|
The
effects of resistance training on satellite cells were well studied but
there are a few studies about the effects of endurance training on satellite
cells. A previous study in human shows that the amplitude of the increase
in satellite cell number following an high intensity interval training
is within the same range as that reported in response to strength training
(Charifi et al., 2003).
Verney et al., 2008
also demonstrat the effects of 14 weeks of concurrent lower body endurance
and upper body resistance training on vastus lateralis and deltoid muscles
of elderly men and they show that satellite cell pool increases similarly
in both muscles, mainly in type II muscle fibers. It is very interesting
that satellite cells can respond to a training intensity much lower than
that used in resistance training because the power developed at VO2peak
is about 25% of the maximal power (Charifi et al., 2003;
Kadi et al., 2005).
However, these human studies investigated effects of high intensity interval
training to elderly men and the training intensity seems to have been
relatively high as an endurance training. In addition, fiber area of vastus
lateralis muscle which was mainly recruited by the endurance training
was significantly increased although aerobic capacity was also increased.
The purpose of this study was to clarify the effect of low-intensity,
long-duration exercise training on satellite cells in skeletal muscle
without associated muscle hypertrophy. As expected, the voluntary running
model enhanced citrate synthase activity but caused no changes in absolute
muscle mass or fiber size. The main finding was that voluntary running
significantly increased the number of satellite cells in the plantaris
muscle and that the increase in satellite cells was positively correlated
with the distance run (r = 0.61, p < 0.05). To our knowledge, this
is the first study to show an increase in the number of satellite cells
in rat skeletal muscle with voluntary running training without muscle
hypertrophy.
Increase
in satellite cells with voluntary wheel running
Many studies have shown increases in the number of satellite cells following
resistance training that leads to muscle hypertrophy (Kadi and Thornell,
2000;
Kadi et al., 2004;
Mackey et al., 2007;
Roth et al., 2001).
An increase in the number of satellite cells is reported to be associated
with fibroblast growth factor (Sheehan and Allen, 1999)
and insulin-like growth factor-I (IGF-I) (Charge and Rudnicki, 2004).
As resistance training increases IGF-I secretion, it also promotes satellite
cell proliferation and fusion and causes muscle hypertrophy. However,
IGF-I secretion is regulated mainly by serum testosterone and growth hormone,
which are determined more by exercise intensity than exercise volume (Hawke,
2005).
The purpose of prolonged endurance training, as in our study, is not to
cause muscle hypertrophy, but rather to increase the oxidative capacity.
Indeed, previous studies have demonstrated that voluntary wheel running
did not affect the plantaris muscle mass or fiber size (Ishihara et al.,
1998;
Rodnick et al., 1989).
In our study, the absolute muscle weight and mean muscle fiber area determined
using a simple method did not differ significantly between the control
and training groups, although the citrate synthase activity was increased
in the training group. Therefore, the exercise intensity of voluntary
wheel running training in this study was insufficient to induce muscle
hypertrophy. Ishihara et al., 1998
also demonstrated that 8 weeks of voluntary running on an unloaded wheel
did not increase the weight or fiber area of the plantaris muscle regardless
of the distance run, whereas running on a wheel in the loaded condition
did. In our study, the running wheel was unloaded, and the results were
consistent with the previous study. Given that voluntary running does
not result in an increase in IGF-I mRNA expression in hind limb muscles
(Matsakas et al., 2004),
we speculate that the increase in the number of satellite cells observed
in this study was not associated with hypertrophy involving the hormonal
mechanisms observed in resistance training.
Verney et al., 2008
have recently suggested that satellite cell population in the human skeletal
muscle might be genetically determined. However, in our study model, the
same strain, gender and age of rats were obtained from a licensed laboratory
animal vender and they were randomly assigned to either a control or training
group. In addition, their voluntary running activities in the training
group were between about 2 and 9 km·day-1 and it was very similar
to previous studies and rats in the training group would not be especially
talented as high runners (Ishihara et al., 1998;
Rodnick et al., 1989).
Therefore, it is thought that there was no difference of genetic factors
between the two groups and that the involvement of genetic factor in the
regulation of satellite cell content could be ruled out in this study
model.
The activation of satellite cells may also involve exercise- induced localized
ultrastructural damage, segmental fiber damage, and the release of inflammatory
substances or growth factors (Kadi et al., 2005).
Myofiber damage leads to the release of nitric oxide, which mediates the
release of active hepatocyte growth factor from the heparin sulfate chains
on the extracellular matrix and surrounding myofibers (Hawke, 2005).
In the present study, it is not clear whether physical activity per se
or muscle injury induced by exercise training secondarily stimulated satellite
cell division; nevertheless, running may markedly stimulate satellite
cells.
For example, McCormick and Thomas, 1992
showed that 10 weeks of progressive treadmill running doubled the satellite
cell mitotic activity and doubled the number of damaged fibers in the
soleus muscle of rats. In addition, Umnova and Seene, 1991
reported that the number of satellite cells increased 2.5-fold with local
muscle damage after 6 weeks of treadmill training. It has been reported
that voluntary wheel running in the mouse causes eccentric contractions,
damaging the hind limb muscles (Werning et al., 1990).
Furthermore, regardless of strain of mice, hind limb muscles are damaged
and repaired with voluntary wheel running (Irintchev and Wernig, 1987).
Although we did not investigate whether the voluntary wheel running caused
muscle damage, we believe that it would have occurred, as in the previous
studies. Therefore, the muscle damage induced by daily voluntary running
may stimulate an increase in the number of satellite cells.
Changes
in domain size and endurance training
Although the fiber area did not differ between the control and training
groups in this study, voluntary wheel running significantly increased
the number of myonuclei. As a result, the myonuclear domain size was significantly
smaller in the training group. One possible explanation for the ability
of endurance training to induce an increase in the number of myonuclei
is related to a change in fiber type. The number of myonuclei is influenced
by fiber type: muscle fibers of slow muscle have smaller myonuclear domains
than those of fast muscle (Roy et al., 1999).
In the plantaris muscle of cats, slow fibers have 25 to 50% more myonuclei
in a longitudinal section and a smaller average myonuclear domain size
compared with fast fibers (Allen et al., 1995).
Voluntary wheel running is considered one of the most effective types
of exercise training to increase oxidative capacity in rodents (Rodnick
et al., 1989);
it can increase the percentage of fast-twitch oxidative glycolytic fibers
and decrease the percentage of fast-twitch glycolytic fibers in the rat
plantaris muscle (Ishihara et al., 1991).
Although we did not determine muscle fiber type in the plantaris muscle,
it is possible that the voluntary wheel running training in our study
transformed fast-twitch glycolytic muscle fibers into slow or oxidative
fibers, as in previous studies. Therefore, the increase in the number
of myonuclei with endurance training could be related to changes in muscle
fiber type and the concomitant increase in the oxidative capacity of fast
type fibers in the plantaris muscle. Alternatively, an increase in muscle
nuclei in the fast fibers may be a prerequisite for a fast-to- slow fiber
transition (Putman et al., 2000).
In addition, in this study, the percentage of satellite cells was positively
correlated with the distance run. Satellite cell activation occurs in
response to various protocols that enhance contractile activity. Putman
et al., 1999
showed that low-frequency electrical stimulation of fast-twitch muscles
in the rat led to a time- dependent increase in satellite cell content
and myonuclear density, although the experiment did not involve physiological
conditioning such as exercise training. Briefly, they showed that the
percentage of satellite cells increased from 3.8% in control muscle to
7.9, 11.5, and 13.8% in muscles stimulated for 5, 10, and 20 days, respectively,
with the transformation of existing fast fibers into slower fibers. In
our study, the percentage of satellite cells was positively correlated
with the distance run (r = 0.61, p < 0.05; Figure
3); the greater the total distance run or time spent exercising, the
greater the percentage increase in satellite cells. In addition, citrate
synthase activity was significantly higher in the training group, and
the increase was also a function of the distance run (r = 0.62, p <
0.05; Figure 2). Combined, these results indicate
a relationship between an increase in satellite cell number and amount
of exercise or muscular oxidative capacity. However, we did not determine
muscle fiber types and regional differences (e.g. distal, middle, or proximal)
in the plantaris muscle and did not analyze a slow type of muscle like
the soleus muscle. Further investigation is required to elucidate the
muscle fiber type and region specific adaptation of satellite cells with
endurance training.
New myonuclei arise by the incorporation of proliferating satellite cells
to maintain the myonuclear domain size, and an increase in the number
of myonuclei generally occurs with increased muscle fiber area (Kadi and
Thornell, 2000).
Resistance training was shown to increase the muscle fiber area, yet the
number of myonuclei was unchanged (Hikida et al., 1998;
Kadi et al., 2004).
Kadi et al., 2004
explained that until a certain limit of hypertrophy is reached, an increase
in the area of muscle fibers could occur without the addition of new myonuclei.
If endurance training were to result in the opposite adaptation to the
phenomenon seen in resistance training, it may be possible that the satellite
cells and myonuclei change first. Further investigation is required to
elucidate the adaptation of satellite cells and myonuclear domain that
occurs with endurance training.
|
|