|
EFFECTS OF ACUTE ECCENTRIC CONTRACTIONS ON RAT ANKLE JOINT STIFFNESS
|
1Graduate School of Health and Sport Science, Nippon Sport Science
University, Tokyo, Japan
2Department of Life Sciences, Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, University
of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan.
3Department of Exercise Physiology, Nippon Sport Science University, Tokyo,
Japan.
| Received |
|
16 July 2007 |
| Accepted |
|
24
October 2007 |
| Published |
|
01
December 2007 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2007) 6, 543 - 548
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| The sensation of joint stiffness is frequently observed after
eccentric contractions (ECs) in human, but the joint stiffness of
animals after ECs has not been examined previously. This study tested
whether a bout of ECs affects rat ankle joint stiffness. We also evaluate
muscle passive tension in the rat hindlimb to examine the relationships
of ankle joint stiffness with muscle passive tension. Anesthetized
male Wistar rats (n = 23) were firmly secured on a platform in the
prone position. A bout of ECs was performed on the gastrocnemius muscle
with a combination of electrically induced tetanic contractions via
a skin electrode and simultaneous forced dorsiflexion of the ankle
joint (velocity, 15°/s; from 0°to 45°). Passive resistive torque (PRT)
of the ankle joint was measured to evaluate joint stiffness. Passive
tension of the exposed gastrocnemius muscle was also measured when
the maximum value of joint stiffness was obtained. The PRT on days
2, 3, and 4 was significantly higher than the pre-treatment value
(days 2 and 4; p < 0.001, days 3; p < 0.01). The passive tension
on day 4 was significantly higher than that of the sham-operated group.
The muscle wet mass was identical in both groups, suggesting the absence
of edema. We conclude PRT increases after ECs in rat ankle joint.
We also show the possibility that it is associated with muscle passive
tension, independent of edema formation.
KEY
WORDS: Lengthening,
flexibility, passive torque, passive tension, animal model.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
The mechanical stiffness of a joint is defined as the absolute
torque that is required to maintain the joint specific angle or
the ratio of the change in the joint torque to the change in joint
angle (Kearney and Hunter, 1990).
Joint stiffness depends on the following three properties that have
different origins: (i) the elastic properties of non-contractile
connective tissues (including joint capsule and skin), (ii) the
elastic properties of the muscle-tendon complex, and (iii) the reflex
activation of a muscle following a change in its length. In particular,
the static passive stiffness of joints largely depends on the elastic
properties of non-contractile and contractile tissues (Gajdosik
et al., 1999).
It has been reported that acute eccentric contractions (ECs) induce
muscle weakness, soreness, and the sensation of stiffness (Chleboun
et al., 1998;
Clarkson et al., 1992;
Nosaka and Clarkson, 1995;
Porter et al., 2002).
Compared to other symptoms, the sensation of stiffness has not been
well analyzed. The sensation of stiffness has been described as
a reluctance to stretch the affected muscle and has been most commonly
evaluated by measuring the post-exercise resting position of the
joint (regarded as range of motion (ROM)) (Clarkson et al., 1992;
Nosaka and Clarkson, 1995;
Stauber et al., 1990).
The elbow angle of a relaxed arm becomes more acute following EC
exercises of the elbow flexors. Immediately after exercise, this
angle begins to decrease and continues to decrease until day 3 in
the previous human studies (Clarkson et al., 1992;
Whitehead et al., 2003).
The resting angle then increases gradually. In addition, Howell
et al., 1993
and Chleboun et al., 1998
measured the joint stiffness (regarded as passive resistive torque
(PRT)) in an intact human elbow. They showed that the PRT increased
immediately after ECs and remained elevated for approximately 4
days. Regardless of the evaluation method used, joint stiffness
is observed to increase after EC exercises.
Various theories have been proposed to explain this increase in
joint stiffness. Clarkson et al., 1992
proposed that an influx or accumulation of calcium could activate
specific enzymes and cause excessive contractures in the damaged
fibers. Howell et al., 1993
stated that the restriction of motion and the apparent decrease
in the resting length of the muscles was due to the occurrence of
an edematous change in the perimuscular connective tissues. Stauber
et al., 1990
concurred and proposed that the swollen tissues that pushed against
the fascia could shorten the muscle passively. The focus of these
hypotheses is to determine whether the elastic properties of the
muscle-tendon complex are associated with the increase in joint
stiffness. However, the direct association of joint stiffness and
passive muscle tension after ECs has not been examined previously.
To directly compare joint stiffness and muscle passive tension,
it is essential to employ experimental animals. With regard to the
effects of ECs on muscle-tendon complex passive tension, Whitehead
et al. (2001;
2003)
performed ECs on exposed cat medial gastrocnemius muscles. Electrical
stimulation was applied via the motor neurons, and the distal tendon
of the medical gastrocnemius was extended to induce ECs. By using
such experimental systems, they clearly demonstrated that passive
tension of the medial gastrocnemius was significantly elevated immediately
after the ECs. Since Whitehead et al., 2001
did not examine ankle joint stiffness in the experimental animal,
the direct relationship between joint stiffness and muscle passive
tension remained unclear. With regard to joint stiffness, Gillette
and Fell, 1996
measured ankle joint stiffness (static PRT) in rats. They revealed
that 7-day hindlimb suspension significantly increased the PRT of
the rat ankle joint. They also measured the ankle joint PRT after
each individual muscle tendon (gastrocnemius, soleus, and plantarius
muscles) was cut. The results revealed that the gastrocnemius and
soleus muscles contributed to the increase in joint PRT in hindlimb-suspended
animals. Direct comparison is important for evaluating the effects
of ECs, as shown by Gillette and Fell; however, such a trial has
not been pursued previously.
In this study, we measured the PRT of rat ankle joints and examined
the relationships between the ankle joint PRT and the gastrocnemius
muscle-tendon complex extensibility. We addressed the following
two specific hypotheses: (i) the ankle joint PRT is increased by
the ECs of the gastrocnemius, and (ii) the ankle joint PRT is related
to the gastrocnemius passive tension. To assess these hypotheses,
based on the reports of Gillette and Fell, 1996
and Gajdosik et al., 1999,
we developed equipment for measurement of the PRT of the rat ankle
joint. The passive tension of gastrocnemius was also evaluated as
reported by Whitehead et al., 2001.
We also measured the muscle mass after ECs to investigate edema
formation.
| METHODS |
Study 1
Animals
The protocol used in this experiment was approved by the Ethics
Committee of Nippon Sports Science University. Six male Wistar
rats (9 weeks old, 267-317 g) were purchased from CLEA Japan
(Tokyo, Japan). The animals were housed individually and maintained
on a 12:12-hour light-dark cycle with the lights on from 7:00
PM until 7:00 AM. Water and food were provided ad libitum during
the experiments.
Equipment
setup for eccentric contraction and torque measurement
The ankle torque of each animal was measured on a dynamometer,
the mechanical setup of which is shown in Figure
1a (same as Nakazato et al., 2007).
The torque of a stepping motor (RKD514HA, Oriental Motor,
Japan) was transmitted to a footplate. The footplate and its
angular velocity were adjustable at 5° intervals. The final
deceleration and backlash movement of the footplate were damped
using a magnetic powder brake (ZKB-0.3AN, Mitsubishi Electric,
Japan). The footplate was positioned such that the anatomical
axis of the ankle coincided with the axis of the dynamometer
shaft. The plantar flexion force was measured by installing
a strain-gauge force transducer (LTB-2KA, Kyowa Electronic
Instruments, Japan). The angular position was measured with
a potentiometer (LP06M3R1HA, Murata Manufacturing, Japan).
Both the force and position signals were sampled at 4000 Hz
by using a data acquisition system (PowerLab/16SP, ADInstruments,
Australia). We confirmed that this system could evaluate linear
relationships from 1. 225 to 2450 mNm. The coefficient of
variance (CV) of 5 measurements in same subject was 0.0251.
Procedure
for performing eccentric contractions on rat gastrocnemius
muscles
Before we performed the ECs, all the animals were anaesthetized
with sodium pentobarbital (1 mg/100 g body mass). The right
lower leg of each animal was used for experimental intervention.
As shown in Figure 1b
(same as Nakazato et al., 2007),
the anesthetized rats were firmly secured on the platform
at ankle joint angle of 0°(defined as the angle at which the
sole of foot and tibial bone are orthogonally positioned).
The electrically stimulated contraction force was measured
as follows. The gastrocnemius muscle was stimulated using
pulses of 0.4-ms duration at supramaximal voltage (30 V).
The stimulus voltage was adjusted to produce maximal isometric
twitch force. The muscle was stimulated at 100 Hz to cause
tetanic contraction. During tetanic contraction via a skin
electrode, ECs were performed 10 times as a single bout with
simultaneous forced dorsiflexion of the ankle joint (velocity,
15°/s; range of motion, from 0°to 45°).
Passive
torque against ankle dorsi-flexion
The static PRT of the ankle joint was measured to evalu-ate
joint stiffness as shown in our previous study (Ochi, E et
al. 2007).
The ankle joint of anesthetized rats was dorsi-flexed from
0° (defined as the angle at which the sole of the foot and
tibial bone are orthogonally positioned) to either 30° or
45° at an angular velocity of 30°/s. The stress relaxation
was allowed to proceed for >90 s until the passive torque
reached an almost steady level. The values of torque measured
90 s after the stretch were used as static PRTs. A joint angle
of 30 degrees was selected because this angle was the optimal
angle observed in preliminary experiment. As for the reason
for selecting PRT45 is to compare with previous study(Gillette
and Fell, 1996).
Six animals were measured at pretreatment, immediately after
treatment, and days 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8 and 10 after treatment.
Study
2
Animals
We did not only measure the joint stiffness in vivo but also
the muscle passive tension in situ. Seventeen male Wistar rats
(9 weeks old, 287-337 g) were purchased from CLEA Japan (Tokyo,
Japan). The animals were housed as well as study 1. Seventeen
rats were randomly assigned into two groups: the EC group (n
= 9) and the sham- operated group (was not performed eccentric
contractions, n = 8)
The passive tension of the exposed gastrocnemius muscle was
measured to evaluate for the muscle-tendon extensibility. The
knee joint and ankle of the anesthetized rats were fixed to
a rigid metal frame. The exposed tissues were covered with phosphate-buffered
saline that was retained in baths fashioned from skin flaps.
The passive tension was recorded after the muscle tendon was
fixed. The hindlimb was dissected to expose the gastrocnemius
muscle. For this, it was necessary to free the gastrocnemius
from the soleus muscle and cut and separate their tendons from
the Achilles tendon. The distal tendon of the gastrocnemius
muscle was connected to the lever arm of a servomotor at an
arbitrary muscle-tendon unit length (Lf). The length was then
increased in a series of 2-mm increments and stretched to 10
mm and holding the muscle at each length for 20 seconds. The
passive tension was measured at each length by averaging the
tension over 1 second at the end of the holding period. After
the passive tension was measured, the gastrocnemius muscle was
removed, trimmed free of connective tissue, and weighed.
Statistical
analysis
Results are expressed as mean ± S.D. In the study of PRT,
Dunnett's multiple comparison test was performed to compare
the forces during pretreatment, immediately after treatment,
and on days 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8 and 10 after the treatment.
The force during pre-treatment at day 0 was used as a control.
In the study of the muscle passive tension, the Student's
t test was used to compare the EC group and the control group.
Significant differences were set at P < 0.05. Pearson's
product-moment correlation coefficient was used to assess
the relationship between parameters. Significant level was
set at P < 0.05.The analysis program used was the statistical
package for the social sciences SPSS software for Windows
(SPSS Japan Inc., Japan.
|
| RESULTS |
Study 1
Passive
resistive torque of the ankle joint after eccentric contractions
Time course change of PRT at 30° after ECs is shown in Figure
2. The static PRT gradually increased and showed significantly
higher values on days 2 (p < 0.001), 3 (p < 0.01), and
4 (p < 0.001) after the ECs. Time course change of PRT at
45° showed the same tendency (Figure
2). Figure 3 shows
the relative increase of ankle joint PRT30 after ECs. Relative
PRT increased around 300% on
day 2 after ECs. The higher tendency of PRT continued until
day 4.
Correlation
between PRT30 and PRT45
We calculated correlation between PRT30 and PRT45. We confirmed
that positive correlations existed between PRT30 and PRT45
(r = 0.839; p < 0.01).
Study
2
Passive
tension of the exposed gastrocnemius muscle
The passive tension of the exposed gastrocnemius muscle on day
4 after ECs was measured (Figure
4). The passive tensions of the EC group at 4, 6, 8, and
10 mm were significantly higher than those of the sham-operated
group. On the other hand, muscle wet mass of the ECs group was
similar to the sham-operated group (ECs group; 1.49 ± 0.07,
Sham-operated group; 1.45 ± 0.13).
Correlation
between passive resistive torque and passive tension
In the study 2, we calculated that correlation between PRT30
and passive tension of gastrocnemius at 10 mm elongation (shown
in Figure 5). Significant
positive correlation was observed between these two parameters
(r = 0.682, p < 0.01.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
In
this study, we confirmed that ECs raise joint PRT and are
associated with reduction of muscle passive tension. The changes
in joint stiffness and muscle passive tension after ECs have
been examined independently and the direct relationships have
not been examined previously (Nosaka and Clarkson, 1995;
Whitehead et al., 2001).
We experimentally showed that ECs increased both joint PRT
and muscle passive tension and these two parameters were significantly
correlated. Although the variation of each parameter existed,
we think that it is due to the individual differences. Hereafter,
we will discuss changes in PRT and muscle passive tension
after ECs.
We
measured PRT as rat ankle joint stiffness. PRTs of rat ankle
joint have not been fully examined previously. Gillette and
Fell, 1996
showed that passive resistive tension of rat ankle joint at
45° was about 50 - 60 g, but they did not show absolute torque.
Given that the lever arm of the rat ankle joint is 1.5 cm
in our present data, then the PRT at 45° is 7.35 - 8.82 mNm.
We measured PRT45 and the obtained value ranged from 4 to
15 mNm. Thus, we confirmed that our experimental setups gave
relational value for PRT. We also confirmed that significant
correlations existed between PRT30 and PRT45 (r = 0.839, p
< 0.01, shown in Table.1). Above all, we conclude that
our employed parameters of PRT30 and PRT45 accurately reflect
stiffness of rat ankle joint.
We confirmed that a significant correlation exists between
gastrocnemius muscle passive tensions and PRT on day 4 after
ECs. This is the first study to show a direct correlation
between them after ECs. Gillette and Fell, 1996
showed that hindlimb uploading made rat ankle joint stiff,
and this increased passive torque was due to musculotendinous
units, especially gastrocnemius. Although another model was
reported, Gillette's study and ours indicate that the viscoelastic
properties of gastrocnemius are a major factor for determining
ankle joint stiffness. On the other hand, thixotropic behaviors
at a relaxed joint are attributed both to the joint structures
and to short-range stiffness of muscles acting at the joint
(Wiegner, 1987).
Since thixotropic behavior is a normal joint characteristic,
abnormal gastrocnemius extensibilities become apparent in
the eccentric contracted joint.
Gastrocnemius muscle wet mass of the ECs group was similar
to that of the sham-operated group. Chleboun et al., 1998
showed that elbow flexor volume increased when elbow joint
stiffness increased after ECs of elbow flexor. Since elevated
muscle wet mass and muscle volume after ECs suggest existence
of edema, our results suggest that factors other than edema
contribute to this phenomenon. Proske et al. (2005)
proposed that the reason for the rise in passive tension is
that after sarcomere disruption by the ECs, there is the likelihood
of membrane damage, perhaps at the level of the t-tubules
or sarcoplasmic reticulum. The consequent uncontrolled release
of Ca2+ into the sarcoplasm activates the contractile
filaments to develop an injury contracture (Proske and Allen,
2005).
We cannot exclude the contribution of edema, but we consider
that Ca2+ also plays an important role in joint
and muscle stiffness after ECs.
|
|
| CONCLUSION |
| In the present study, we determined that one bout of ECs increases
both joint stiffness and gastrocnemius passive tensions. We also confirm
that there were significant correlations between ankle joint PRT and
gastrocnemius muscle-tendon complex extensibilities. We also show
the possibility that joint stiffness is associated with muscle passive
tension, independent of edema formation. |
| ACNOWLEDGMENTS |
| This study was supported by the Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research
(No.15300224) from the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science
and Technology of Japan. The authors thank Tatsuro Hirose and Hongsun
Song for technical advice and helpful discussions. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- We confirmed that ECs raise joint PRT and are associated with
reduction of muscle passive tension.
- The changes in joint stiffness and muscle passive tension after
ECs have been examined independently and the direct relationships
have not been examined previously.
- We experimentally showed that ECs increased both joint PRT and
muscle passive tension and these two parameters were significantly
correlated.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Ochi EISUKE
Employment: Nippon Sports Science University, Department
of Preventive Medicine and Public health.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Exercise physiology and exercise
biochemistry.
E-mail: ochi@nittai.ac.jp |
|
Ishii
NAOKATA
Employment: University of Tokyo, Department of Life Sciences.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Exercise physiology and exercise
biochemistry.
E-mail: ishii@idaten.u-tokyo.ac.jp |
|
Nakazato
KOICHI
Employment: Nippon Sports Science University, Department
of Sports Physiology.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Exercise physiology and sports injuries.
E-mail: nakazato@nittai.ac.jp |
|
|
|
|