|
JOURNAL
OF
SPORTS SCIENCE &
MEDICINE
|
|
Review
article
|
THE METABOLIC DEMANDS OF KAYAKING: A REVIEW |
|||||||||
Jacob S. Michael |
|||||||||
School of Exercise and Sport Science, Faculty of Health Sciences, Sydney University, Australia. |
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
© Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2008) 7, 1-7 Search Google Scholar for Citing Articles |
|||||||||
|
|
| ABSTRACT | |||||||||||
| Flat-water kayaking is one of the best-known competitive canoeing
disciplines in Australia and across the European countries. From a stationary
start, paddlers are required to paddle their kayaks with maximal effort
along the length of the competing distance. The ultimate criterion of kayak
performance is the time taken to paddle a designated competition distance.
In flat-water racing, events are contested over 500 and 1000 metres. To
approximate the ultimate criterion over these distances, the velocity of
the kayak should be measured. Furthermore, other factors that affect performance,
such as force, power, technique and aerobic fitness, would all provide a
valuable insight to the success of the kayak paddler. Specific research
performed examining the physiological demands on kayak paddlers demonstrate
high levels of both aerobic power and anaerobic capacity. It is the purpose
if this review to present the published physiological data relating to men's
and women's kayaking. With a number of recent publications, a need for an
updated review is necessary. The present review summarises recent data on
anthropometrics, physiological characteristics of successful and unsuccessful
kayak athletes and methods of physiological testing. Due to the fact that
more data have been reported for male competitors than for their female
counterparts, the demands of kayaking on male athletes will be the main
focus for this review. The review also suggests areas for future research
into flatwater kayaking performance. Understanding the physiological requirements
of kayaking can assist coaches and athletes in a number of ways. During
competition or training, such information is helpful in the selection of
appropriate protocols and metabolic indices to monitor an athlete's performance
improvements and assess an athlete's suitability for a particular race distance.
Furthermore, it may aid the coach in the development of more specific training
programs for their athletes.
Key words: Kayak, ergometer, anthropometry, oxygen demand, aerobic power, lactate. |
|
| INTRODUCTION | |||||||||||
|
Energy
demand during competitive kayaking Anthropometric
characteristics of kayakers |
|
| OXYGEN DEMANDS DURING KAYAKING | |||||||||||
| VO2 measures of kayakers Exercise physiologists have utilised a variety of testing methods to estimate VO2 peak in kayakers (Table 2). The proportion of whole body musculature required during exercise in studies testing kayak paddlers varies. Physiological tests of kayak paddlers have been carried out during on water analysis (Gray et al., 1995; Pendergast et al., 1989; Tesch, 1983; van Someren et al., 1999), kayak ergometry (Billat et al., 1996; Bishop et al., 2002; Fry and Morton, 1991; Hahn et al., 1988; Pendergast et al., 1979; Tesh et al., 1976), arm cranking (Bergh et al., 1976; Pendergast et al., 1979; Tesch, 1976; 1983; Tesch and Lindeberg, 1984), bicycle ergometry (Bergh et al., 1976; Pendergast et al., 1979; Pyke et al., 1973; Tesch et al., 1976), treadmill running (Sidney and Shephard, 1973; Tesch, 1983; Tesch et al., 1976) and combined activity of the legs and arms (Bergh et al., 1976; Hahn et al., 1988; Pendergast et al., 1979). The effects of proportion of muscle used must be taken into account when discussing kayak paddler performance. Although a number of testing methods have been preformed, the ideal method of testing is to measure oxygen consumption on the water. Six male Swedish sprint kayakers of Olympic standard were reported to reach a peak oxygen uptake of 4.67 L·min-1 during an on water 1000m race (Tesch, 1983). In another study by van Someren et al., 1999 9 well trained kayak paddlers produced an average peak value of 4.27 L·min-1 for VO2 for the same race distance at maximal effort, lower than the 4.71 L·min-1 and 4. 67 L·min-1 reported when measuring elite Swedish kayak paddlers (Tesch et al., 1976 and Tesch, 1983 respectively). Considering that all studies examined paddlers during maximal efforts, it was speculated that the differences observed were a result of the subject characteristics in the study by van Someren et al., 1999. The subject population were not of elite standard and one could argue they were at a lower skill and conditioning level. Findings by Fry and Morton, 1991 further support van Someren et al., 1999. It can therefore be assumed from these results presented that the more skilled paddlers are more likely to obtain a greater peak rate of oxygen consumption. Studying 38 kayak paddlers from the Western Australian championships, Fry and Morton, 1991 classified the paddlers as either state team paddlers and non-state team members based on an objective selection policy, including performance time and position. Using a Monarch mechanically braked bicycle ergometer mounted on a kayak frame, the VO2peak values for the subjects were determined using a progressive test to exhaustion. The mean VO2peak values for the state team kayakers reached 4.78 L·min-1, a value significantly higher than the mean VO2peak for the non-state team paddlers (3.87 L·min-1). However, when maximal oxygen consumption was expressed in ml·kg-1·min-1, although remaining higher, there was no significant difference between the state and non-state team paddlers. Bishop, 2000 explains that while a large aerobic power is very important, anthropometric characteristics can also influence performance. Paddlers of the state team were found to be slightly heavier and taller than the less successful paddlers. Significant strength differences and reduced, but not significant skinfold measurements, were also found to be associated with the state team members. To account for the difference in oxygen consumption, Fry and Morton, 1991 suggested that the aerobic power to weight ratio is not as important for kayak success as absolute aerobic power. This implies that the kayaker can afford to be large without detriment to success provided they can produce high levels of aerobic power. A potential confounder to the suggestion from Fry and Morton, 1991 above is that no measures of technique or skill, other than time to complete the task, were recorded. One could argue that on the basis of rowing studies by Smith and Loschner, 2000 skilled kayak paddlers are better able to minimise any excess body movements within the kayak to provide a more powerful and efficient stroke compared to their sub-elite counterparts. Rowing studies, such as Loschner et al., 2000 and Smith and Loschner, 2000 have analysed the movement of a rowing scull and found the amount of yaw (sideways deviation), pitch (bobbing movement) and roll (roll of the boat from side to side) induced in the boat by a rower affected the efficiency of boat propulsion and hence influenced the velocity of the rowing scull. Considering the complex nature of kayaking, this could potentially manifest as a change in oxygen consumption of the athlete if differences in technique are assumed between performance level and would be a fertile area of future investigation. VO2peak
of kayakers vs others sports |
|
| ANAEROBIC COMPONENT OF KAYAKING | |||||||||||
|
Anaerobic
threshold of kayakers Anaerobic
power of paddlers |
|
| CONCLUSION | |||||||||||
|
Elite male kayakers appear homogeneous in shape and physical size, being
differentiated from the general population by their greater upper body
girth and narrow, hips (Ackland et al., 2003)
and demonstrate superior aerobic and anaerobic qualities (Hahn et al.,
1988;
Tesch et al., 1976;
Tesch, 1983;
Pendergast et al., 1989;
Zamparo et al., 1999).
Kayakers have reported VO2peak values of around 58 ml·kg-1·min-1
(4.7 L·min-1) and lactate values of around 12 mM during laboratory
and on water testing. For kayaking, a sport that relies on high maximal
aerobic power, the anaerobic energy system also seems to be important
for successful performance. van Someren and Oliver, 2001
reported that the mean lactate threshold occurred at a blood lactate concentration
of 2.7 mmol·L-1, at a HR of 170 beats·min-1 and
a VO2 of 44.2 ml·kg-1·min-1. The lactate
threshold presented corresponded to a percentage of 89.6% of the maximum
heart rate and 82.4% of the VO2 peak. |
|
| AUTHORS BIOGRAPHY | |
Jacob S. MICHAEL Employment: PhD student, Faculty of Health Sciences, Sydney University, Australia. Degree: BappSc. Research interest: Physiology and biomechanics of kayaking. E-mail: jmic3063@mail.usyd.edu.au |
![]() |
Kieron B. ROONEY Employment: Lecturer, Exercise Health and Performance Research Group, University of Sydney, Australia. Degree: PhD. Research interest: Biochemistry, exercise physiology, creatine supplementation, insulin secretion and carbohydrate metabolism. E-mail: K.Rooney@fhs.usyd.edu.au |
![]() |
Richard SMITH Employment: Lecturer, Exercise Health and Performance Research Group, University of Sydney, Australia. Degree: PhD. Research interest: Water sport biomechanics, footwear. E-mail: R.Smith@usyd.edu.au |
![]() |