Journal of Sports Science and Medicine
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine
ISSN: 1303 - 2968   
Ios-APP Journal of Sports Science and Medicine
Androit-APP Journal of Sports Science and Medicine
Views
3867
Download
426
 
©Journal of Sports Science and Medicine ( 2018 ) 17 , 475 - 484

Review article
Efficacy of Exercise Therapy in Persons with Burnout. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
Oliver Ochentel , Crystal Humphrey, Klaus Pfeifer
Author Information
Department of Sport Science and Sport, Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany

Oliver Ochentel
✉ Department of Sport Science and Sport, Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany
Email: Oliver-Ochentel@gmx.de
Publish Date
Received: 24-04-2018
Accepted: 23-07-2018
Published (online): 14-08-2018
Share this article
 
ABSTRACT

An increasing amount of scientific work suggests positive effects of exercise-related interventions in patients with burnout. Exercise therapy could therefore be a useful intervention procedure in the treatment of burnout. The aim of this meta-analysis is to examine empirical findings for exercise therapy used to treat burnout in the occupational setting, including the variety of the application and variety of the exercise modality itself. Electronic databases (PubMed, Cochrane Library, Scopus, PubPsych, PsycInfo) were searched (January 2018) for randomized controlled trials reporting on exercise therapy intervention studies in persons with burnout. The burnout scores from the various measurement instruments as well as standardized mean differences (SMDs) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated and seen as the main outcomes and measures. Four out of six studies with a total sample of 248 participants could be used for meta-analysis. A statement on the combined effect size can only be made with caution due to the length of the confidence interval of [-0.41; 0.09]. With an I² value of 0%, no heterogeneity is present in this meta-analysis. Ultimately there was no clear difference found between intervention and control conditions. This paper does not support the widespread assumption that exercise therapy seems to be a successful means to alleviate burnout symptoms. However, the different types of physical activity and treatment modalities used in the included studies impede clear conclusions. Future studies should deal with the specific efficacy of different exercise modalities and their combination with further cognitive behavioural or mindfulness-based interventions.

Key words: physical activity, sports, adults, employment, occupational diseases, occupational health


           Key Points
  • First systematic review and meta-analysis of high quality studies (randomized controlled trials) analysing the state of research in the field of exercise therapy and burnout.
  • This study relativized the view of physical activity as an effective treatment.
  • This study highlights the lack of a stringent intervention concept and the understanding of the underlying mechanisms of action.

INTRODUCTION

Burnout syndrome in the occupational context has been a topic of concern for many years, affecting predominantly employed populations. The expression to be “burned-out” describes that a person is no longer able to “burn” or to be productive concerning their responsibilities, thus often their paid work. This requires that the affected persons assigned their work a high value. This may give people the impression that the person suffering from burnout has a high and therefore positive evaluation of his or her work effort and thus perceives his/her absence from work due to burnout not as a personal weakness. This “positive” use of the term burnout, in comparison to the concept of depressive disorder, which appears to be viewed significantly more negative, allows affected persons to expect less stigmatisation. The term burnout is therefore used more often than the term depression (Bahlmann et al., 2013; Berger et al., 2012). The International Classification of Diseases published by the World Health Organization has not taken up burnout as an independent disease (Krollner and Krollner, 2018). It lists, in an appendix, factors which can affect the wellbeing of individuals. In section Z 73, “problems associated with difficulties in coping with life” are listed. Burnout is considered to be a state of physical and mental exhaustion and is encoded in a diagnosis by the number Z 73.0 (Berger et al., 2012). Burnout is described by the German Society of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Psychosomatics and Neurology as an exhaustion and overload syndrome, which is a risk condition for a later psychiatric or physical illness (DGPPN, 2017). The burnout syndrome is mainly work related and occurs very often after a long period of high workload in a combination with perceived stressful working conditions (Naczenski et al., 2017). According to Maslach (Maslach, 2003), job burnout is defined by three dimensions: exhaustion, cynicism and a sense of inefficacy. Current reports show an increase of the prevalence of the burnout syndrome. For example, the AOK - one of Germany’s largest health insurance companies - published a report in 2014 focusing on work absenteeism (AOK, 2014). This report, written by the scientific Department (WidO) of the AOK, reported that between 2004 and 2013 there was an increase from 8.1 days to 87.6 days taken off work per 1000 insured persons of the AOK per year due to a medical inability to work classified under the diagnosis group Z 73. Associated with this increase in work absenteeism is of course the economic damage caused by losing time at work. The study by the Association of Psychotherapists in Germany (Bundespsychotherapeutenkammer, BPtK) on medically excused days off work from 2015 is based on data from nearly 85% of the statutorily insured individuals in Germany (BPtK, 2015). This study demonstrates that one in every 5 individuals who were medically excused from work for more than six weeks were diagnosed with a mental disease, such as burnout.

As burnout syndrome is not listed as an independent disease in the international classification of diseases, no clear diagnosis can be made based on explicit symptoms (ICD-10, 2017). In the literature, up to 100 single symptoms are mentioned as an indication of burnout (Ahola et al., 2005; Ekstedt et al., 2006; Kakiashvili et al., 2013; Kissling et al., 2014; Mohren et al., 2003; Peterson et al., 2008; Soares et al., 2007; Toker et al., 2012). The most frequently mentioned symptom in people with burnout is an excessive, persistent or even chronic physical as well as mental fatigue (Ahola et al., 2005; Appels and Mulder, 1989; Ekstedt et al., 2006; Kakiashvili et al., 2013; Mohren et al., 2003; Peterson et al., 2008; Soares et al., 2007; Toker et al., 2012). The condition of fatigue is considered a risk factor for a number of other diseases, like acute myocardial infarction, heart disease, common colds, flu, gastrointestinal disorders, infections (Honkonen et al., 2006; Mohren et al., 2003) and many more (Corrigan et al., 1995; Kakiashvili et al., 2013; Peterson et al., 2008; Toker et al., 2012). Some studies mention that burnout increases the occurrence of mental and physical exhaustion and of diseases such as cardiovascular disease, metabolic syndrome and depression (Ahola et al., 2005; Appels and Mulder, 1989; Bianchi et al., 2015; Kakiashvili et al., 2013; Kitaoka-Higashiguchi et al., 2009; Soares et al., 2007; Toker et al., 2012). Studies conclude that the effects of burnout and cardiovascular disease incidence are interdependent (Appels and Mulder, 1989; Honkonen et al., 2006; Kakiashvili et al., 2013; Shirom, 2005; Soares et al., 2007; Toker et al., 2012).

This wide range of possible comorbidities weakens affected persons, thereby intensifies the state of exhaustion, which further encourages the above-described relationships. Medicine is confronted with the problem that for burnout there is no consensus in neither diagnosis and treatment (Kakiashvili et al., 2013). Therapy programs are highly varied and often unclear. Treatments for burnout include encouraging a healthy diet, taking vitamin supplements, reducing alcohol consumption, naturopathic remedies, relaxation and mindfulness therapies, gymnastics, sports, massages, creative activities, spiritual and/or religious practices, adopting an ancient or far-eastern philosophy, animal therapy, spending time with friends etc. (Hillert, 2012a). Often, individuals with burnout are treated with regimens designed to treat depression (Ahola et al., 2005; Kakiashvili et al., 2013). In fact, the most common drugs administered in the treatment of burnout are antidepressants (Kakiashvili et al., 2013). However, the general treatment is also aimed at mitigating the personal or environmental causes of the syndrome like developing coping skills or creating organizational changes at work (Kakiashvili et al., 2013). The contents of the various therapies are often comprising three parts: general-strengthening, relaxation and occupational support (Hillert, 2012b) in form of decreasing job demands, increasing job control or the level of participation in decision making (Awa et al., 2010). The content, however, is usually not selected on the basis of empirical findings, but rather on subjective experiences of the clinic and the possibilities of the respective treatment location (Hillert, 2012b).

A series of studies suggest that physical activity based interventions are indicated in the treatment of burnout in an occupational setting. The positive impact of physical activity is often mentioned, but the reasons for that remain unexplained. The effect of physical activity on burnout may be ascribed to psychological changes. Physical activity can be seen as a behavioural distraction from stressful situations and hereby degrade the psychological impact of a situation (Altshuler and Ruble, 1989). Physical activity fosters the development of perceptions like mastery and self efficacy (Salmon, 2001) and has therefore the ability to diminish sensitivity to negative stimuli. Physiological changes by physical activity could reduce the persons’ physiological sensitivity to chronic stress (i.e. burnout) (Forcier et al., 2006). Employees could deal with stress at work without being physiologically overwhelmed by it. This could lead to faster physical recovery after a stressful experienced situation and therefore to a reduction of the risk of burnout (Altshuler and Ruble, 1989; Jackson and Dishman, 2006; Klaperski et al., 2014; Salmon, 2001). Fundamentally, it is well established that regular physical activity has a preventive effect on various diseases (Pedersen and Saltin, 2015). For example it has a demonstrated positive effect on coronary heart disease, cerebrovascular diseases, arterial hypertension, diabetes mellitus, stress anxiety disorders and depression (Pedersen and Saltin, 2015; Reimers and Brooks, 2003). In addition, aerobic physical activity reduces anxiety which appears in an occupational context (Salmon, 2001). There is a positive relation between physical activity and emotional well-being (Galper et al., 2006). Studies show that the preventive effect of physical exertion increases with the progression in exercise intensity and duration (Kushi et al, 1997; Lee and Skerrett, 2001; Thompson et al., 2003).

In one study, more than half of the participants with mild to moderately severe depression, experienced a reduction in depression symptoms after an exercise intervention based on running (Greist et al., 1979). Another study shows that exercise (running) has positive effects on work-related fatigue and employee well-being (de Vries et al., 2017). It has been shown that aerobic exercise groups and/or strength training groups, compared to a control group, lead to a clear reduction in the depression score (Pappas et al., 1990). Furthermore, McCann & Holmes show in their study that a group, which conducted exercise achieved significantly better treatment results than the group which performed relaxation exercises as well as the control group (McCann and Holmes, 1984). The authors report a marked antidepressant effect after the endurance training protocol, while the relaxation exercises remained ineffective. This finding is supported by Blumenthal, who assigns an effect to exercise that is comparable to that of adequate psychopharmacological treatment (Blumenthal et al, 1999). The sport or exercise type does not seem to be decisive for the effectiveness of the exercise-based therapy.

The existing literature describes the effects of physical activity on symptoms and comorbidities of burnout, however, the listed therapeutic content does not have a high-quality, empirical evidence-base. A rigorous evaluation of high-quality studies with regard to the efficacy of a treatment of burnout through physical activity is still lacking. A first attempt was made by the systematic review of Naczenski et al. (2017), who conclude that physical activity seems to be effective in reducing burnout. However, this conclusion is based on the findings of only two randomized controlled trials and eight nonrandomized, non-controlled intervention studies or prospective observational studies and therefore should be treated with caution. The aim of this review article is to review the current literature for studies with the highest quality standard (randomized controlled trials) regarding the efficacy of physical activity in patients with burnout. Data from the included studies will be summarized in a meta-analysis.

METHODS

Search strategy

We carried out a systematic literature search on articles published up to 23.01.2018 in the databases Pubmed (Medline), Cochrane Library, Scopus, Pubpsych and PsycInfo. We developed the search query based on the PICO model (Costa Santos et al., 2007). Depending on the capability of the databases MeSH-Terms were entered into the search. The Boolean operators “AND” and “OR” were used to combine the research terms. Over the course of the search query, several search combinations were examined in cooperation with an expert of the library of the University of Erlangen-Nürnberg and the respective sources were compared. An additional check was made by checking whether already known and relevant articles were found in the search results. Since the search for MeSH-Terms is not possible in the database Scopus, a modified search was carried out on that platform. In addition, the terms “motor activity” and / or “physical activity” were incorporated into the search query which resulted in partially different hit numbers. An additional query was made for the PsycInfo database. The complete search queries can be viewed in the appendix.

Selection criteria

Articles obtained by the systematic search were exported and saved into the Citavi literature management program. The query revealed a total list of 967 titles after removing the duplicates. A first selection was carried out independently by two reviewers (O.O. and C.H.) by reviewing titles and abstracts. The orientation was based on the following inclusion criteria: The articles must be written in English or German and physical activity must be included as a primary intervention in the study. Furthermore, studies had to include questionnaires measuring the level of burnout. Studies have been excluded, if the participants haven’t been in an employable age.

During this search, a ‘movement-based therapy’ or ‘exercise therapy’ was considered a planned physical activity intervention - developed with regard to a therapeutic treatment goal and prescribed to the patient (Pubmed, 2017). Physical activity is defined as “any bodily movement produced by skeletal muscles that results in energy expenditure” (Caspersen et al., 1985). The inclusion criteria were applied to the retrieved articles by both reviewers (O.O. & C.H.) individually, with consultation in cases of uncertainty. Articles were included in the subsequent full text analysis only if consensus between the reviewers was achieved. After the first selection the citation list consisted of 137 articles.

Both reviewers then screened the full text of those articles included by title and abstract to identify all relevant data and make a decision regarding final inclusion. The process of selection is shown in Figure 1.

In this case, all full texts were reviewed except for two. The two remaining sources (Gillmann et al., 2015; Stevens, 2011) could neither be obtained through the interlibrary loan of the university library, nor via direct E-mail contact with the authors.

Quality assessment

In a final selection, 6 articles were selected that were randomized and controlled in their design. Using a modified version of the 11-step PEDro scale (Macedo et al, 2010; Maher et al., 2003), the studies were assessed for possible risk of bias and overall quality (Table 1). The quality criterion “patient blinded” has been excluded, because patients can’t be blinded for exercise therapy, since they receive an “active” intervention. The first criterion provides a statement about the external validity and is not taken into account in the determination of the total value. If any given criterion is present it gets a point (and is noted with a check in the table). If the criterion was absent (marked with an x in the table) it was awarded 0 points. Therefore the maximum PEDro score in our modified version is 9.

Data extraction and statistical analysis

From all articles that met the review criteria, basic information was extracted into a standardised spreadsheet which included the sample size, the test method used, the type of physical activity performed, etc. (Table 2).

Only the raw data, collected directly after the end of the intervention or the intervention period were included. In the case of missing data in the published studies, the authors were contacted by email. After a period of three weeks, a reminder was sent. Only Marina Heiden replied and sent mean values and standard deviations, thus the study of Heiden et al. (Heiden et al., 2007) could be included into the meta-analysis. The studies by Mealer et al. (Mealer et al., 2014) and Stenlund et al. (Stenlund et al., 2009b) could not be considered in the meta-analysis, since a shift of the analysed parameters was reported through the median and the 0.25-0.75 quartiles. A calculation of the mean values and standard deviations, which is necessary for the calculation of the meta-analysis, was not possible here, since the necessary raw data was not available and the authors could not be contacted. In this way, 4 out of 6 studies were ultimately eligible for evaluation through meta-analysis. In order to investigate the general effect of exercise therapy on burnout syndrome, the data from the burnout measurement of the physical activity intervention groups was compared to the values of the control groups who hadn’t been exercising. In this meta-analysis, no analysis of subgroups could be carried out since too few studies were available. For the meta-analysis, the Review manager RevMan 5.3 (version 5.3.5) of the Cochrane Collaboration was used (The Cochrane Collaboration, 2014). All values used were steady and were entered in the form of mean value and standard deviation. The standardized difference of two mean values (SMD) with a 95% confidence interval (CI) and the random-effects model was used in the calculation to pool the data from different identified measurement tools. The heterogeneity was determined by ι² und χ² and a 95% CI. The I² statistic describes the percentage of variability in the estimated effect that is owing to heterogeneity rather than chance: 30% to 60% shows moderate heterogeneity, while greater than 60% represents substantial heterogeneity (Borenstein et al., 2009; Sterne et al., 2011).

RESULTS

Study characteristics

The selection process resulted in a list of 6 RCTs (Table 2) that were considered for a meta-analysis. On the basis of missing or only partly existing data, only the first 4 RCTs of Table 2 could be included in the meta-analysis. All available studies were published in the period from 2007 to 2017. The most important study features are summarized in Table 2. The sample size varied between 27 and 96, with all participants being of an employable age. There was large variability in the physical activity used as a therapy modality, from individual activities such as running, cycling, swimming, walking to group activities such as water gymnastics and qigong. In some cases also strength training and endurance activities on various ergometers (treadmill, wheel ergometer, rowing ergometer, stepper) were used. The frequency of therapy was reported in the spectrum between daily sessions and sessions every 14 days. The duration of exercise sessions varied from 30 minutes to 1 hour. The study intervention period ranged from 4 weeks to one year, with the majority of the studies having a treatment period of 10 to 12 weeks. Follow-up was performed in 1 of 6 studies with a follow-up period of 6 months. The dropout rates varied between 3 and 23 participants. All six studies assessed physical activity and burnout or the main dimension of burnout, the emotional exhaustion, with questionnaires.

Methodological quality

Before the assessment of the methodological quality, one has to be aware of our modification of the PEDro scale. Most studies are of moderate or rather good quality (PEDro value 5-7) and only one study had a very low risk of bias (PEDro value 8). As only randomized control trials (RCTs) were included in this meta-analysis, all studies fulfill the criterion of randomization. With one exception (Heiden et al., 2007), all studies also fulfill the criteria of intention-to-treat, the between-group comparison and the specification of point and scattering dimensions. A blinded group assignment of the participants took place in four studies (Mealer et al., 2014; Stenlund et al., 2009b). The study groups were comparable in the values of the initial measurements. In four out of six studies a central outcome could be measured in more than 85% of the originally participating subjects. None of the studies show a blinding of the subjects and therapists. In only one study, it is explicitly stated that the investigators were blinded to participant allocation (Mealer et al., 2014).

Effects of exercise therapy

For the meta-analytic comparison (exercise therapy vs. no exercise therapy), 4 RCTs with a total sample of 248 subjects could be considered. All of these studies report a significant (de Vries et al., 2017; Bretland and Thorsteinsson, 2015; Heiden et al., 2007) or non-significant (Eskilsson et al., 2017 ) reduction of the burnout or the emotional exhaustion score. A statement on the estimation of the combined effect size is only possible to a limited extent due to the size of the confidence interval [-0.41, 0.09]. The confidence intervals of the studies overlap, thus indicating homogeneity (Zlowodzki et al., 2007). In addition, an I² value of 0% (p= 0.41) is present, which is a reference for non-heterogeneity as well (Zlowodzki et al., 2007). In this regard, it can be concluded that the total variability across the results of the studies is attributable to chance (Weckmann et al., 2015). The fact that the confidence interval of the summary estimate cross the line of no effect, shows the absence of a significant difference between intervention and control condition (Weckmann et al., 2015) (Figure 2).

DISCUSSION

In this day and age, many employees suffer from burnout and therefore this syndrome constitutes a problem that has to be taken seriously. Therefore, great effort should be made to contain this syndrome. The positive effect of physical activity on burnout syndrome is indicated by several studies (Alarcon et al., 2009; Brenninkmeijer and van Yperen, 2003; Bretland and Thorsteinsson, 2015; Deligkaris et al., 2014; Ekstedt et al., 2006; Heiden et al., 2007; Higgins, 1986; Kristensen et al., 2005; Maslach and Jackson, 1986; Mealer et al., 2014, Stenlund et al., 2012; Schaufeli et al., 2009;). Given evidence and theory, we expected physical activity might be a helpful treatment for the reduction of burnout. The aim of this meta-analysis was the examination of this assumption on the basis of empirical analyses. In contrast to the study of Naczenski et al. (2017), we try to focus on solely high quality studies. From an initial selection of 24 studies, 6 studies - all randomized and controlled - were included in the study. Due to missing data, only four studies could be used for the meta-analysis. We recognise that a greater number of included studies would have strengthened the results of this meta-analysis. In partial defence of our approach, Valentin et al. argued that already a small number of two studies would be sufficient to perform a meta-analysis to overcome small sample sizes and to detect effects of interests (Walker et al., 2008). Therefore a statement on the effect of exercise therapy from the results of the meta-analysis is notable and consistent but needs to be treated with caution. This limitation is attributed primarily to factors which prevent the specification of an effect size. The length of the confidence intervals depends to a large extent on the sample size of the individual studies, however, less than 100 people participated in each single study. The width of the confidence interval [-0.41, 0.09] gives no clear indication of the effect size. Nevertheless, there was no heterogeneity (I²=0%) between the studies. Although three out of four studies report a significant difference between intervention and control conditions, there couldn’t be found an overall effect with the help of the meta-analysis. This result is not in line with the findings of Naczenski et al. (2017), who conclude that physical activity seems to be effective to reduce burnout. This difference might have several reasons. First of all the conclusions of the included studies have to be considered with caution. In this line de Vries et al. (2017) already mentions that their results, that participants with exercise intervention recovered more with respect to the outcomes emotional exhaustion and overall fatigue, are based on imbalances at baseline with regard to work characteristics and outcome measures. Further the findings of Bretland and Thorsteinsson (2015), who couldn’t find an association between exercise and fatigue, which is the primary outcome of de Vries et al. (2017), contradicts the above mentioned findings. Heiden et al. (2007) report only small differences between intervention and control group. Another reason might be the small number of included studies. Strikingly, the reported intervention modalities are quite heterogeneous (Table 3).

The variability in intervention modalities is even in the small number of included studies high. The participants were treated with cardiovascular training, strength training, cognitive behavioural training and / or a combination of some of the above mentioned. Regarding the long-term effects, only two studies (de Vries et al., 2017; Heiden et al., 2007) report follow-up measures, but the time intervals of these measures differ from six weeks (de Vries et al., 2017) to 6/12 months (Heiden et al., 2007). Based on this variability a comparison of the individual intervention measures is hardly possible. In addition, there is often no precise information on the duration and intensity of the interventions. In some cases, only minimum requirements for the participants are mentioned (Bretland and Thorsteinsson, 2015; Mealer et al., 2014). This lack of information causes possibly a reporting bias. The duration of the intervention also varies from 4 weeks to 12 weeks. The interventions were partly carried out in a supervised group setting and / or alone (de Vries et al., 2017; Bretland and Thorsteinsson, 2015; Heiden et al., 2007; Mealer et al., 2014; Stenlund et al., 2009b). Obviously a stringent intervention concept and the understanding of the underlying mechanisms of action is missing. The documentation of the intervention was partly self-reported (frequency of training sessions and weekly training hours) and is therefore subject to bias (de Vries et al., 2017; Bretland and Thorsteinsson, 2015; Heiden et al., 2007; Mealer et al., 2014). A comparison of the effectiveness of the individual interventions is therefore difficult. Furthermore, the combination of cognitive behavioural therapies and exercise-therapeutic contents only allows the assessment of the effectiveness of the individual interventions to be conditional (Heiden et al., 2007).

The use of different measuring instruments (Table 2) with their different definitions also makes it difficult to compare the results. This meta-analysis examined merely of whether exercise as an intervention had a positive effect on burnout syndrome or not.

Finally the number of included studies of high quality is too small to make a reliable statement. This is a huge limitation and reveals a research desideratum. Hence the need for more high quality studies in this field is evident.

In conclusion the results of this meta-analysis do not provide evidence that exercise therapy is effective in persons with occupational burnout.

Nevertheless, it would go too far to conclude, that exercise therapy is not effective in persons with burnout at all, because several studies have reported positive changes (Bretland and Thorsteinsson, 2015; Heiden et al., 2007; van Rhenen et al., 2005; Gerber et al., 2013a; 2013b; White et al., 2011).

But, besides exercise therapy also other promising types of therapy exist like cognitive behavioural therapy and mindfulness-based therapy (Heiden et al., 2007; Grossmann et al., 2004; Fjorback et al., 2011; Jouper and Johansson, 2013; Smith et al., 2008; Felton et al., 2015; Stenlund et al., 2009a; van Rhenen et al., 2005; White et al., 2011; Yung et al., 2004). All of these interventions seem to be effective in reducing perceived stress and burnout (Smith et al., 2008; Stenlund et al., 2009a). Regarding long-term effects, cognitive behavioural therapy has a sustained advantage compared to pure exercise therapy interventions (Heiden et al., 2007). Cognitive behavioural therapy may have a long-term effect as the affected persons benefit from their acquired ability to break up and alter old patterns of behaviour (Stenlund et al., 2012). They can use these abilities in the long term and thus protect themselves against a relapse. It appears that self-care activities can be seen as a protective factor in therapy, which protects the people concerned from renewed burnout.

A systematic review (Fjorback et al., 2011) of only randomized controlled trials concludes that mindfulness-based stress reduction is a useful tool for increasing mental health and reducing symptoms of stress and anxiety. Another meta-analysis states, that mindfulness-based stress reduction is useful for a lot of chronic disorders, by improving coping strategies (Grossmann et al., 2004). The same problem, as with exercise therapy is, that the mechanisms by which mindfulness-based programs achieve these benefits are still unclear (Fjorback et al., 2011).

CONCLUSION

Due to a lack of high quality studies the current meta-analysis does not support the widespread assumption that exercise therapy is a successful means to alleviate burnout symptoms. The results of the single studies with high quality included in this review only partially suggest the positive effect of exercise in patients with burnout syndrome. The conducted meta-analysis summarizes the effects and reveals that there is no clear evidence for the efficacy of exercise therapy in persons with burnout. The different types of physical activity used in the included studies and the different treatment modalities impede clear conclusions. Often, in the treatment of burnout, cognitive behavioural therapy or mindfulness-based therapy is used in parallel with exercise therapy, which enables the persons concerned to cope better with their stressors. A combination of cognitive behavioural therapy, mindfulness-based therapy and exercise therapy might also help to increase adherence to physical activity.

The informative value of the present study is limited by some aspects. The results of this review are based on only four studies in the meta-analysis and a total of six studies in the narrative evaluation due to the inclusion criteria of randomized controlled trials. Thus, the results summarized here cannot support the statement that exercise has a positive influence on burnout. Countervailing the above mentioned limitations, the rigor and extent of this paper’s literature search criteria and the adherence to PRISMA guidelines for conducting and reporting and the focus on high qualitive studies, may be this review paper’s strength and a significant contribution to existing literature (Prisma, 2017).

In summary, the meta-analysis clearly shows, that there is lack of high quality studies, thus revealing a huge research gap. This is astonishing because the interrelationship of effects between physical therapy and burnout is frequently mentioned in studies.

In future studies, high methodological standards are necessary, on the one hand with regard to evaluation design, on the other hand with a view to the detailed description of the intervention contents and methods (Slade et al. 2016). Future studies would benefit from a generally accepted definition of burnout syndrome as well as a consensus in the use of assessment methods. Future work should also address the specific efficacy of different exercise modalities as well as their combination with further cognitive behavioural or mindfulness-based interventions.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The experiments comply with the current laws of the country in which they were performed. The authors have no conflict of interest to declare.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Oliver Ochentel
Employment: PhD-student at Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany
Degree: Secondary school teacher
Research interests: Rehabilitation and burnout prevention
E-mail: Oliver-Ochentel@gmx.de
 

Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Crystal Humphrey
Employment: Teacher at Franconian International School
Degree: Masters student at Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany
Research interests: workplace health, health behaviour change, health education in schools
E-mail:
 

Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Klaus Pfeifer
Employment: Full professor – Chair for Exercise and Health at Friedrich-Alexander-University Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany
Degree: PhD
Research interests: Rehabilitation Science, Exercise Therapy, Health-related Physical Activity, Interdisciplinary Human Movement Science and Training Science
E-mail:
 
 
REFERENCES
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Ahola K., Honkonen T., Isometsä E., Kalimo R., Nykyri E., Aromaa A., Lönnqvist J. (2005) The relationship between job-related burnout and depressive disorders--results from the Finnish Health 2000 Study. Journal of Affective Disorders 88, 55-62.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Alarcon G., Eschleman K.J., Bowling N.A. (2009) Relationships between personality variables and burnout. A meta-analysis. Work & Stress 23, 244-263.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Altshuler J.L., Ruble D.N. (1989) Developmental changes in children’s awareness of strategies for coping with uncontrollable stress. Child Development 60, 1337-1349.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine AOK. (2014) AOK (WidO) Fehlzeitenreport. Hg. v. Badura, B., Ducki, A. and Klose, J., Meyer, M. Available from URL: http://www.wido.de/fzr_2014.html [Accessed 2 March 2017].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Appels A., Mulder P. (1989) Fatigue and heart disease. The association between ‘vital exhaustion’ and past, present and future coronary heart disease. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 33, 727-738.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Awa W.L., Plaumann M., Walter U. (2010) Burnout prevention. A review of intervention programs. Patient Education and Counseling 78, 184-190.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Bahlmann J., Angermeyer M.C., Schomerus G. (2013) “Burnout” statt “Depression” - eine Strategie zur Vermeidung von Stigma?. Psychiatrische Praxis 40, 78-82.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Berger, M., Linden, M., Schramm, E., Hillert, A., Vorderholzer, U. and Maier, W. (2012) Positionspapier der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Psychiatrie, Psychotherapie und Nervenheilkunde (DGPPN) zum Thema Burnout. Available from URL: http://www.dgppn.de [Accessed 03 April 2017].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Bianchi R., Schonfeld I.S., Laurent E. (2015) Burnout-depression overlap: a review. Clinical Psychology Review 36, 28-41.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Blumenthal J.A., Babyak M.A., Moore K.A., Craighead W.E., Herman S., Khatri P., Waugh R., Napolitano M.A., Forman L.M., Appelbaum M., Doraiswamy P.M., Krishnan K.R. (1999) Effects of exercise training on older patients with major depression. Archives of Internal Medicine 159, 2349-2356.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Borenstein, M., Hedges, L.V., Higgins, J.P.T. and Rothstein, H.R. (2009) Introduction to meta-analysis. Chichester U.K.: John Wiley & Sons.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine BPtK. (2015) BPtK-Studie zur Arbeitsunfähigkeit. Psychische Erkrankungen und Krankengeldmanagement. Available from URL: https://www.bptk.de/publikationen/bptk-studie.html [Accessed 2 March 2017].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Brenninkmeijer V., Van Yperen N. (2003) How to conduct research on burnout: advantages and disadvantages of a unidimensional approach in burnout research. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 60, i16-i20.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Bretland R.J., Thorsteinsson E.B. (2015) Reducing workplace burnout: The relative benefits of cardiovascular and resistance exercise. PeerJ 3, e891-.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Caspersen C.J., Powell K.E., Christenson G.M. (1985) Physical activity, exercise and physical fitness: Definitions and distinctions for health-related research. Public Health Reports 100, 126-131.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Corrigan P.W., Holmes E.P., Luchins D. (1995) Burnout and collegial support in state psychiatric hospital staff. Journal of Clinical Psychology 51, 703-710.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine da Costa Santos C.M., de Mattos Pimenta C.A., Nobre M.R. (2007) The PICO strategy for the research question construction and evidence search. Revista Latino-Americana de Enfermagem 15, 508-511.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine de Vries J.D., van Hooff M.L., Guerts S.A.E., Kompier M.A.J. (2017) Exercise to reduce work-related fatigue among employees. A randomized controlled trial. Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health 43, 337-349.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Deligkaris P., Panagopoulou E., Montgomery A.J., Masoura E. (2014) Job burnout and cognitive functioning: A systematic review. Work & Stress 28, 107-123.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine DGPPN. (2017) Available from URL: https://www.dgppn.de [Accessed 2 March 2017].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Ekstedt M., Söderström M., Åkerstedt T., Nilsson J., Søndergaard H.P., Aleksander P. (2006) Disturbed sleep and fatigue in occupational burnout. Scand J Work Environ Health 32, 121-131.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Eskilsson T., Slunga Järvholm L., Malmberg Gavelin H., Stigsdotter Neely A., Boraxbekk C.J. (2017) Aerobic training for improved memory in patients with stress-related exhaustion. A randomized controlled trial. BMC Psychiatry 17, 322.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Felton T.M., Coates L., Christopher J.C. (2015) Impact of mindfulness training on counseling students’ perceptions of stress. Mindfulness 6, 159-169.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Fjorback L.O., Arendt M., Ornbøl E., Fink P., Walach H. (2011) Mindfulness-based stress reduction and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 124, 102-119.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Forcier K., Stroud L.R., Papandonatos G.D., Hitsmann B., Reiches M., Krishnamoorthy J., Niaura R. (2006) Links between physical fitness and cardiovascular reactivity and recovery to psychological stressors: A meta-analysis. Health Psychology 25, 723-739.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Galper D.I., Trivedi M.H., Barlow C.E., Dunn A.L., Kampert J.B. (2006) Inverse Association between Physical Inactivity and Mental Health in Men and Women. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 38, 173-178.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Gerber M., Brand S., Elliot C., Holsboer-Trachsler E., Puhse U., Beck J. (2013a) Aerobic exercise training and burnout: a pilot study with male participants suffering from burnout. BMC Research Notes 6, 78.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Gerber M., Lindwall M., Lindegard A., Borjesson M., Jonsdottir I.H. (2013b) Cardiorespiratory fitness protects against stress-related symptoms of burnout and depression. Patient Education and Counseling 93, 146-152.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Gillman L., Adams J., Kovac R., Kilcullen A., House A., Doyle C. (2015) Strategies to promote coping and resilience in oncology and palliative care nurses caring for adult patients with malignancy: a comprehensive systematic review. JBI Database of Systematic Reviews and Implementation Reports 13, 131-204.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Greist J.H., Klein M.H., Eischens R.R., Faris J., Gurman A.S., Morgan W.P. (1979) Running as treatment for depression. Comprehensive Psychiatry 20, 41-54.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Grossman P., Niemann L., Schmidt S., Walach H. (2004) Mindfulness-based stress reduction and health benefits. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 57, 35-43.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Heiden M., Lyskov E., Nakata M., Sahlin K., Sahlin T., Barnekow-Bergkvist M. (2007) Evaluation of cognitive behavioural training and physical activity for patients with stress-related illnesses: a randomized controlled study. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 39, 366-373.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Higgins N.C. (1986) Occupational stress and working women: The effectiveness of two stress reduction programs. Journal of Vocational Behavior 29, 66-78.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Hillert A (2012a) Wie wird Burn-out behandelt? Zwischen Wellness, berufsbezogener Stresspravention, Psychotherapie und Gesellschaftskritik. Bundesgesundheitsblatt, Gesundheitsforschung, Gesundheitsschutz 55, 190-196.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Hillert A (2012b) Burnout: eine zeitgemäße psychische Störung? Geschichte, Konzepte, Perspektiven. Psychiatrie und Psychotherapie up2date6 , 1-15.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Honkonen T., Ahola K., Pertovaara M., Isometsä E., Kalimo R., Nykyri E., Aromaa A., Lönnqvist J. (2006) The association between burnout and physical illness in the general population--results from the Finnish Health 2000 Study. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 61, 59-66.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine ICD-10. (2017) International Statistical Classification of Diseases and related Health Problems 10th Revision. Available from URL: http://www.icd-code.de/icd/code/ICD-10-GM.html [Accessed 2 March 2017].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Jackson E.M., Dishman R.K. (2006) Cardiorespiratory fitness and laboratory stress. A meta-regression analysis. Psychophysiology 43, 57-72.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Jouper J., Johansson M. (2013) Qigong and mindfulness-based mood recovery: Exercise experiences from a single case. Journal of Bodywork and Movement Therapies 17, 69-76.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Kakiashvili T., Leszek J., Rutkowski K. (2013) The medical perspective on burnout. International Journal of Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health 26, 401-412.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Kissling W., Mendel R., Forstl H. (2014) Das Burnout-Syndrom: Pravalenz, Symptome, Differenzialdiagnose und Therapie. Deutsche Medizinische Wochenschrift (1946) 139, 2587-2596.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Kitaoka-Higashiguchi K., Morikawa Y., Miura K., Sakurai M., Ishizaki M., Kido T., Naruse Y., Nakagawa H. (2009) Burnout and risk factors for arteriosclerotic disease. Follow up study. Journal of Occupational Health 51, 123-131.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Klaperski S., von Dawans B., Heinrichs M., Fuchs R. (2014) Effects of a 12-week endurance training program on the physiological response to psychosocial stress in men. A randomized controlled trial. Journal of Behavioral Medicine 37, 1118-1133.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Kristensen T.S., Borritz M., Villadsen E., Christensen K.B. (2005) The Copenhagen Burnout Inventory. A new tool for the assessment of burnout. Work & Stress 19, 192-207.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Krollner, B., Krollner, D.M. (2018): ICD-Code. Available from URL: unter http://www.icd-code.de/ [Accessed 22 April 2018].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Kushi L.H., Fee R.M., Folsom A.R., Mink P.J., Anderson K.E., Sellers T.A. (1997) Physical activity and mortality in postmenopausal women. JAMA 277, 1287-1292.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Lee I.M., Skerrett P.J. (2001) Physical activity and all-cause mortality: what is the dose-response relation?. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise 33, 459-471.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Macedo L.G., Elkins M.R., Maher C.G., Moseley A.M., Herbert R.D., Sherrington C. (2010) There was evidence of convergent and construct validity of Physiotherapy Evidence Database quality scale for physiotherapy trials. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 63, 920-925.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Maher C.G., Sherrington C., Herbert R.D., Moseley A.M., Elkins M. (2003) Reliability of the PEDro scale for rating quality of randomized controlled trials. Physical therapy 83, 713-721.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Maslach C (2003) Job Burnout: New Directions in Research and Intervention. Current Directions in Psychological Science 12, 189-192.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Maslach, C. and Jackson, S.E. (1986) Maslach Burnout Inventory manual. 2nd edition. Consulting Psychologists Press.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine McCann I.L., Holmes D.S. (1984) Influence of aerobic exercise on depression. Journal of personality and social psychology 46, 1142-1147.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Mealer M., Conrad D., Evans J., Jooste K., Solyntjes J., Rothbaum B., Moss M. (2014) Feasibility and acceptability of a resilience training program for intensive care unit nurses. American Journal of Critical Care 23, e97-105.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Mohren D.C.L., Swaen G.M.H., Kant I., van Amelsvoort L.G.P.M., Borm P.J.A., Galama J.M.D. (2003) Common infections and the role of burnout in a Dutch working population. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 55, 201-208.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Naczenski L.M., Vries J.D., de van Hooff M.L.M., Kompier M.A.J. (2017) Systematic review of the association between physical activity and burnout. Journal of Occupational Health 59, 477-494.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Pappas G.P., Golin S., Meyer D.L. (1990) Reducing Symptoms of Depression With Exercise. Psychosomatics 31, 112-113.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Pedersen B.K., Saltin B. (2015) Exercise as medicine - evidence for prescribing exercise as therapy in 26 different chronic diseases. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports 25, 1-72.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Peterson U., Demerouti E., Bergström G., Samuelsson M., Asberg M., Nygren A. (2008) Burnout and physical and mental health among Swedish healthcare workers. Journal of Advanced Nursing 62, 84-95.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine PRISMA. (2017) PRISMA. Transparent reporting of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Available from URL: http://www.prismastatement.org [Accessed 2 March 2017].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Pubmed. (2017) Exercise therapy. MeSH-Terms. Available from URL: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/mesh/68005081 [Accessed 16 April 2017].
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Reimers, C.D. and Brooks, A. (2003) Neurologie, Psychiatrie und Sport. Stuttgart, New York: Thieme.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Salmon P (2001) Effects of physical exercise on anxiety, depression and sensitivity to stress - a unifying theory. Clinical Psychology Review 21, 33-61.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Schaufeli W.B., Leiter M.P., Maslach C. (2009) Burnout. 35 years of research and practice. Career Development International 14, 204-220.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Shirom A (2005) Reflections on the study of burnout The views expressed in Work & Stress commentaries are those of the author(s), and do not necessarily represent those of any other person or organization, or of the journal. Work & Stress 19, 263-270.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Slade, S.C., Dionne, C.E., Underwood, M. and Buchbinder, R. (2016) Consensus on Exercise Reporting Template (CERT): Explanation and Elaboration Statement. British Journal of Sports Medicine. pii: bjsports-2016-096651
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Smith B.W., Shelley B.M., Dalen J., Wiggins K., Tooley E., Bernard J. (2008) A pilot study comparing the effects of mindfulness-based and cognitive-behavioral stress reduction. Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (New York, N.Y.) 14, 251-258.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Soares J.J.F., Grossi G., Sundin O. (2007) Burnout among women: associations with demographic/socio-economic, work, life-style and health factors. Archives of Women’s Mental Health 10, 61-71.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Stenlund T., Ahlgren C., Lindahl B., Burell G., Steinholtz K., Edlund C., Nilsson L., Knutsson A., Birgander L.S. (2009a) Cognitively oriented behavioral rehabilitation in combination with Qigong for patients on long-term sick leave because of burnout: REST--a randomized clinical trial. International Journal of Behavioral Medicine 16, 294-303.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Stenlund T., Birgander L.S., Lindahl B., Nilsson L., Ahlgren C. (2009b) Effects of Qigong in patients with burnout: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 41, 761-767.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Stenlund T., Nordin M., Jarvholm L.S. (2012) Effects of rehabilitation programmes for patients on long-term sick leave for burnout: a 3-year follow-up of the REST study. Journal of rehabilitation medicine 44, 684-690.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Sterne J.A.C., Sutton A.J., Ioannidis J.P.A., Terrin N., Jones D.R., Lau J., Carpenter J., Rücker G., Harbord R.M., Schmid C.H., Tetzlaff J., Deeks J.J., Peters J., Macaskill P., Schwarzer G., Duval S., Altman D.G., Moher D., Higgins J.P.T. (2011) Recommendations for examining and interpreting funnel plot asymmetry in meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials. BMC Research Methods and Reporting 342, 1-8.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Stevens S.N.M. (2011) Understanding how employees unwind after work: Expanding the construct of ‘recovery’. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering 72, 587.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine The Cochrane Collaboration. (2014) Review Manager (RevMan). Version 5.3: The Nordic Cochrane Centre.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Thompson P.D., Buchner D., Pina I.L., Balady G.J., Williams M.A., Marcus B.H., Berra K., Blair S.N., Costa F., Franklin B., Fletscher G.F., Gordon N.F., Pate R.R., Rodriguez B.L., Yancey A.K., Wenger N.K. (2003) Exercise and physical activity in the prevention and treatment of atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. A statement from the Council on Clinical Cardiology (Subcommittee on Exercise, Rehabilitation, and Prevention) and the Council on Nutrition, Physical Activity, and Metabolism (Subcommittee on Physical Activity). Circulation 107, 3109-3116.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Toker S., Melamed S., Berliner S., Zeltser D., Shapira I. (2012) Burnout and risk of coronary heart disease: a prospective study of 8838 employees. Psychosomatic Medicine 74, 840-847.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Valentine J.C, Pigott T.D., Rothstein H.R. (2010) How many studies do you need?. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics 35, 215-247.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Van Rhenen W., Blonk R.W.B., van der Klink J.J.L., van Dijk F.J.H., Schaufeli W.B. (2005) The effect of a cognitive and a physical stress-reducing programme on psychological complaints. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health 78, 139-148.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Walker E., Hernandes A.V., Kattan M.W. (2008) Meta-analysis: Ist strengths and limitations. Cleveland Clinic Journal of Medicine 75, 431-439.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Weckmann G., Chenot J.F., Reber K.C. (2015) A practical approach to reading and interpreting meta-analyses. Zeitschrift für Allgemeinmedizin 91, 469-473.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine White P.D., Goldsmith K.A., Johnson A.L., Potts L., Walwyn R., DeCesare J.C., Baber H.L., Burgess M., Clark L.V., Cox D.L., Bavinton J., Angus B.J., Murphy G., Murphy M., O’Dowd H., Wilks D., Mc Crone P., Chalder T., Sharpe M. (2011) Comparison of adaptive pacing therapy, cognitive behaviour therapy, graded exercise therapy, and specialist medical care for chronic fatigue syndrome (PACE). A randomised trial. The Lancet 377, 823-836.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Yung P.M.B., Fung M.Y., Chan T.M.F., Lau B.W.K. (2004) Relaxation training methods for nurse managers in Hong Kong: a controlled study. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing 13, 255-261.
Journal of Sports Science and Medicine Zlowodzki M., Poolman R.W., Kerkhoffs G.M., Tornetta P., Bhandari M. (2007) How to interpret a meta-analysis and judge its value as a guide for clinical practice. Acta Orthopaedica 78, 598-609.
 
 
 
Home Issues About Authors
Contact Current Editorial board Authors instructions
Email alerts In Press Mission For Reviewers
Archive Scope
Supplements Statistics
Most Read Articles
  Most Cited Articles
 
    
 
JSSM | Copyright 2001-2018 | All rights reserved. | LEGAL NOTICES | Publisher

It is forbidden the total or partial reproduction of this web site and the published materials, the treatment of its database, any kind of transition and for any means, either electronic, mechanic or other methods, without the previous written permission of the JSSM.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.