training, physical activity, and physiological comparisons between
the young CF patient and health. Secondly, the review aims to provide
future directions in exercise and CF research, and investigate the
current census of opinion regarding the role of exercise and exercise
testing in the young CF patient.
| EXERCISE
TESTING AND PROGNOSIS |
|
In
a landmark study, Nixon et al., 1992
determined factors that are associated with an eight year
survival rate of 109 young patients with CF. They found a
significant correlation between peak oxygen uptake (VO2peak)
and survival at eight years. Thus, becoming the first study
to report an association between the aerobic capacity of children,
adolescents and young adults with CF and survival over an
eight year period. Nixon and colleagues reported that VO2peak
was a strong predictor of survival, even after adjustment
to other prognostic variables such as age, sex, lung function,
bacterial colonisation and nutritional status. Patients with
a high level of fitness (> 82 % predicted VO2peak)
had a 83 % chance of survival at eight years, compared to
a 51 % and 28 % chance of survival for patients with medium
(59-81 % predicted VO2peak) and low fitness (<
58 % predicted VO2peak), respectively. These data,
however, do not establish a cause and effect relationship.
Aerobic capacity may not be an indictor of the patient's overall
health. Nevertheless, the study showed that aerobic capacity
could be used as a strong predictor of survival in these patients.
A recent study by Pianosi et al., 2005,
however, is the first to investigate both the utility of VO2peak
and decline of VO2peak as a predictor of survival.
Twenty-eight children aged 8 to 17 years, over a five-year
period performed annual pulmonary function and maximal exercise
tests to determine FEV1 and VO2peak.
The magnitude of the change in the young patients' FEV1
and VO2peak over time, and survival over the subsequent
7 to 8 years were used to determine their significance as
predictors of survival. Pianosi and colleagues reported that
the measurement of VO2peak from maximal exercise
tests were significant predictors of patient survival. Furthermore,
during the observation period a mean annual decline in VO2peak
of 2.1 mL.kg-1.min-1 was reported in
70 % of the patients. A dramatic increase in survival over
the subsequent 7 to 8 years was seen in patients whose VO2peak
exceeded 45 mL.kg-1.min-1. In contrast,
patients with a VO2peak less than 32 mL.kg-1.min-1
showed a survival rate of 60 % over the subsequent 7 to 8
years. The FEV1 was also reported as a significant
predictor of survival. The patients' first and last measurement
of FEV1 over five years and rate of decline in
FEV1 over the time period were all significant
predictors of mortality.
Previous studies investigating the prognostic value of exercise
testing in young CF patients have placed much emphasis on
the assessment of VO2peak to predict outcomes such
as functional capacity, disease severity and survival. Other
physiological assessments derived through exercise testing
have been neglected. The oxygen uptake (VO2) kinetics
during exercise and recovery, carbon dioxide (CO2)
retention, oxygen desaturation and muscle strength can all
be assessed through exercise testing and may all have prognostic
value. Researchers are now focusing attention on other physiological
assessments derived from exercise testing that may hold prognostic
significance, other than VO2peak alone. Furthermore,
researchers are using more sophisticated techniques to model
the VO2 kinetic responses from exercise in CF patients.
Hebestreit et al., 2005
has investigated the VO2 kinetics at the onset
of exercise in patients with CF. Eighteen CF patients and
15 healthy controls aged 10-33 years completed two to four
transitions from low-intensity cycling at 20 W to cycling
at 1.3-1.4 W.kg-1 body weight. VO2 data
from the submaximal exercise tasks were modelled interpolated
second by second, time aligned and averaged. Monoexponential
equations were used to describe phase II responses. Hebestreit
and colleagues reported no significant differences in the
amplitude in the model of the phase II VO2 response
between the CF patients and healthy controls; however, the
time constant tau was significantly prolonged in the CF patients.
Thus, demonstrating a slower VO2 kinetic response
in patients with CF.
Recent work by Pouliou et al., 2001
investigated the VO2 kinetics during early recovery
from maximal exercise in adult patients with CF. Pouliou and
colleagues reported that the VO2 kinetics following
maximal exercise is prolonged in adult CF patients when compared
to healthy adults, and that the prolonged recovery is closely
related to the Schwachman score (r = 0.81; P < 0.001),
a widely accepted system of clinical evaluation to assess
disease severity. The VO2 kinetics following maximal
exercise was also significantly correlated to other indexes
of functional capacity such as FEV1 (r = 0.90;
P < 0.001) and VO2peak (r = 0.81; P < 0.001).
This novel approach to health assessment offers, from a clinical
view, an exercise assessment that is independent from effort
and physical fitness. Pouliou and colleagues used a linear
regression model to evaluate the VO2 kinetics for the first
minute of the recovery period. However, no rationale was given
to suggest why a linear model would fit the response. The
linear model used by Pouliou et al. does not identify the
slow phase of the recover period and, furthermore, may only
identify 40 % of the fast phase. Assessment of the VO2
kinetics during recovery can be used even with submaximal
exercise, which is important for debilitated CF patients who
cannot produce maximal exercise performances. Furthermore,
data from maximal exercise testing may not be reproducible,
is dependent on patient motivation and the criteria used by
the clinician to terminate the test.
Javadpour et al., 2005
recently examined CO2 retention during exercise
testing, and discovered it had an association with a rapid
decline in lung function. Children with CF aged 11 to 15 years
performed annual pulmonary function and exercise testing over
a three-year period. CO2 retention was defined
as a rise of > 5 mm Hg end tidal CO2
from the first work rate until the peak work rate, and a failure
to reduce end CO2 after the peak work rate by 3
mm Hg by the termination of exercise. Using this definition
of CO2 retention Javadpour and colleagues reported
that children with CF who were found to have CO2
retention on exercise testing showed a faster rate of decline
in FEV1 when compared to those who did not retain
CO2. The decline in FEV1 between patients
who retained CO2 and patients who showed no CO2
retention during exercise over a 12 month period was reported
as -3.2 % (SD 1.1) and -2.3 % (SD 0.9), respectively. After
24 months the decline was reported as -6.3 % (SD 1.3) and
-1.8 % (SD 1.1), respectively. Finally, after 36 months the
decline in FEV1 was -5.3 % (SD 1.2) and -2.6 %
(SD 1.1), respectively. Both patients who retained CO2
during exercise and those who showed no CO2 retention
started the study with similar baseline FEV1, 62
% and 64 % predicted, respectively. The overall decline in
FEV1 was, however, 14.8 % (SD 2.1) and 6.7 % (SD
1. 8), respectively. The study suggests that children with
CF with a similar degree of pulmonary disease as measured
by FEV1, if found to have CO2 retention
on exercise testing, will have a greater decline in FEV1
over a three year period than children with CF who do not
retain CO2. This shows the identification of CO2
retention during exercise can be an additional prognostic
marker of disease progression in children with CF. Furthermore,
as FEV1 is closely associated with survival in
this patient group, CO2 retention during exercise
testing will help identify those patients who may require
more intensive therapy to prevent this increased rate in pulmonary
decline.
|
| EXERCISE
TRAINING |
|
Aerobic fitness is associated with prolonged survival and quality
of life. Therefore, most studies investigating the potential
of exercise programmes have assessed the effects of aerobic
training. In one training study, however, Selvadurai et al.,
2002
compared the effects of both aerobic and strength training.
CF inpatients aged 8 to 16 years were randomly allocated into
an aerobic or strength training group, and exercised five
times a week for 3 weeks. Selvadurai and colleagues reported
that children who received aerobic training had significantly
better VO2peak, activity levels and quality of
life than children in the strength- training group. Children
in the strength-training group when compared to the aerobic
training group, however, had better weight gain (total mass,
as well as fat-free mass), lung function and leg strength,
which all have a high correlation with health status. The
findings of this study support the proposition that a combination
of aerobic and strength training may be the best training
programme for young CF patients. Future studies assessing
the potential of exercise programmes should assess the combination
of different exercises to optimise training programmes for
young CF patients.
Klijn et al., 2004
are the first authors to conduct a high intensity anaerobic
training programme for children with CF. The authors suggest
that children may be more suited to high intensity anaerobic
training, as children's natural activity patterns are characterised
by very short vigorous bouts of physical activity, interspersed
with varying levels of low to moderate intensities. In a randomised,
controlled study 11 children with CF participated in a 12-week
anaerobic training programme. The children trained two days
per week, with each session lasting 30 to 45 minutes. The
training consisted of anaerobic activities lasting 20 to 30
seconds. The control group consisting of 9 young CF patients
were asked not to change their normal daily activities. Participants
of the exercise programme showed significant improvements
in both anaerobic and aerobic performance and quality of life
as measured by a disease specific health-related quality of
life questionnaire. Children in the control group showed no
improvements in any measured parameters. This study also identified
the benefits of including different exercises into training
programmes designed for children with CF. Furthermore, the
inclusion of different types of exercises adds variation to
training, which may help to improve adherence.
A later study by Orenstein et al., 2004
also supports the suggestion of incorporating both aerobic
and anaerobic exercises into training programmes to optimise
the functional capacity of the young CF patient. During a
one-year randomised controlled trial, 67 young patients with
CF, aged 8 to 18 years, participated in either an aerobic
or upper-body strength-training programme. All children were
asked to exercise at least three times per week for 12 consecutive
months. Each patient in the aerobic training group was given
a stair stepping machine and instructed to exercise five minutes
per session, gradually increasing to 30 minutes per session.
Young patients in the upper-body strength group were given
a weight resistance machine, which they used to perform bicep
curls, lateral pull-downs and bench presses. The exercises
were individually tailored to each patient's strength, and
the exercises increased gradually by the number of sets and
repetitions as well as by the amount of resistance per bout
over the year. Contrary to previous studies, Orenstein and
colleagues reported that aerobic training did not, however,
produce greater fitness or greater pulmonary function than
strength training. Furthermore, both types of training increased
upper-body strength and physical work capacity.
|
|
| PHYSICAL
ACTIVITY |
|
Maintaining
high levels of physical activity is important in the management
of CF. Clinicians encourage young patients with CF to take regular
exercise to help mobilise mucous secretions and enhance or preserve
breathing capacity. Exercise tolerance, however, in CF is limited
and inactivity itself results in deconditioning. Thus, a negative
feedback loop is formed, making physical activity even more difficult.
A recent study by Selvadurai et al., 2004
measured the habitual activity levels in boys and girls with different
degrees of CF lung disease and healthy controls. Each child completed
an activity diary for two weeks and wore a validated accelerometer
on the same days the activity diary was completed. What made this
study unique from previous studies, however, was the authors sought
to determine correlations between the young CF patients' physical
activity and functional capacity, and quality of wellbeing. Selvadurai
and colleagues reported significant correlations between activity
levels and aerobic capacity (r = 0.55; P < 0.01), anaerobic power
(r = 0.63; P < 0.01) and quality of wellbeing (r = 0.61; P <0.01).
In children with moderate to severe lung disease, body mass percentile
correlated well with activity levels, implicating possible effects
of poor nutrition on muscle mass and functional ability.
Selvadurai and colleagues further reported that there were no significant
differences in habitual activity between prepubescent children with
CF and controls, and regardless of disease severity there were no
differences in habitual activity between prepubescent boys and girls
with CF. After puberty, however, differences in habitual activity
become evident. Pubescent boys with CF were significantly
more active than girls with the same degree of disease severity,
and pubescent children with moderate to severe CF were less active
than controls. Only pubescent children with mild CF were significantly
more active than controls. This study highlights the importance
of maintaining physical activity levels after puberty, when it is
suggested that children with CF start becoming less active, particularly
in girls.
The importance of maintaining physical activity in girls with CF
is also emphasised in a recent study by Schneiderman-Walker et al.,
2005.
Schneiderman-Walker and colleagues reported that the annual rate
of decline in FEV1 was related to habitual physical activity in
girls. Children with CF were divided into quartiles depending on
activity levels derived from a Habitual Activity Estimation Scale;
their FEV1 was measured over a two-year period. In the lowest two
activity quartiles girls had a more rapid rate of decline in FEV1
(-3.40 and -3.05 % predicted, respectively), than girls in the two
highest activity quartiles (-0.93 and +1.17 % predicted, respectively).
In boys, however, the rate of decline of FEV1 was similar in all
activity quartiles (-0.93 % predicted). Preserving FEV1 is central
to the management of CF as it has a strong relationship with survival.
An inactive lifestyle may partially explain the poorer survival
of female patients with CF.
|
| PHYSIOLOGICAL
COMPARISONS BETWEEN THE YOUNG CF PATIENT AND HEALTHY CHILDREN |
CF
is also characterised by diminished nutritional status caused by diseased
gastrointestinal tracts and pancreatic insufficiency. This can lead
to malnutrition affecting the growth and maturation of skeletal muscle
through childhood and adolescence. Recent studies have investigated
the effect of reduced muscle size on exercise performance, to determine
if intrinsic pathophysiological defects exist in young CF muscle.
In a study by de Meer et al., 1999
it was reported that children with mild to moderate CF had significantly
weaker peripheral muscle force than healthy controls. Peripheral muscle
weakness was associated with diminished work capacity and an increased
oxygen cost of exercise. A disproportionate decrease in maximum cycle
workload was observed in children with CF when compared to healthy
controls, even in patients with normal pulmonary function and nutritional
status. From these findings de Meer and colleagues implicated that
impaired exercise performance in the young CF patient is at least
partly due to a pathophysiological factor in skeletal muscle that
cannot be readily attributed to nutritional factors. As a consequence,
intrinsic abnormalities may exist in the muscle of young CF patients,
which contribute to a reduced exercise performance.
Moser et al., 2000
hypothesised that exercise impairment in children with CF is primarily
due to a reduction in muscle mass rather than abnormalities in muscle
metabolism. Muscle size was estimated from midthigh muscle cross-sectional
area (MTCSA) by magnetic resonance imaging, and exercise performance
was determined by progressive cycle ergometer testing. Contrary to
the hypothesis, the results showed that a reduction in VO2peak
was observed even when normalised to MTCSA, whereas MTCSA was only
slightly smaller in children with CF than in control subjects. Therefore,
a reduced muscle mass alone could not account for all of the impairment
of VO2peak observed in the young CF patients. In agreement
with de Meer and colleagues, impaired oxygen delivery or intrinsic
abnormalities of muscle function are also responsible for reduced
exercise performance in children with CF. More studies are needed
to identify specific intrinsic abnormalities of skeletal muscle in
CF. |
| FUTURE
DIRECTIONS |
There
is a growing awareness among clinicians of the importance of exercise
testing and prescription. Recent research by Pianosi et al., 2005
has reinforced the prognostic value of VO2peak in young
patients with CF, reporting a strong correlation between annual decline
in VO2peak and survival over an eight-year period. Work
by Pouliou et al., 2001
and Javadpour et al., 2005
has started to focus attention on other physiological parameters derived
from exercise testing, besides the assessment of VO2peak,
to determine if they hold any prognostic value. Pouliou and colleagues
found a relationship between the VO2 kinetics during recovery
from maximal exercise in adult CF patients and disease severity. Whilst,
Javadpour et al. reported that CO2 retention on exercise
testing was associated with a faster rate of decline in FEV1
in children with CF. Further investigations of other physiological
parameters which can be measured through exercise testing is needed,
to determine if they hold greater prognostic value than established
ones.
Advances in exercise prescription are being initiated. The benefits
of including anaerobic and strength exercises into training programmes
for young patients with CF have been reported (Selvadurai et al.,
2002;
Klijn et al., 2004;
Orenstein et al., 2004).
Furthermore, anaerobic and strength exercises can provide variety
to training programmes, which have been generally dominated by aerobic
exercises. Novel and exciting exercise programmes can now be prescribed
to help maintain the enthusiasm of the young CF patient to continue
and adhere to training programmes. The importance of adherence to
exercise prescriptions and maintaining physical activity levels in
children with CF has also been highlighted. Children with CF after
puberty become less active than their healthy peers and this trend
is particularly evident in girls (Selvadurai et al., 2004).
A relationship between the annual rate of decline in FEV1
and habitual physical activity in girls has been identified (Schneiderman-Walker
et al., 2005).
Preserving FEV1 through exercise prescription and physical
activity is central to the management of CF, and this observation
may partially explain the poorer survival of female CF patients. More
studies are needed to assess which training programmes are the most
successful in promoting adherence. Consequently, studies would require
a longer follow-up period to monitor patient attrition.
The use of exercise testing and prescription among clinicians appears,
however, to be underused. Barker et al., 2004
conducted a national survey to characterise the opinions and practises
of CF centres in Germany. From the results of the survey Barker and
colleagues reported that despite an overwhelming belief in both the
benefits of exercise testing and prescription among clinicians, exercise
remains underused. From the returned questionnaires 87 % of clinicians
viewed physical exercise as being extremely important or very important,
and expressed an interest in expanding the prognostic and therapeutic
applications of exercise. The feasibility of conducting exercise tests
was not viewed as a major problem, equipment was available and one
physician plus an assistant could conduct the majority of tests. Only
60 % of specialised centres, however, performed some sort of exercise
testing at an average frequency of 2.3 years for patients aged eight
and above. Furthermore, protocols and indication criteria were often
non-standardized or not specified at all. Only two thirds of caregivers
advised their patients to engage in physical activity, but failed
to discuss specific modalities and potential hazards.
Whether this survey presents an accurate reflection of the opinions
and practises of exercise in CF centres across Europe and the developed
world remains as yet unknown. The work of Barker and colleagues shows
a belief among clinicians in the importance of exercise testing and
prescription; however, these beliefs are often not being put into
practise. Feasibility studies may be a future direction for research
to determine if the logistics of exercise tests within public healthcare
are practical. It is well established that exercise in children with
CF is both safe and beneficial, and the value of exercise tests are
recognised among clinicians. Informing and motivating clinicians may
increase the use of exercise tests and programmes as a prognostic
tool and therapy within the healthcare management of the young CF
patient. |
| CONCLUSION |
| Exercise
testing offers an integrated, objective assessment of cardiovascular,
respiratory, muscular and metabolic function of the patient. This
is not achieved by individual tests of lung function, radiological
investigations or measures of nutritional status that are routinely
used in the clinical evaluation of CF. Additional information from
exercise testing on the overall functional capacity of the patient
can provide the clinician with a more comprehensive clinical assessment.
This assessment could then be used to prescribe medication, more intensive
therapy and transplantation. Results from exercise tests can also
be used to prescribe individualised exercise programmes designed to
help preserve and maintain the functional capacity and overall health
of the patient. Exercise should be central to the management of CF.
There is a strong association between fitness and survival, and exercise
programmes have shown to improve exercise tolerance and functional
capacity. At present no other therapy is more effective, in maintaining
health and an active lifestyle in young patients with CF, than exercise. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- New
methods of health assessment from exercise testing in the young
CF patient have shown to have prognostic value.
- The
introduction of new training methods into exercise programmes
can improve the functional capacity and quality of life of young
patients with CF.
- Exercise
is still being underused in the healthcare management of the CF
patient.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Daniel
STEVENS
Employment: PhD student, University of Exeter, CHERC.
Degree: BSc, MSc.
Research interests: Physiological responses to exercise
in young patients with chronic chest diseases.
E-mail: d.stevens@ex.ac.uk |
|
Craig
A. WILLIAMS
Employment: Assoc. Prof., University of Exeter, CHERC.
Degree: BEd (Hons), MSc, PhD.
Research interests: Muscle metabolism, maximal intensity
exercise, fatigue, physiological methodology.
E-mail: c.a.williams@exeter.ac.uk |
|
|
|
|