|
JOURNAL
OF
SPORTS SCIENCE &
MEDICINE
|
|
Research
article
|
THE EFFECTS OF COLD WHIRLPOOL ON POWER, SPEED, AGILITY, AND RANGE OF MOTION |
|||||||||
Stephen M. Patterson1 |
|||||||||
1Department of Exercise and Sport Science, and 2Department of Mathematics, University of Wisconsin - La Crosse, La Crosse, USA |
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
© Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2008) 7, 387 - 394 Search Google Scholar for Citing Articles |
|||||||||
|
|
| ABSTRACT | ||||||||||||
| The purpose was to determine if cold whirlpool treatment decreases
functional performance equally regardless of gender. A secondary aim was
to determine if there is a gradual increase in functional performance across
time. Twenty-one college-aged subjects volunteered to participate in this
study and were required to perform four measures of functional performance
including: counter movement vertical jump, T-test, 36.58-meter dash (40-yard),
and active range of motion of the ankle. Participants were treated with
a 20 minute, 10 degree Celsius cold whirlpool following the pre-test of
a given functional performance measure. Participants demonstrated significant
decreases in counter movement vertical jump, T-test, and 40-yard dash performance
immediately following treatment. Vertical jump performance remained impaired
for at least 32 minutes. While both the T-test and 40-yard dash were affected
for 7 and 22 minutes post- treatment, respectively. Participants also demonstrated
significant decreases in peak power and average power immediately after
and for 32 minutes post-treatment. Dorsiflexion was significantly decreased
7 and 12 minutes following treatment. There were no differences for plantar
flexion, inversion, or eversion. These data suggest functional performance
was affected immediately following and for up to 32 minutes after cold whirlpool
treatment. It was also evident that there is a gradual performance increase
for each measure of functional performance across time. Therefore, the consequences
should be carefully considered before returning athletes to activity following
cold whirlpool treatment.
Key words: Functional performance, cryotherapy, therapeutic modalities. |
|
| INTRODUCTION | ||||||||||||
| In the sports medicine setting, the use of cryotherapy is a widely
accepted therapeutic modality. While the benefits of cryotherapy are agreed
upon by many, there may be certain physiological changes which hinder performance.
Several studies have aimed to establish if the use of cryotherapy adversely
affects various measures which play a role in functional performance. These
include proprioception (Ingersoll et al., 1992;
LaRiviere and Osternig, 1994),
power (Ferretti et al., 1992),
strength (Mattacola and Perrin, 1993),
speed (Bergh and Ekblom, 1979;
Richendollar et al., 2006),
and agility (Cross et al., 1996;
Evans et al., 1995).
Cryotherapy, has been shown to have no effect on joint position sense or
sensory perception and therefore, proprioception appears to be unaffected
by the use of cold in the treatment of athletic injuries (Ingersoll et al.,
1992;
LaRiviere and Osternig, 1994).
Power and isokinetic strength, both appear to be decreased immediately following
the application of various cryotherapeutic modalities (Ferretti et al.,
1992;
Hatzel and Kaminski, 2000;
Mattacola and Perrin, 1993;
Ruiz et al., 1993).
However, most research pertaining to strength changes and cryotherapy has
primarily been limited to isometric contractions (Johnson and Bahamonde,
1996;
Mattacola and Perrin, 1993).
The results of these studies, unfortunately, are equivocal and strength
has been shown to increase (Mattacola and Perrin, 1993)
and decrease (Johnson and Bahamonde, 1996).
Speed and agility, both which are essential to athletic participation have
not been studied in great detail (Bergh and Ekblom, 1979;
Cross et al., 1996;
Evans et al., 1995;
Richendollar et al., 2006).
Limited studies, however, have demonstrated that following a cold treatment
in which muscle was directly cooled, functional performance may be impaired
(Cross et al., 1996).
Conversely, a cold treatment that only cools a joint may not adversely alter
agility (Evans et al., 1995).
Previous literature examining functional performance and cryotherapy has primarily been limited to the effects of functional performance immediately, within minutes following cold application (Cross et al., 1996; Evans et al., 1995). While this is important, past research fails to take into account the effects of tissue re-warming and the subsequent effect on functional performance. Assuming tissue re-warming occurs, the immediate affects of the cold treatment should subside and a gradual increase in performance may occur. Often cryotherapy is used to offset the pain, swelling, and dysfunction associated with minor athletic trauma with athletes returning to activity shortly after treatment. Since many forms of cryotherapy are used by sports medicine clinicians before or during athletic participation, a more knowledgeable understanding of the immediate and delayed effects of cryotherapy on functional performance is necessary. Specifically, the cold whirlpool has become an increasingly popular modality due to its ability to treat larger areas, its analgesic massaging effect, the integration of therapeutic exercises, as well as all the benefits of cold. Therefore, our purpose was to investigate the effects of a cold whirlpool treatment on various measures of functional performance at subsequent time intervals following cold whirlpool treatment. |
|
| METHODS | ||||||||||||
|
This
research experiment used a repeated measures pretest-posttest design.
Twenty-one, apparently healthy, participants who were recruited by word
of mouth volunteered for this study (Table 1). Those who suffered a lower extremity injury in the
past six months were excluded from this study. Furthermore, participants
that indicated a contraindication to the use of cryotherapy (e.g. cold
allergy, Raynaud's phenomenon) or physical activity were excluded from
this study. Informed consent and health history questionnaire forms were
completed prior to participation and approval from the university's institutional
review board was also granted. Anaerobic
power Pavg
(W) = 41.4 * VJ(cm) + 31.2 *mass(kg) - 13.9 * height(cm) + 431 Speed Agility Treatment |
|
| RESULTS | ||||||||||||
|
Anaerobic
power Speed Agility Active
range of motion |
|
| DISCUSSION | ||||||||||||
|
Our
results indicated that a 20 minute, 10°C cold whirlpool treatment applied
to the lower legs had an immediate and subsequent impairment on functional
performance. CMJ heights, peak power, and average power were impaired
for at least 32 minutes, thereby never reaching pre-test baseline levels.
Both the T-test and 40-yard dash times
were also impaired immediately after treatment and for at least 7 and
22 minutes following treatment, respectively. Dorsiflexion was decreased
7 and 12 minutes following cold whirlpool immersion, while plantar flexion,
inversion, and eversion appeared to be unaffected by cold whirlpool immersion.
|
|
| AUTHORS BIOGRAPHY | |
Stephen M. PATTERSON Employment: Associate Athletic Trainer at Saint Cloud State University. Degree: MSc. Research interests: The gender bias of ACL injuries and rehabilitation, lower extremity evaluation, cryotherapy and its effects on performance variables. E-mail: smpatterson@stcloudstat.edu |
![]() |
Brian E. UDERMANN Employment: Associate Professor in the Department of Exercise and Sports Science at the University of Wisconsin-La Crosse. Degree: PhD. Research interests: Musculoskeletal Assessments of the Low Back. E-mail: udermann.bria@uwlax.edu |
![]() |
Scott T. DOBERSTEIN Employment: Head athletic trainer and senior lecturer in the department of Sports Science at the university of Wisconsin-La Crosse. Degree: MSc. Research interests: Lower extremity injuries, therapeutic modalities, clinical evaluation techniques. E-mail: doberste.scot@uwlax.edu |
![]() |
David M. REINEKE Employment: Associate Professor of Statistics at the University of Wisconsin - La Crosse. Degree: PhD. Research interests: Applied statistics. E-mail: Reineke.davi@uwlax.edu |
![]() |