|
HIGH-VELOCITY RESISTANCE EXERCISE PROTOCOLS IN OLDER WOMEN: EFFECTS
ON CARDIOVASCULAR RESPONSE
|
1College of Physical Education, Faculdades Unidas do Norte de Minas, Brazil,
2Graduate School of Physical Education, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro,
Brazil, 3Graduate School of Physical Education, Catholic University of
Brasilia, Brazil, 4College of Physical Education, University of Brasilia,
Brazil, 5Dept. of Health, Physical Education, and Recreation, Utah State
University, USA.
| Received |
|
06 August 2007 |
| Accepted |
|
15
October 2007 |
| Published |
|
01
December 2007 |
©
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2007) 6, 560 - 567
Search
Google Scholar for Citing Articles
| ABSTRACT |
| Acute cardiovascular responses to different high-velocity resistance
exercise protocols were compared in untrained older women. Twelve
apparently healthy volunteers (62.6 ± 2.9 y) performed three different
protocols in the bench press (BP). All protocols involved three sets
of 10 repetitions performed with a 10RM load and 2 minutes of rest
between sets. The continuous protocol (CP) involved ten repetitions
with no pause between repetitions. The discontinuous protocols were
performed with a pause of five (DP5) or 15 (DP15) seconds between
the fifth and sixth repetitions. Heart rate (HR), systolic blood pressure
(SBP), rate pressure product (RPP), Rating of Perceived Exertion (RPE),
and blood lactate (BLa) were assessed at baseline and at the end of
all exercise sets. Factorial ANOVA was used to compare the cardiovascular
response among different protocols. Compared to baseline, HR and RPP
were significantly (p < 0.05) higher after the third set in all
protocols. HR and RPP were significantly (p < 0.05) lower in DP5
and DP15 compared with CP for the BP exercise. Compared to baseline,
RPE increased significantly (p < 0.05) with each subsequent set
in all protocols. Blood lactate concentration during DP5 and DP15
was significantly lower than CP. It appears that discontinuous high-velocity
resistance exercise has a lower cardiovascular demand than continuous
resistance exercise in older women.
KEY
WORDS: Aging,
weight training, blood pressure, heart rate, perceived exertion.
|
| INTRODUCTION |
|
Aging is associated with a progressive loss of muscle mass and
strength, leading to a decline in physical function and increased
disability (Baumgartner et al., 1998;
Roubenoff et al., 1997).
Muscular strength tends to peak between the second and third decade
of life and remains essentially unchanged until about 50 years,
when loss begins to occur at an accelerated rate (Nair, 1995).
This process is believed to be caused by both muscle tissue atrophy
and a loss of muscle fibers (Kamel, 2003;
Lexell, 1995).
Type II fibers, also known as fast-twitch fibers, are more affected
by aging than type I fibers, which leads to a diminished ability
to develop muscle power (Hakkinen et al., 2001a;
2001b;
Izquierdo et al., 1999).
Despite the structural and functional changes that occur with aging,
skeletal muscle trainability appears to be preserved, and many positive
physiological adaptations occur in older persons as a result of
exercise. In this regard, resistance exercise is recognized as a
safe and effective strategy to improve lean body mass, muscle strength,
and power as well as the ability to perform functional tasks (Bottaro
et al., 2007;
Galvao and Taaffe, 2005;
Skelton et al., 1995).
However, when prescribing resistance exercise to this population,
assessment of acute physiological responses to exercise is of particular
importance, especially when safety is considered. During resistance
exercise, a number of acute changes occur in the cardiovascular
system, such as increases in heart rate (HR), blood pressure (BP),
and rate pressure product (RPP). These acute cardiovascular responses
are influenced by numerous factors, including active muscle mass,
exercise intensity, number of repetitions, type of exercise, and
type of muscle contraction (Mayo and Kravitz, 1999;
Rozenek et al., 1993).
Numerous studies have investigated the chronic effects of low-velocity
and/or high- velocity resistance training on improving muscular
fitness and functional performance in the elderly (Bottaro et al.,
2007;
Earles et al., 2001;
Fielding et al., 2002;
Hakkinen et al., 2001a;
2001b;
2002;
Henwood and Taaffe, 2005;
Hruda et al., 2003;
Izquierdo et al., 2001;
Miszko et al., 2003;
Newton et al., 2002).
Other studies have investigated the acute effects of resistance
training and isometric muscle contractions on acute cardiovascular
response in older adults (Petrofsky and Lind, 1975;
Rozenek et al., 1993;
Sagiv et al., 1988;
Van Loan et al., 1989;
Wescott and Howes, 1983).
However, limited research has been published that compares the acute
cardiovascular responses to different protocols of high-velocity
resistance exercise in older adults.
One strategy that could be used to reduce cardiovascular stress
imposed by high-velocity resistance training is the use of pauses
between repetitions. Coelho et al., 2003
compared two formats of high-velocity resistance training protocols
(continuous vs discontinuous) on HR and rate of perceived exertion
(RPE) in young subjects and concluded that the discontinuous protocol
was significantly less demanding. However, the authors did not evaluate
SBP, and studies in younger persons may not be fully applicable
to the elderly since previous studies have reported different cardiovascular
responses between younger and older persons (Smolander et al., 1998;
Van Loan et al., 1989).
We are unaware of any published studies analyzing high-velocity
continuous and discontinuous resistance training protocols on acute
cardiovascular responses (HR, BP, RPP) and RPE in older subjects.
Therefore, the purpose of the present study was to evaluate and
compare the effects of one continuous and two discontinuous high-velocity
resistance exercise protocols on the cardiovascular responses in
older women.
| METHODS |
|
Subjects
Twelve apparently healthy older women between 60 and 70 years
old (62.6 ± 2.9 y) participated in the study protocol. All
volunteers were untrained and had not performed resistance
training regularly in the year before the study. Exclusion
criteria included orthopedic or neurological conditions that
could limit exercise, history of cardiovascular or other systemic
diseases that could interfere with the tests, and intake of
medications that could influence acute cardiovascular responses
to exercise. The University's ethical review board approved
the study design, and all subjects read and signed a consent
form prior to participation in the study.
Anthropometry
Body weight was assessed with a digital scale to the nearest
0.1 kg, and height was assessed with a stadiometer to the
nearest 0.1 cm (Toledo do Brazil, São Bernardo do Campo, SP
- Brazil). Measurements were made with the subjects in light
clothes and shoes removed. Body mass index (BMI) was calculated
as body weight (in kilograms) divided by the square of height
(in meters).
Ten
maximum repetition (10RM) tests
To reduce the effects of neurological adaptation from familiarization
to baseline measures and to maximize reliability, subjects
trained for three weeks (2 d/wk) before the first 10RM test.
In the week before the experiment, the load for 10RM was determined
for each subject in the horizontal bench press (BP) exercise
by using the maximum weight that could be lifted for 10 consecutive
repetitions. If the subject did not accomplish 10RM in the
first attempt, the weight was adjusted by 4-10 kg and a minimum
of five minutes of rest was given before the next attempt.
Only three trials were allowed per testing session. The tests
were repeated in all subjects and data were analyzed by Pearson
product moment correlations to estimate day-to-day 10RM reliability
(r = 0.97, p < 0.01). BP 10RM loads were 19.7
± 2.9 kg.
Experimental
procedures
To avoid any threats of internal validity, all 12 subjects
performed each of the three protocols in a counterbalance
order; for some the first testing session was the continuous
protocol (CP) while others started with the discontinuous
protocols of either 5 (DP5) or 15 (DP15) seconds rest between
the fifth and sixth repetitions. At least 48 but not more
than 72 hrs of recovery time was allowed between each training
session. All tests were conducted in the same facility between
1:30 PM and 4:00 PM. Subjects refrained from ingesting caffeine
and alcohol for 24 hours before all tests, and no other strenuous
exercise was performed before the experimental sessions. After
baseline measurements of SBP and HR, volunteers warmed up
on a stationary bicycle for 10 minutes, followed by one set
of 10 repetitions at 50% of the 10RM load.
During the continuous protocol (CP) subjects performed 10
repetitions with no pause between them. The two discontinuous
protocols were performed with a pause of five (DP5) or 15
(DP15) seconds between the fifth and sixth repetitions. During
the pauses of the discontinuous protocols the weight was re-racked.
All protocols were performed at the load obtained during the
10RM test with two minutes rest intervals between sets. However,
to maintain the same training volume, subjects who did not
complete 10 repetitions of the second or third sets during
the first random protocol (CP, DP5, or DP15) were instructed
to repeat the same number of reps during the second and the
third protocols. Subjects were instructed to perform repetitions
with maximum velocity in the concentric phase and to take
2-3 seconds to complete the eccentric phase. The same technician
controlled the rest intervals during all tests using a digital
chronometer. Subjects were instructed on proper breathing
technique to discourage the Valsalva maneuver.
Heart
rate, blood pressure and rate pressure product
Heart-rate (HR) was assessed using a portable telemetric device
(Polar S810, Polar Electro Inc, Kempele - Finland). Using
standardized techniques, a trained technician measured systolic
blood pressure (SBP) by auscultation using a mercury column
syphgmomanometer (Glicomed, Rio de Janeiro, RJ - Brazil).
Rate pressure product (RPP) was also calculated (RPP = HR
x SBP x 10-2, arbitrary units), as it is considered a reliable
predictor of myocardial oxygen demand (Gobel et al., 1978;
Kitamura et al., 1972;
Nelson et al., 1974;
White, 1999).
We are aware that intra-arterial pressure measurement is considered
the golden standard method for assessing blood pressures and
that the auscultation method tends to underestimate this parameter.
However, the intra-arterial measurement is an invasive procedure
that might put participants at risk, which leads to a recommendation
to avoid its use in healthy subjects (Perloff et al., 1993;
Raftery, 1991),
and we found it particularly limiting in older subjects. Even
though the error margin of the auscultation method is higher,
the assumption that the tendency to underestimate SBP is constant
throughout the exercises makes it suitable for comparing cardiovascular
demand from different protocols of exercise in the same person.
During the adaptation phase, baseline SBP was measured and
mean and standard deviation (SD) were calculated in order
to set reference values. Before the beginning of the tests,
subjects sat for 20 minutes in a quiet place for HR and SBP
measurements. SBP was recorded as the moment of hearing the
first Korotkoff sound
and diastolic BP (DBP) as the moment of disappearance of the
Korotkoff sound. If the values obtained at the baseline testing
were out of the range defined as mean ± SD of the reference
values, the tests were not performed. HR was constantly measured
and the highest value of HR obtained at the end of the exercise
was used in the analysis. SBP was measured immediately after
the end of each set of the BP exercise. Each resting blood
pressure was measured by the same technician in all subjects,
and reliability data were analyzed (r = 0.96, p < 0.01).
Rating
of perceived exertion (RPE)
RPE was assessed immediately after each set using the OMNI-RES
scale (Robertson et al., 2003).
The reproducibility of the RPE test was 0.84 (p < 0.01)
for the BP exercise.
Blood
lactate (BLa)
A small sample of blood (25 ?l) was taken from the right ear
lobe after the completion of each protocol. Blood from these
incisions was allowed to flow into a Brand NH4 heparinized
capillary tube. From the capillary tube, the blood was added
to a labeled Eppendorf tube filled with buffer (1% sodium
fluoride) at a ratio of 1:3 (blood to buffer). These samples
were then placed in a refrigerator at approximately 4ºC to
be further analyzed using the YSI 1500 Lactate Analyzer (Yellow
Springs Instrument Co., Yellow Springs, OH - USA).
Statistical
analysis
Standard statistical methods were used to calculate means
and standard deviations (SD). Differences in HR, SBP, RPP
and RPE were assessed using factorial ANOVA; a 3 x 4 design
[protocol (CP, DP5, DP15) x time (baseline, first, second,
and third sets)] was used for HR, SBP, RPP, and a 3 x 3 design
[protocol (CP, DP5, DP15) x time (first, second, and third
sets)] was used for RPE. Differences in BLa responses were
assessed with a one way repeated measure ANOVA. Multiple comparisons
with confidence interval adjustment by the LSD procedure were
used for post-hoc comparisons when necessary. The p < 0.05
criterion was used for establishing statistical significance.
All statistical analyses werdone with the SPSS 10.0 software
(SPSS, Chicago, IL - USA).
|
| RESULTS |
|
Descriptive characteristics of the sample (N = 12) are presented
in Table 1
Heart
rate (HR)
Table 2 represents the
HR values for different protocols during the BP exercises.
Within protocol analysis revealed that HR was significantly
lower at baseline when compared to the first, second, and
third sets (p < 0.05). During the CP, HR was higher in
the second and third sets in comparison to the first set (p
< 0.05). Moreover, after the second and third sets, HR
was higher during CP than both DP5 and DP15 (p < 0.05).
Systolic
blood pressure (SBP)
The SBP values are presented in Table
3. Within group analysis for all protocols revealed that
SBP was lower at baseline than after the first, second, and
third sets, and lower after the first set in comparison with
the second and third sets (p < 0.05). No significant differences
in SBP were found between-groups.
Rate
pressure product (RPP)
The values for RPP are presented in Figure
1. In all protocols, RPP was lower at baseline than after
the first, second, and third sets (p < 0.05), and RPP was
lower in the first set in comparison to the second and third
sets (p < 0.05). In the second and third sets, RPP was
higher for the CP in comparison to both DP5 and DP15.
Rate
of perceived exertion (RPE)
RPE values are presented in Figure
2. According to the results, RPE progressively increased
throughout the sets. RPE in the third set was higher than
both second and first, and
RPE in the second was higher than first (p < 0.05). However,
there were no differences for RPE among the three protocols.
Blood
lactate (BLa)
Values of BLa after different protocols are illustrated in
Figure 3. For the BP
exercise, BLa concentration after CP was higher in comparison
to DP15 (p < 0.05). However, after DP5, BLa was not significantly
higher than DP15.
|
| DISCUSSION |
|
Previous
reviews have stated that high-velocity resistance training
may provide specific benefits to elderly subjects (Kraemer
et al., 2002;
Porter, 2006),
and this has been supported in recent experiments (Bottaro
et al., 2007;
Henwood and Taaffe, 2005;
2006).
However, myocardial oxygen consumption (HR x SBP) increases
substantially during the performance of dynamic resistance
exercise (Fleck and Kraemer, 2004).
Inability to supply oxygen to the myocardium when demand is
high appears to be related to several cardiovascular events,
including transient myocardial ischemia, acute myocardial
infarction, and sudden death (Withe, 1999).
Both research findings and clinical experience indicate that
resistance exercise is relatively safe (Williams et al., 2007).
However, most studies of resistance exercise have enrolled
selected, low-risk individuals, and many are too small to
provide reliable estimates of event rates on a population-wide
basis (McCartney, 1999).
Thus, monitoring cardiovascular responses to resistance exercise
with measures of HR, BP, and perceived exertion are commonly
recommended (Williams et al., 2007).
Analogous to the risks associated with aerobic exercise, cardiovascular
risks associated with resistance training are likely determined
by the age of the participant,
his or her habitual physical activity and fitness level, underlying
CVD, and the intensity of resistance training. Although excessive
BP elevations have been documented with high-intensity resistance
exercise, for example, 80% to 100% of 1-RM performed to exhaustion,
such elevations are generally not a concern with low- to moderate-intensity
resistance training performed with correct breathing technique
and avoidance of the Valsalva maneuver (McCartney, 1999).
The present study used moderate-intensity training in older
women, and the Valsalva maneuver was avoided. All subjects
completed the test protocols without incidents.
According to our results, all protocols lead to increases
in HR, SBP, and RPP in comparison to baseline. Other studies
that have characterized the continuous blood pressure response
to weight lifting through the use of intra-arterial canulation
and blood pressure recordings have shown similar specific
blood pressure responses as demonstrated in the present study
(Fleck and Dean, 1987;
Gotshall et al., 1999;
MacDougall et al., 1992).
Gotshall et al., 1999,
using three sets of 10RM, reported that SBP and mean pressures
increased progressively within each set with the number of
the repetition and also increased with each subsequent set
of double-leg presses.
The peak pressures reported by Gotshall et al., 1999
were higher than those reported in the present study; however,
the subjects in the Gotshall et al., 1999
study were college age males while participants in the current
study were older women. Additionally, subjects in the Gotshall
et al., 1999
study performed lower body exercise (double-leg press) and
subjects in the present study performed upper body exercise
(BP).
The HR response to exercise involves an integration of the
cardiovascular, muscular, and central nervous systems ( Mayo
and Kravitz, 1999;
Mitchell et al., 1980;
1981).
Contraction of skeletal muscle, activation of afferent fibers
by stretch, and increased metabolite production can contribute
to changes in HR during resistance training (Stone et al.,
1985).
In addition, exercise also promotes a rise in plasma catecholamines,
an increase in sympathetic stimulation, and a decrease in
parasympathetic drive (Mayo and Kravitz, 1999).
The acute blood pressure response to resistance training is
comprised of central and peripheral components (Mayo and Kravitz,
1999).
The central mechanisms arise from supraspinal brain regions
and are directly related to voluntary effort, while the peripheral
components originate in the active muscle (Mitchell, 1990;
Sale et al., 1994).
Additionally, the high intra-muscular pressure associated
with resistance exercise promote mechanical compression of
arterial vessels, occluding blood flow to the active tissues
(Lind et al., 1964).
These lead to increases in metabolic by-products such as H+,
lactate, and ADP, which, in turn, activate nerve endings and
stimulate the pressure reflex (Mayo and Kravitz, 1999).
Between groups comparison revealed that RPP and HR was lower
in DP5 and DP15 than CP in the second and third sets of the
BP exercise. No between-groups difference in SBP occurred
between CP and both discontinuous protocols during the BP
exercise. Therefore, data analysis revealed that differences
in RPP during the BP exercise seem to be mainly determined
by differences in the HR response.
In a previous study, older subjects performed hip flexion
and shoulder abduction under two different protocols (Veloso
et al., 2003).
In one protocol, four sets of six repetitions were performed;
in the other, subjects performed two sets of 12 continuous
repetitions, both at the load obtained in the 12RM test. In
both protocols, hip flexion and shoulder abduction were performed
in an alternate manner with no rest between exercises. According
to the results, there were no differences between protocols
for HR, however, significant differences were observed in
SBP and RPP when the second continuous set was compared to
the second intermittent set. Nevertheless, the exercises were
performed in an alternate manner with no rest between them
despite the continuous or intermittent nature of the protocol,
which limits comparison with the present study.
In agreement with the present study, Coelho et al., 2003
found that BLa and HR responses to a continuous resistance
training protocol (12 repetitions performed at high velocity)
was significantly higher than after a discontinuous protocol
(15-second pause between the sixth and seventh repetitions)
in young subjects. However, the authors reported significant
differences in RPE, which is in contrast to the present study.
After considering the Coelho et al., 2003
study, we also hypothesized that CP would elicit a higher
RPE than DP15 of the same external work. This difference might
be related to the resistance training protocol. The protocol
of Coelho et al., 2003
involved the performance of 12 repetitions in six exercises,
which should have been more metabolically demanding, as seen
by BLa values more than twice as high as the values found
in the present analysis. Another difference may be the methods
used in the analysis; the present study used the OMNI-RES
scale, while Coelho et al., 2003
used the CR-10 scale.
It is possible that during DP15 and DP5, at least partial
recovery of CP stores may have occurred, leading to an increased
utilization of the ATP-CP anaerobic metabolic pathway. Additionally,
the utilization of pauses during the sets may have lead to
a reduced vascular occlusion. These may have decreased metabolite
accumulation and thus, to a lower stimulus to chemical receptors.
BLa analysis showed that BLa values for CP and DP5 were higher
than values for DP15; therefore, the stimulation of chemical
receptors may have been weaker for CP and DP5.
|
|
| CONCLUSION |
In
conclusion, based on the present findings, it appears that discontinuous
high-velocity resistance exercise may have a lower cardiovascular
demand than continuous resistance exercise in older women. There was
a 7.2% reduction in RPP for DP5 compared to CP at the end of the third
set, and a SBP reduction of ~ 5 mmHg and ~3 mmHg for the second and
third set, respectively. Although the difference between protocols
is not great, it may still be physiologically relevant. According
to Whelton et al., 2002,
even a modest 3 mmHg drop in SBP has been associated with reduced
cardiac morbidity by 5% to 9%, stroke by 8% to 14%, and all-cause
mortality by 4%.
Also, it appears that there is no difference between DP5 and DP15
on RPP. Thus, applying a 5-second pause might be a good strategy to
decrease cardiovascular strain during high-velocity muscle contraction
resistance training in older women. It is worth noting that, although
no difference was reported between DP5 and DP15, a 15-second pause
could be distinguished as a rest interval between sets and create
a false set leading to different chronic adaptations.
These findings may help exercise scientists prescribe high-velocity
resistance exercise in a safe manner. It is not known, however, whether
the chronic physiological adaptations associated with resistance exercise
are similar for continuous and discontinuous protocols; therefore,
future studies regarding this topic are warranted. |
| KEY
POINTS |
- The assessment of cardiovascular responses to high-velocity resistance
exercise in older individuals is very important for exercise prescription
and rehabilitation in elderly population.
- Discontinuous protocol decrease myocardial oxygen consumption
(HR x SBP) during the performance of dynamic high-velocity resistance
exercise in older women.
- The decrease in RPP (~ 8.5%) during the discontinuous protocol
has clinical implications when developing high-velocity resistance
exercise strategies for elderly individuals.
|
| AUTHORS
BIOGRAPHY |
Rodrigo SILVA
Employment: Prof., College of Physical Education, Faculdades
Unidas do Norte de Minas, and State University of Montes Claros,
Montes Claros, MG, Brazil.
Degree: MS.
Research interests: Aging exercise physiology and Strength
training.
E-mail: lacif_pesquisa@yahoo.com.br |
|
Jefferson
NOVAES
Employment: Prof., Graduate School of Physical Education,
Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Physical fitness and performance.
E-mail: jsnovaes@terra.com.br |
|
Ricardo
Jacó de OLIVEIRA
Employment: Prof., Graduate School of Physical Education,
Catholic University of Brasília, Brasília, DF, Brazil.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Aging exercise physiology and Genetics.
E-mail: rjaco@pos.ucb.br |
|
Paulo
GENTIL
Employment: PhD student, University of Brasília, DF, Brazil.
Degree: MS.
Research interests: Strength training and Genetics.
E-mail: paulogentil@hotmail.com
|
|
Dale WAGNER
Employment: Prof., Dept. of Health, Physical Education,
and Recreation, Utah State University. Logan, UT, USA.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Body composition, Exercise physiology
and Strength training.
E-mail: Dale.Wagner@usu.edu
|
|
Martim BOTTARO
Employment: Prof., College of Physical Education, University
of Brasília, Brasília, DF, Brazil.
Degree: PhD.
Research interests: Aging exercise physiology and Strength
training.
E-mail: martim@unb.br
|
|
|
|
|