|
JOURNAL
OF
SPORTS SCIENCE &
MEDICINE
|
|
Research
article
|
EFFECT OF AN ON-SIGHT LEAD ON THE PHYSIOLOGICAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL RESPONSES TO ROCK CLIMBING |
|||||||||
Nick Draper1 ,
Glenys A. Jones2, Simon Fryer2,
Chris Hodgson2 and Gavin Blackwell1 |
|||||||||
1School of Sciences and Physical Education, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, Canterbury, NZ 2Centre for Sports Science and Medicine, University of Chichester, Chichester, West Sussex, UK |
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
© Journal of Sports Science and Medicine (2008) 7, 492 - 498 Search Google Scholar for Citing Articles |
|||||||||
|
|
| ABSTRACT | ||||||||||||
| Rock climbing is a multi-discipline activity that encompasses
forms such as bouldering, top roping and lead climbing on natural and artificial
climbing surfaces. A major focus of research has been explanation of physiological
functioning. More recent research indicates that anxiety levels are elevated
for less experienced climbers and in response to lead climbing ascents.
Research regarding the demands of rock climbing has placed a lesser focus
on the interaction of psychological and physiological factors. The objective
of this study was to examine the effects of an on-sight lead climb on the
physiological and psychological demands of the climb in comparison with
a subsequent lead climb. Ten intermediate level climbers volunteered to
complete the two climbing trials, on-sight lead climb (OSLC) and second
lead climb (LC2). Climb time, lactate concentrations (baseline, pre climb,
post climb and 15 min post climb), heart rate (1 min pre climb, peak HR,
1 min post climb and average climb across the duration of the climb), oxygen
consumption, pre climb anxiety (CSAI-2R) were assessed for each climber
for both trials. Results indicated that there were significant differences
in self reported pre climb somatic and cognitive anxiety (t(9) = 2.79, p
= 0.01, t(9) = 1.94, p = 0.043), climb time (t(9) = 3.07, p = 0.0052) and
post climb lactate concentrations between the climbs (t(9) = 2.58, p = 0.015).
These results indicate that psychological as well as physiological stress
impact upon the response to rock climbing. The higher anxiety levels associated
with an OSLC are likely to have influenced the physiological responses for
the intermediate climbers in this study. Future studies should take into
account the type of climbing, experience of climbers and the number of ascents
as well as taking into account the interaction between physiological and
psychological factors in response to rock climbing.
Key words: Rock climbing, on-sight lead, lactate concentration, oxygen consumption. |
|
| INTRODUCTION | ||||||||||||
|
As an increasingly popular adventure sport, there has been a growing
research interest regarding the physiological demands of rock climbing.
The period from 1990 to 2006 saw a 37,514 person increase in membership
of the British Mountaineering Council (BMC - the National Governing Body
for rock climbing in the UK). There are now over 63,000 UK members of
the BMC and more than 150,000 active climbers in the UK alone (BMC, 2004;
2006).
|
|
| METHODS | ||||||||||||
|
Participants Experimental
Overview Procedures Blood
analysis
Statistical
analysis |
|
| RESULTS | ||||||||||||
|
The
Kolomogorov-Smirnov test results indicated normality of distribution for
all variables within the study. Descriptive data for climb time, VO2,
average (across the length of the climb) HR and CSAI-2R are displayed
in Table 2. The results for mean
VO2, and average HR were very similar, with differences of
less than 1 mL.kg-1.min-1 and 2 bts. min-1, despite
the 32 s mean difference in climb time for the two climbs. Results indicated
that the OSLC took longer to complete for all ten participants in the
study. Paired samples t-tests for each of these variables indicated there
were non-significant differences between the climbs for mean VO2and
average HR across the climb. There was, however, a significant difference
between the climb times (t(9) = 3.07, p = 0.0052). |
|
| DISCUSSION | ||||||||||||
|
The focus
of this study was an investigation of the effects of prior knowledge of
a climb upon the physiological and psychological responses pre, during
and post performance. The results indicate that mean climb time, VO2,
and average HR were higher for the OSLC (Table
1). The mean climb time for LC2 were very similar to those reported
by Draper et al., 2008b
which were on the same height of climb (9.38 m). The mean climb time for
the OSLC was significantly slower (p = 0.0052) and this can be most likely
attributed to the additional time required for route planning during a
first ascent. The mean VO2 of approximately 25 mL.kg-1.min-1
for the two conditions in this study was similar to that obtained in previous
research and may indicate that the oxygen consumption plateau suggested
by Watts, 2004
for climbs between 80 - 100 s may extend to climbs of up to 240 seconds
or more. |
|
| AUTHORS BIOGRAPHY | |
Nick DRAPER Employment: Senior Lecturer, School of Sciences and Physical Education, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand. Degree: PhD, MA, BEd(Hons). Research interests: Adventure Physiology - physiological response to environmental and exercise demands in adventure sports. Exercise science pedagogy. E-mail: nick.draper@canterbury.ac.nz |
![]() |
Glenys A. JONES Employment: Postgraduate Researcher in Metabolic Nutrition & Performance, University of Chichester, UK. Degree: BSc (Hons) Nutrition, MSc, SES Physiology. Research interests: The sources of and the effects of histidine containing dipeptides on performance and health. E-mail: GJONES2@chi.ac.uk |
![]() |
Simon FRYER Employment: Postgraduate Research at University of Chichester, UK and Lecturer at Southdowns College, UK. Degree: BA(Hons), MSc. Research interests: Developing the field of knowledge surrounding physiological performance and adaptation in extreme environments. Specific interests lie in the physiological and psychophysiological effects of altitude, mountaineering and rock climbing. E-mail: sfryer@southdowns.ac.uk |
![]() |
Chris HODGSON Employment: Senior Lecturer, University of Chichester, UK. Degree: BA(Hons), MSc. Research interests: Learning and performing in complex and challenging environments and how we can improve performance during environmentally induced stress. E-mail: C.Hodgson@chi.ac.uk |
![]() |
Gavin BLACKWELL Employment: Post-graduate student/Sports Science Technician, University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand. Degree: BSc. Research interests: Physiological assessment of exercise. E-mail: gavin.blackwell@canterbury.ac.nz |
![]() |