Table 6. The main results of the studies that examined the effects of protein supplementation on recovery kinetics in team sports. |
Study |
Type of exercise test |
Supplementation |
Muscle damage markers |
Inflammatory markers /oxidative markers |
Muscle soreness |
Performance markers |
Arent et al., 2010 |
Graded maximal treadmill test to exhaustion |
Resurgex Plus® vs isocaloric placebo |
Resurgex < PLA: ↑ CK |
Resurgex < PLA: ↑ 8-isoprostane & LPO |
------ |
Resurgex = PLA VO2max, VLT & time-to-exhaustion |
Betts et al., 2009 |
90 min of high-intensity intermittent shuttle-running |
CHO vs CHO+PRO |
CHO + WP = CHO: ↑ CK CHO + WP = CHO: ↑ Myoglobin CHO + WP = CHO: ↑ LDH |
CHO + WP = CHO: ↑ IL-6 CHO + WP = CHO: ↑ IL-10 CHO + WP = CHO: ↑ IL-1 receptor antagonist CHO + WP = CHO: ↑ CRP |
CHO+WP = CHO |
CHO + WP = CHO: Peak isometric force |
Cockburn et al., 2013 |
Unilateral knee flexions (6 sets x 10 reps, 1.05 rad/s-1, 90-s rest) on isokinetic dynamometer |
Semi-skimmed milk vs water |
SSM = Water: CK SSM = Water: Myoglobin |
------ |
SSM = Water |
SSM = Water: CM jump height SSM = Water: Reactive strength SSM < Water (tendency): ↑10-m & 15-m sprint time |
Gentle et al., 2014 |
87-min basketball game stimulation test |
CHO meal vs CHO+PRO meal |
CHO+PRO < CHO: ↑ CK |
------ |
CHO+PRO =CHO |
CHO+PRO > CHO: Free throw success CHO+PRO < CHO (tendency): Mean sprint time CHO+PRO = CHO: Jump height |
Gilson et al., 2010 |
4-day soccer training period, with increased training duration |
CHO vs Low-fat chocolate milk |
LCM = CHO : Myoglobin, LCM < CHO: ↑ CK (at 4d) |
------ |
LCM = CHO |
LCM = CHO T-drill, Vertical jump, isometric quadriceps force (MVC) & fatigue ratings |
Gunnarsson et al., 2013 |
A competitive soccer match |
Normal diet vs high carbohydrate-high protein diet |
WP + CHO > NDiet: ↑ CK (at 24h) WP + CHO < NDiet: ↑ Myoglobin |
------ |
------ |
------ |
Highton et al., 2013 |
Modified LIST |
CHO vs CHO+PRO |
------ |
------ |
------ |
WP + CHO = CHO: Distance covered WP + CHO = CHO: Maximal speed WP + CHO < CHO: ↑ Average speed |
Naclerio et al., 2014 |
90-min Intermittent repeated sprint test |
PLA vs CHO vs CHO+PRO multi-ingredient |
WPCM < CHO & PL: ↑ CK (at 24h) WPCM (tendency) & CHO < PL: ↑ myoglobin (at 1h) |
WPCM = CHO = PL: ↑ IL-6 |
------ |
WPCM = CHO = PL: Total sprint time WPCM = CHO = PL: 15-m sprint time |
Naclerio et al., 2015 |
90-min IRS test |
PLA vs CHO vs CHO+PRO multi-ingredient |
WPCM = CHO = PL: ↑ CK (at 24h) WPCM & CHO < PL: ↑ myoglobin (at 1h) |
WPCM = CHO = PL: ↑ IL-6 CHO < WPCM & PL: ↑ Neutrophil CHO < WPCM & PL: ↑ Monocyte WPCM = CHO = PL: Lymphocytes |
------ |
WPCM = CHO = PL: Total sprint time WPCM = CHO = PL: Time IRS+15-m sprint WPCM < CHO & PL: Perception of fatigue |
Poulios et al., 2018 |
Two-trial (2 weeks), 2 soccer matches & 4 practices/week |
Milk Protein Smooth (PRO) vs isoenergetic placebo (maltodextrin) |
PRO=PL: ↑ CK PRO=PLA: ↑WBC(Post G1-Post G2) PRO=PL: ↑Granulocyte (Post G1-Post G2) |
PRO=PL: ↑TBARS (G1-D2,G2-D1), PL: ↑TBARS(G1-D1, G1-D3,G2-D2), PRO=PL: ↑PC(G1-D1, G1-D2, G1-D3, G2-D1), PL: ↑PC(G2-D3) PRO=PL ↓GSH(G1-D1, G1-D2, G1-D3), PRO>PL :↑GSH(G2-D1), PRO=PL: ↑TAC |
PRO=PL: ↑DOMS (G1-D1, G1-D2, G1-D3, G2-D1, G2-D2, G2-D3) |
PRO=PL: ↑10-m sprint, ↑30-m sprint(G1-D1, G1-D2, G1-D3, G2-D1, G2-D2, G2-D3), PRO=PLA:↓CMJ(G1-D1, G1-D2, G1-D3, G2-D1, G2-D2, G2-D3) PRO<PL: ↓KF eccentric strength(4h post G2), PRO<PL: ↓KE concentric strength, PRO<PL: ↓High-intensity running(G2 75–90 min vs. 0–15 min), PL: ↓HR, ↓TD |
|
PL, placebo; LPO, lipid hydroperoxides; VO2max, maximal oxygen consumption; VLT, velocity at lactate threshold; CHO, carbohydrates; PRO, protein; WP, whey protein; CK, creatine kinase activity; LDH, lactate dehydrogenase activity; IL, interleukin; CRP, C reactive protein; s, seconds; d, days; SSM, semi-skimmed milk; LCM, low-fat chocolate milk; CM, counter-movement; MVC, maximal voluntary contraction; NDiet, normal diet; ↑, increase; WPCM, whey protein carbohydrate multi-ingredient supplement; IRS, intermittent repeated sprint, G, Game; WBC, White blood cells; TBARS, thiobarbituric acid; PC, Protein carbonyls; GSH: Glutathione; KF, Knee Flexors; KE, Knee Extensors; TD, Total Distance. |
|