Supplementary Tables

Table S7. Summary statistics for the grading component “scientific correctness” Summary Statistics for Scientific Correctness.

Question Number		Mean	Median	Interquartile Range	Minimum	Maximum
1	ChatGPT	8.26	8	1.0	5	10
1	PT	5.43	6	4.0	1	10
2	ChatGPT	8.04	8	2.0	4	10
2	PT	5.22	5	2.5	2	10
3	ChatGPT	7.26	8	1.0	1	10
3	PT	6.33	7	3.0	1	10
4	ChatGPT	7.85	8	2.0	6	10
4	PT	7.89	8	2.0	4	10
5	ChatGPT	8.07	8	1.5	2	10
5	PT	7.85	8	2.0	2	10
6	ChatGPT	7.81	8	2.0	5	10
6	PT	7.63	8	2.0	2	10
7	ChatGPT	7.89	8	2.0	4	10
7	PT	5.93	6	3.0	1	10
8	ChatGPT	7.59	8	2.0	4	10
8	PT	6.19	7	3.0	0	10
9	ChatGPT	7.44	8	3.0	3	10
9	PT	6.85	7	2.5	0	10

Table S8. Summary statistics for the grading component “ comprehensibility” Summary Statistics for Comprehensibility.

Question Number		Mean	Median	Interquartile Range	Minimum	Maximum
1	ChatGPT	7.67	8	2.0	3	10
1	PT	7.81	8	2.0	4	10
2	ChatGPT	8.63	9	1.5	5	10
2	PT	6.15	6	3.0	1	10
3	ChatGPT	8.48	9	2.0	5	10
3	PT	7.37	8	3.0	3	10
4	ChatGPT	7.81	8	2.0	3	10
4	PT	7.33	7	1.5	3	10
5	ChatGPT	8.44	8	1.5	5	10
5	PT	8.22	8	2.0	6	10
6	ChatGPT	8.37	8	1.0	6	10
6	PT	7.11	7	1.5	3	10
7	ChatGPT	8.52	9	1.0	5	10
7	PT	6.70	6	2.5	3	10
8	ChatGPT	8.26	8	1.0	5	10
8	PT	7.26	7	2.0	4	10
9	ChatGPT	8.04	8	2.0	4	10
9	PT	7.30	7	3.0	4	10

Table S9. Summary statistics for the grading component “actionability” Summary Statistics for Actionability.

Question Number		Mean	Median	Interquartile Range	Minimum	Maximum
1	ChatGPT	6.78	7	4.00	2	10
1	PT	6.83	7	2.50	3	10
2	ChatGPT	7.22	7	3.00	2	10
2	PT	5.11	5	3.50	1	10
3	ChatGPT	8.20	8	1.75	6	10
3	PT	7.33	8	1.00	3	10
4	ChatGPT	6.52	7	1.50	0	10
4	PT	7.11	7	2.00	2	10
5	ChatGPT	7.59	8	1.50	3	10
5	PT	7.26	8	1.00	3	9
6	ChatGPT	7.78	8	2.00	2	10
6	PT	6.48	7	2.50	2	10
7	ChatGPT	8.04	8	1.50	3	10
7	PT	6.44	7	3.00	2	10
8	ChatGPT	7.33	7	3.00	3	10
8	PT	6.52	7	3.00	0	10
9	ChatGPT	7.15	7	3.00	3	10
9	PT	6.78	7	2.50	2	10