|
JOURNAL
OF
SPORTS SCIENCE &
MEDICINE
|
|
Research
article
|
A MULTI-STAGE ULTRA-ENDURANCE RUN OVER 1,200 KM LEADS TO A CONTINUOUS ACCUMULATION OF TOTAL BODY WATER |
|||||||||
Beat Knechtle1,2 |
|||||||||
1Gesundheitszentrum St. Gallen, St. Gallen, Switzerland, 2Department of General Practice, University of Zürich, Zürich, Switzerland, 3Deutschlandlauf, Horb-Nordstetten, Germany, 4Division of Biophysical Chemistry, Biozentrum, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland |
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
© Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2008) 7, 357 - 364 Search Google Scholar for Citing Articles |
|||||||||
|
|
| ABSTRACT | |||||||||||||
| We determined whether ultra-runners in a multi-stage ultra- endurance
run lose body mass, fat mass, skeletal muscle mass or total body water in
a descriptive field study at the 'Deutschlandlauf' 2007 a 1,200 km run within
17 consecutive days with 10 male non-professional Caucasian ultra-runners
(mean ± SD, 43.8 ± 6.2 years, 73.8 ± 6.0 kg body mass, 1.77 ± 0.05 m body
height, BMI 23.3 ± 1.8 kg·m-2). Body mass, fat mass, skeletal muscle mass,
lean body mass and percent total body water were determined using bioelectrical
impedance analysis and the anthropometric method before the race and after
each stage. In addition, urinary specific gravity was measured in order
to quantify hydration status. Fat mass (bioelectrical impedance analysis)
decreased by 3.9 kg (p < 0.05), skeletal muscle mass (anthropometric
method) decreased by 2.0 kg (p < 0.05) whereas percent total body water
increased by 6.1 % (p < 0.05) by the end of the race. Ultra-runners in
a multi-stage ultra-endurance event over 1,200 km, with 17 consecutive stages,
showed a cumulative increase in percent total body water, a decrease in
skeletal muscle mass and a decrease in fat mass, depending upon the method
used. We presume that the eccentric component of running leads to damage
of skeletal muscle, leading to rhabdomyolysis, with impaired renal function.
Key words: Body fat - body mass - dehydration - skeletal muscle mass. |
|
| INTRODUCTION | |||||||||||||
| Running is one of the most popular endurance sport disciplines
and marathon running in particular has increased over recent years. Apart
from marathon running, ultra-marathon running is becoming more and more
attractive. Within running there is a difference between ultra-distance
events, of more than the marathon distance, and multi-day runs. Abundant
literature is available about single ultra-distance running, but little
is known about the effects on the human body after running hundreds or even
thousands of kilometres within a few days or weeks (Knechtle and Kohler,
2007;
Raschka and Plath, 1992;
Raschka et al., 1991).
In a run over 1,000 km within 20 days, all skin-fold thicknesses and fat mass showed a tendency to decrease; only the thigh skin-fold initially increased, and then further decreased from the 4th day onwards in the study reported by Raschka and Plath, 1992. In a further study (Raschka et al., 1991) on a run over the same distance, muscle mass initially decreased from 59.3 to 58.9 kg on day 11 and increased at the end of the run to 59.9 kg, which was higher than the muscle mass at the start. As a result of the initially decreased muscle mass, all muscle circumferences were reduced with the exception of the thigh (Raschka et al., 1991). The authors concluded that high mechanical stresses experienced by the lower extremities had a positive effect on skeletal muscle mass. In contrast to these findings, in a recent investigation during a multi-stage ultra-endurance run over 338 km in 5 days, skeletal muscle mass was significantly reduced after the first day and then remained stable (Knechtle and Kohler, 2007). The difference between these findings could be the longer performance (1,000 versus 338 km) with different exercise intensities since in both races, anthropometric techniques were used to estimate muscle mass. The aim of the present investigation was to study the effects of a multi-stage ultra-endurance run of 1,200 km in 17 days, where athletes had to run on average more than 70 km per day. In addition to the anthropometrical measurements used in the shorter multi-day run (Knechtle and Kohler, 2007), the change of total body water, percent body fat and lean body mass using bioelectrical impedance analysis was determined. Urinary specific gravity was additionally measured after every stage in order to determine hydration status. The hypothesis was to investigate any change in body mass, skeletal muscle mass and/or fat mass. |
|
| METHODS | |||||||||||||
|
Subjects The
race Measurements
and calculations SM
= Ht x (0.00744 x CAG2 0.00088 x CTG2 + 0.00441 x CCG2) + 2.4 x sex -
0.048 x age + race + 7.8 %BF = 0.465 0.180(Σ7SF) - 0.0002406(Σ7SF)2 0.0661(age) where Σ7SF = sum of skin-fold thickness of chest, midaxillary, triceps, subscapular, abdomen, suprailiac and thigh mean, according to Ball et al., 2004. Circumference
of the upper arm, thigh and calf were measured at the largest circumference
of the limb to the nearest 0.1 cm. At the thigh, circumference was determined
20 cm above the upper pole of the patella. Skin-fold thicknesses of chest,
midaxillary (vertical), triceps, subscapular, abdominal (vertical), suprailiac
(at anterior axillary), thigh and calf were measured with a skin- fold
calliper (GPM-Hautfaltenmessgerät, Siber & Hegner, Zurich, Switzerland)
to the nearest 0.2 cm at the right side, according to Lee et al., 2000.
Every measurement using anthropometric techniques was taken by the same
person 3 times, and the mean value used for calculation. % TBW, LBM and
% BF were measured with the BIA balance (Tanita BC- 545). Impedance measurements
were performed with the athletes standing in an upright position, barefoot
in running wear, on foot-electrodes on the platform of the instrument,
with the legs and thighs not touching, and the arms not touching the torso.
The subjects stood on the 4 foot- electrodes: 2 oval-shaped and 2 heel-shaped
electrodes, and gripped the 2 palm-and-thumb electrodes in order to yield
2 thumb- and 2 palm-electrodes. The skin and the electrodes were pre-cleaned
and dried. USG was determined with the Combur10 Test® (Roche Diagnostics,
Mannheim, Germany). The test detects the ion concentration of urine. In
the presence of cations, protons are released by a complexing agent and
produce a colour change in the indicator bromthymol from blue via blue-green
to yellow. |
|
| RESULTS | |
|
BM, FM determined using anthropometric techniques (Ant), FM and SM using BIA, did not change after the first stage (Figures 1 and 2). However, SM (Ant) decreased by 2.0 kg and FM (BIA) reduced by 3.9 kg (p < 0.05) during the race (Figure 1); in comparison FM (Ant) did not change (Figure 2). % TBW did not change after the first stage, however, it increased significantly (p < 0.05) during the race (Figure 1). Calculated TBW increased by 2.3 Litres. USG, prerace, was 1.013 ± 0.007 and increased to 1.023 ± 0. 005 at day 6. Then USG values dropped slowly to recover to a second peak at day 13 (1.021 ± 0.005). However, the changes did not reach statistical significance (Figure 3). |
| DISCUSSION | |||||||||||||
|
The main finding of this field study was that FM - depending upon the method used (anthropometry versus BIA) - as well as SM (determined using anthropometric techniques) decreased during the run. In addition, % TBW increased. Interestingly, BM and USG showed no change. Decrease
of body mass Protein
catabolism with hypoproteinemic edema? Increased
protein synthesis with increased plasma volume? Change
of plasma volume due to hormonal changes? Dehydration
and impaired renal function due to skeletal muscle damage in running The
problem of timing of determination of body mass after endurance performance What
was the importance of stage 11? Nutrient
and energy intake |
|
| CONCLUSION | |||||||||||||
| Ultra-runners in a multi-stage ultra-endurance run over 1,200 km in 17 stages suffered a decrease of skeletal muscle mass and fat mass - when determined with bioelectrical impedance analysis - as well as an increase of total body water. We presume that the continuous eccentric exercise leads to damage of skeletal muscle, a continuous rhabdomyolysis and an impairment of renal function, thus leading to a continuous accumulation of body water. In future studies, the continuous and increasing damage of skeletal muscle with associated impairment of renal function should be documented with indirect biochemical parameters such as metabolites in blood and urine. In a follow-up study the enzyme creatine kinase should be measured (CK) in order to provide evidence for the hypothesis of rhabdomyolysis. In addition, hormones of fluid and electrolyte metabolism should be measured to give / allow further insights in the regulation of water metabolism during ultra-endurance performance. With dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry the continuous decrease of skeletal muscle mass could be better determined. In future investigations, the performance level of the runners should be included as a potential factor to explain different results in some anthropometric parameters in ultra-endurance athletes. Additionally, in future studies in ultra-endurance performance, energy intake and energy expenditure should be directly quantified in order to investigate the relationship between an increased protein intake in the face of a reduced skeletal muscle mass. |
|
| AUTHORS BIOGRAPHY | |
Beat KNECHTLE Employment: Gesundheitszentrum St. Gallen and Department of General Practice, University of Zurich, Switzerland. Degree: MD. Research interests: Anthropometry and change of body composition in ultra-endurance. E-mail: beat.knechtle@hispeed.ch |
![]() |
Brida DUFF Employment: Nurse, Gesundheitszentrum St. Gallen, Switzerland. Research interests: Anthropometry and body composition in ultra-endurance. E-mail: bridaduff@hotmail.com |
![]() |
Ingo SCHULZE Employment: Race director Deutschlandlauf and Trans-Europe-Foot-Race, Deutschlandlauf, Germany. Research interests:Nutrition, anthropometry and body composition in ultra-endurance. E-mail: ultralauf@ischulze.de |
![]() |
Götz KOHLER Employment: Biozentrum, University of Basel, Switzerland. Degree: PhD. Research interests: Muscle metabolism, cycling pedalling rate. E-mail: goetz.kohler@unibas.ch |
![]() |